How to read sources
In this conflict, information is a weapon on every side. These cards help you check a claim before you pass it on β whoever it comes from.
Before the steps: get the frame, and read every source as true from where it stands
Start with the timeline. A source makes sense only against the history it comes out of. Someone who knows that Hebron 1929 and Deir Yassin 1948 both happened, that both peoples were expelled from somewhere, and which events each side's story is built on, reads a new claim very differently from someone meeting it cold. Explore the timeline, with the 'Shared core events' filter first.
Then treat every source as true from its own perspective. Don't start by asking whether it's lying; ask what the writer saw, what they believe, and what would have to be true for them to say this. A Gaza doctor's account, an Israeli army statement, a settler's video and a UN report are each true to what their authors know and want you to see. Reading them that way keeps you from the easiest trap of all, rejecting a source because it's 'likely to be wrong' (see judging a claim by who said it), and it shows you exactly where two true-from-their-side accounts diverge. That gap is where the steps below come in.
A reading strategy in five steps
- Wait before you share. In this war the first version of a dramatic claim is often wrong, on both sides: the al-Ahli hospital blast, the '40 beheaded babies', the 'list of terrorists' that was a calendar. A day costs nothing. The correction nobody sees
- Find the first source. Who said it first, and could they know yet? 'According to' is the most important phrase in any report, and it's the first thing to fall off as a story travels. Who is the authority?
- Read the other side's own sources. Not their opponents' summary of them: their own outlets, data and words. Search in their vocabulary too, because a search in one side's words only finds that side's answer. You need the argument to find the argument Β· Two languages, two stories
- Count sources, not articles. Twenty outlets repeating one ministry's figure are one source; ten reports citing each other are one cluster. The citation loop Β· a worked example
- Separate the facts from the verdict. 'Many children died' and 'it's genocide' are different kinds of claim; so are 'Hamas fought from hospitals' and 'every strike was lawful'. A good source tells you which one it's making. When a proxy becomes 'confirmed' Β· The image does the arguing
A deliberate media diet
In many countries the mainstream coverage of this conflict leans heavily one way, sometimes to the point of leaving out the other side's data entirely (see the records of the BBC and the New York Times, and Haaretz's English headlines). The fix isn't to swap one feed for another; it's to follow at least one source from each side on purpose, and read them in their own words.
- Israeli: The Times of Israel; Haaretz (compare the Hebrew and English editions); Ynet.
- Palestinian and Arab: WAFA (the Palestinian Authority's news agency); Al Jazeera (compare the Arabic and English services).
- Each people's own opinion polls: the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research; the Israel Democracy Institute (see who speaks for them?).
- Checkers, labelled as such: independent fact-checkers and open-source investigators (AFP Fact Check, BBC Verify, Bellingcat) and the partisan monitors on each side (CAMERA on one, Electronic Intifada and similar outlets on the other), which are good at finding the other side's errors and poor at finding their own.
The toolbox
The cards behind the strategy, for when you want to go deeper into one kind of trap.
What the marks mean
- β checked against the original (for newspaper clippings: read on the scan itself).
- β not yet checked β treat with care, and tell us if you can verify it.
- 1 cluster several sources that cite each other or share their data β count them as one.
- Source types: law / court, primary document, data, history, press, advocacy / view β an advocacy source can be right, but read it as a position.