Argument Β· heard from pro-Palestinian voices

β€œPalestine was definitely a thing β€” there was even a newspaper called Filastin in 1911 β€” and almost no Jews lived there, so Israel was a hostile takeover.”

A Palestinian people and country existed before Zionism; Jews were a negligible foreign presence who arrived and seized it.

Made publicly as a pro-Palestinian argument by Hamas

Where it's been said

β€œIn 1918, the Palestinian people owned 98.5% of the Palestine land and represented 92% of the population on the land of Palestine. While the Jews, who were brought to Palestine in mass immigration campaigns in coordination between the British colonial authorities and the Zionist Movement, managed to seize control of not more than 6% of the lands in Palestine and to be 31% of the population prior to 1948.”
Hamas, Hamas Media Office β€” 'Our Narrative… Operation Al-Aqsa Flood', section 'Why Operation Al-Aqsa Flood?', 2024-01-21 βœ“

Traps in play:β—† Which Palestine?β—† Which territory?β—† The exception as proof

  1. Why people find it convincing

    • A regional identity of the Arabs of Palestine existed before the Mandate. Isa al-Isa, from a Jaffa Orthodox Christian family, founded the newspaper Filastin ('Palestine') in Jaffa in January 1911. By PalQuest's account it 'began as a twice-weekly publication and was principally concerned with the welfare of the Orthodox community; later it warned of the dangers of Zionism'. The Ottoman authorities closed it in October 1913, 'claiming that it had published articles inciting ethnic prejudice'.
    • The land's people warned from the start. In March 1899 Yusuf Diya al-Khalidi, former mayor of Jerusalem, wrote to Theodor Herzl through the Chief Rabbi of France (1 March 1899) that Palestine was 'an integral part of the Ottoman Empire' and 'inhabited by others than Israelites', and ended: 'in the name of God, let Palestine be left alone.' The same letter began by granting the Jewish claim: 'Who can contest the rights of the Jews to Palestine? My God, historically it is really your country!' (The letter is in French; these are this site's translations, the French on the card.) His objection was to Zionism 'in the geographical sense'. He warned that it put the Jews of Turkey, and above all of Palestine, in danger, and wrote that Jews who came were 'welcome' as faithful Ottoman subjects (translated from the French text published by the journal Conditions). Herzl answered on 19 March 1899 that the Jews would raise the inhabitants' well-being ('But who would think of sending them away? It is their well-being, their individual wealth which we will increase by bringing in our own'), and that if the Sultan did not accept his proposals, 'we will search and, believe me, we will find elsewhere what we need' (PalQuest's unofficial translation of the French). Rashid Khalidi frames 'The Hundred Years' War on Palestine' around this letter: the book's description opens with it and its warning, 'in the name of God, let Palestine be left alone' (Open Library record, read). The German historian Alexander SchΓΆlch called the letter al-Khalidi's 'last known, practically prophetic, political act', an appeal out of a 'holy duty of conscience' to 'leave Palestine in peace', which Herzl answered by stressing the benefit Jewish immigration would bring to 'la population non juive en Palestine' (Jerusalem Quarterly, 2005). That other Palestinian historians date the conflict from it is not yet sourced here ⚠.
    • Jews were a small minority when systematic counting began: the British census of 23 October 1922 enumerated 83,794 Jews in a population of 757,182, and before it 'there existed no systematic arrangements for registering the population of Palestine'. The Zionist movement set out to change that through immigration, and the people already living there were not asked: 'in Palestine we do not propose even to go through the form of consulting the wishes of the present inhabitants of the country', Balfour wrote in 1919.
    • The Mandate was imposed by Britain and the League of Nations with a commitment to a Jewish national home, against the wishes of the Arab majority. The objection was on record before the Mandate began: on 12 December 1918 Palestinian figures, Isa al-Isa among them, sent a statement to the Paris Peace Conference and the British Foreign Office 'protesting the Zionist movement's attempt to turn Palestine into a Jewish National Home' (PalQuest).
    • In 1948 around 700,000 Palestinian Arabs (the UN Conciliation Commission's 1950 estimate: 'approximately 711,000') fled or were expelled and were not allowed to return; and 'more than 400 Palestinian villages' were 'destroyed or depopulated' (the Institute for Palestine Studies' reference work All That Remains, 1992). That is the Nakba, and it is real.
  2. What's true

    A regional identity of the land's Arabs was real, Jews were a minority, and the Nakba happened.

    Filastin is solid evidence that 'Palestinians were invented in 1964' is wrong β€” though what it shows is a regional identity of the land's Arabs (the political bodies of the time called themselves 'Palestine Arab' congresses and parties), not a fully formed nation in today's sense. Jews were 'less than 10 per cent' of the population in 1917, by the UN's own study, and 83,794 of 757,182 in the 1922 census. The Arab majority opposed the Balfour policy from the start, and the 1948 displacement of ~700,000 people β€” with return denied afterwards β€” is the core Palestinian grievance. Walid Khalidi's reference work, from a Palestinian research institute, 'describes in detail the more than 400 Palestinian villages that were destroyed or depopulated by Israel in 1948' (publisher's description).

    referenceInstitute for Palestine Studies, PalQuest, 'Isa al-Isa' (biography) (1911) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28): 'In January 1911, he founded the newspaper Filastin, which began as a twice-weekly publication and was principally concerned with the welfare of the Orthodox community; later it warned of the dangers of Zionism'; closed by the Ottoman authorities in October 1913; signed the statement of 12 December 1918 to the Paris Peace Conference and the British Foreign Office 'protesting the Zionist movement's attempt to turn Palestine into a Jewish National Home'; co-founded the Muslim-Christian Association in Jaffa to oppose the Balfour Declaration. Archive issues of Filastin: National Library of Israel's historical Arabic press collection (not consulted here). Re-read 2026-10-12: 'In October 1913, the Ottoman authorities closed down his newspaper, claiming that it had published articles inciting ethnic prejudice.'

    Open source β†—

    historyUN study 'The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem', Part II (1947–1977), UNISPAL (1978) finding βœ“

    Read 2026-09-30. Partition voted on 29 November 1947: '33 votes in favour and 13 against with 10 abstentions'. The Palestine Arab Higher Committee condemned the plan as 'An excess of injustice to Palestine … a flagrant violation of the natural rights of the Arabs in their own country'; 'The Zionist Organization approved of the partition resolution, although objecting the Jewish state had not been allotted enough territory'. Prepared for the UN Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People. Also (re-read 2026-09-30): the UK told the UN that if the Assembly recommended 'a policy which was not acceptable to the Jews and the Arabs, the United Kingdom Government would not feel able to implement it'; abstentions on 29 November 1947 included the 'United Kingdom'; Britain 'announced that it would terminate the Mandate on 15 May 1948, several months before the time envisaged in the United Nations plan'. Re-read 2026-10-01: the partition resolution 'awarded 56 per cent of the territory of Palestine to 32 per cent of its population'; within the Jewish State 'there would remain a very large number of Palestinian Arabs: 497,000 (including 90,000 Bedouin) against 498,000 Jews', with about 10,000 Jews left in the Arab State; 'The partition resolution contained detailed safeguards to ensure the rights of minorities'. The study includes a chapter on the UN Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People and that Committee's recommendations. Re-read 2026-10-12, on the end of the Mandate: 'Jewish forces moved to occupy further territory beyond the boundaries specified by the Partition resolution. Irregular units from neighbouring Arab States had already entered Palestine in the final weeks of the Mandate, and now regular forces from these countries crossed into Palestine. The Arab League informed the United Nations Secretary-General by cable of the reasons for the Arab action.' Partition resolution as quoted there (re-read 2026-10-12): Jewish State '498 000' Jews and '407 000' Arabs and others, 'In addition there will be in the Jewish State about 90,000 (Arab) Bedouins'; citizens and residents 'shall, upon the recognition of independence, become citizens of the State in which they are resident'.

    Open source β†—

    dataJ. B. Barron (Superintendent of Census), 'Palestine: Report and General Abstracts of the Census of 1922', taken on 23 October 1922 (Jerusalem, 1923) β€” scanned copy (1923) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28; OCR of a scan). Para. 7: 'The total population of Palestine enumerated on the 23rd of October, 1922, was 757,182. This total includes the military, and persons of foreign nationality. Prior to the Census there existed no systematic arrangements for registering the population of Palestine.' Table I (with the report's erratum): Jews 83,794; Christians 73,024; Muslim total garbled in the OCR (reported elsewhere as 590,890, 78%, not relied on here). Table III (Population of Municipal Areas), Jerusalem: Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971 (OCR '33,t71'); Christians 14,699; total 62,578 (checked 2026-09-29). Jerusalem row (OCR, re-checked 2026-09-29): Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971; Christians 14,699; other columns 6, 484 and 5; total 62,578.

    Open source β†—

    historyWalid Khalidi (ed.), All That Remains: The Palestinian Villages Occupied and Depopulated by Israel in 1948 (Institute for Palestine Studies, 1992) (1992) pattern βœ“

    Publisher's description as held by Open Library (read 2026-09-30): 'describes in detail the more than 400 Palestinian villages that were destroyed or depopulated by Israel in 1948'; research and text by Sharif S. Elmusa and Muhammad Ali Khalidi. A Palestinian research institute's reference work; the book itself not read here.

    Open source β†—

  3. What's left out

    'almost no Jews' is wrong, and there was no Palestinian state to take over.

    In the 1922 census Jerusalem had 33,971 Jews among 62,578 residents, a majority; the Jewish Encyclopedia gives about 29,000 Jews of some 46,500 people in 1903, up from 3,000 in 1837, when 'the number of Jews in the Holy City was very small', with growth after the 1837 Safed and Tiberias earthquake and the persecutions in Russia. The same encyclopedia gives the old Jewish communities (the Old Yishuv) elsewhere: Safed in 1904, 'population … 21,000, included 7,000 Jews'; Tiberias, 'The Jews of Tiberias number about 2,000 in a total population of 3,600'; Hebron, 'a population of 14,000, including 1,100 Jews', down from 1,490 in 1890. They had also shrunk and regrown: in Safed the plague of 1742 and the earthquake of 1769 left 'only seven families', where 'in 1492 the Hebrew population had numbered 10,000'. A minority in the country, but far from none. Under the Ottomans, 'Palestine' was a region spread across administrative districts: the Sanjaq of Jerusalem, 'independent' and answering directly to Istanbul from 1874, and the Sanjaqs of Acre and Nablus, which belonged to the Province of Syria and from 1888 to the Province of Beirut. A 'Province of Jerusalem' joining all three in 1872 'prefigured to a large extent the future boundaries of Palestine' but 'lasted only two months' (PalQuest, Institute for Palestine Studies); Filastin shows a regional identity, not a sovereign country. Nobody conquered a Palestinian state, because none existed β€” which doesn't cancel the people's rights, but does change what 'takeover' can mean.

    Traps here:β—† Which Palestine?β—† Which territory?

    dataJ. B. Barron (Superintendent of Census), 'Palestine: Report and General Abstracts of the Census of 1922', taken on 23 October 1922 (Jerusalem, 1923) β€” scanned copy (1923) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28; OCR of a scan). Para. 7: 'The total population of Palestine enumerated on the 23rd of October, 1922, was 757,182. This total includes the military, and persons of foreign nationality. Prior to the Census there existed no systematic arrangements for registering the population of Palestine.' Table I (with the report's erratum): Jews 83,794; Christians 73,024; Muslim total garbled in the OCR (reported elsewhere as 590,890, 78%, not relied on here). Table III (Population of Municipal Areas), Jerusalem: Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971 (OCR '33,t71'); Christians 14,699; total 62,578 (checked 2026-09-29). Jerusalem row (OCR, re-checked 2026-09-29): Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971; Christians 14,699; other columns 6, 484 and 5; total 62,578.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Encyclopedia (1901–1906), 'Jerusalem', section 'Modern: Population' and 'Jews of Jerusalem' (1906) aggregate βœ“

    Read 2026-09-30. 'The present population of Jerusalem is about 46,500. Of this number 29,000 are Jews; 8,500, Moslems; and the remaining 9,000, Christians of different sects.' 'Up to 1837 the number of Jews in the Holy City was very small … The earthquake at Safed and Tiberias in 1837 caused many to move southward … The next great movement toward Jerusalem occurred in connection with the persecutions in Russia … From 3,000 in 1837, the Jews have … increased to 29,000 in 1903.' A contemporary Jewish reference work.

    Open source β†—

    historyPalQuest (Institute for Palestine Studies), 'Ottoman Territorial Reorganization, 1840-1917' incident βœ“

    Read 30 Sept 2026. May 1872: the sanjaqs of Acre, Nablus and Jerusalem separated from the Province of Syria as 'Quds-i Sherif Vilayeti'; 'This "Province of Jerusalem," which prefigured to a large extent the future boundaries of Palestine, lasted only two months'; Midhat Pasha returned Acre and Nablus to Syria and gave Jerusalem 'an independent (mustaqil) status subordinated directly to the Ministry of the Interior at the Porte', kept 'from 1874 until the outbreak of World War I'; March 1888: new Province of Beirut including the Sanjaqs of Beirut, Acre and Nablus; the boundaries 'were administrative and not natural or geographical'. Author field on the page not clearly captured.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Encyclopedia (1901–1906), articles 'Safed', 'Tiberias' and 'Hebron' (1906) aggregate βœ“

    Read 30 Sept 2026 on jewishencyclopedia.com (Safed: /articles/12990-safed; Tiberias: /articles/14386-tiberias; Hebron: /articles/7465-hebron). Safed: 'In 1904 the population of Safed, 21,000, included 7,000 Jews'; the plague of 1742 and earthquake of 1769 left 'only seven families … whereas in 1492 the Hebrew population had numbered 10,000'; the plague of 1812 'carried off four-fifths of the Jewish population'. Tiberias: 'The Jews of Tiberias number about 2,000 in a total population of 3,600'. Hebron: 'a population of 14,000, including 1,100 Jewsβ€”690 Sephardim and 410 Ashkenazim. In 1890 there was a Jewish population of 1,490, but it has been diminishing.' A Jewish reference work of its time; the figures are its own, sources not given per figure.

    Open source β†—

    How people and land actually changed hands before 1948.

    Under the Mandate, most Jewish immigration was legal: by the UN study's count, 'legal immigration alone accounted for over 376,000, with illegal immigration being estimated at another 65,000', while 'A good part' of the Jewish community's growth 'was due to births within Palestine'; the 1939 White Paper capped legal immigration at 75,000 over five years β€” during the Holocaust. Before 1948, Jewish land was acquired by purchase, including from absentee owners such as the Beirut Sursock family in the Vale of Esdraelon. The British Hope Simpson report (1930) recorded both sides: 'The soreness felt owing to the sale of large areas by the absentee Sursock family to the Jews and the displacement of the Arab tenants is still acute', with the area officers counting 1,270 displaced farmers; and 'The Jewish authorities have nothing with which to reproach themselves in the matter of the Sursock lands. They paid high prices for the land … It was not their business, but the business of the Government' to protect the Arab tenants. Those who came built a society: the Histadrut labour federation, founded in 1920, set up during the Mandate what became Bank Hapoalim, the Solel Boneh construction company and the Kupat Holim Clalit health fund, institutions that 'would enable the new state to emerge'; it was a Jewish workers' union, and Arab citizens were not admitted until May 1953 (Jewish Virtual Library); the people who declared independence in 1948 were residents of the country. The 1947 UN partition plan was accepted by the Jewish side and rejected by the Arab leadership, and the war that followed included an invasion by Arab states; the expulsions happened during that war.

    Traps here:β—† Which Palestine?β—† Which territory?

    primary documentBritish White Paper of 1939 (Cmd. 6019) (1939) βœ“

    75,000 Jewish immigrants over five years. Re-read 2026-10-12 (Avalon text): the quota 'would allow of the admission, as from the beginning of April this year, of some 75,000 immigrants over the next five years'; 'After the period of five years, no further Jewish immigration will be permitted unless the Arabs of Palestine are prepared to acquiesce in it.'

    Open source β†—

    primary documentUN General Assembly Resolution 181 (II): Future government of Palestine (1947) βœ“

    Partition plan.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentPalestine: Report on Immigration, Land Settlement and Development (Sir John Hope Simpson, 1930), UNISPAL copy (1930) finding βœ“

    Read 30 Sept 2026. 'The soreness felt owing to the sale of large areas by the absentee Sursock family to the Jews and the displacement of the Arab tenants is still acute. It was evident on every occasion of discussion with the Arabs, both effendi and fellahin.' 'The Jewish authorities have nothing with which to reproach themselves in the matter of the Sursock lands. They paid high prices for the land, and in addition they paid to certain of the occupants of those lands a considerable amount of money which they were not legally bound to pay. It was not their business, but the business of the Government to see to it that the position of the Arabs was not adversely affected'. Displaced 'farmers' from those villages: 1,270 by the Area Officers' records, 'nearly double' the memorandum's 688.

    Open source β†—

    referenceUnited Nations (prepared for the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People), 'The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem', Part I: 1917–1947 βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28). Quotes Balfour's memorandum to Curzon of 11 August 1919: 'For in Palestine we do not propose even to go through the form of consulting the wishes of the present inhabitants of the country'; 'The four Great Powers are committed to zionism … of far profounder import than the desires and prejudices of the 700,000 Arabs who now inhabit that ancient land'; 'I do not think that zionism will hurt the Arabs, but they will never say they want it.' The study was prepared under a UN committee on Palestinian rights. Re-read 2026-10-01 (1936–39): 'In April 1936, what started as minor Arab-Jewish clashes quickly flared into a widespread revolt. A new union of Palestinian political parties was formed, the Arab Higher Committee, headed by the Mufti of Jerusalem … The Committee called for a general strike to support the demand for national government'; 1938 casualties 'reached a total of 3,717, as against 246 in 1937'; 'the Jewish side also conducted its own retaliations and reprisals'; by 1933 'the various Palestinian political parties and groupings had united to form an Arab Executive Committee'. The study's own framing ('Palestinian resistance to foreign rule and to foreign colonization'). Re-read 2026-10-01: it quotes 'an official British document': 'On the 22nd July 1946, the campaign conducted by terrorist organizations reached a new climax with an explosion which wrecked a wing of the King David Hotel in Jerusalem, containing the offices of the Government Secretariat as well as part of military headquarters, and killed 86 public servants, Arab, Jewish and British, as well as five members of the public'; and 'That the Irgun Tzeva'i Leumi and the Stern Group have worked since last autumn in co-operation with the Haganah High Command on certain of these operations'. Re-read 2026-10-01 (immigration): the population rose 'from the 750,000 of the 1922 census to almost 1,850,000 at the end of 1946'; the Jewish population 'from 56,000 after the First World War to 84,000 in 1922 to 608,000 in 1946'; 'A good part of this was due to births within Palestine but legal immigration alone accounted for over 376,000, with illegal immigration being estimated at another 65,000 – a total of 440,000'; the Jewish community 'in 1947 constituted nearly a third'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Compared to the 100,000 in the 1920s, Palestine received about 232,000 legal immigrants in the 1930s. The Jewish population in 1939 numbered over 445,000 out of a total of about 1,500,000 – nearly 30 per cent compared to the less than 10 per cent 20 years before'; 1936 revolt: attacks 'on British troops and police posts as well as on Jewish settlements, sabotage of roads, railways, pipelines'; 'The British administration imposed curfews, called in troop reinforcements from Britain, Egypt and Malta, and resorted to mass arrests, collective fines, and internments in concentration camps and other emergency measures'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Israel Society & Culture: The Histadrut' βœ“

    Read 2026-10-02. Founded 12 December 1920 at the Haifa Technion β€˜as a trade union that would organize the economic activities of Jewish workers’; 8,394 of 16,608 workers were members in 1922; β€˜founded and established economic, financial, cultural, sports, and industrial institutions during the British Mandate that would enable the new state to emerge’ (Bank Hapoalim, Solel Boneh, Kupat Holim Clalit); β€˜It was not until May 7, 1953, that Israeli Arabs were permitted to join the union.’ Later history: decline after liberalisation and the 1995 health law; about 800,000 workers today.

    Open source β†—

  4. More context

    How to talk about this.

    Acknowledge first: there was an Arab society in Palestine with its own towns, press and politics before Zionism, and the newspaper Filastin (1911) is proof. Ask one question: 'does a people's existence decide who may also live there, and on what terms?'; that's the question both sides actually disagree about. Share one checkable thing: Filastin itself, and its warnings about Zionism (PalQuest). What not to say: 'there was no Palestine', which the site's own timeline disproves. From the other side: grant the Palestinian society, then ask how Jewish land was acquired before 1948, and what that means for the word 'takeover'. And ask back, from the first side, how most of the rest came under Israeli control: in the 1948 war and under the Absentees' Property Law (see 'The Palestinians left voluntarily in 1948 β€” their own leaders told them to go.').

    referenceInstitute for Palestine Studies, PalQuest, 'Isa al-Isa' (biography) (1911) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28): 'In January 1911, he founded the newspaper Filastin, which began as a twice-weekly publication and was principally concerned with the welfare of the Orthodox community; later it warned of the dangers of Zionism'; closed by the Ottoman authorities in October 1913; signed the statement of 12 December 1918 to the Paris Peace Conference and the British Foreign Office 'protesting the Zionist movement's attempt to turn Palestine into a Jewish National Home'; co-founded the Muslim-Christian Association in Jaffa to oppose the Balfour Declaration. Archive issues of Filastin: National Library of Israel's historical Arabic press collection (not consulted here). Re-read 2026-10-12: 'In October 1913, the Ottoman authorities closed down his newspaper, claiming that it had published articles inciting ethnic prejudice.'

    Open source β†—

    primary documentPalestine: Report on Immigration, Land Settlement and Development (Sir John Hope Simpson, 1930), UNISPAL copy (1930) finding βœ“

    Read 30 Sept 2026. 'The soreness felt owing to the sale of large areas by the absentee Sursock family to the Jews and the displacement of the Arab tenants is still acute. It was evident on every occasion of discussion with the Arabs, both effendi and fellahin.' 'The Jewish authorities have nothing with which to reproach themselves in the matter of the Sursock lands. They paid high prices for the land, and in addition they paid to certain of the occupants of those lands a considerable amount of money which they were not legally bound to pay. It was not their business, but the business of the Government to see to it that the position of the Arabs was not adversely affected'. Displaced 'farmers' from those villages: 1,270 by the Area Officers' records, 'nearly double' the memorandum's 688.

    Open source β†—

    law / courtAbsentees' Property Law, 5710-1950 (Israel), English text as hosted in Adalah's Discriminatory Laws Database (1950) βœ“

    Read 1 Oct 2026. s. 1(b): an 'absentee' is an owner of property in Israel who at any time from '29th November, 1947' until the end of the state of emergency was a national of Lebanon, Egypt, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Trans-Jordan, Iraq or Yemen, or was in one of those countries 'or in any part of Palestine outside the area of Israel', or 'left his ordinary place of residence in Palestine' for a place outside Palestine before 1 September 1948 or for a place 'held at the time by forces which sought to prevent the establishment of the State of Israel'; s. 2: the Minister of Finance appoints a Custodianship Council, whose chairman 'shall be called the Custodian'; s. 19: the Custodian may sell immovable vested property only to 'a Development Authority'. Hosted by Adalah, which lists it as discriminatory.

    Open source β†—

  5. Where it leads if pressed

    What was taken over?

    Land from people who lived on it

    Yes in 1948 β€” flight and expulsion, return barred. Before 1948, mostly purchases and legal immigration.

    β†’ The Palestinians left voluntarily in 1948 β€” their own leaders told them to go.
    A Palestinian state

    There was none β€” a region with a regional Arab identity, not a sovereign country.

    β†’ Which Palestine?

    Working it out: three claims in one sentence, each with its own evidence.

    The sentence makes three claims, and the evidence settles them differently. 'Palestine was a thing': yes, as an Arab society with its own towns, press and politics. The newspaper Filastin, founded in Jaffa in 1911, later 'warned of the dangers of Zionism', and the Ottomans had made Jerusalem a province of its own in 1872, which 'prefigured to a large extent the future boundaries'. That refutes 'Palestinians were invented in 1964'. It does not show a Palestinian state that could be taken over; there was none. 'Almost no Jews lived there': no, on the census itself. In 1922 Jews were 83,794 of 757,182, about 11% of the whole (this page's arithmetic), a minority; but in Jerusalem they were 33,971 of 62,578, a majority, and there were old communities in Safed, Tiberias and Hebron. 'A hostile takeover': this is where the dispute really sits. Before 1948, immigration under the Mandate was mostly legal (over 376,000 legal immigrants, about 65,000 illegal, by the UN study) and land was bought, sometimes from absentee owners such as the Sursock family, displacing Arab tenants, whose 'soreness … is still acute', as the British report recorded. The Mandate itself was imposed without the consent of the Arab majority: Balfour wrote that 'we do not propose even to go through the form of consulting the wishes of the present inhabitants'. And in 1948 about 711,000 Arabs became refugees. The worst case for each side. For 'hostile takeover': grant every grievance; before 1948 the growth was largely legal immigration and purchase, not conquest; Jews were a majority in Jerusalem itself, and already before the Mandate (about 29,000 of 46,500 in the Jewish Encyclopedia of 1906); and the Mandate bound Britain to safeguard 'the civil and religious rights of all the inhabitants of Palestine, irrespective of race and religion'. For 'there was no takeover at all': grant every legal purchase; the framework was imposed without the inhabitants' consent, the objection was voiced from the start (in 1899 the mayor of Jerusalem, Yusuf Diya al-Khalidi, wrote that the country had an indigenous people who would not easily accept their own displacement: 'in the name of God, let Palestine be left alone', as described in Rashid Khalidi's book, and in Alexander SchΓΆlch's 2005 study, where the letter goes to the French chief rabbi Zadok Kahn, 'a friend of Herzl', and appeals 'in the name of God' to the Zionists 'to leave Palestine in peace'; while Herzl's reply asked 'who would think of sending them away?'), tenants were displaced, and 1948 ended in mass displacement. Holds on the evidence here: an Arab Palestinian society existed; Jews were a minority overall and a majority in Jerusalem; the Mandate lacked the Arab majority's consent; 1948 displaced most of the Arabs in what became Israel. Arguable: that the whole process amounts to a takeover, or that it does not. Not supported: that almost no Jews lived there, or that a Palestinian state existed to be taken over.

    What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean

    referenceInstitute for Palestine Studies, PalQuest, 'Isa al-Isa' (biography) (1911) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28): 'In January 1911, he founded the newspaper Filastin, which began as a twice-weekly publication and was principally concerned with the welfare of the Orthodox community; later it warned of the dangers of Zionism'; closed by the Ottoman authorities in October 1913; signed the statement of 12 December 1918 to the Paris Peace Conference and the British Foreign Office 'protesting the Zionist movement's attempt to turn Palestine into a Jewish National Home'; co-founded the Muslim-Christian Association in Jaffa to oppose the Balfour Declaration. Archive issues of Filastin: National Library of Israel's historical Arabic press collection (not consulted here). Re-read 2026-10-12: 'In October 1913, the Ottoman authorities closed down his newspaper, claiming that it had published articles inciting ethnic prejudice.'

    Open source β†—

    historyPalQuest (Institute for Palestine Studies), 'Ottoman Territorial Reorganization, 1840-1917' incident βœ“

    Read 30 Sept 2026. May 1872: the sanjaqs of Acre, Nablus and Jerusalem separated from the Province of Syria as 'Quds-i Sherif Vilayeti'; 'This "Province of Jerusalem," which prefigured to a large extent the future boundaries of Palestine, lasted only two months'; Midhat Pasha returned Acre and Nablus to Syria and gave Jerusalem 'an independent (mustaqil) status subordinated directly to the Ministry of the Interior at the Porte', kept 'from 1874 until the outbreak of World War I'; March 1888: new Province of Beirut including the Sanjaqs of Beirut, Acre and Nablus; the boundaries 'were administrative and not natural or geographical'. Author field on the page not clearly captured.

    Open source β†—

    dataJ. B. Barron (Superintendent of Census), 'Palestine: Report and General Abstracts of the Census of 1922', taken on 23 October 1922 (Jerusalem, 1923) β€” scanned copy (1923) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28; OCR of a scan). Para. 7: 'The total population of Palestine enumerated on the 23rd of October, 1922, was 757,182. This total includes the military, and persons of foreign nationality. Prior to the Census there existed no systematic arrangements for registering the population of Palestine.' Table I (with the report's erratum): Jews 83,794; Christians 73,024; Muslim total garbled in the OCR (reported elsewhere as 590,890, 78%, not relied on here). Table III (Population of Municipal Areas), Jerusalem: Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971 (OCR '33,t71'); Christians 14,699; total 62,578 (checked 2026-09-29). Jerusalem row (OCR, re-checked 2026-09-29): Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971; Christians 14,699; other columns 6, 484 and 5; total 62,578.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Encyclopedia (1901–1906), articles 'Safed', 'Tiberias' and 'Hebron' (1906) aggregate βœ“

    Read 30 Sept 2026 on jewishencyclopedia.com (Safed: /articles/12990-safed; Tiberias: /articles/14386-tiberias; Hebron: /articles/7465-hebron). Safed: 'In 1904 the population of Safed, 21,000, included 7,000 Jews'; the plague of 1742 and earthquake of 1769 left 'only seven families … whereas in 1492 the Hebrew population had numbered 10,000'; the plague of 1812 'carried off four-fifths of the Jewish population'. Tiberias: 'The Jews of Tiberias number about 2,000 in a total population of 3,600'. Hebron: 'a population of 14,000, including 1,100 Jewsβ€”690 Sephardim and 410 Ashkenazim. In 1890 there was a Jewish population of 1,490, but it has been diminishing.' A Jewish reference work of its time; the figures are its own, sources not given per figure.

    Open source β†—

    referenceUnited Nations (prepared for the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People), 'The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem', Part I: 1917–1947 βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28). Quotes Balfour's memorandum to Curzon of 11 August 1919: 'For in Palestine we do not propose even to go through the form of consulting the wishes of the present inhabitants of the country'; 'The four Great Powers are committed to zionism … of far profounder import than the desires and prejudices of the 700,000 Arabs who now inhabit that ancient land'; 'I do not think that zionism will hurt the Arabs, but they will never say they want it.' The study was prepared under a UN committee on Palestinian rights. Re-read 2026-10-01 (1936–39): 'In April 1936, what started as minor Arab-Jewish clashes quickly flared into a widespread revolt. A new union of Palestinian political parties was formed, the Arab Higher Committee, headed by the Mufti of Jerusalem … The Committee called for a general strike to support the demand for national government'; 1938 casualties 'reached a total of 3,717, as against 246 in 1937'; 'the Jewish side also conducted its own retaliations and reprisals'; by 1933 'the various Palestinian political parties and groupings had united to form an Arab Executive Committee'. The study's own framing ('Palestinian resistance to foreign rule and to foreign colonization'). Re-read 2026-10-01: it quotes 'an official British document': 'On the 22nd July 1946, the campaign conducted by terrorist organizations reached a new climax with an explosion which wrecked a wing of the King David Hotel in Jerusalem, containing the offices of the Government Secretariat as well as part of military headquarters, and killed 86 public servants, Arab, Jewish and British, as well as five members of the public'; and 'That the Irgun Tzeva'i Leumi and the Stern Group have worked since last autumn in co-operation with the Haganah High Command on certain of these operations'. Re-read 2026-10-01 (immigration): the population rose 'from the 750,000 of the 1922 census to almost 1,850,000 at the end of 1946'; the Jewish population 'from 56,000 after the First World War to 84,000 in 1922 to 608,000 in 1946'; 'A good part of this was due to births within Palestine but legal immigration alone accounted for over 376,000, with illegal immigration being estimated at another 65,000 – a total of 440,000'; the Jewish community 'in 1947 constituted nearly a third'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Compared to the 100,000 in the 1920s, Palestine received about 232,000 legal immigrants in the 1930s. The Jewish population in 1939 numbered over 445,000 out of a total of about 1,500,000 – nearly 30 per cent compared to the less than 10 per cent 20 years before'; 1936 revolt: attacks 'on British troops and police posts as well as on Jewish settlements, sabotage of roads, railways, pipelines'; 'The British administration imposed curfews, called in troop reinforcements from Britain, Egypt and Malta, and resorted to mass arrests, collective fines, and internments in concentration camps and other emergency measures'.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentPalestine: Report on Immigration, Land Settlement and Development (Sir John Hope Simpson, 1930), UNISPAL copy (1930) finding βœ“

    Read 30 Sept 2026. 'The soreness felt owing to the sale of large areas by the absentee Sursock family to the Jews and the displacement of the Arab tenants is still acute. It was evident on every occasion of discussion with the Arabs, both effendi and fellahin.' 'The Jewish authorities have nothing with which to reproach themselves in the matter of the Sursock lands. They paid high prices for the land, and in addition they paid to certain of the occupants of those lands a considerable amount of money which they were not legally bound to pay. It was not their business, but the business of the Government to see to it that the position of the Arabs was not adversely affected'. Displaced 'farmers' from those villages: 1,270 by the Area Officers' records, 'nearly double' the memorandum's 688.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentUN Conciliation Commission for Palestine, General Progress Report and Supplementary Report (11 December 1949 – 23 October 1950), UNISPAL copy (1950) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-29). 'The estimate of the statistical expert, which the Committee believes to be as accurate as circumstances permit, indicates that the refugees from Israel-controlled territory amount to approximately 711,000. The fact that there is a higher number of relief recipients appears to be due among other things to duplication of ration cards, addition of persons who have been displaced from area other than Israel-held areas and of persons who, although not displaced, are destitute.'

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Encyclopedia (1901–1906), 'Jerusalem', section 'Modern: Population' and 'Jews of Jerusalem' (1906) aggregate βœ“

    Read 2026-09-30. 'The present population of Jerusalem is about 46,500. Of this number 29,000 are Jews; 8,500, Moslems; and the remaining 9,000, Christians of different sects.' 'Up to 1837 the number of Jews in the Holy City was very small … The earthquake at Safed and Tiberias in 1837 caused many to move southward … The next great movement toward Jerusalem occurred in connection with the persecutions in Russia … From 3,000 in 1837, the Jews have … increased to 29,000 in 1903.' A contemporary Jewish reference work.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentLeague of Nations Mandate for Palestine (1922) βœ“

    Read on the Avalon Project (2026-09-30). Art. 2: conditions 'as will secure the establishment of the Jewish national home … and also for safeguarding the civil and religious rights of all the inhabitants of Palestine, irrespective of race and religion'; Art. 4: 'An appropriate Jewish agency shall be recognised as a public body …'; Art. 6: 'while ensuring that the rights and position of other sections of the population are not prejudiced, shall facilitate Jewish immigration under suitable conditions and shall encourage … close settlement by Jews on the land, including State lands and waste lands'. Preamble: 'recognition has thereby been given to the historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine'. Art. 22 (re-read 2026-10-12): 'English, Arabic and Hebrew shall be the official languages of Palestine. Any statement or inscription in Arabic on stamps or money in Palestine shall be repeated in Hebrew and any statement or inscription in Hebrew shall be repeated in Arabic.' Art. 6 in full (Avalon, re-read 2026-10-15): 'The Administration of Palestine, while ensuring that the rights and position of other sections of the population are not prejudiced, shall facilitate Jewish immigration under suitable conditions and shall encourage, in co-operation with the Jewish agency referred to in Article 4, close settlement by Jews on the land, including State lands and waste lands not required for public purposes.'

    Open source β†—

    referenceOpen Library, record for Rashid Khalidi, The Hundred Years' War on Palestine (2020) (2020) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-29). The book's description: 'In 1899, Yusuf Diya al-Khalidi, mayor of Jerusalem, alarmed by the Zionist call to create a Jewish national home in Palestine, wrote a letter aimed at Theodore Herzl: the country had an indigenous people who would not easily accept their own displacement. He warned of the perils ahead, ending his note, "in the name of God, let Palestine be left alone."' The book itself is not read here.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentPalQuest (Institute for Palestine Studies), 'Letter from Theodore Herzl to Yusuf Diya-uddin al-Khalidi' β€” French text and unofficial English translation (1899) incident βœ“

    Read 29 Sept 2026. Perspective: a Palestinian research institute's document collection; its source is Walid Khalidi, ed., From Haven to Conquest (IPS, 2nd ed. 1987). Dated Vienna, 19 March 1899. Translation: 'You see another difficulty, Excellency, in the existence of the non-Jewish population in Palestine. But who would think of sending them away? It is their well-being, their individual wealth which we will increase by bringing in our own.' He also writes that 'there is absolutely nothing to fear from their immigration', that the movement is 'concerned with opening up new resources for the Ottoman Empire', and that if the Sultan 'will not accept it, we will search and, believe me, we will find elsewhere what we need'. It is Herzl's letter only; al-Khalidi's own letter ('let Palestine be left alone') is not on this page.

    Open source β†—

    historyAlexander SchΓΆlch, 'An Ottoman Bismarck from Jerusalem: Yusuf Diya' al-Khalidi (1842-1906)', Jerusalem Quarterly 24 (2005) (2005) finding βœ“

    Read 2026-10-02 (PalQuest's copy of the PDF; the palestine-studies.org copy is walled). 'His last known, practically prophetic, political act was a letter to the French head rabbi, Zadok Kahn, a friend of Herzl, written in the spring of 1899'; al-Khalidi feared Zionism 'would jeopardize the friendly association of Muslims, Christians and Jews in Palestine' and 'out of a β€œholy duty of conscience” and β€œin the name of God” appealed to the Zionists to leave Palestine in peace'; Herzl answered on 19 March 1899, emphasising 'the great benefit' to the Ottoman empire and to 'la population non juive en Palestine'. Cites Mandel, The Arabs and Zionism before World War I (1976), pp. 47–9.

    Open source β†—

    The real dispute is the legitimacy of the Mandate β€” and what follows from 'takeover'.

    'They came legally' answers the invasion claim but not the deeper one: Britain committed to a Jewish national home without the consent of the Arab majority β€” whose law was it? That is the honest core, and it deserves engagement. But if 'a minority grew by immigration and later won a war' makes a state illegitimate, the same rule would reach other states, including the Arab states created by the same post-Ottoman settlement. Followed through, one version of it ends at 'the Jews should leave'. The question to ask is whether the speaker means that version or the one about consent.

    primary documentLeague of Nations Mandate for Palestine (1922) βœ“

    Read on the Avalon Project (2026-09-30). Art. 2: conditions 'as will secure the establishment of the Jewish national home … and also for safeguarding the civil and religious rights of all the inhabitants of Palestine, irrespective of race and religion'; Art. 4: 'An appropriate Jewish agency shall be recognised as a public body …'; Art. 6: 'while ensuring that the rights and position of other sections of the population are not prejudiced, shall facilitate Jewish immigration under suitable conditions and shall encourage … close settlement by Jews on the land, including State lands and waste lands'. Preamble: 'recognition has thereby been given to the historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine'. Art. 22 (re-read 2026-10-12): 'English, Arabic and Hebrew shall be the official languages of Palestine. Any statement or inscription in Arabic on stamps or money in Palestine shall be repeated in Hebrew and any statement or inscription in Hebrew shall be repeated in Arabic.' Art. 6 in full (Avalon, re-read 2026-10-15): 'The Administration of Palestine, while ensuring that the rights and position of other sections of the population are not prejudiced, shall facilitate Jewish immigration under suitable conditions and shall encourage, in co-operation with the Jewish agency referred to in Article 4, close settlement by Jews on the land, including State lands and waste lands not required for public purposes.'

    Open source β†—

The usual reply β€” and its own traps

Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.

heard from pro-Israel voicesβ€œIt was a land without a people, for a people without a land.” Both lean on: β—† Which Palestine? heard from pro-Israel voicesβ€œThere's no such thing as a Palestinian people β€” it was invented in 1964.” Both lean on: β—† Which Palestine? β—† The exception as proof

Where this argument points

This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions β€” for, against or around them:

On the timeline

Keep exploring

From the archive

How newspapers reported related events at the time β€” suggested by the archive's own tags, not yet reviewed for this argument. Open a scan and judge for yourself.

Scans: kvetch-of-the-day news archive.