How to read sources

In this conflict, information is a weapon on every side. These cards help you check a claim before you pass it on β€” whoever it comes from.

Before the steps: get the frame, and read every source as true from where it stands

Start with the timeline. A source makes sense only against the history it comes out of. Someone who knows that Hebron 1929 and Deir Yassin 1948 both happened, that both peoples were expelled from somewhere, and which events each side's story is built on, reads a new claim very differently from someone meeting it cold. Explore the timeline, with the 'Shared core events' filter first.

Then treat every source as true from its own perspective. Don't start by asking whether it's lying; ask what the writer saw, what they believe, and what would have to be true for them to say this. A Gaza doctor's account, an Israeli army statement, a settler's video and a UN report are each true to what their authors know and want you to see. Reading them that way keeps you from the easiest trap of all, rejecting a source because it's 'likely to be wrong' (see judging a claim by who said it), and it shows you exactly where two true-from-their-side accounts diverge. That gap is where the steps below come in.

A reading strategy in five steps

  1. Wait before you share. In this war the first version of a dramatic claim is often wrong, on both sides: the al-Ahli hospital blast, the '40 beheaded babies', the 'list of terrorists' that was a calendar. A day costs nothing. The correction nobody sees
  2. Find the first source. Who said it first, and could they know yet? 'According to' is the most important phrase in any report, and it's the first thing to fall off as a story travels. Who is the authority?
  3. Read the other side's own sources. Not their opponents' summary of them: their own outlets, data and words. Search in their vocabulary too, because a search in one side's words only finds that side's answer. You need the argument to find the argument Β· Two languages, two stories
  4. Count sources, not articles. Twenty outlets repeating one ministry's figure are one source; ten reports citing each other are one cluster. The citation loop Β· a worked example
  5. Separate the facts from the verdict. 'Many children died' and 'it's genocide' are different kinds of claim; so are 'Hamas fought from hospitals' and 'every strike was lawful'. A good source tells you which one it's making. When a proxy becomes 'confirmed' Β· The image does the arguing

A deliberate media diet

In many countries the mainstream coverage of this conflict leans heavily one way, sometimes to the point of leaving out the other side's data entirely (see the records of the BBC and the New York Times, and Haaretz's English headlines). The fix isn't to swap one feed for another; it's to follow at least one source from each side on purpose, and read them in their own words.

The toolbox

The cards behind the strategy, for when you want to go deeper into one kind of trap.

β—† The authority endpointThe UN has said so. / Read the OHCHR report. / The IDF has confirmed it.Which body exactly? With what mandate β€” court, political body, appointed experts, advocacy group, government? What method β€” witnesses, satellite data, statistics, compiled media reports? Which sources do its footnotes lead to, and do those sources cite each other (one cluster, not many)? Has any court ruled?β—† Citation loopEvery major organisation agrees. / It's been confirmed by multiple sources.Where does this number or finding originate β€” who counted, how, verified by whom? Do the sources cite each other, or share their data? How many independent clusters are there, not how many sources? Does the original source say what the downstream ones say it says?β—† Reading an incident storyLook what they did β€” it's all over the news.What happened just before? Who was injured, by whom β€” settlers, soldiers, residents, or both sides of a clash? What exactly is being counted, and how was it verified? What's the denominator, and what's the comparison β€” per capita, per year, against which other place? Do the other side's authorities confirm or dispute it?β—† The image does the arguingJust look at this picture.Where and when was it taken, and who posted it first? (A reverse image search takes a minute.) What does it show, and what does it only suggest? What caused it, according to whom, and has anyone independent looked? What would the data on this say, and why am I being shown this instead?β—† The correction nobody seesIt was all over the news.Who is the original source, and could they know yet? How many outlets confirmed it independently, rather than citing each other? Was it corrected, and how prominently compared with the original?β—† What happened next?Everyone knows what happened.When was this first said, and by whom? What has been added, corrected or taken back since? Has a court, an inquiry or the record itself caught up?β—† The argument that isn't meant to winAnyone who doesn't accept this is in denial.Could this argument ever convince someone on the other side, and does its framing even try? What would a version look like that the other side could hear, and is anyone making it? Who gains when both sides stay angry?β—† Two languages, two storiesBut that's not what they said in Arabic (or Hebrew).What did they say in their own language, to their own people? Who translated it, and who chose which parts to translate? Can I check the translation against the original instead of dismissing it by who translated it? Is there a version for the other audience, and how does it differ? Which version shows up in what they actually do?β—† You need the argument to find the argumentI looked it up β€” nobody even disputes it.What would the other side call this? Which primary source would settle it, and have I looked at it rather than at articles about it? How many distinct original sources did I find, not how many articles?β—† Proxy presented as outcomeIt's been confirmed. / The numbers prove it.Is this measured, estimated, modelled or projected? What would the outcome look like if it were true β€” and did it happen? What does the source's own fine print say?β—† Identity as authorityAs a Palestinian… / As a Jew… / That's hasbara. / That's taqiyya.Is this testimony about an experience, or a claim about a checkable fact? Would the claim be true if someone else said it? Is there evidence this specific account is inauthentic, or only a presumption from what it says?β—† Which territory?Israel does X. / Palestine is occupied.Which of the four territories does this fact describe? Which one does the conclusion target? Would the claim still hold if the territory were named? A direct way to ask it: 'Draw me the map you mean' β€” of Palestine when someone says Israel isn't real or must end, of Israel when someone says there is no occupation. The drawing shows which territory the claim is about, and a reluctance to draw is itself an answer worth noticing.β—† Motte and bailey[A bold claim] β€” when challenged: 'All I said was [a modest one].'Which exact claim are we discussing β€” can we write it down? If I grant the modest version, do you still hold the bold one β€” on what evidence? What would the slogan look like if it said only the modest thing?β—† "They all…"They all… / That's what they're like.How many β€” and how do we know? Can I name someone in the group who doesn't fit? Is this a doctrine of an organisation, or the view of its supporters?β—† The exception as proofHere's the proof: [one artefact, one quote, one incident]How typical is this item β€” what do the other sources from the same years show? Would the conclusion survive if this one item disappeared? Is there an equally striking item pointing the other way, and why wasn't it chosen? What exactly does the item show (that something existed) and what is it being used to show (that it was the rule)?β—† Where does the story start?They started it β€” look at what they just didWhat happened in the days before this? Is this act a response β€” and is the thing it responded to mentioned? Would the story still read the same if it started one step earlier? Am I giving context to both sides, or only to mine?β—† Which name?It's called [our name], not [their name]How old is each name, and who used it when? Does the other side's name also carry real history? Is the name doing the work that evidence should do?β—† Refusing to say the name'The Zionist entity'What does the name decide before the argument starts? Would the speaker use this word for a state or people they recognise? Does 'Zionist' here mean a political position, or Jews? If it means supporters of a Jewish state, which ones, and what do they support?β—† The loaded questionHave you stopped beating your wife?What does this question assume? Would I agree with that assumption if it were stated as a claim? Can I answer the assumption first, then the question? Is the same question put to the other side?β—† DARVO: deny, attack, reverseYou're the real aggressor here.Was the specific claim addressed, or only its messenger? Can both be true β€” the accuser has an agenda AND the wrong happened? And the reverse: a DARVO-shaped answer does not by itself show the accusation is true. Who is being cast as victim, and does the evidence support that role?

What the marks mean