Argument · heard from pro-Israel voices
“The Palestinians left voluntarily in 1948 — their own leaders told them to go.”
There was no expulsion: Arab leaders and armies told the population to leave temporarily and return after victory, so Israel bears no responsibility for the refugees.
Made publicly as a pro-Israel argument by American-Israeli Cooperative Enterprise (Jewish Virtual Library)
Where it's been said
“A plethora of evidence exists demonstrating that Palestinians were encouraged to leave their homes to make way for the invading Arab armies.”
Traps in play:◆ "They all…"◆ DARVO: deny, attack, reverse
Why people find it convincing
- In Haifa in April 1948, after Jewish forces captured the city, Arab leaders were evacuating their own community: a UP report in the New York Times said they 'tentatively agreed to stop evacuating their people', and that 'it was believed that between 15,000 and 20,000 Arabs still were in the city, out of more than 60,000' (NYT, 26 April 1948).
- Reporting at the time said so. In April 1949 a New York Times correspondent wrote from Tel Aviv that 'until now no voice had been raised to stay these people in their panicky flight. On the contrary, their leaders encouraged it, not realizing what the ultimate effect would be' (NYT, 8 April 1949).
- An Arab leader said it. Khalid al-Azm, Syria's prime minister in 1948–49, wrote in his memoirs (Beirut, 1973) that one cause of the Arab defeat was 'the call by the Arab governments to the inhabitants of Palestine to evacuate it': 'We brought destruction upon a million Arab refugees by calling on them and pleading with them to leave their land.' This is the passage pro-Israel advocates quote most, and it is in the memoir (checked against the Arabic, vol. 1: «لقد قضينا على مليون لاجىء عربي، وذلك بدعوتهم والالحاح عليهم بترك ارضهم ودورهم»). The same passage also gives what the compilation quoted here leaves out, at the point where its ellipsis falls (COJS; other compilations not checked): he lists, as the fifth Arab failure, the Arab governments' call on Palestinians 'to evacuate it and take refuge in the neighbouring Arab countries, after panic had spread in their ranks following the Deir Yassin incident'.
- Some Arab leaders did choose evacuation in specific places: at Haifa in April 1948, after the city fell, they chose it rather than accept terms (NYT, 26 April 1948, below); that wealthier families left early, before the fighting, is not yet sourced here (Benny Morris's work is the usual reference ⚠).
- The war was started by the rejection of partition and then an invasion by Arab states; people flee wars. Benny Morris's account of the first phase: the Arab Higher Committee 'flatly rejected the resolution and any thought of partition', and December 1947 – March 1948 'was marked by Arab initiatives and attacks and Jewish defensiveness, increasingly punctuated by Jewish reprisals' (The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited, ch. 3 summary).
- Jews in areas Arab forces took were killed or lost their homes too. At Kfar Etzion, after the Etzion Bloc surrendered on 14 May 1948, 'the Arabs murdered 127 men and women'; the rest were taken prisoner to Transjordan and the four kibbutzim 'were totally destroyed' (Jewish Virtual Library). The Jewish Quarter of Jerusalem's Old City, 2,200 residents when the siege began, surrendered to the Arab Legion on 28 May 1948 (Central Zionist Archives). Under the surrender terms, 'approximately 2000 women, children, old and religious people' were 'to be evacuated to Jewish quarters new Jerusalem under supervision International Red Cross', and 'three hundred men of military age' taken 'prisoners of war to Amman'; the UN's Azcárate told the US consulate that the Arab Legion 'had carried out evacuation efficiently and according surrender agreement' (US Vice Consul in Jerusalem, telegram of 29 May 1948, FRUS).
- Historian Efraim Karsh (Palestine Betrayed, Yale University Press, 2010) argues that 'from the early 1920s onward, a corrupt and extremist leadership worked toward eliminating the Jewish national revival and protecting its own interests', while 'the majority of Palestinian Arabs yearned to live and thrive under peaceful coexistence'. His sources are 'Western, Soviet, UN, and Israeli documents declassified over the past decade, as well as unfamiliar Arab sources' (publisher's description). How far he makes Israeli expulsions an exception is in the book, which is not read here ⚠.
- Benny Morris, whose archival work on the exodus is central here, rejects the planned-expulsion version. His conclusion: the 1948 war 'was launched by the Palestinian Arabs, who rejected the UN partition resolution and embarked on hostilities aimed at preventing the birth of Israel. That war and not design, Jewish or Arab, gave birth to the Palestinian refugee problem'; 'there was no pre-war Zionist plan to expel "the Arabs"', and pre-war 'transfer' thinking was never 'translated, in the course of the war, into an agreed, systematic policy of expulsion'. The same summary carries the other half: displacement 'was inherent in Zionist ideology and, in microcosm, in Zionist praxis from the start of the enterprise', and the leaders' periodic endorsement of 'transfer' – 'voluntary and agreed, if possible, but coerced if not' – 'readied hearts and minds for the denouement of 1948', when 'some 700,000 Arabs were displaced from their homes' (The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited, conclusion, Cambridge summary). 'War and not design' answers the master-plan charge; in this summary it does not say the refugees left of their own accord.
What's true
Flight had many causes, and in some places Arab leadership organised it.
Haifa is the best-known case: after the city fell, Arab leaders chose evacuation rather than accept terms, while some Jewish figures urged people to stay (NYT, 26 April 1948). Fear played a part by an Arab prime minister's own account: Syria's Khalid al-Azm wrote of the call to evacuate coming 'after panic had spread in their ranks following the Deir Yassin incident' (memoirs, as compiled by COJS and in the Arabic original). A year later the New York Times correspondent Gene Currivan, reporting from Tel Aviv (8 April 1949), wrote: 'Until now no voice had been raised to stay these people in their panicky flight. On the contrary, their leaders encouraged it, not realizing what the ultimate effect would be.' That is a reporter's assessment at the time; later archival work finds mixed causes, including expulsions. Whether the collapse of Arab leadership and services, and early departures of the well-off, also played a part is not sourced on this page ⚠. Benny Morris, whose archival work is central here, concludes that 'That war and not design, Jewish or Arab, gave birth to the Palestinian refugee problem' (see the bullet above). Others, such as Walid Khalidi and Ilan Pappé, put planned expulsion first (see below).
newspaper'Arabs to End Haifa Evacuation' (UP) (1948) incident ✓
Scan from the kvetch-of-the-day news archive.
NYT 1948-04-26; vision-verified. Image re-read 2026-10-12 ('Arabs to End Haifa Evacuation', HAIFA, April 25 (UP)): 'The Jews who captured this city on Thursday won a victory of peace today when Arab leaders tentatively agreed to stop evacuating their people. It was believed that between 15,000 and 20,000 Arabs still were in the city, out of more than 60,000. Police reported that about 700 had returned today from outlying districts to which they had fled.'
newspaper'Arab Leaders in Appeal' by Gene Currivan (1949) incident ✓
Scan from the kvetch-of-the-day news archive.
NYT 1949-04-08, Tel Aviv; vision-verified. A correspondent's assessment; later archival work finds mixed causes, including expulsions. Image re-read 2026-10-12 (Gene Currivan, 'Arab Leaders in Appeal'): 'For the first time since the Arabs started their exodus from Israel in panic, their own leaders appealed to them today to stay where they were' (Ramallah radio, controlled by King Abdullah); 'Until now no voice had been raised to stay these people in their panicky flight. On the contrary, their leaders encouraged it, not realizing what the ultimate effect would be. The net result is that the Arab countries have upward of 500,000 refugees on their hands and Israel has their homes and villages.'
historyBenny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited (2004) finding
Archival standard work; multiple causes by locality. Chapter 'The first wave: the Arab exodus, December 1947 – March 1948' (doi:10.1017/CBO9780511816659.007): its Cambridge Core summary read 29 Sept 2026: the AHC 'flatly rejected the resolution and any thought of partition'; 'the period December 1947 – March 1948 was marked by Arab initiatives and attacks and Jewish defensiveness, increasingly punctuated by Jewish reprisals'; 'The attackers never pretended to single out combatants'. The chapter body (pp. 65–162) is not read; the book's findings on Arab-ordered evacuations are still unchecked (bullet 3 ⚠).
historyEfraim Karsh, Palestine Betrayed (Yale University Press, 2010) (2010) finding ✓
Publisher's description read via OpenAlex (doi:10.12987/9780300169454), 29 Sept 2026: 'from the early 1920s onward, a corrupt and extremist leadership worked toward eliminating the Jewish national revival and protecting its own interests'; 'the majority of Palestinian Arabs yearned to live and thrive under peaceful coexistence with the evolving Jewish national enterprise'; sources: 'Western, Soviet, UN, and Israeli documents declassified over the past decade, as well as unfamiliar Arab sources'. The book itself is not read.
historyBenny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited (Cambridge University Press), 'Conclusion' — chapter summary on Cambridge Core (2004) finding ✓
Read 2026-10-01, Cambridge Core summary (DOI confirmed via Crossref; Cambridge gives print publication year 2003 for the chapter pages). 'The first Arab–Israeli war, of 1948, was launched by the Palestinian Arabs, who rejected the UN partition resolution and embarked on hostilities aimed at preventing the birth of Israel. That war and not design, Jewish or Arab, gave birth to the Palestinian refugee problem.' 'But the displacement of Arabs from Palestine or from the areas of Palestine that would become the Jewish State was inherent in Zionist ideology and, in microcosm, in Zionist praxis from the start of the enterprise'; 'the Zionist leaders' thinking about, and periodic endorsement of, "transfer" during those decades – voluntary and agreed, if possible, but coerced if not – readied hearts and minds for the denouement of 1948 and its immediate aftermath, in which some 700,000 Arabs were displaced from their homes (though the majority remained in Palestine).' 'But there was no pre-war Zionist plan to expel "the Arabs" from Palestine or the areas of the emergent Jewish State; and the Yishuv did not enter the war with a plan or policy of expulsion. Nor was the pre-war "transfer" thinking ever translated, in the course of the war, into an agreed, systematic policy of expulsion.' The chapter body is not read; the summary does not address Arab-ordered evacuations.
advocacy / viewKhalid al-Azm, Mudhakkarat (Memoirs), 3 vols., Beirut 1973 — as quoted by the Center for Online Judaic Studies (from J. E. Katz's compilation of refugee quotations) (1973) incident ✓
Center for Online Judaic Studies compilation (read, 2026-09-29): '…the call by the Arab governments to the inhabitants of Palestine to evacuate it and leave for the bordering Arab countries … We brought destruction upon a million Arab refugees by calling on them and pleading with them to leave their land.' Compared with the Arabic original (alazm-memoirs-arabic, 2026-09-29), the compilation's ellipsis falls where al-Azm writes that the call came 'after panic had spread in their ranks following the Deir Yassin incident'.
What's left out
Expulsions and massacres happened too, and return was then barred by policy.
People were expelled: from Lydda and Ramle (July 1948), where a civilian population 'numbering some 50,000' was driven out, by Yitzhak Rabin's own censored account (New York Times, 1979); villages were depopulated (more than 400 'destroyed or depopulated by Israel in 1948', as All That Remains describes its subject; see 'Israel is evil and illegitimate — it has no right to exist.'); the Deir Yassin massacre (April 1948) spread terror that drove flight elsewhere, as Syria's prime minister Khalid al-Azm wrote of the 'panic … following the Deir Yassin incident'. Whatever the cause of leaving, Israel then blocked return: in August 1948 Foreign Minister Moshe Shertok said return would be discussed only as part of a peace treaty, describing 'the Palestinian Arab exodus of 1948' as one of those 'cataclysmic phenomena' that change the course of history (NYT, 2 August 1948). The counts of villages emptied differ by definition: Benny Morris identified 369, Walid Khalidi's All That Remains (1992) listed 418, villages its publisher describes as 'destroyed or depopulated', and the advocacy body PLANDS now counts 531 localities (as PLANDS itself surveys the counts); how many were later razed is not separately sourced here ⚠; the Absentees' Property Law (1950) vested the property of 'absentees' (owners of property in Israel who, from 29 November 1947, had among other things left for a place outside Palestine before 1 September 1948 or for a place 'held at the time by forces which sought to prevent the establishment of the State of Israel') in a state Custodian, who could sell land only to a Development Authority. 'They left voluntarily' — even where true — doesn't answer why they could never come back. At the other end of the historians' debate, Walid Khalidi (from 1959–61) and Ilan Pappé (The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine, 2006) argue that expulsion was planned and systematic, with Plan Dalet as its blueprint (see 'The Nakba was a pre-planned ethnic cleansing'). Morris's conclusion sits between them: 'no pre-war Zionist plan to expel', but displacement 'inherent in Zionist ideology' and leaders' 'periodic endorsement of "transfer"'; how widespread the expulsions were, in his chapters, is not read here ⚠. Quotations like al-Azm's, written years later by a politician blaming other Arab governments, leave open the question that matters: were there local calls to evacuate in some places, or a general order to leave? Only the archives can answer it (see Morris) ⚠.
Traps here:◆ "They all…"◆ DARVO: deny, attack, reverse
newspaper'Bars Repatriation Now' by Gene Currivan (1948) incident ✓
Scan from the kvetch-of-the-day news archive.
NYT 1948-08-02; vision-verified; Shertok's reply to the UN Mediator.
law / courtAbsentees' Property Law, 5710-1950 (Israel), English text as hosted in Adalah's Discriminatory Laws Database (1950) ✓
Read 1 Oct 2026. s. 1(b): an 'absentee' is an owner of property in Israel who at any time from '29th November, 1947' until the end of the state of emergency was a national of Lebanon, Egypt, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Trans-Jordan, Iraq or Yemen, or was in one of those countries 'or in any part of Palestine outside the area of Israel', or 'left his ordinary place of residence in Palestine' for a place outside Palestine before 1 September 1948 or for a place 'held at the time by forces which sought to prevent the establishment of the State of Israel'; s. 2: the Minister of Finance appoints a Custodianship Council, whose chairman 'shall be called the Custodian'; s. 19: the Custodian may sell immovable vested property only to 'a Development Authority'. Hosted by Adalah, which lists it as discriminatory.
historyBenny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited (2004) finding
Archival standard work; multiple causes by locality. Chapter 'The first wave: the Arab exodus, December 1947 – March 1948' (doi:10.1017/CBO9780511816659.007): its Cambridge Core summary read 29 Sept 2026: the AHC 'flatly rejected the resolution and any thought of partition'; 'the period December 1947 – March 1948 was marked by Arab initiatives and attacks and Jewish defensiveness, increasingly punctuated by Jewish reprisals'; 'The attackers never pretended to single out combatants'. The chapter body (pp. 65–162) is not read; the book's findings on Arab-ordered evacuations are still unchecked (bullet 3 ⚠).
historyIlan Pappé, The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (Oneworld, 2006) (2006) finding ✓
Publisher's page read (2026-09-29): 'Between 1947 and 1949, over 400 Palestinian villages were deliberately destroyed, civilians were massacred and around a million men, women, and children were expelled from their homes at gunpoint.' Master-plan thesis; the book itself not read here. The 'around a million' exceeds the UNCCP's 1950 estimate (~711,000).
historyWalid Khalidi, 'Plan Dalet: Master Plan for the Conquest of Palestine', Journal of Palestine Studies 18(1) (1988), reprinting his 1961 article (1988) finding ✓
Read in full 2026-10-14 (JSTOR copy supplied by the editor). The 1988 issue reprints Khalidi's 1961 article ('The following is the text of Professor Khalidi's 1961 article … Reprinted with permission') with a new introduction and the plan's text in translation. Introduction (1988): 'Zionism's responsibility for the Palestinian exodus and diaspora is an integral part of the genesis of the State of Israel'; of Morris: he 'mentions discussions before 1948 in the highest Zionist circles of the "transfer" (euphemism for expulsion) of the Arab population, but he sees no link between this and Plan Dalet'. The 1961 text: Plan Dalet was 'the general plan for military operations within the framework of which the Zionists launched successive offensives in April and early May 1948', offensives 'which entailed the destruction of the Palestinian Arab community and the expulsion and pauperization of the bulk of the Palestine Arabs'. The plan's text as he prints it: 'Destruction of villages (setting fire to, blowing up, and planting mines in the debris), especially those population centers which are difficult to control continuously'; 'In the event of resistance, the armed force must be wiped out and the population must be expelled outside the borders of the state'; 'In the absence of resistance, garrison troops will enter the village'. A Palestinian historian, founder of the Institute for Palestine Studies.
pressThe New York Times, 'Israel Bars Rabin From Relating '48 Eviction of Arabs' (23 October 1979) (1979) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-29; archive text). A cabinet censorship board barred from Rabin's memoirs 'a first-person account of the expulsion of 50,000 Palestinian civilians'. Rabin: 'the fate of the civilian population of Lod and Ramle, numbering some 50,000'; 'Clearly, we could not leave Lod's hostile and armed populace in our rear'; 'Allon and I held a consultation. I agreed that it was essential to drive the inhabitants out'; 'Great suffering was inflicted upon the men taking part in the eviction action'; Rabin 'attributes the final decision on expulsion to David Ben-Gurion'. Other accounts (Kurzman) attributed it to residents 'opening fire … shortly after surrendering'; 'In some places, the Israelis expelled the Palestinians, while in others they encouraged them to stay.' Re-read 2026-10-12: 'in both "O Jerusalem" and "Genesis 1948" by Dan Kurzman, the eviction from Lod was attributed to the local residents' opening fire on the Israelis shortly after surrendering'; 'Throughout the rest of the country, however, the pattern was mixed. In some places, the Israelis expelled the Palestinians, while in others they encouraged them to stay.' Rabin: 'I agreed that it was essential to drive the inhabitants out.'
primary documentKhalid al-Azm, Mudhakkirat Khalid al-'Azm (Memoirs), vol. 1 (Beirut, 1973), chapter 'The era of independence in Syria' (archive.org scan, Arabic OCR) (1973) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-29; Arabic OCR, page number garbled). Item five of his list of Arab failures in 1948: «ومن هذا القبيل دعوة الحكومات العربية اهالي فلسطين الى الجلاء منها واللجوء الى البلاد العربية التاخمة، بعد بث الذعر في صفوفهم على اثر واقعة دير ياسين» ('the Arab governments' call to the people of Palestine to evacuate it and take refuge in the neighbouring Arab countries, after panic had spread in their ranks following the Deir Yassin incident'); «نحن نطالب منذ ١٩٤٨ باعادة اللاجئين الى ديارهم، ونحن الذين حملناهم على الخروج منها» ('since 1948 we demand the refugees' return, while it was we who made them leave'); «لقد قضينا على مليون لاجىء عربي، وذلك بدعوتهم والالحاح عليهم بترك ارضهم ودورهم وعملهم وصنعتهم». English renderings on this site. Al-Azm died in 1965; the memoir was published posthumously.
historyBenny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited (Cambridge University Press), 'Conclusion' — chapter summary on Cambridge Core (2004) finding ✓
Read 2026-10-01, Cambridge Core summary (DOI confirmed via Crossref; Cambridge gives print publication year 2003 for the chapter pages). 'The first Arab–Israeli war, of 1948, was launched by the Palestinian Arabs, who rejected the UN partition resolution and embarked on hostilities aimed at preventing the birth of Israel. That war and not design, Jewish or Arab, gave birth to the Palestinian refugee problem.' 'But the displacement of Arabs from Palestine or from the areas of Palestine that would become the Jewish State was inherent in Zionist ideology and, in microcosm, in Zionist praxis from the start of the enterprise'; 'the Zionist leaders' thinking about, and periodic endorsement of, "transfer" during those decades – voluntary and agreed, if possible, but coerced if not – readied hearts and minds for the denouement of 1948 and its immediate aftermath, in which some 700,000 Arabs were displaced from their homes (though the majority remained in Palestine).' 'But there was no pre-war Zionist plan to expel "the Arabs" from Palestine or the areas of the emergent Jewish State; and the Yishuv did not enter the war with a plan or policy of expulsion. Nor was the pre-war "transfer" thinking ever translated, in the course of the war, into an agreed, systematic policy of expulsion.' The chapter body is not read; the summary does not address Arab-ordered evacuations.
historyWalid Khalidi (ed.), All That Remains: The Palestinian Villages Occupied and Depopulated by Israel in 1948 (Institute for Palestine Studies, 1992) (1992) pattern ✓
Publisher's description as held by Open Library (read 2026-09-30): 'describes in detail the more than 400 Palestinian villages that were destroyed or depopulated by Israel in 1948'; research and text by Sharif S. Elmusa and Muhammad Ali Khalidi. A Palestinian research institute's reference work; the book itself not read here.
advocacy / viewPalestine Land Society (Salman Abu Sitta), 'Compilation of the Depopulated Villages List' aggregate ✓
Read (2026-09-29). Pro-Palestinian advocacy body; its framing: 'An expanded list of 531 localities ethnically cleansed during the 1948 Holocaust, exceeding in number previously published lists'. Surveys earlier counts: 'Morris identified 369 villages … and assigned the causes of exodus for most of them'; 'Walid Khalidi (1992) … listed 418 villages', with a 'clear definition' ('villages with a distinct identity'), excluding 'towns and places where no permanent structures … existed'. Only the counts and definitions are used on the site.
More context
How to talk about this.
Acknowledge first: many Palestinians did flee in 1948 out of fear, some on their leaders' advice, and in a war that followed the Arab leadership's rejection of partition and, from May 1948, an invasion by Arab states. Ask one question: 'whatever the reason they left, why weren't they allowed back?'; that part is on the record. Share one checkable thing: Israel's own decision in 1948 to bar the refugees' return before a peace, which its foreign minister, Moshe Shertok, wrote to the UN Mediator on 1 August 1948: 'we find ourselves unable to agree on their re-admission to the Israel-controlled areas … because of over-riding considerations bearing on our immediate security, the outcome of the present war and the stability of the future peace settlement'. What not to say: 'they all left voluntarily', which erases Lydda, Ramle and the expulsions documented by Israeli historians. From the other side: grant the documented cases of Arab leaders urging flight and the Arab states' war, then ask what a just answer for the refugees' descendants would be now.
primary documentUN Mediator on Palestine (Count Folke Bernadotte), Progress Report, A/648, 16 September 1948 — Annex II: letter from the Foreign Minister of the Provisional Government of Israel, 1 August 1948 (UNISPAL) (1948) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28). Shertok to the Mediator, Hakirya, 1 August 1948: 'we are not unmindful of the plight of the Arabs who, as a result of the present war, find themselves uprooted from their homes'; 'If, nevertheless, we find ourselves unable to agree on their re-admission to the Israel-controlled areas, it is because of over-riding considerations bearing on our immediate security, the outcome of the present war and the stability of the future peace settlement.' The Mediator's own view (part I, V): 'the right of these refugees to return to their homes at the earliest practical date should be established'.
Where it leads if pressed
Working it out: three questions the slogan runs together.
'They left voluntarily' answers three different questions at once, and the evidence on each is different. Why did people leave? The record shows several causes, varying by place: in Haifa, Arab leaders chose evacuation; Syria's prime minister wrote that Arab governments called on Palestinians to leave 'after panic had spread … following the Deir Yassin incident'; at Lydda and Ramle, by Yitzhak Rabin's own censored account, a population 'numbering some 50,000' was driven out. Benny Morris, after the archives, concludes that 'war and not design, Jewish or Arab, gave birth to the Palestinian refugee problem', while also writing that 'transfer' thinking 'readied hearts and minds' for 1948, and that there was no 'agreed, systematic policy of expulsion'. Others, such as Walid Khalidi and Ilan Pappé, argue for planned expulsion. How many places, by which cause? The counts depend on definitions: Morris identified 369 villages and assigned causes for most; Khalidi listed 418 'villages with a distinct identity'; an advocacy list counts 531 localities. A single cause cannot be read off any of them. Why could they not return? Here the record is not in dispute: on 1 August 1948 Israel's foreign minister told the UN mediator that Israel was 'unable to agree on their re-admission … because of over-riding considerations bearing on our immediate security', and the 1950 Absentees' Property Law placed their property under Israeli control. The worst case for each side. For 'they left voluntarily': take every case of Arab-ordered evacuation at face value; Lydda and Ramle still happened, by an Israeli prime minister's own account, and Plan Dalet itself provided that 'in the event of resistance … the population must be expelled outside the borders of the state' (see 'The Nakba was a pre-planned ethnic cleansing — Plan Dalet was the blueprint.'). For 'it was a planned expulsion': take the strongest documented expulsions; the leading Israeli archival historian still finds no agreed, systematic policy, the Arab-ordered evacuations are on the record too, and the war removed Jewish communities where Arab forces won: when the Old City's Jewish Quarter surrendered in 1948, about 2,000 women, children, old and religious people were evacuated to the Jewish side and 300 men taken to Amman as prisoners (US consular cable), and the four Etzion kibbutzim were destroyed after the massacre of 127 at Kfar Etzion (Jewish Virtual Library). Holds on the evidence here: flight had several causes, including expulsions and Arab-ordered evacuations; return was then barred by Israeli policy. Arguable, as historians argue: that expulsion was more central than Morris allows, or less. Not supported: that all left voluntarily, or that all were expelled under a master plan.
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean
newspaper'Arabs to End Haifa Evacuation' (UP) (1948) incident ✓
Scan from the kvetch-of-the-day news archive.
NYT 1948-04-26; vision-verified. Image re-read 2026-10-12 ('Arabs to End Haifa Evacuation', HAIFA, April 25 (UP)): 'The Jews who captured this city on Thursday won a victory of peace today when Arab leaders tentatively agreed to stop evacuating their people. It was believed that between 15,000 and 20,000 Arabs still were in the city, out of more than 60,000. Police reported that about 700 had returned today from outlying districts to which they had fled.'
advocacy / viewKhalid al-Azm, Mudhakkarat (Memoirs), 3 vols., Beirut 1973 — as quoted by the Center for Online Judaic Studies (from J. E. Katz's compilation of refugee quotations) (1973) incident ✓
Center for Online Judaic Studies compilation (read, 2026-09-29): '…the call by the Arab governments to the inhabitants of Palestine to evacuate it and leave for the bordering Arab countries … We brought destruction upon a million Arab refugees by calling on them and pleading with them to leave their land.' Compared with the Arabic original (alazm-memoirs-arabic, 2026-09-29), the compilation's ellipsis falls where al-Azm writes that the call came 'after panic had spread in their ranks following the Deir Yassin incident'.
pressThe New York Times, 'Israel Bars Rabin From Relating '48 Eviction of Arabs' (23 October 1979) (1979) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-29; archive text). A cabinet censorship board barred from Rabin's memoirs 'a first-person account of the expulsion of 50,000 Palestinian civilians'. Rabin: 'the fate of the civilian population of Lod and Ramle, numbering some 50,000'; 'Clearly, we could not leave Lod's hostile and armed populace in our rear'; 'Allon and I held a consultation. I agreed that it was essential to drive the inhabitants out'; 'Great suffering was inflicted upon the men taking part in the eviction action'; Rabin 'attributes the final decision on expulsion to David Ben-Gurion'. Other accounts (Kurzman) attributed it to residents 'opening fire … shortly after surrendering'; 'In some places, the Israelis expelled the Palestinians, while in others they encouraged them to stay.' Re-read 2026-10-12: 'in both "O Jerusalem" and "Genesis 1948" by Dan Kurzman, the eviction from Lod was attributed to the local residents' opening fire on the Israelis shortly after surrendering'; 'Throughout the rest of the country, however, the pattern was mixed. In some places, the Israelis expelled the Palestinians, while in others they encouraged them to stay.' Rabin: 'I agreed that it was essential to drive the inhabitants out.'
historyBenny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited (Cambridge University Press), 'Conclusion' — chapter summary on Cambridge Core (2004) finding ✓
Read 2026-10-01, Cambridge Core summary (DOI confirmed via Crossref; Cambridge gives print publication year 2003 for the chapter pages). 'The first Arab–Israeli war, of 1948, was launched by the Palestinian Arabs, who rejected the UN partition resolution and embarked on hostilities aimed at preventing the birth of Israel. That war and not design, Jewish or Arab, gave birth to the Palestinian refugee problem.' 'But the displacement of Arabs from Palestine or from the areas of Palestine that would become the Jewish State was inherent in Zionist ideology and, in microcosm, in Zionist praxis from the start of the enterprise'; 'the Zionist leaders' thinking about, and periodic endorsement of, "transfer" during those decades – voluntary and agreed, if possible, but coerced if not – readied hearts and minds for the denouement of 1948 and its immediate aftermath, in which some 700,000 Arabs were displaced from their homes (though the majority remained in Palestine).' 'But there was no pre-war Zionist plan to expel "the Arabs" from Palestine or the areas of the emergent Jewish State; and the Yishuv did not enter the war with a plan or policy of expulsion. Nor was the pre-war "transfer" thinking ever translated, in the course of the war, into an agreed, systematic policy of expulsion.' The chapter body is not read; the summary does not address Arab-ordered evacuations.
historyWalid Khalidi, 'Plan Dalet: Master Plan for the Conquest of Palestine', Journal of Palestine Studies 18(1) (1988), reprinting his 1961 article (1988) finding ✓
Read in full 2026-10-14 (JSTOR copy supplied by the editor). The 1988 issue reprints Khalidi's 1961 article ('The following is the text of Professor Khalidi's 1961 article … Reprinted with permission') with a new introduction and the plan's text in translation. Introduction (1988): 'Zionism's responsibility for the Palestinian exodus and diaspora is an integral part of the genesis of the State of Israel'; of Morris: he 'mentions discussions before 1948 in the highest Zionist circles of the "transfer" (euphemism for expulsion) of the Arab population, but he sees no link between this and Plan Dalet'. The 1961 text: Plan Dalet was 'the general plan for military operations within the framework of which the Zionists launched successive offensives in April and early May 1948', offensives 'which entailed the destruction of the Palestinian Arab community and the expulsion and pauperization of the bulk of the Palestine Arabs'. The plan's text as he prints it: 'Destruction of villages (setting fire to, blowing up, and planting mines in the debris), especially those population centers which are difficult to control continuously'; 'In the event of resistance, the armed force must be wiped out and the population must be expelled outside the borders of the state'; 'In the absence of resistance, garrison troops will enter the village'. A Palestinian historian, founder of the Institute for Palestine Studies.
historyIlan Pappé, The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (Oneworld, 2006) (2006) finding ✓
Publisher's page read (2026-09-29): 'Between 1947 and 1949, over 400 Palestinian villages were deliberately destroyed, civilians were massacred and around a million men, women, and children were expelled from their homes at gunpoint.' Master-plan thesis; the book itself not read here. The 'around a million' exceeds the UNCCP's 1950 estimate (~711,000).
advocacy / viewPalestine Land Society (Salman Abu Sitta), 'Compilation of the Depopulated Villages List' aggregate ✓
Read (2026-09-29). Pro-Palestinian advocacy body; its framing: 'An expanded list of 531 localities ethnically cleansed during the 1948 Holocaust, exceeding in number previously published lists'. Surveys earlier counts: 'Morris identified 369 villages … and assigned the causes of exodus for most of them'; 'Walid Khalidi (1992) … listed 418 villages', with a 'clear definition' ('villages with a distinct identity'), excluding 'towns and places where no permanent structures … existed'. Only the counts and definitions are used on the site.
primary documentUN Mediator on Palestine (Count Folke Bernadotte), Progress Report, A/648, 16 September 1948 — Annex II: letter from the Foreign Minister of the Provisional Government of Israel, 1 August 1948 (UNISPAL) (1948) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28). Shertok to the Mediator, Hakirya, 1 August 1948: 'we are not unmindful of the plight of the Arabs who, as a result of the present war, find themselves uprooted from their homes'; 'If, nevertheless, we find ourselves unable to agree on their re-admission to the Israel-controlled areas, it is because of over-riding considerations bearing on our immediate security, the outcome of the present war and the stability of the future peace settlement.' The Mediator's own view (part I, V): 'the right of these refugees to return to their homes at the earliest practical date should be established'.
law / courtAbsentees' Property Law, 5710-1950 (Israel), English text as hosted in Adalah's Discriminatory Laws Database (1950) ✓
Read 1 Oct 2026. s. 1(b): an 'absentee' is an owner of property in Israel who at any time from '29th November, 1947' until the end of the state of emergency was a national of Lebanon, Egypt, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Trans-Jordan, Iraq or Yemen, or was in one of those countries 'or in any part of Palestine outside the area of Israel', or 'left his ordinary place of residence in Palestine' for a place outside Palestine before 1 September 1948 or for a place 'held at the time by forces which sought to prevent the establishment of the State of Israel'; s. 2: the Minister of Finance appoints a Custodianship Council, whose chairman 'shall be called the Custodian'; s. 19: the Custodian may sell immovable vested property only to 'a Development Authority'. Hosted by Adalah, which lists it as discriminatory.
primary documentPlan Dalet (Plan D), General Section, 10 March 1948, translated from Sefer Toldot Hahaganah, vol. 3 (1972), Appendix 48, as published by PalQuest (Institute for Palestine Studies) (1948) ✓
Read (2026-09-29). Objective: 'to gain control of the areas of the Hebrew state and defend its borders', and of Jewish settlements outside them. Section on 'operations against enemy population centers located inside or near our defensive system in order to prevent them from being used as bases by an active armed force': 'Destruction of villages (setting fire to, blowing up, and planting mines in the debris), especially those population centers which are difficult to control continuously'; combing operations: 'In the event of resistance, the armed force must be destroyed and the population must be expelled outside the borders of the state … In the absence of resistance, garrison troops will enter the village and take up positions in it'. Translation published by a Palestinian research institute; the Hebrew source is the Haganah's official history.
primary documentForeign Relations of the United States, 1948, vol. V part 2, doc. 345: telegram from the Vice Consul at Jerusalem (Burdett) to the Secretary of State, 29 May 1948 (1948) incident ✓
Read 29 Sept 2026 (Office of the Historian). 'Terms surrender of Jews in Old City are: 1. Approximately 2000 women, children, old and religious people to be evacuated to Jewish quarters new Jerusalem under supervision International Red Cross. 2. Three hundred men of military age to be taken prisoners of war to Amman.' Abdullah el-Tel reported firing during the evacuation; 'Azcarate of United Nations who was in Old City at time told Consulate General that Arab Legion had carried out evacuation efficiently and according surrender agreement.'
referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Israeli War of Independence: The Battle For Gush Etzion (1947–1948)' ✓
Read 29 Sept 2026. Perspective: JVL is a project of the American-Israeli Cooperative Enterprise. 'On Friday, the day that the state was proclaimed, they could no longer hold out. They surrendered. In the massacre of Kfar Etzion, the Arabs murdered 127 men and women.' 'The remainder were taken prisoner to Transjordan. The four kibbutzim were totally destroyed.' 'Two hundred and forty settlers, Haganah and Palmah fighters were killed at the Etzion Bloc during five-and-a-half months of war.'
The Nakba happened; the question is what's owed now.
The expulsions at Lydda and Ramle, and others documented by Israeli historians, rule out 'they all left voluntarily'; the causes of the wider flight are argued over (see above). Acknowledging them doesn't settle the political question — how many can return where, compensation, and the parallel Jewish exodus from Arab lands (see 'UNRWA keeps millions of Palestinians as refugees forever — a problem kept alive on purpose.', 'There was a Jewish Nakba too — it was a population exchange, so the Palestinian refugee question is settled.'). It is the starting point for answering it.
The usual reply — and its own traps
Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.
heard from pro-Palestinian voices“The Nakba was a pre-planned ethnic cleansing — Plan Dalet was the blueprint.”Where this argument points
This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions — for, against or around them:
On the timeline
Keep exploring
From the archive
How newspapers reported related events at the time — suggested by the archive's own tags, not yet reviewed for this argument. Open a scan and judge for yourself.
1948-04-23 · The New York Times · ✓Jews Seize Haifa in Furious Battle; Arabs Agree to Go
1948-08-03 · The New York Times · ✓British Offer Aid to Arab Refugees
1948-08-10 · The New York Times · ✓IRO Shuns Problem of Arab Refugees
1949-04-08 · The New York Times · ✓Arab Leaders in Appeal
1949-08-06 · The New York TimesIsrael to Resettle Arab Refugees Before Actual Accord is SignedScans: kvetch-of-the-day news archive.

