Theme
“This website is Zionist propaganda.”
The site lives on a domain called listentojews.org, defends Israel's right to exist, traces the genocide list instead of accepting it, and says 'Pallywood' is sometimes real. Whatever it claims about balance, it's hasbara with extra steps.
Why people find it convincing
- The domain is listentojews.org, and the site is part of that project.
- It argues against the claim that Israel has no right to exist (see 'Israel is evil and illegitimate — it has no right to exist.'), and many of its toolkit cards were prompted by arguments common in the pro-Palestinian movement.
- The documented corrections record it highlights, in the BBC's and the New York Times' coverage, runs mostly one way.
- It traces the list of voices behind 'genocide' rather than accepting it (see 'The citation map of the genocide claim').
What's true
The site isn't neutral. It takes a side.
It takes the side of a solution: any solution that lets both peoples live. It starts from two premises and says so: the Jewish people and the Palestinian people each have a legitimate claim to live in safety and self-determination in this land. If 'Zionist' means accepting the first premise, the site is Zionist. It is just as firmly committed to the second, and it isn't pro any political camp, government or movement.
What's left out
What a propaganda site wouldn't do.
It concedes, in full and in its own voice, points the pro-Israel arguments on this site leave out: the Nakba and Deir Yassin, settler violence, the eliminationist statements of Israeli officials, the famine conditions, the killings near aid sites, the pre-war genocide charge's real grievances. It aims to state every argument the way its strongest advocates would, and its toolkit cards give pro-Israel examples of the traps as well as pro-Palestinian ones. It publishes its own verification numbers, generated from its database, including how many sources have been checked against the original so far; it describes the bias of the AI model that helps write it and which way that bias runs; and it corrects itself in public. You can check any of this: pick a page and look for what it leaves out. If you find something, tell us.
The picture
Who makes this site, and where I stand.
Sidenote is part of the listentojews.org project. It is made by one person, with the help of an AI model whose biases are described on the method page. I'm not Jewish or Israeli myself, but I work together with people who are. I became a Zionist because it was the only community that let me be pro-Palestinian without hatred; every pro-Palestinian space I tried asked me first to hate Israel, a purity test (see 'The purity loop'). I don't do hatred. I call myself a Zionist partly to help defuse the argument, at the core of antizionism, that Zionism is one violent movement. So this site starts from what I found missing there: both peoples have a legitimate claim to live in safety in this land, and every argument, from either side, deserves its strongest form and an honest check. I mostly write for people who are being drawn toward a radical position on either side — antizionism, the conflation of Islam with Islamism, Kahanism — and who feel the pull of the true points inside it; that is a reason to check this site hardest where it answers them. I want the best possible outcome for everyone involved, I want true and lasting peace, and that might mean an outcome that I wouldn't actively support at this point in time. That is fine. That is also why this site doesn't argue a case. A strong argument for one side would be one more voice in a fight that is sometimes kept going on purpose: in November 2023 one Russian network amplified photos of Stars of David stencilled on walls in Paris, feeding Jews' fear (France's foreign ministry), and in the same month ran a fake copy of a French newspaper claiming the French president had 'the blood of Palestinians on his hands' (Euronews). Fear for one side, anger for the other, from one network. Many people come to this conflict from something good: a sense of justice, care for one people's safety, grief. I don't want to talk anyone out of that. I want them to keep it while seeing the people on the other side as people, with fears and claims of their own, so that the motivation stays and the harm it can do falls away. That is what the 'What's true' notes for the other side, the worst case for one's own side and the mirrors are for: not balance for its own sake, but room for the humanity of everyone involved.
primary documentFrench Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs, 'Russie – Nouvelle ingérence numérique russe contre la France' (statement, 9 November 2023) (2023) finding ✓
Read 2026-10-13 (French; translations here are this site's). 'La France condamne avec fermeté l'implication du réseau russe Recent Reliable News (RRN/Doppelgänger) dans l'amplification artificielle et la primo-diffusion sur les réseaux sociaux des photos des tags représentant des étoiles de David dans le 10e arrondissement de Paris.' 'S'agissant des faits eux-mêmes, l'enquête judiciaire en cours devra établir la possible responsabilité d'un commanditaire étranger.' VIGINUM 'a détecté le 6 novembre 2023 l'implication d'un réseau de 1095 bots sur la plateforme X (anciennement Twitter), ayant publié 2589 posts'; affiliated to RRN 'avec un haut degré de confiance'; 'la première publication authentique des photos des tags semble être intervenue le 30 octobre à 19h37 sur X, VIGINUM a identifié les premières publications du réseau de bots RRN dès le 28 octobre, à partir de 19h24, soit près de 48h avant.' The ministry's reading: 'une stratégie opportuniste et irresponsable visant à exploiter les crises internationales pour semer la confusion et à créer des tensions dans le débat public en France et en Europe.' A government's attribution, from its own agency's detection. This site's translations of the phrases quoted on its pages: '1095 bots', '2589 posts', 'with a high degree of confidence', 'nearly 48 hours', 'to exploit international crises to sow confusion and create tensions'.
pressEuronews (The Cube), Sophia Khatsenkova, 'Doppelganger: How a Russian disinformation campaign is exploiting the Israel-Hamas war' (22 November 2023) (2023) finding ✓
Read 2026-10-13. 'From the font to the layout, everything looks exactly like the website of the French daily Le Parisien. … the article that claims French President Emmanuel Macron has "the blood of Palestinians on his hands." In reality, it's a fake article, published on an almost identical platform with just a slightly different URL'; spoofed Spiegel pages in German; 'there is a common theme: the suggestion that the financial support coming from Western powers has been diverted from Ukraine to Israel'; the X accounts sharing the spoofs were mostly 'created in September and October 2023' with no followers (per the Antibot4Navalny collective). On the Paris Stars of David: the Moldovan couple 'claimed to have acted on the orders of a Russian individual in exchange for money', but 'a direct link between this incident and the Doppelganger disinformation campaign has not y[et been established]' (text cut off in the copy read).
Pushed, not persuaded.
My story isn't unusual, and it runs both ways. Some people end up on a side not because an argument convinced them but because the other side's fanatics pushed them away, or because of what they were shown. Some are pushed toward Israel by antisemitism and purity tests; others are pushed against Israel by the footage from Gaza. Either way the result is a side chosen by reaction. This site tries to offer the other route: the arguments, in full, so that whatever you end up thinking, you chose it.
Reading the numbers: the site's own balance, counted.
A site that claims fairness can be asked to count itself, so here is one count, made in October 2026 by the AI model that helps write it and open to checking by anyone on the pages themselves. Which claims get tested: of the 59 argument pages, 30 test a claim made from the pro-Palestinian side, 26 a claim made from the pro-Israeli side, and 3 neither. Whom the conclusions cost: of 57 'Safe on the evidence' lines in the worked notes, 13 cut mainly against pro-Palestinian claims, 15 mainly against pro-Israeli claims, 23 against both, and 6 against neither. A second count of the same lines, under a stricter rule, comes out differently: counting a line as one-sided only if it grants nothing to the other side in the same sentence gives 7 against pro-Palestinian claims, 14 against pro-Israeli claims, 30 against both and 6 against neither. The difference is where the counterweight sits: lines that cost pro-Palestinian claims more often carry a concession in the same sentence ('the toll is very large'), while lines that cost pro-Israeli claims put it in the 'not supported' line instead; of 21 'not supported' lines checked on these pages, 20 rule out an overclaim on each side. Three limits. The coding is a judgement, and the editor has argued that some lines counted as costing the pro-Israeli side are shared ground. Direction is not weight: lines that cost the pro-Israeli side are often about gaps and accountability, while lines that cost the pro-Palestinian side often refute maximal claims, and a count cannot say whether that reflects the claims or the writing. And a balanced count is only weak evidence; the real test is whether each line holds on its sources, page by page. One more limit, about symmetry: the toolkit cards give one example from each side by design. The pairing shows that a technique is used in both directions, not that both sides use it equally, and where the evidence on a question is lopsided the worked notes are meant to say so rather than balance it (see 'The exception as proof' on proportion). The worst case for each reading. For 'it's Zionist propaganda': the site tests slightly more pro-Palestinian claims than pro-Israeli ones, but on the stricter count its safe lines contradict pro-Israeli claims outright twice as often as pro-Palestinian ones. For 'it's anti-Israel': on the first count the conclusions cost each side about equally often, and the 'not supported' lines almost all cut both ways. For 'it's balanced, so it's right': balance in the count says nothing about whether a given line is true. Holds on the evidence here: testing runs in both directions in similar numbers; how evenly the conclusions fall depends on the coding rule (13 to 15 on one, 7 to 14 on a stricter one), which is itself a reason not to lean on either count. Open, needs an outside count: a coding not done by the site itself. Not supported: judging the site's accuracy by its balance, in either direction.
Where it leads if pressed
Where it leads: judge the pages, not the domain.
'It's propaganda because of who made it' is the genetic fallacy (see 'Judging by origin'), the same move as 'it's false because Al Jazeera reported it' or 'because MEMRI translated it'. The mirror accusation, that the site is 'pro-Hamas' or antisemitic because it grants Palestinian points, is heard from the other side. Being accused from both directions is only weak evidence of fairness. The real test is the content: whether the concessions are real, whether the strongest arguments are really the strongest, and whether the site corrects what it gets wrong.
Traps here:◆ Judging by origin