Check your favourite argument.

The Israel–Palestine debate isn't Jews against Arabs. It's ideologues against people who want a solution β€” on both sides. This site takes a side: the side of a solution, any solution that lets both peoples live.

Every argument here is stated the way its best advocates would, then shown what's true in it, what it leaves out, which reasoning trap it tends to fall into β€” and what it leads to if you follow it through. You'll find your side's arguments too. That's the point.

Explore the timeline→From ancient Israel to today, and which events each side's story is built on.

Arguments (59)

Every argument is examined the same way, whichever side it comes from. Filter by who makes it, or by how well we've found it anchored in public sources.

Side Topic Dispute Sort Heard

Topic and dispute labels are editorial judgements; hover a dispute button for its meaning.

pro-Palestinianβ€œIsrael is committing genocide in Gaza.”commonβ—† Citation loopβ—† The authority endpointβ—† Proxy presented as outcomeβ—† "It's not complicated"β—† Holocaust inversionβ—† Judging by originβ—† Motte and baileypro-Palestinianβ€œIsrael is a settler-colonial state.”commonβ—† Which territory?β—† Which Zionism?pro-Palestinianβ€œIsrael is an apartheid state.”made publiclyβ—† Which territory?β—† Citation loopβ—† Motte and baileypro-Israelβ€œJews can only be safe as a majority in their own state.”hot potatocommonβ—† Proxy presented as outcomeβ—† The strict enemy framepro-Palestinianβ€œPalestine was definitely a thing β€” there was even a newspaper called Filastin in 1911 β€” and almost no Jews lived there, so Israel was a hostile takeover.”made publiclyβ—† Which Palestine?β—† Which territory?β—† The exception as proofboth sidesβ€œUNRWA keeps millions of Palestinians as refugees forever β€” a problem kept alive on purpose.”made publiclyβ—† Negotiation as a weaponβ—† "What about you?"both sidesβ€œIsrael is starving Gaza β€” famine has been confirmed.”made publiclyβ—† Proxy presented as outcomeβ—† The authority endpointβ—† "It's not complicated"pro-Palestinianβ€œIsrael never wanted peace β€” it breaks every ceasefire and uses talks to take more land.”made publiclyβ—† "They all…"β—† The strict enemy framepro-Palestinianβ€œ'Zionist' is not an ethnicity, a race or a religion β€” so nothing said about Zionists can be antisemitic.”made publiclyβ—† Which Zionism?β—† Motte and baileypro-Palestinianβ€œA 3,000-year-old promise doesn't justify a genocide.”made publiclyβ—† Motte and baileyβ—† Which Zionism?pro-Palestinianβ€œFrom the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.”commonβ—† Motte and baileyβ—† Same slogan, different goalsβ—† Which Palestine?pro-Palestinianβ€œIsrael is evil and illegitimate β€” it has no right to exist.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† The strict enemy frameβ—† Motte and baileyβ—† Where does the story start?β—† False dilemmapro-Israelβ€œThe Palestinians left voluntarily in 1948 β€” their own leaders told them to go.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† "They all…"β—† DARVO: deny, attack, reversepro-Palestinianβ€œJews lived peacefully in the Arab world for centuries until Zionism ruined it; they left because Israel lured them.”made publiclyβ—† "They all…"pro-Israelβ€œThe West Bank isn't occupied β€” it's disputed territory, and Jews have every right to live there.”hot potatocommonβ—† Which territory?β—† Motte and baileypro-Israelβ€œThe Palestinians never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity.”made publiclyβ—† "What about you?"β—† "They all…"pro-Palestinianβ€œA religion doesn't justify having a country.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† Which Zionism?β—† "What about you?"both sidesβ€œAl-Aqsa is in danger.”made publiclyβ—† The strict enemy frameβ—† Proxy presented as outcomepro-Palestinianβ€œThe IDF is a terrorist army that targets Palestinian civilians on purpose.”assertedβ—† Reading an incident storyβ—† The exception as proofβ—† The strict enemy frameβ—† The loaded questionpro-Palestinianβ€œIsrael's real goal is 'Greater Israel' β€” from the Nile to the Euphrates.”made publiclyβ—† Motte and baileyβ—† Which territory?β—† "They all…"pro-Israelβ€œIslam is a cancer destroying the West β€” Israel is just the front line.”made publiclyβ—† Which Islam?β—† "They all…"β—† The strict enemy framepro-Israelβ€œThere's no such thing as a Palestinian people β€” it was invented in 1964.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† Which Palestine?β—† "They all…"β—† The exception as proofβ—† The argument that isn't meant to winpro-Palestinianβ€œZionists are the modern Nazis.”made publiclyβ—† The strict enemy frameβ—† "They all…"β—† DARVO: deny, attack, reverseβ—† Holocaust inversionβ—† The argument that isn't meant to winpro-Israelβ€œArab citizens of Israel have full equality β€” they vote, sit in the Knesset and on the Supreme Court.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† Motte and baileyβ—† Which territory?pro-Israelβ€œHamas uses Gaza's civilians as human shields, so it is responsible for their deaths.”made publiclyβ—† Reading an incident storyβ—† The strict enemy framepro-Palestinianβ€œIsrael is an ethnostate.”made publiclyβ—† "What about you?"β—† Which territory?pro-Palestinianβ€œThat's hasbara β€” Israel pays people to post this.”made publiclyβ—† Identity as authorityβ—† The purity loopβ—† Judging by originpro-Palestinianβ€œOnly a small share of ancient Jews ever left; Palestinians are the real descendants of the ancient inhabitants, and today's Jews are mostly Europeans.”made publiclyβ—† "They all…"pro-Israelβ€œThe Arab world loves Palestine in words and abandons Palestinians in deeds.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† The exception as proofβ—† "What about you?"pro-Palestinianβ€œ'It's not genocide because the ICJ hasn't ruled' is like calling a school shooting a 'tussle' until a judge rules.”made publiclyβ—† "It's not complicated"β—† The authority endpointpro-Israelβ€œThe Mufti was Hitler's ally β€” Palestinian nationalism has Nazi roots.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† "They all…"β—† Judging by originβ—† The exception as proofpro-Palestinianβ€œThe Nakba was a pre-planned ethnic cleansing β€” Plan Dalet was the blueprint.”made publiclyβ—† "They all…"pro-Israelβ€œIsrael left Gaza in 2005 β€” there has been no occupation there since.”made publiclyβ—† Motte and baileyβ—† Proxy presented as outcomepro-Palestinianβ€œJews don't need a state β€” they should live as equal citizens wherever they're from.”made publiclyβ—† Judging by originβ—† The strict enemy framepro-Israelβ€œMost Palestinians are descendants of recent Arab immigrants who came for the jobs Zionism created; the real locals were only a few villagers and tribes.”made publiclyβ—† "They all…"β—† Judging by originpro-Israelβ€œIt was a land without a people, for a people without a land.”made publiclyβ—† Which Palestine?β—† "They all…"pro-Israelβ€œAid to Gaza feeds Hamas β€” they turn anything into weapons.”made publiclyβ—† The exception as proofβ—† The strict enemy framepro-Israelβ€œThere was a Jewish Nakba too β€” it was a population exchange, so the Palestinian refugee question is settled.”made publiclyβ—† "What about you?"pro-Palestinianβ€œIsrael is a cancerous tumour in the region β€” the Zionist regime will be uprooted.”made publiclyβ—† The strict enemy frameβ—† Judging by originpro-Israelβ€œJerusalem is Israel's united capital, and all its residents are equal.”made publiclyβ—† Which territory?β—† Motte and baileypro-Israelβ€œSettler violence is a handful of extremists β€” the 'hilltop youth' β€” and Israel deals with them.”made publiclyβ—† "They all…"β—† Citation loopβ—† Reading an incident storyβ—† DARVO: deny, attack, reversepro-Israelβ€œIran is the head of the octopus β€” cut it off and Hamas and Hezbollah fall.”made publiclyβ—† Proxy presented as outcomeβ—† The strict enemy framepro-Israelβ€œThe 'right of return' is a backdoor to ending Israel β€” by making Jews a minority.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† The strict enemy framepro-Palestinianβ€œWhat would you do if you were oppressed for 75 years? October 7 didn't come from nowhere.”made publiclyβ—† Where does the story start?β—† The strict enemy framepro-Palestinianβ€œIsrael was a British colonial project β€” the Empire planted the Jews in Palestine.”made publiclyβ—† "They all…"β—† Which Palestine?pro-Palestinianβ€œIsrael doesn't even have gay marriage β€” its gay-friendly image is pinkwashing.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† The strict enemy frameβ—† The exception as proofpro-Israelβ€œJordan is Palestine β€” the Palestinians already have their state.”made publiclyβ—† Which territory?β—† Which Palestine?pro-Palestinianβ€œThe GHF aid sites were death traps β€” aid used as a weapon of genocide.”made publiclyβ—† The exception as proofβ—† Proxy presented as outcomepro-Israelβ€œ'Queers for Palestine' is like chickens for KFC.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† "They all…"β—† The strict enemy frameboth sidesβ€œUNRWA is Hamas. / The accusations against UNRWA are Israeli propaganda.”made publiclyβ—† "They all…"β—† The authority endpointβ—† DARVO: deny, attack, reversepro-Israelβ€œUnder Islam, Jews were humiliated second-class dhimmis β€” and Islamists want to bring it back.”hot potatomade publiclyβ—† Which Islam?β—† The exception as proofpro-Palestinianβ€œThe people who cheered crippling sanctions on Iran suddenly call economic pressure on Israel 'collective punishment'.”made publiclyβ—† "What about you?"pro-Palestinianβ€œI'm not an extremist, I'm just against child killers, and Israel's army are child killers.”made publiclyβ—† The strict enemy frameβ—† "It's not complicated"β—† "They all…"pro-Palestinianβ€œVictim card revoked.”made publiclyβ—† "They all…"β—† The purity loopβ—† DARVO: deny, attack, reverseβ€œJews have been expelled from 109 countries β€” what do they have in common?”actual argument?β—† The exception as proofβ—† "They all…"β—† DARVO: deny, attack, reverseboth sidesβ€œTheir leader isn't even from here: Netanyahu is Polish, Arafat was Egyptian.”made publiclyβ—† Judging by originboth sidesβ€œUNRWA schools teach hatred of Jews and Israel.”made publiclyβ—† Citation loopβ—† "They all…"pro-Israelβ€œBethlehem was Christian under Israel; under the Palestinian Authority the Christians were pushed out”made publiclyβ—† Where does the story start?β—† The exception as proofpro-Israelβ€œIf there are any journalists in Gaza who aren't Hamas, they're damn hard to find.”made publiclyβ—† "They all…"β—† The strict enemy frameβ—† Identity as authority

The traps

Like learning to spot phishing: the same moves turn up on every side. Each card shows the signs, the questions to ask, and where the trap appears β€” in both directions.

β—† "They all…"They all… / That's what they're like.9 pro-Palestinian Β· 10 pro-Israel Β· 2 bothβ—† The strict enemy frameThey are purely evil. / There are no innocents on the other side.9 pro-Palestinian Β· 8 pro-Israel Β· 1 bothβ—† Motte and bailey[A bold claim] β€” when challenged: 'All I said was [a modest one].'7 pro-Palestinian Β· 4 pro-Israelβ—† The exception as proofHere's the proof: [one artefact, one quote, one incident]4 pro-Palestinian Β· 6 pro-Israelβ—† Which territory?Israel does X. / Palestine is occupied.5 pro-Palestinian Β· 4 pro-Israelβ—† "What about you?"But what about… / You did it too.3 pro-Palestinian Β· 3 pro-Israel Β· 1 bothβ—† Judging by originThat idea comes from [bad source], so it's wrong.4 pro-Palestinian Β· 2 pro-Israel Β· 1 bothβ—† Proxy presented as outcomeIt's been confirmed. / The numbers prove it.2 pro-Palestinian Β· 3 pro-Israel Β· 2 bothβ—† DARVO: deny, attack, reverseYou're the real aggressor here.2 pro-Palestinian Β· 2 pro-Israel Β· 1 bothβ—† Which Palestine?Palestine is [X] / Free Palestine3 pro-Palestinian Β· 3 pro-Israelβ—† "It's not complicated"This isn't a complicated issue. / There is no neutral position between oppressor and oppressed.3 pro-Palestinian Β· 1 bothβ—† Citation loopEvery major organisation agrees. / It's been confirmed by multiple sources.2 pro-Palestinian Β· 1 pro-Israel Β· 1 bothβ—† The authority endpointThe UN has said so. / Read the OHCHR report. / The IDF has confirmed it.2 pro-Palestinian Β· 2 bothβ—† Which Zionism?Zionism is [X]4 pro-Palestinianβ—† Reading an incident storyLook what they did β€” it's all over the news.1 pro-Palestinian Β· 2 pro-Israelβ—† Where does the story start?They started it β€” look at what they just did2 pro-Palestinian Β· 1 pro-Israelβ—† Holocaust inversionIsrael is doing to the Palestinians what the Nazis did to the Jews2 pro-Palestinianβ—† Identity as authorityAs a Palestinian… / As a Jew… / That's hasbara. / That's taqiyya.1 pro-Palestinian Β· 1 pro-Israelβ—† The argument that isn't meant to winAnyone who doesn't accept this is in denial.1 pro-Palestinian Β· 1 pro-Israelβ—† The purity loopAnyone who says something positive about Israel, or works with Israelis, is a Zionist β€” so what they say doesn't count.2 pro-Palestinianβ—† Which Islam?Islam is [X] / Islamophobia Β· 2 pro-Israelβ—† False dilemmaYou either support Israel or you support human rights β€” you can't do both.1 pro-Palestinianβ—† Negotiation as a weaponThey're only negotiating to buy time. / The ceasefire is a trick. Β· 1 bothβ—† Same slogan, different goalsWe all want the same thing: Free Palestine.1 pro-Palestinianβ—† The loaded questionHave you stopped beating your wife?1 pro-Palestinianβ—† Allies in destructionThe enemy of my enemy is my friend.β—† Flattened wordsJihad, shahid, waqf, hudna, taqiyyaβ—† Irony and the dripIt was just a joke. / Can't you take a joke?β—† Loud in public, quiet dealsThey'll never agree to anything β€” just listen to them.β—† One word two meaningsThat's not what they meant. / That's exactly what they meant.β—† Refusing to say the name'The Zionist entity'β—† See what my llm saysSee what my AI chatbot tells me.β—† Seen this story beforeWe've seen this story before.β—† The correction nobody seesIt was all over the news.β—† The flood of chargesColonialism, apartheid, genocide, ethnic cleansing, famine, child killers, organ harvesting, the lobby… how do you explain all that?β—† The image does the arguingJust look at this picture.β—† They said it themselvesThey said it themselves.β—† Two languages, two storiesBut that's not what they said in Arabic (or Hebrew).β—† What happened next?Everyone knows what happened.β—† Which name?It's called [our name], not [their name]β—† Who speaks for them?Palestinians want… / Israelis want…◆ Wikipedia as backgroundLook it up, it's on Wikipedia.β—† You need the argument to find the argumentI looked it up β€” nobody even disputes it.

So what would you do β€” and what's in the way?

Arguments point somewhere. Try the solutions people actually propose: what each one requires, what happens to each people, who supports it, and what history says about it. Then the deadlocks: the fears on both sides that have stopped every one of them so far. None is presented as the answer β€” the aim is to know what you're supporting.

Two statesA Palestinian state alongside Israel, roughly on the 1967 lines with agreed land swaps.Two states, one homeland (confederation)Two sovereign states with open borders, shared institutions and a shared Jerusalem; citizenship and residence are separated.Local rule: clans, cities and cantonsInstead of one national government per people, power lies with local communities that already govern themselves: Arab clans and cities, Jewish towns and communities, federated or coordinated above.Parallel states: two states on the same landTwo states, Israel and Palestine, each covering the whole land between the river and the sea. Citizenship follows the person, not the territory: every resident belongs to one of the two states, wherever they live.One democratic state with equal rightsOne state from the river to the sea, every person an equal citizen.One state with equal rights that remains a Jewish stateIsrael extends its sovereignty and full, equal citizenship to the Palestinians of the West Bank, and keeps its Jewish national character, as it does today with its Arab citizens.The Trump plan: 'Peace to Prosperity' (2020)A demilitarised Palestinian state on most of the West Bank, plus Gaza and land swaps; Israel annexes the settlements and the Jordan Valley, with 'the potential to facilitate more than $50 billion in new investment over ten years'.The Gaza plan: Board of Peace and a technocratic Gaza (2025)End the war, release the hostages, disarm Hamas, and run Gaza through a technocratic committee of Palestinians and international experts under an international Board of Peace, with an international force, while a Palestinian state stays a conditional 'pathway'.Regional land swap (the Eiland plan)Make the land bigger: Egypt gives Sinai land to enlarge Gaza, the Palestinians give Israel part of the West Bank where settlements stand, and Israel gives Egypt land in the Negev.Trading the 'Triangle': land and people swapped for settlement blocsIsrael keeps the West Bank settlement blocs; in exchange, Arab-majority towns inside Israel near the Green Line (the 'Triangle' around Wadi Ara and Umm al-Fahm) become part of a Palestinian state, with their residents.Shrinking the conflict: less control now, no final dealLeave the final status open and make occupation lighter step by step: roads linking the Palestinian areas without checkpoints, more work permits and economic ties, more room for Palestinian self-rule, while Israel keeps security control.Hudna: a long-term truce without recognitionA ceasefire for 10, 30 or more years in exchange for Israeli withdrawal to the 1967 lines, without recognising Israel or ending the claims. Hamas has offered versions of it since the 1990s.The Jordanian option: the West Bank back to Jordan, or a Jordanian–Palestinian federationInstead of a separate Palestinian state, the populated parts of the West Bank return to Jordanian rule or join Jordan in a federation, while Israel keeps security zones such as the Jordan Valley.International trusteeship: an outside administration for a transitionAn international or regional body governs Gaza (or all the territories) for a set period, providing security and services while local institutions are rebuilt, before handing over to Palestinian self-government.Binationalism: one state shared by two nationsOne state in which Jews and Arabs are recognised as two national communities with guaranteed shared power, not a majority ruling a minority; the idea behind Brit Shalom and Ihud before 1948.A Middle East union: solving it inside a regional frameworkIsrael and a Palestinian state, alongside their neighbours, join an EU-style regional framework, with open trade, shared infrastructure, security guarantees and eventually freedom of movement, so that borders matter less and the conflict is settled as part of a regional bargain.United Arabia: dissolving the conflict into a larger federationA thought experiment: the whole region, Israel and Palestine included, joins one large federation of autonomous states, so that the question of who owns the land between the river and the sea stops being about sovereignty.The original Mandate: a confederation on both banks of the JordanGo back to the map before 1922, when the Mandate for Palestine still included Transjordan: a confederation of Israel, a Palestinian state and Jordan across both banks of the river, in which Jews are a minority of the whole but keep their own state, army and immigration, and Palestinians gain room, a state and a shared economy.Managing the conflict (the status quo)No final settlement: occupation of the West Bank, separation from Gaza, periodic rounds of war.One state under Jewish rule, without equal rightsIsrael annexes the West Bank but does not give its Palestinians citizenship.Palestinians leave ('transfer' / 'voluntary emigration')The land becomes Jewish by moving Palestinians out β€” to Jordan, Egypt, or elsewhere.One Arab (or Islamic) state from the river to the seaIsrael ends; Palestine covers the whole land as an Arab state (PLO Charter 1968) or an Islamic one (Hamas).Three Gazas: an annexed strip, a 'red zone' and a 'Gaza of Peace' (Wilf, 2026)Split the Strip in three: a small symbolic area annexed to Israel, a Hamas-run 'red zone' for those choosing continued war, and an IDF-run 'Gaza of Peace' whose entrants renounce UNRWA refugee status β€” cutting the refugee card in a public ceremony β€” before reconstruction money flows.

What's in the way

See which deadlock blocks which solution β†’

From here to there: pick a target, see what blocks it and what could loosen it β†’

What happened, and who remembers what

Many arguments lean on history β€” the Irgun, Deir Yassin, the Nakba, 1967, Oslo, October 7. The timeline sets out what happened, from ancient Israel to today, and marks which events Israeli schooling puts centre stage and which the pro-Palestinian story does. Much of the talking past each other starts there.

Themes