Argument · heard from pro-Israel voices

“There was a Jewish Nakba too — it was a population exchange, so the Palestinian refugee question is settled.”

Around 850,000 Jews left Arab countries as ~700,000 Palestinians left Israel; the two displacements cancel out, and Palestinians should be absorbed by Arab states as the Jews were by Israel.

Made publicly as a pro-Israel argument by Zvi Gabay

Where it's been said

Context
“Whereas it would be inappropriate and unjust for the United States to recognize rights for Palestinian refugees without recognizing equal rights for Jewish refugees from Arab countries … for any comprehensive Middle East peace agreement to be credible and enduring, the agreement must address and resolve all outstanding issues relating to the legitimate rights of all refugees, including Jews, Christians, and other populations, displaced from countries in the Middle East”
US House of Representatives, H.Res. 185 (110th Congress), non-binding 'sense of the House' resolution, passed 1 April 2008 — Engrossed text (GovInfo) — the parity version: both refugee groups must be resolved, not one cancelling the other, 2008-04-01 ✓
“Ostensibly, a population exchange took place between the State of Israel and the Arab states, as population exchanges took place between India and Pakistan. But the Arab states, directed by the Arab League, prevent recognition of this and a humane solution to a problem they themselves created.”
Zvi Gabay, writing on the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs website — 'A just solution to the Middle East refugee problem', JCPA Hebrew site (blog), 11 September 2012, responding to Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon's initiative; our translation. The same text says 856,000 Jews fled and '650,000 Palestinians abandoned the firing positions and their homes'., 2012-09-11 ✓

Traps in play:◆ "What about you?"

  1. Why people find it convincing

    • The numbers are comparable: the US House of Representatives resolved in 2008 that 'approximately 850,000 Jews have been displaced from Arab countries since the declaration of the State of Israel in 1948' (H.Res. 185), against the UN's 1950 estimate of about 711,000 Palestinian refugees (Conciliation Commission). Both displacements followed the 1948 war, though the Jewish figure covers departures spread over the following decades.
    • Its advocates argue the Jewish exodus was not a scatter of local events but one policy set off by the war: in May 1948 the New York Times reported an Arab League draft law under which Jews in Arab states would be treated as 'members of the Jewish minority state of Palestine', with their accounts frozen and suspected Zionists interned (NYT, 16 May 1948). The text itself survives as the World Jewish Congress sent it to the British Foreign Office on 22 January 1948 ('Text of Law drafted by Political Committee of Arab League': Jewish citizens to be registered 'as members of the Jewish minority State of Palestine', 'bank accounts of Jews will be frozen', 'an active Zionist … will be interned'). The WJC said the draft had, 'we are informed', been 'drawn up and submitted to the Moslem countries by the Arab League'; an Arab League copy is not found here ⚠. The Foreign Office official who minuted the letter wrote: 'We have no knowledge of the enclosure … I suggest that he should be asked for the source of his information. Nor have we any evidence that measures of this kind have been taken or are contemplated in any Arab State', while listing travel restrictions on Jews in Syria and Lebanon and 'some destruction of Jewish property in Aleppo' after the partition vote.. If the Arab states tied their Jews' fate to Palestine, the argument goes, the two displacements belong in one ledger — as the US House said in 2008, it would be 'inappropriate and unjust' to recognise rights for Palestinian refugees 'without recognizing equal rights for Jewish refugees from Arab countries' (H.Res. 185).
    • Jewish refugees from Arab lands lost homes and property, and no UN agency was created for them, though the UN refugee office did treat some as refugees: in February 1957 High Commissioner Auguste Lindt told the UN Refugee Fund that 'those refugees from Egypt who are not able, or not willing to avail themselves of the protection of the Government of their nationality fall under the mandate of my office' (his words name refugees from Egypt, not Jews as such), and in July 1967 a UNHCR letter said that 'Jews from Middle Eastern and North African countries' could 'be considered prima facie within the mandate of this Office' (both as quoted by JIMENA, Jews Indigenous to the Middle East and North Africa; UNHCR's own copies were not reachable ⚠).
    • Population exchanges ended some mid-20th-century conflicts (Greece–Turkey 1923, India–Pakistan 1947).
    • Israel absorbed its refugees, often in harsh transit camps; some Arab states kept Palestinians stateless: by Human Rights Watch's account (c. 2000), Syria 'maintained the stateless status of its Palestinians but has afforded them the same economic and social rights enjoyed by Syrian citizens', and in Lebanon 'hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are stateless', while in Jordan most 'have citizenship'.
  2. What's true

    The Jewish exodus was real and large — some 850,000 people who left or were driven from Arab countries.

    A 2008 US House resolution counts 'approximately 850,000 Jews' 'displaced from Arab countries since the declaration of the State of Israel in 1948' (H.Res. 185; see 'Jews lived peacefully in the Arab world for centuries until Zionism ruined it; they left because Israel lured them.'). Lyn Julius, author of Uprooted (2018), states the framing in her own words: 'the Jewish nakba' was 'the expulsion of 870,000 Mizrahi Jews from Arab and Muslim countries. The two nakbas took place around the same time and in roughly similar numbers. In effect, it was a population exchange' (JNS, 25 July 2023). The facts of the exodus stand on their own; the 'exchange' conclusion drawn from them is what the next note questions.

    advocacy / viewLyn Julius, 'The distorted "nakba" narrative', JNS (opinion, 25 July 2023) (2023) ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. 'the Jewish nakba. The latter was the expulsion of 870,000 Mizrahi Jews from Arab and Muslim countries. The two nakbas took place around the same time and in roughly similar numbers. In effect, it was a population exchange'; Mizrahi Jews and descendants 'more than half of Israeli Jews today'; they 'do not have the ability, legal right or desire to return'. Opens with Diaspora Minister Amichai Chikli's remarks on the nakba; the column's subhead reads 'Comparisons to the Holocaust are misleading and appalling'. Author's byline (as recorded when the book card was made): author of Uprooted (Vallentine Mitchell, 2018); the book itself is not read.

    Open source ↗

    primary documentUS House of Representatives, H.Res. 185 (110th Congress), engrossed text, 1 April 2008 (2008) ✓

    Read (GovInfo PDF): 'it would be inappropriate and unjust for the United States to recognize rights for Palestinian refugees without recognizing equal rights for Jewish refugees from Arab countries'; a deal must resolve the rights 'of all refugees'. Also: 'Whereas approximately 850,000 Jews have been displaced from Arab countries since the declaration of the State of Israel in 1948'.

    Open source ↗

  3. What's left out

    It wasn't an agreed exchange, the victims are different people, and some Mizrahim reject the framing.

    No treaty exchanged these populations; each displacement happened to different people, who each lost their own homes. A Palestinian family from Jaffa was not compensated by an Iraqi Jewish family's arrival in Israel, and vice versa. The refugee label was contested among Jews from Arab countries in Israel themselves: in 1975 Knesset Speaker Yisrael Yeshayahu said 'We did not want to call ourselves refugees … We had messianic aspirations', and the Tunisia-born Knesset member Mathilda Gez asked, 'If we appear as refugees, how can we go before them and talk about immigration based on the Zionist idea …' Yehouda Shenhav of Tel Aviv University, who quotes both, notes that the exchange thesis, put forward 'primarily in order to contest the claim of the Palestinian national movement to the right of return', 'was not fully compatible' with the claim that Jews 'lived under the protection of Islam for thousands of years' (British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, 2002). The Greece–Turkey exchange rested on a treaty: the 1923 Lausanne convention, under which 'there shall take place a compulsory exchange' of Greek Orthodox Turkish nationals and Muslim Greek nationals, who 'shall not return to live in Turkey or Greece respectively without the authorization' of the government (Art. 1); India–Pakistan rested on a partition by Act of Parliament ('two independent Dominions shall be set up in India, to be known respectively as India and Pakistan', Indian Independence Act 1947, s. 1), whose text, as read here, contains no provision for moving populations; and no agreement between Israel and the Arab states covering these two displacements is cited by the exchange thesis's proponents quoted here.

    Traps here:◆ "What about you?"

    historyYehouda Shenhav, 'Jews from Arab Countries and the Palestinian Right for Return: An Ethnic Community in Realms of National Memory', British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies 29(1): 27–56 (2002) — author's copy on McGill's Palestinian Refugee ResearchNet (2002) finding ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. On WOJAC's three theses (primordiality, population exchange, property exchange, 'formulated in the mid-1970's'); the exchange thesis 'adduced … primarily in order to contest the claim of the Palestinian national movement to the right of return'; 'not fully compatible with the primordiality thesis'; Yaakov Meron's expulsion thesis ('an Arab policy of expulsion'); Yeshayahu (29 May 1975) and Mathilda Gez quoted against the refugee label. The author's 2006 book The Arab Jews (the card's earlier title) is not read. Re-read 2026-10-12: Knesset Speaker Yisrael Yeshayahu (29 May 1975): '... We did not want to call ourselves refugees. We came to this country before the establishment of the state, too...'; Mathilda Gez: 'If we appear as refugees, how can we go before them and talk about immigration based on the Zionist idea...'; the primordiality thesis 'sought to demonstrate that Jews lived under the protection of Islam for thousands of years, whereas the refugee thesis emphasized the opposite'.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtConvention Concerning the Exchange of Greek and Turkish Populations (Lausanne, 30 January 1923), Wikisource transcription (1923) ✓

    Read 2026-10-01 via the Wikisource MediaWiki API (the web page showed a captcha; the API was used with an honest user-agent, as for Wikiquote earlier). Preamble: 'The Government of the Grand National Assembly of Turkey and the Greek Government have agreed upon the following provisions'. Art. 1: 'As from the 1st May, 1923, there shall take place a compulsory exchange of Turkish nationals of the Greek Orthodox religion established in Turkish territory, and of Greek nationals of the Muslim religion established in Greek territory. These persons shall not return to live in Turkey or Greece respectively without the authorization of the Turkish Government or of the Greek Government respectively.' Art. 2 exempts 'The Greek inhabitants of Constantinople' among others. A public-domain treaty text, transcribed.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtIndian Independence Act 1947 (10 & 11 Geo. 6 c. 30), as enacted, legislation.gov.uk (1947) ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. Long title: 'An Act to make provision for the setting up in India of two independent Dominions'. S. 1(1): 'As from the fifteenth day of August, nineteen hundred and forty-seven, two independent Dominions shall be set up in India, to be known respectively as India and Pakistan.' Bengal and the Punjab each divided into two new provinces (ss. 3–4). A search of the enacted text for 'population' and 'exchange' found no provision for moving populations.

    Open source ↗

  4. More context

    Reading the numbers

    The 'exchange' argument rests on two numbers being 'roughly similar'. Read side by side, they are of the same order, but they measure different things. (1) The figures: the UN Conciliation Commission's statistical expert estimated Palestinian refugees from Israel-held territory at 'approximately 711,000' in 1950; the US House resolution of 2008 counts 'approximately 850,000 Jews' 'displaced from Arab countries since the declaration of the State of Israel in 1948'; Lyn Julius gives 870,000. 850,000 is about 1.2 times 711,000 (this page's arithmetic). A count from the time shows how much the frame matters: a World Jewish Congress memorandum of January 1948, reported by the New York Times, tabulated 'Jewish residents in Arab countries' at a 'Total … 899,000', but the list also counts Iran (90,000), Turkey (75,000) and Afghanistan (5,000); without those three it is 729,000 (this page's arithmetic), and it counts residents, not people displaced. (2) The windows: the first figure counts people displaced within about two years of 1948; the second counts departures 'since' 1948, over the following decades. Comparing them compares one wave with a long outflow. (3) The sources: one is a UN technical estimate made at the time; the other is a figure adopted in a political resolution sixty years later. Each can be right, but they were not produced by the same method. (4) What an exchange requires: the 1923 Greek–Turkish exchange, an exchange in the treaty sense, began with 'The Government of the Grand National Assembly of Turkey and the Greek Government have agreed upon the following provisions'; no such agreement covered 1948 and after. The worst case for each side. For 'it cancels out': take the larger Jewish figure; the numbers being similar does not make the losses interchangeable, no treaty made them so, and even the push factors are contested in places: the 1950–51 Baghdad bombings that preceded the mass departure from Iraq have had their authorship 'publicly contested for 75 years, with two Israeli official commissions of inquiry', and the historian Avi Shlaim attributes three of the five to the Zionist underground (Middle East Eye's review of his memoir). For 'the Jewish exodus was minor': take the smaller Palestinian figure; on either count the Jewish exodus was of the same order, and Iraq's 1950 terms, among others, show it was not simply voluntary; a draft law circulated in 1948 under the Arab League's name would have treated Jews 'as members of the Jewish minority State of Palestine', with bank accounts frozen (NYT, 16 May 1948; the text is the World Jewish Congress's copy, and the Foreign Office minuted that it had 'no knowledge of the enclosure'); the pressure also predates Israel: in the Farhud in Baghdad in 1941, rioters 'murdered between 150 and 180 Jews', by the US Holocaust Memorial Museum's account (an official commission counted 128). Holds on every reading: both displacements were real and large, of the same order of magnitude. Could happen only with an agreed framework: treating them together, as President Clinton suggested in 2000. Not supported by any reading: that one cancels the other, or that the numbers alone make it an exchange (see 'Reading war numbers').

    What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean

    primary documentUN Conciliation Commission for Palestine, General Progress Report and Supplementary Report (11 December 1949 – 23 October 1950), UNISPAL copy (1950) aggregate ✓

    Read (2026-09-29). 'The estimate of the statistical expert, which the Committee believes to be as accurate as circumstances permit, indicates that the refugees from Israel-controlled territory amount to approximately 711,000. The fact that there is a higher number of relief recipients appears to be due among other things to duplication of ration cards, addition of persons who have been displaced from area other than Israel-held areas and of persons who, although not displaced, are destitute.'

    Open source ↗

    primary documentUS House of Representatives, H.Res. 185 (110th Congress), engrossed text, 1 April 2008 (2008) ✓

    Read (GovInfo PDF): 'it would be inappropriate and unjust for the United States to recognize rights for Palestinian refugees without recognizing equal rights for Jewish refugees from Arab countries'; a deal must resolve the rights 'of all refugees'. Also: 'Whereas approximately 850,000 Jews have been displaced from Arab countries since the declaration of the State of Israel in 1948'.

    Open source ↗

    advocacy / viewLyn Julius, 'The distorted "nakba" narrative', JNS (opinion, 25 July 2023) (2023) ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. 'the Jewish nakba. The latter was the expulsion of 870,000 Mizrahi Jews from Arab and Muslim countries. The two nakbas took place around the same time and in roughly similar numbers. In effect, it was a population exchange'; Mizrahi Jews and descendants 'more than half of Israeli Jews today'; they 'do not have the ability, legal right or desire to return'. Opens with Diaspora Minister Amichai Chikli's remarks on the nakba; the column's subhead reads 'Comparisons to the Holocaust are misleading and appalling'. Author's byline (as recorded when the book card was made): author of Uprooted (Vallentine Mitchell, 2018); the book itself is not read.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtConvention Concerning the Exchange of Greek and Turkish Populations (Lausanne, 30 January 1923), Wikisource transcription (1923) ✓

    Read 2026-10-01 via the Wikisource MediaWiki API (the web page showed a captcha; the API was used with an honest user-agent, as for Wikiquote earlier). Preamble: 'The Government of the Grand National Assembly of Turkey and the Greek Government have agreed upon the following provisions'. Art. 1: 'As from the 1st May, 1923, there shall take place a compulsory exchange of Turkish nationals of the Greek Orthodox religion established in Turkish territory, and of Greek nationals of the Muslim religion established in Greek territory. These persons shall not return to live in Turkey or Greece respectively without the authorization of the Turkish Government or of the Greek Government respectively.' Art. 2 exempts 'The Greek inhabitants of Constantinople' among others. A public-domain treaty text, transcribed.

    Open source ↗

    primary documentUS House of Representatives, H.Res. 185 (110th Congress), introduced text (2007) (2007) ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). Quotes President Clinton 'in an interview after Camp David II in July 2000': 'There will have to be some sort of international fund set up for the refugees. There is, I think, some interest, interestingly enough, on both sides, in also having a fund which compensates the Israelis who were made refugees by the war, which occurred after the birth of the State of Israel.' (The interview itself is not read here; his 7 January 2001 remarks, read on the Clinton White House archive, say 'All refugees should receive compensation from the international community for their losses'.)

    Open source ↗

    pressGene Currivan, 'Ready to Aid Iraqi Jews' (Special to The New York Times) (1950) incident ✓

    NYT 1950-03-18 (dateline Tel Aviv, March 17); vision-verified 2026-10-01 from the archive's scan. 'the decision of Iraq to permit the departure of her Jews, of whom 60,000 are prepared to leave immediately'; the Jewish Agency 'prepared to receive at least 20,000 at once'; 'It is considered extremely unlikely that all of Iraq's 150,000 Jews intend to emigrate'; 'Israel is committed to a program of accepting all those who must come because of pressure upon them in their countries. Those who are not subject to persecution will be asked to bide their time'; 'Under the arrangement made by the Iraqi Government all those who left for Israel would first be forced to renounce their citizenship … if they did not sell their property before making such a declaration they would have no claim to it thereafter.'

    historyThe Farhud, Baghdad, 1–2 June 1941 (1941) incident ✓

    USHMM Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'The Farhud' (read 30 Sept 2026): 'rioters murdered between 150 and 180 Jews, injured 600 others'; 'According to the official report of the commission investigating the incident, 128 Jews were killed, 210 were injured'; 'about 135,000 Jews lived in Iraq (nearly 3 percent of the total population), with about 90,000 in Baghdad'. The Jews' share of Baghdad's population is not given there. Also: about 1,500 stores and homes looted; the official commission's report: 128 killed, 210 injured. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Other Arab nationalists also perceived the Baghdad Jews as Zionists or Zionist sympathizers and justified the attacks as a response to Arab-Jewish conflict in Palestine. Nevertheless, killing helpless Jews, including women and children, was an unprecedented phenomenon that contradicted Muslim law. In this situation, antisemitic ideology, derived in part from Nazi propaganda, helped to legitimize murdering Jews in Iraq.'

    Open source ↗

    advocacy / viewMiddle East Eye, review of Avi Shlaim, 'Three Worlds: Memoirs of an Arab-Jew' (12 July 2023) (2023) ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). The Zionist underground 'active since 1942 in the aftermath of the barbaric Farhud'; the five bombings' authorship 'publicly contested for 75 years, with two Israeli official commissions of inquiry'; Shlaim: 'three of the five bombings were the work of the Zionist underground'; Yusuf Ibrahim Basri 'recruited and trained by the Mossad', hanged January 1952; the first bombing attributed to Istiqlal 'tentatively'; the synagogue grenade (four killed) described as the revenge of an Iraqi criminal.

    Open source ↗

    newspaper'Jews in Grave Danger in All Moslem Lands' (incl. map, and sub-article 'Nine Hundred Thousand in Africa and Asia Face Wrath of Their Foes') (1948) pattern ✓

    The New York Times · 1948-05-16 · checked against the scan

    Newspaper clipping scanNewspaper clipping scanNewspaper clipping scanNewspaper clipping scan

    Scan from the kvetch-of-the-day news archive.

    NYT 1948-05-16; vision-verified; WJC figures are an advocacy source. Images re-read 2026-10-12 (4 parts, Mallory Browne): 'Nearly 900,000 Jews live in these Moslem and Arab countries'; the World Jewish Congress memorandum of 19 Jan 1948 tabulated 'Jewish residents in Arab countries' to a 'Total … 899,000', a list that also counts Iran (90,000), Turkey (75,000) and Afghanistan (5,000); the Arab League political committee's draft law: Jews 'would be considered "members of the Jewish minority state of Palestine"', bank accounts frozen; Iraq: no Jew may leave 'unless he deposits £5,000 ($20,000)'.

    primary documentUK National Archives, FO 371/68367: World Jewish Congress (A. L. Easterman) to the Foreign Office, 22 January 1948, enclosing the 'Text of Law drafted by Political Committee of Arab League' and the WJC memorandum to ECOSOC (archive.org scan) (1948) incident ✓

    Read (2026-09-29; OCR of FO 371/68367, part 5). Covering letter: 'This Draft Law has, we are informed, been drawn up and submitted to the Moslem countries by the Arab League.' Enclosed text: registration of Jewish citizens 'as members of the Jewish minority State of Palestine' within seven days; 'bank accounts of Jews will be frozen' to finance 'resistance to Zionist ambitions in Palestine'; foreign Jews to leave or serve in Arab armies; 'an active Zionist will be considered as a political prisoner and will be interned', his resources 'confiscated'; Jews who prove themselves anti-Zionist 'free to act as he likes, provided that he declares his readiness to join the Arab armies'. It is the WJC's copy, not an Arab League original. Foreign Office minute on the same file (February 1948, signature illegible in the OCR): 'We have no knowledge of the enclosure to Mr. Easterman's letter. I suggest that he should be asked for the source of his information. Nor have we any evidence that measures of this kind have been taken or are contemplated in any Arab State'; it lists permits for Jews to cross the Syrian–Lebanese frontier or leave Lebanon, Jewish students at the American University of Beirut ordered to leave, violence in Aden and 'some destruction of Jewish property in Aleppo immediately after the vote'.

    Open source ↗

    How to talk about this.

    Acknowledge first: around 850,000 Jews left or were driven out of Arab countries after 1948, lost property and homes. Ask one question: 'does one people's loss cancel another's, or are both owed an answer?'; neither expulsion undoes the other. Share one checkable thing: Iraq's 1950 terms, under which Jews leaving for Israel 'would first be forced to renounce their citizenship' and lose unsold property (NYT, 18 March 1950; see 'Jews lived peacefully in the Arab world for centuries until Zionism ruined it; they left because Israel lured them.'). What not to say: 'it was a population exchange, so we're even', which the Palestinians who lost their homes never agreed to. From the other side: grant the Jewish refugees fully, then ask why Palestinian refugees' descendants are still refugees more than seventy-five years later. Part of the answer lies with the host states, which differ: around 2000 Human Rights Watch found that in Jordan 'most of the 1.5 million Palestinians have citizenship and are well integrated', while 'In Lebanon, in sharp contrast, hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are stateless and over half live in overcrowded camps.'

    primary documentUS House of Representatives, H.Res. 185 (110th Congress), engrossed text, 1 April 2008 (2008) ✓

    Read (GovInfo PDF): 'it would be inappropriate and unjust for the United States to recognize rights for Palestinian refugees without recognizing equal rights for Jewish refugees from Arab countries'; a deal must resolve the rights 'of all refugees'. Also: 'Whereas approximately 850,000 Jews have been displaced from Arab countries since the declaration of the State of Israel in 1948'.

    Open source ↗

    pressGene Currivan, 'Ready to Aid Iraqi Jews' (Special to The New York Times) (1950) incident ✓

    NYT 1950-03-18 (dateline Tel Aviv, March 17); vision-verified 2026-10-01 from the archive's scan. 'the decision of Iraq to permit the departure of her Jews, of whom 60,000 are prepared to leave immediately'; the Jewish Agency 'prepared to receive at least 20,000 at once'; 'It is considered extremely unlikely that all of Iraq's 150,000 Jews intend to emigrate'; 'Israel is committed to a program of accepting all those who must come because of pressure upon them in their countries. Those who are not subject to persecution will be asked to bide their time'; 'Under the arrangement made by the Iraqi Government all those who left for Israel would first be forced to renounce their citizenship … if they did not sell their property before making such a declaration they would have no claim to it thereafter.'

    advocacy / viewHuman Rights Watch, 'Treatment and Rights in Arab Host States' (right-of-return campaign briefing, undated, c. 2000) finding ✓

    Read (2026-09-29); undated, latest year cited 1999. 'In Jordan … most of the 1.5 million Palestinians have citizenship and are well integrated'; 'Syria has maintained the stateless status of its Palestinians but has afforded them the same economic and social rights enjoyed by Syrian citizens'; 'In Lebanon, in sharp contrast, hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are stateless and over half live in overcrowded camps.'

    Open source ↗

  5. Where it leads if pressed

    Both groups are owed an answer — possibly in one framework.

    The honest version is not 'cancel out' but 'include both'. The idea has been raised at the top. After Camp David in July 2000, President Clinton said there would 'have to be some sort of international fund set up for the refugees', and that there was 'some interest, interestingly enough, on both sides, in also having a fund which compensates the Israelis who were made refugees by the war' (as quoted in H.Res. 185). Using the Jewish exodus to deny Palestinian claims repeats the erasure it rightly complains of; using the Nakba to deny the Jewish exodus does the same in reverse.

    primary documentUS House of Representatives, H.Res. 185 (110th Congress), introduced text (2007) (2007) ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). Quotes President Clinton 'in an interview after Camp David II in July 2000': 'There will have to be some sort of international fund set up for the refugees. There is, I think, some interest, interestingly enough, on both sides, in also having a fund which compensates the Israelis who were made refugees by the war, which occurred after the birth of the State of Israel.' (The interview itself is not read here; his 7 January 2001 remarks, read on the Clinton White House archive, say 'All refugees should receive compensation from the international community for their losses'.)

    Open source ↗

The usual reply — and its own traps

Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.

heard from pro-Palestinian voices“Jews lived peacefully in the Arab world for centuries until Zionism ruined it; they left because Israel lured them.” Its traps: ◆ "They all…"

On the timeline

Keep exploring

From the archive

How newspapers reported related events at the time — suggested by the archive's own tags, not yet reviewed for this argument. Open a scan and judge for yourself.

Scans: kvetch-of-the-day news archive.