Argument · heard from pro-Israel voices
“It was a land without a people, for a people without a land.”
Before Zionist settlement, Palestine was empty or nearly so; nobody was displaced because nobody was really there.
Made publicly as a pro-Israel argument by Israel Zangwill
Where it's been said
“Palestine is a country without a people; the Jews are a people without a country.”
“If Lord Shaftesbury was literally inexact in describing Palestine as a country without a people, he was essentially correct, for there is no Arab people living in intimate fusion with the country, utilising its resources and stamping it with a characteristic impress: there is at best an Arab encampment.”
“The theology of the Empire … speaks of land without people even when they know the land has people – and not just any people.”
Traps in play:◆ Which Palestine?◆ "They all…"
Why people find it convincing
- Nineteenth-century travellers described a neglected land. Mark Twain, in The Innocents Abroad (1869): 'We traversed some miles of desolate country whose soil is rich enough, but is given over wholly to weeds--a silent, mournful expanse.' A traveller's impression, not a census — which is the next point.
- The first full census, taken by the British on 23 October 1922, counted 757,182 people in all of Palestine. Before it 'there existed no systematic arrangements for registering the population'. That small number is what the argument's advocates point to.
- In 1868 the Ottomans banished Bahá'u'lláh to 'Akká, which by Shoghi Effendi's account 'had sunk, under the Turks, to the level of a penal colony to which murderers, highway robbers and political agitators were consigned from all parts of the Turkish empire'. He quotes Bahá'u'lláh's words, written before his arrival: 'According to what they say, it is the most desolate of the cities of the world … and the foulest in water', and a proverb that 'a bird when flying over it would drop dead' (God Passes By, 1944).
- Swamps were drained and agriculture transformed during the Mandate. The British Hope Simpson report (1930) records that 'Very much has been done in the drainage of swamps and marshes, in great part by Jewish agency and in great part by the Government', with the Supreme Muslim Council draining one too, and calls the Jewish agencies' drainage and new methods of agriculture 'highly valuable'. The same report warns that 'It is a mistake to assume that the Vale of Esdraelon was a wilderness before the arrival of the Jewish settlers', and that it is 'unjust to the povertystricken fellah' who had been removed from those lands to suggest he was 'a useless cumberer of the ground'.
- There was no Palestinian state: the 1922 count was a British census, and advocates conclude there was no sovereign Palestinian government to take land from (how that bears on the people living there is the argument the notes take up).
What's left out
Several hundred thousand people lived there, in towns and villages — read literally, the slogan erased them.
The British census of October 1922, the first systematic count, found 757,182 people, of whom 83,794 were Jews and 73,024 Christians; most of the rest were Muslims (their figure is illegible in the scan read here). For the mid-19th century, the Israeli historian Yehoshua Porath writes that 'about four hundred thousand Arabs—the great majority of whom were Muslims—lived in Palestine', while 'there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity"'. Jaffa, Nablus, Hebron, Gaza and Jerusalem were living towns, with hundreds of villages around them. Taken literally, the slogan leaves those people out of the count, and that is the point the Palestinian objection presses.
Traps here:◆ Which Palestine?◆ "They all…"
dataJ. B. Barron (Superintendent of Census), 'Palestine: Report and General Abstracts of the Census of 1922', taken on 23 October 1922 (Jerusalem, 1923) — scanned copy (1923) aggregate ✓
Read (2026-09-28; OCR of a scan). Para. 7: 'The total population of Palestine enumerated on the 23rd of October, 1922, was 757,182. This total includes the military, and persons of foreign nationality. Prior to the Census there existed no systematic arrangements for registering the population of Palestine.' Table I (with the report's erratum): Jews 83,794; Christians 73,024; Muslim total garbled in the OCR (reported elsewhere as 590,890, 78%, not relied on here). Table III (Population of Municipal Areas), Jerusalem: Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971 (OCR '33,t71'); Christians 14,699; total 62,578 (checked 2026-09-29). Jerusalem row (OCR, re-checked 2026-09-29): Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971; Christians 14,699; other columns 6, 484 and 5; total 62,578.
historyYehoshua Porath, 'Mrs. Peters's Palestine', New York Review of Books (1986) finding ✓
Read in full (NYRB, 16 Jan 1986). Porath (Hebrew University) on Peters' thesis in his words: 'Much of Mrs. Peters's book argues that at the same time that Jewish immigration to Palestine was rising, Arab immigration to the parts of Palestine where Jews had settled also increased. Therefore, in her view, the Arab claim that an indigenous Arab population was displaced by Jewish immigrants must be false, since many Arabs only arrived with the Jews'; he answers with the Lovers of Zion settlers' writings 'filled with references to the Arabs surrounding them everywhere in Palestine'. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'in 1947 there were about 1.3 million Arabs living in Palestine'; 'most of the growth of the Palestinian Arab community resulted from a process of natural increase'; mid-19th century 'about four hundred thousand Arabs'. No '100,000 immigrants' figure in the review. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'It is true that in the middle of the nineteenth century there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity." But about four hundred thousand Arabs—the great majority of whom were Muslims—lived in Palestine, which was divided by the Ottomans into three districts.'
More context
What the slogan gets right: parts of the land were poor and run-down.
Travellers described late-Ottoman Palestine as poor and neglected in places: Mark Twain crossed 'desolate country whose soil is rich enough, but is given over wholly to weeds'. Swamps covered parts of the lowlands until they were drained, 'in great part by Jewish agency and in great part by the Government', with the Supreme Muslim Council also taking 'a share' (Hope Simpson, 1930). Others saw more: Ahad Ha'am wrote in 1891 that 'It is very difficult to find in the land cultivated fields that are not used for planting' (see below). 'Akká's selection as the end of the line for exile shows how grim conditions could be: Bahá'u'lláh quoted what 'they say' of it — 'the most desolate of the cities of the world, the most unsightly of them in appearance, the most detestable in climate, and the foulest in water … the metropolis of the owl' — and in Shoghi Effendi's account the authorities hoped the life sentence 'would lead to their eventual extermination'. 'Without a people' can be read as literally empty or as 'without a distinct nation or state' (the sources below show both readings); the phrase circulated among 19th-century Christian restorationists before Zionist writers such as Israel Zangwill used it. Zangwill wrote in December 1901: 'Palestine is a country without a people, the Jews are a people without a country', calling it 'comparatively empty for eighteen hundred years', while the same article describes Es-Salt ('the ancient Ramoth-Gilead or perhaps Mizpah') as 'a tiny corner cultivated by the Arabs' (Frank Leslie's Popular Monthly). Lord Shaftesbury's 1854 diary has both readings in one passage: Syria 'is wasted without an inhabitant' (a biblical quotation), and 'will soon be without a ruler, without a known and acknowledged power to claim dominion … There is a country without a nation'. Zangwill later came to see 'the Arab presence in Palestine as an insuperable obstacle' and turned to finding a Jewish homeland elsewhere (the Jewish Territorial Organization, 1905). By 1917 he was arguing for a British Palestine again, and his book The Voice of Jerusalem (1920) keeps both halves side by side. It reprints his 1917 article calling the slogan 'a misleading mistake. The country holds 600,000 Arabs', ruling out 'massacring the modern Canaanites', and proposing that the Arabs be 'gently persuade[d] … to "trek"' to Arab lands. In the same book he calls a 'voluntary trek' 'literally the only "way out"', and writes that Shaftesbury, though 'literally inexact', was 'essentially correct, for there is no Arab people living in intimate fusion with the country … there is at best an Arab encampment'.
primary documentBahá'u'lláh, Súriy-i-Haykal (to Náṣiri'd-Dín Sháh), in The Summons of the Lord of Hosts, para. 83 ✓
Read 2026-09-30 (text as held in the editor's local copy of the bahai.org library, BH00038:83). 'Erelong shall the exponents of wealth and power banish Us from the land of Adrianople to the city of ‘Akká. According to what they say, it is the most desolate of the cities of the world, the most unsightly of them in appearance, the most detestable in climate, and the foulest in water. It is as though it were the metropolis of the owl …'
primary document'Abdu'l-Bahá, A Traveler's Narrative (bahai.org text) ✓
Read 2026-09-30 (local copy of the bahai.org text, AB00003:156). Quotes Bahá'u'lláh: 'We are about to shift from this most remote place of banishment unto the prison of ‘Akká. And, according to what they say, it is assuredly the most desolate of the cities of the world … and the foulest in water …'
historyShoghi Effendi, God Passes By (1944), ch. 12 (1944) incident ✓
Read 2026-09-30 (Bahá'í Reference Library). 'Akká 'had sunk, under the Turks, to the level of a penal colony to which murderers, highway robbers and political agitators were consigned from all parts of the Turkish empire'; quotes the Lawh-i-Sultán: 'the most desolate of the cities of the world, the most unsightly of them in appearance, the most detestable in climate, and the foulest in water'; 'according to a proverb, a bird when flying over it would drop dead'; hopes 'that the sentence of life-long imprisonment … would lead to their eventual extermination'; the farmán dated 26 July 1868.
primary documentMark Twain, The Innocents Abroad (1869) incident ✓
Read (Project Gutenberg): e.g. 'We traversed some miles of desolate country whose soil is rich enough, but is given over wholly to weeds--a silent, mournful expanse'. A traveller's impression, not a census.
primary documentLord Shaftesbury, diary entry of 17 May 1854, in Edwin Hodder, The Life and Work of the Seventh Earl of Shaftesbury, K.G., vol. 2 (London, 1887), p. 478 (archive.org scan, University of Toronto copy) (1854) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-29; OCR text). On writing to Sir Moses Montefiore about asking the Sultan for a firman 'granting to the Jewish people power to hold land in Syria': 'Syria "is wasted without an inhabitant;" these vast and fertile regions will soon be without a ruler, without a known and acknowledged power to claim dominion. … There is a country without a nation; and God now, in His wisdom and mercy, directs us to a nation without a country. His own once loved, nay, still loved people, the sons of Abraham, of Isaac, and of Jacob.' A private diary, published after his death; the 'without an inhabitant' phrase is a biblical quotation. Hodder notes he had laid 'a scheme for the Colonisation of Syria before Lord Palmerston in 1840'.
primary documentIsrael Zangwill, 'The Redemption of Palestine by the Jews', Frank Leslie's Popular Monthly, vol. 53 no. 2 (December 1901), pp. 209 ff. — Internet Archive scan (OCR); the parallel 'The Return to Palestine', New Liberal Review (December 1901), not read (1901) incident ✓
Read 1 Oct 2026 (OCR text). 'Palestine is a country without a people, the Jews are a people without a country. The regeneration of the soil would bring the regeneration of the people. It is marvelous that the country should have remained comparatively empty for eighteen hundred years, but it cannot remain unexploited much longer.' The same article mentions Es-Salt, 'a tiny corner cultivated by the Arabs', exporting raisins.
referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Israel Zangwill' (biography) ✓
Read: founded the Jewish Territorial Organization (ITO) in 1905; 'Seeing the Arab presence in Palestine as an insuperable obstacle', he advocated territorialism; in 1923 declared 'political Zionism is dead'.
primary documentIsrael Zangwill, The Voice of Jerusalem (London: Heinemann, 1920; New York: Macmillan, 1921), pp. 96–97 and 108–109 (archive.org scan of the Macmillan edition) (1920) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-29; OCR text). Pp. 96–97 reprint his May 1917 magazine article: "'Give the country without a people,' magnanimously pleaded Lord Shaftesbury, 'to the people without a country.' Alas, it was a misleading mistake. The country holds 600,000 Arabs"; 'unless the Jews are to begin their new life by massacring the modern Canaanites which is out of the question Zionism must, it would seem, remain largely moonshine'; Palestine is 'not so much occupied by the Arabs as over-run by them'; 'we must gently persuade them to "trek"'. Pp. 108–109 (1920 text): 'amicable race-redistribution or a voluntary trek like that of the Boers' is 'literally the only "way out"', and if impracticable 'the whole Zionist project was a chimera'; 'if Lord Shaftesbury was literally inexact in describing Palestine as a country without a people, he was essentially correct, for there is no Arab people living in intimate fusion with the country … there is at best an Arab encampment'. Shaftesbury's own 1854 diary wording was 'a country without a nation'. Re-read 2026-10-12 (archive.org text of The Voice of Jerusalem, 1920): 'if Lord Shaftesbury was literally inexact in describing Palestine as a country without a people, he was essentially correct, for there is no Arab people living in intimate fusion with the country, utilising its resources and stamping it with a characteristic impress: there is at best an Arab encampment'; and 'my suggestion of amicable race-redistribution or a voluntary trek like that of the Boers from Cape Colony is literally the only "way out" of the difficulty of creating a Jewish State in Palestine'.
primary documentSir John Hope Simpson, 'Palestine: Report on Immigration, Land Settlement and Development' (Cmd. 3686, 1930), UNISPAL copy (1930) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29). 'The Chief Immigration Officer has brought to notice that illicit immigration through Syria and across the northern frontier of Palestine is material … steps to this end must be taken … to prevent unemployment lists being swollen by immigrants from TransJordania.' Also: 7,800 travellers stayed without permission in 1927–30, and 'the number of persons who evade the frontier control'. The report does not break these figures down by community. Re-read 2026-09-30, on land: 'Very much has been done in the drainage of swamps and marshes, in great part by Jewish agency and in great part by the Government. The Supreme Moslem Council has also taken a share' (Wadi Rubin); the P.I.C.A.'s Kabbara swamp drainage; on the Vale of Esdraelon: 'It is a mistake to assume that the Vale of Esdraelon was a wilderness before the arrival of the Jewish settlers and that it is now a paradise'; the drainage and new methods 'highly valuable'; 'It is, however, unjust to the povertystricken fellah' who has been removed from these lands that the suggestion should continually be made that he was a useless cumberer of the ground'. Also (re-read 2026-10-12): 'At the time of writing, even with marked unemployment among Arabs, Egyptian labour is being employed in certain individual cases, and its ingress has been the subject of adverse comment in the Press.'
primary documentAhad Ha'am, 'Emet me-Eretz Yisrael' ('Truth from Eretz Israel', Hamelitz, June 1891), excerpt in the Jewish Virtual Library's biography of Ahad Ha'am (1891) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28): 'We who live abroad are accustomed to believe that almost all Eretz Israel is now uninhabited desert and whoever wishes can buy land there as he pleases. But this is not true. It is very difficult to find in the land cultivated fields that are not used for planting.' Also: the Arabs 'see and understand what we are doing and what we wish to do on the land, but they keep quiet'; the passage also contains period stereotypes ('the Arabs do not like working too much in the present for a distant future'). English translation as given by JVL.
How to talk about this.
Acknowledge first: the slogan 'a land without a people for a people without a land' circulated, and early Zionists, Zangwill among them (above), at times wished the Arab population away. Ask one question: 'how many Zionist leaders actually believed the land was empty, and how many argued about what to do with the people there?'; the record shows both. Share one checkable thing: Ahad Ha'am's 1891 essay 'Truth from Eretz Yisrael', written after his first visit: 'We who live abroad are accustomed to believe that almost all Eretz Israel is now uninhabited desert … But this is not true. It is very difficult to find in the land cultivated fields that are not used for planting.' He also warned that the Arabs 'see and understand what we are doing and what we wish to do on the land'. What not to say: 'Zionism always planned to expel the Arabs' as a single story, or 'there was nobody here' as a defence. From the other side: grant that the slogan existed and did harm, then ask what the Zionists who knew better proposed.
primary documentAhad Ha'am, 'Emet me-Eretz Yisrael' ('Truth from Eretz Israel', Hamelitz, June 1891), excerpt in the Jewish Virtual Library's biography of Ahad Ha'am (1891) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28): 'We who live abroad are accustomed to believe that almost all Eretz Israel is now uninhabited desert and whoever wishes can buy land there as he pleases. But this is not true. It is very difficult to find in the land cultivated fields that are not used for planting.' Also: the Arabs 'see and understand what we are doing and what we wish to do on the land, but they keep quiet'; the passage also contains period stereotypes ('the Arabs do not like working too much in the present for a distant future'). English translation as given by JVL.
Where it leads if pressed
Working it out: empty of people, or empty of a nation? The numbers and the two readings.
The slogan can mean two different things, and the evidence answers them differently. Read literally, 'without a people' means empty, and the counts refute it: Yehoshua Porath puts the mid-19th-century population at 'about four hundred thousand Arabs'; the 1922 census counted 757,182 people, of whom 83,794 were Jews, leaving about 673,000 others, roughly two-thirds more than Porath's earlier figure (this page's arithmetic). Even the slogan's best-known Zionist user corrected it: Israel Zangwill wrote in 1917 that it 'was a misleading mistake. The country holds 600,000 Arabs'. Read as 'without a nation', it is a different claim: Porath writes that in the mid-19th century 'there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity"', and Zangwill himself fell back on this reading in 1920, that Shaftesbury was 'literally inexact' but 'essentially correct, for there is no Arab people living in intimate fusion with the country, utilising its resources and stamping it with a characteristic impress: there is at best an Arab encampment'. That reading is arguable as history of identity, and the site's 'There's no such thing as a Palestinian people — it was invented in 1964.' page tests it; but it does not make the land empty, and Zangwill's own conclusion from it was that the Arabs would have to be persuaded to 'trek', which shows what was at stake. Ahad Ha'am had already warned in 1891, after his first visit, that the belief in an 'uninhabited desert' was 'not true'. The worst case for each side. For 'a land without a people': take the 'no nation' reading at its strongest; several hundred thousand people still lived there, and the reading was used to argue for their removal. Its own origin points the same way: the Christian restorationist Lord Shaftesbury wrote of 'a country without a nation' as a political claim about who ruled, 'without a known and acknowledged power to claim dominion', and travellers' accounts of the time describe neglect, not absence: Mark Twain's 'desolate country whose soil is rich enough, but is given over wholly to weeds' is an impression, not a count. For 'the slogan proves Zionists meant to erase Palestinians': take Zangwill at his worst; Ahad Ha'am and others in the movement argued about the people already there, and Zangwill himself left mainstream Zionism, seeing the Arab presence as an obstacle. Holds on the evidence here: the land was inhabited, by several hundred thousand people, mostly Arab; some Zionists knew it and said so. Arguable, as a question about identity: that a distinct Palestinian national identity formed later. Not supported: that the land was empty, or that every Zionist believed it was.
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean
historyYehoshua Porath, 'Mrs. Peters's Palestine', New York Review of Books (1986) finding ✓
Read in full (NYRB, 16 Jan 1986). Porath (Hebrew University) on Peters' thesis in his words: 'Much of Mrs. Peters's book argues that at the same time that Jewish immigration to Palestine was rising, Arab immigration to the parts of Palestine where Jews had settled also increased. Therefore, in her view, the Arab claim that an indigenous Arab population was displaced by Jewish immigrants must be false, since many Arabs only arrived with the Jews'; he answers with the Lovers of Zion settlers' writings 'filled with references to the Arabs surrounding them everywhere in Palestine'. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'in 1947 there were about 1.3 million Arabs living in Palestine'; 'most of the growth of the Palestinian Arab community resulted from a process of natural increase'; mid-19th century 'about four hundred thousand Arabs'. No '100,000 immigrants' figure in the review. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'It is true that in the middle of the nineteenth century there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity." But about four hundred thousand Arabs—the great majority of whom were Muslims—lived in Palestine, which was divided by the Ottomans into three districts.'
dataJ. B. Barron (Superintendent of Census), 'Palestine: Report and General Abstracts of the Census of 1922', taken on 23 October 1922 (Jerusalem, 1923) — scanned copy (1923) aggregate ✓
Read (2026-09-28; OCR of a scan). Para. 7: 'The total population of Palestine enumerated on the 23rd of October, 1922, was 757,182. This total includes the military, and persons of foreign nationality. Prior to the Census there existed no systematic arrangements for registering the population of Palestine.' Table I (with the report's erratum): Jews 83,794; Christians 73,024; Muslim total garbled in the OCR (reported elsewhere as 590,890, 78%, not relied on here). Table III (Population of Municipal Areas), Jerusalem: Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971 (OCR '33,t71'); Christians 14,699; total 62,578 (checked 2026-09-29). Jerusalem row (OCR, re-checked 2026-09-29): Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971; Christians 14,699; other columns 6, 484 and 5; total 62,578.
primary documentIsrael Zangwill, The Voice of Jerusalem (London: Heinemann, 1920; New York: Macmillan, 1921), pp. 96–97 and 108–109 (archive.org scan of the Macmillan edition) (1920) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-29; OCR text). Pp. 96–97 reprint his May 1917 magazine article: "'Give the country without a people,' magnanimously pleaded Lord Shaftesbury, 'to the people without a country.' Alas, it was a misleading mistake. The country holds 600,000 Arabs"; 'unless the Jews are to begin their new life by massacring the modern Canaanites which is out of the question Zionism must, it would seem, remain largely moonshine'; Palestine is 'not so much occupied by the Arabs as over-run by them'; 'we must gently persuade them to "trek"'. Pp. 108–109 (1920 text): 'amicable race-redistribution or a voluntary trek like that of the Boers' is 'literally the only "way out"', and if impracticable 'the whole Zionist project was a chimera'; 'if Lord Shaftesbury was literally inexact in describing Palestine as a country without a people, he was essentially correct, for there is no Arab people living in intimate fusion with the country … there is at best an Arab encampment'. Shaftesbury's own 1854 diary wording was 'a country without a nation'. Re-read 2026-10-12 (archive.org text of The Voice of Jerusalem, 1920): 'if Lord Shaftesbury was literally inexact in describing Palestine as a country without a people, he was essentially correct, for there is no Arab people living in intimate fusion with the country, utilising its resources and stamping it with a characteristic impress: there is at best an Arab encampment'; and 'my suggestion of amicable race-redistribution or a voluntary trek like that of the Boers from Cape Colony is literally the only "way out" of the difficulty of creating a Jewish State in Palestine'.
primary documentIsrael Zangwill, 'The Redemption of Palestine by the Jews', Frank Leslie's Popular Monthly, vol. 53 no. 2 (December 1901), pp. 209 ff. — Internet Archive scan (OCR); the parallel 'The Return to Palestine', New Liberal Review (December 1901), not read (1901) incident ✓
Read 1 Oct 2026 (OCR text). 'Palestine is a country without a people, the Jews are a people without a country. The regeneration of the soil would bring the regeneration of the people. It is marvelous that the country should have remained comparatively empty for eighteen hundred years, but it cannot remain unexploited much longer.' The same article mentions Es-Salt, 'a tiny corner cultivated by the Arabs', exporting raisins.
primary documentAhad Ha'am, 'Emet me-Eretz Yisrael' ('Truth from Eretz Israel', Hamelitz, June 1891), excerpt in the Jewish Virtual Library's biography of Ahad Ha'am (1891) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28): 'We who live abroad are accustomed to believe that almost all Eretz Israel is now uninhabited desert and whoever wishes can buy land there as he pleases. But this is not true. It is very difficult to find in the land cultivated fields that are not used for planting.' Also: the Arabs 'see and understand what we are doing and what we wish to do on the land, but they keep quiet'; the passage also contains period stereotypes ('the Arabs do not like working too much in the present for a distant future'). English translation as given by JVL.
referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Israel Zangwill' (biography) ✓
Read: founded the Jewish Territorial Organization (ITO) in 1905; 'Seeing the Arab presence in Palestine as an insuperable obstacle', he advocated territorialism; in 1923 declared 'political Zionism is dead'.
primary documentLord Shaftesbury, diary entry of 17 May 1854, in Edwin Hodder, The Life and Work of the Seventh Earl of Shaftesbury, K.G., vol. 2 (London, 1887), p. 478 (archive.org scan, University of Toronto copy) (1854) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-29; OCR text). On writing to Sir Moses Montefiore about asking the Sultan for a firman 'granting to the Jewish people power to hold land in Syria': 'Syria "is wasted without an inhabitant;" these vast and fertile regions will soon be without a ruler, without a known and acknowledged power to claim dominion. … There is a country without a nation; and God now, in His wisdom and mercy, directs us to a nation without a country. His own once loved, nay, still loved people, the sons of Abraham, of Isaac, and of Jacob.' A private diary, published after his death; the 'without an inhabitant' phrase is a biblical quotation. Hodder notes he had laid 'a scheme for the Colonisation of Syria before Lord Palmerston in 1840'.
primary documentMark Twain, The Innocents Abroad (1869) incident ✓
Read (Project Gutenberg): e.g. 'We traversed some miles of desolate country whose soil is rich enough, but is given over wholly to weeds--a silent, mournful expanse'. A traveller's impression, not a census.
'underdeveloped' is not 'empty', and neither decides rights.
A poor, neglected land with a real population is a setting where a newcomer's development and a native grievance can both be real, and on this page's sources both are. Hope Simpson credits the draining of the swamps 'in great part' to Jewish agency (and in great part to the Government); the 1922 census and Porath count the people who were already there, whom the slogan, taken literally, left out.
primary documentSir John Hope Simpson, 'Palestine: Report on Immigration, Land Settlement and Development' (Cmd. 3686, 1930), UNISPAL copy (1930) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29). 'The Chief Immigration Officer has brought to notice that illicit immigration through Syria and across the northern frontier of Palestine is material … steps to this end must be taken … to prevent unemployment lists being swollen by immigrants from TransJordania.' Also: 7,800 travellers stayed without permission in 1927–30, and 'the number of persons who evade the frontier control'. The report does not break these figures down by community. Re-read 2026-09-30, on land: 'Very much has been done in the drainage of swamps and marshes, in great part by Jewish agency and in great part by the Government. The Supreme Moslem Council has also taken a share' (Wadi Rubin); the P.I.C.A.'s Kabbara swamp drainage; on the Vale of Esdraelon: 'It is a mistake to assume that the Vale of Esdraelon was a wilderness before the arrival of the Jewish settlers and that it is now a paradise'; the drainage and new methods 'highly valuable'; 'It is, however, unjust to the povertystricken fellah' who has been removed from these lands that the suggestion should continually be made that he was a useless cumberer of the ground'. Also (re-read 2026-10-12): 'At the time of writing, even with marked unemployment among Arabs, Egyptian labour is being employed in certain individual cases, and its ingress has been the subject of adverse comment in the Press.'
dataJ. B. Barron (Superintendent of Census), 'Palestine: Report and General Abstracts of the Census of 1922', taken on 23 October 1922 (Jerusalem, 1923) — scanned copy (1923) aggregate ✓
Read (2026-09-28; OCR of a scan). Para. 7: 'The total population of Palestine enumerated on the 23rd of October, 1922, was 757,182. This total includes the military, and persons of foreign nationality. Prior to the Census there existed no systematic arrangements for registering the population of Palestine.' Table I (with the report's erratum): Jews 83,794; Christians 73,024; Muslim total garbled in the OCR (reported elsewhere as 590,890, 78%, not relied on here). Table III (Population of Municipal Areas), Jerusalem: Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971 (OCR '33,t71'); Christians 14,699; total 62,578 (checked 2026-09-29). Jerusalem row (OCR, re-checked 2026-09-29): Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971; Christians 14,699; other columns 6, 484 and 5; total 62,578.
historyYehoshua Porath, 'Mrs. Peters's Palestine', New York Review of Books (1986) finding ✓
Read in full (NYRB, 16 Jan 1986). Porath (Hebrew University) on Peters' thesis in his words: 'Much of Mrs. Peters's book argues that at the same time that Jewish immigration to Palestine was rising, Arab immigration to the parts of Palestine where Jews had settled also increased. Therefore, in her view, the Arab claim that an indigenous Arab population was displaced by Jewish immigrants must be false, since many Arabs only arrived with the Jews'; he answers with the Lovers of Zion settlers' writings 'filled with references to the Arabs surrounding them everywhere in Palestine'. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'in 1947 there were about 1.3 million Arabs living in Palestine'; 'most of the growth of the Palestinian Arab community resulted from a process of natural increase'; mid-19th century 'about four hundred thousand Arabs'. No '100,000 immigrants' figure in the review. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'It is true that in the middle of the nineteenth century there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity." But about four hundred thousand Arabs—the great majority of whom were Muslims—lived in Palestine, which was divided by the Ottomans into three districts.'
The usual reply — and its own traps
Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.
heard from pro-Palestinian voices“Palestine was definitely a thing — there was even a newspaper called Filastin in 1911 — and almost no Jews lived there, so Israel was a hostile takeover.” heard from pro-Palestinian voices“A 3,000-year-old promise doesn't justify a genocide.”Where this argument points
This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions — for, against or around them: