Argument · heard from pro-Israel voices
“Most Palestinians are descendants of recent Arab immigrants who came for the jobs Zionism created; the real locals were only a few villagers and tribes.”
Before Zionism the land was nearly empty, with a small population of peasants and tribes. Most of today's Palestinians descend from economic migrants of the late Ottoman and Mandate years, and their surnames still show where they came from, so their claim to be the land's people is weaker than it looks.
Made publicly as a pro-Israel argument by Daniel Pipes and Winston Churchill
Where it's been said
“Many of those who now consider themselves Palestinian refugees were either immigrants themselves before 1948 or the children of immigrants. This historical fact reduces their claim to the land of Israel.”
advocacy / viewDaniel Pipes, review of Joan Peters, 'From Time Immemorial', Commentary (July 1984) (1984) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-28). 'Many of those who now consider themselves Palestinian refugees were either immigrants themselves before 1948 or the children of immigrants. This historical fact reduces their claim to the land of Israel'; the book's work 'should materially influence the future course of the debate'. The page adds a March 1986 update in which Pipes replied to Yehoshua Porath's critical review (see porath-1986-review).
“So far from being persecuted, the Arabs have crowded into the country and multiplied till their population has increased more than even all world Jewry could lift up the Jewish population.”
“From a position of apparently great learning and research, she attempts to refute the Arab myths merely by substituting the Jewish myths for them.”
“Who are the Palestinians? We have many families named Al-Matzri, whose roots are Egyptian.”
Traps in play:◆ "They all…"◆ Judging by origin
Why people find it convincing
- Some Arab migration into Palestine did happen. In 1831 'more than six thousand peasants crossed the Egyptian border', fleeing forced labour under Muhammad Ali, and later arrivals continued up to 1948, though, as the same authors note, those later waves were not recorded in writing and can only be reconstructed 'based on oral testimonies' (Kressel and Aharoni, Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, 2013, citing Sabri 1930). Under the Mandate, the Hope Simpson report (1930) called illicit immigration 'through Syria and across the northern frontier of Palestine' 'material' and warned of unemployment lists 'swollen by immigrants from TransJordania', without saying how many of the illicit entrants were Arabs. For labourers from the Hauran specifically, see the next point.
- Some common surnames record an origin elsewhere: al-Masri (Egyptian), al-Mughrabi (Maghrebi; Jerusalem's Maghrebi quarter was a 12th-century endowment, per Mujir al-Din), Hourani, al-Halabi (Aleppan).
- Arab population growth was fastest in the districts where the Jewish-driven economy grew, around Jaffa and Haifa, which suggests newcomers: the economist Fred Gottheil calculates that in those sub-districts the 1931 Arab population was 64,790 above what natural increase alone would give (Middle East Quarterly, 2003; he concedes the census data themselves show only natural increase and legal migration).
- The League of Nations heard a specific claim: at the Permanent Mandates Commission (5 June 1935) Lord Lugard cited an interview in La Syrie (12 August 1934) in which the Governor of the Hauran said 'in the last few months from 30,000 to 36,000 Hauranese had entered Palestine and settled there', and M. Orts noted the Governor 'even referred to the large sums remitted by these immigrants to their families'. The British representative, Mr. Moody, called it 'a gross exaggeration', because 'the Palestine Government had taken special measures on the eastern and north-eastern frontier', and said infiltration from or through Trans-Jordan was not 'any very serious problem'. How many came and stayed is not settled by either statement.
- Nineteenth-century travellers described a sparsely populated, neglected land (Mark Twain, 1869: 'a silent, mournful expanse'), and in the mid-19th century 'there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity"', as the historian Yehoshua Porath puts it, though 'about four hundred thousand Arabs' lived there.
- A Hamas leader has said it: in 2012 Gaza's interior minister, Fathi Hammad, told an Egyptian TV channel 'Who are the Palestinians? We have many families named Al-Matzri, whose roots are Egyptian', and that half his own family was Egyptian (as reported by Algemeiner/Tazpit from the broadcast).
What's true
Some migration, some telling surnames, and faster growth where the Jewish economy grew.
Migration from Egypt and elsewhere is documented, and some surnames preserve it: the Hope Simpson report (1930) noted that 'Egyptian labour is being employed in certain individual cases', and that 'illicit immigration through Syria and across the northern frontier of Palestine is material'. Earlier migration is documented too: in 1831 'more than six thousand peasants crossed the Egyptian border', whom Muhammad Ali regarded 'as renegades who had taken flight' from forced labour, by the account of Gideon Kressel and Reuven Aharoni (Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, 2013). They add that the later influx, 'up to 1948', was not recorded: 'One can only reconstruct to some extent, based on oral testimonies'. The economist Fred Gottheil finds 64,790 more Arabs in 1931 than natural growth would give in the sub-districts that later became Israel, which he attributes to illegal immigration and/or movement from elsewhere in Palestine.
advocacy / viewFred M. Gottheil, 'The Smoking Gun: Arab Immigration into Palestine, 1922-31', Middle East Quarterly (Winter 2003) (2003) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29). Middle East Forum journal (pro-Israel-leaning). Applying a natural growth rate to the 1922 Arab population of the sub-districts with large Jewish populations 'generates an expected population size for 1931 of 398,498 or 64,790 less than the actual population recorded in the British census', which he attributes largely to immigration; citing Bachi, 'at least one-third of Palestine's population growth may be attributed to immigration'. He concedes that the census data themselves show growth 'generated by natural increase and legal migrations alone', and reports McCarthy's counter-argument (that immigrants' deaths would have been registered), which he disputes. Re-read 2026-09-30: the 'one-third' is his inference for 1800–1914 from Bachi's growth-rate differential (Bachi: 'It is possible that part of the growth of the Muslim population was due to immigration'); the 64,790 (1922–31) he attributes to 'illegal immigration … and/or registered Arab Palestinians moving from outside the Jewish-identified sub-districts'. Re-read 2026-10-02: McCarthy's numbers rest 'in part, on Bachi's reporting of 900 illegal Arab immigrants per year over the period 1931-45', which Gottheil says Bachi limited to those ‘discovered by the mandatory authorities’; Bachi: ‘in the present state of knowledge, we have been unable to even guess the size of total immigration’; a 2.5% natural rate on the 1922 stock gives 735,799, ‘97.6 percent of the 753,822 recorded in the 1931 census’. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'this unaccounted population increase must have been either illegal immigration not accounted for in the British census and/or registered Arab Palestinians moving from outside the Jewish-identified sub-districts to those sub-districts so identified'.
historyYehoshua Porath, 'Mrs. Peters's Palestine', New York Review of Books (1986) finding ✓
Read in full (NYRB, 16 Jan 1986). Porath (Hebrew University) on Peters' thesis in his words: 'Much of Mrs. Peters's book argues that at the same time that Jewish immigration to Palestine was rising, Arab immigration to the parts of Palestine where Jews had settled also increased. Therefore, in her view, the Arab claim that an indigenous Arab population was displaced by Jewish immigrants must be false, since many Arabs only arrived with the Jews'; he answers with the Lovers of Zion settlers' writings 'filled with references to the Arabs surrounding them everywhere in Palestine'. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'in 1947 there were about 1.3 million Arabs living in Palestine'; 'most of the growth of the Palestinian Arab community resulted from a process of natural increase'; mid-19th century 'about four hundred thousand Arabs'. No '100,000 immigrants' figure in the review. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'It is true that in the middle of the nineteenth century there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity." But about four hundred thousand Arabs—the great majority of whom were Muslims—lived in Palestine, which was divided by the Ottomans into three districts.'
primary documentSir John Hope Simpson, 'Palestine: Report on Immigration, Land Settlement and Development' (Cmd. 3686, 1930), UNISPAL copy (1930) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29). 'The Chief Immigration Officer has brought to notice that illicit immigration through Syria and across the northern frontier of Palestine is material … steps to this end must be taken … to prevent unemployment lists being swollen by immigrants from TransJordania.' Also: 7,800 travellers stayed without permission in 1927–30, and 'the number of persons who evade the frontier control'. The report does not break these figures down by community. Re-read 2026-09-30, on land: 'Very much has been done in the drainage of swamps and marshes, in great part by Jewish agency and in great part by the Government. The Supreme Moslem Council has also taken a share' (Wadi Rubin); the P.I.C.A.'s Kabbara swamp drainage; on the Vale of Esdraelon: 'It is a mistake to assume that the Vale of Esdraelon was a wilderness before the arrival of the Jewish settlers and that it is now a paradise'; the drainage and new methods 'highly valuable'; 'It is, however, unjust to the povertystricken fellah' who has been removed from these lands that the suggestion should continually be made that he was a useless cumberer of the ground'. Also (re-read 2026-10-12): 'At the time of writing, even with marked unemployment among Arabs, Egyptian labour is being employed in certain individual cases, and its ingress has been the subject of adverse comment in the Press.'
historyGideon M. Kressel and Reuven Aharoni, 'Egyptian Émigrés in the Levant of the 19th and 20th Centuries' (Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, 2013) (2013) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29). JCPA: see its org page; the authors are an anthropologist (Ben-Gurion University) and a historian (formerly Haifa University). 'In 1831, more than six thousand peasants crossed the Egyptian border (Sabri, 1930: 131)', viewed by Muhammad Ali 'as renegades who had taken flight' from forced labour; 'The waves of newcomers in the early 1830s were partly recorded in writing, but not the influx of immigrants that followed and in fact intensified in the years to come – up to 1948 … One can only reconstruct to some extent, based on oral testimonies'.
What's left out
Most Arabs of Palestine were settled farmers and townspeople whose families had been there long before the Mandate.
The majority were fellahin in villages and townspeople in Jaffa, Nablus, Hebron, Gaza and Jerusalem, with tribes in the Negev and elsewhere a minority, out of 'about 1.3 million Arabs living in Palestine' in 1947 (Porath, from the Mandate's statistics). How much Arab immigration there was is genuinely uncertain (overall figures for 1922–45 are uncertain by the sources' own account: Justin McCarthy's estimate rests partly on Roberto Bachi's figure of 900 illegal Arab immigrants a year for 1931–45, which, Gottheil points out, Bachi gave only for entries the police discovered, writing that 'we have been unable to even guess the size of total immigration'; Gottheil also notes that for the country as a whole a 2.5% natural growth rate reproduces 97.6% of the 1931 census count — both as reported by Gottheil, who disputes McCarthy; McCarthy's own book is not read here ⚠). The demographer Roberto Bachi wrote of 1800–1914 only that 'It is possible that part of the growth of the Muslim population was due to immigration'; the economist Fred Gottheil (Middle East Quarterly, pro-Israel-leaning) argues from Bachi's growth rates that 'at least one-third of Palestine's population growth may be attributed to immigration'. For 1922–31 Gottheil finds 64,790 more Arabs in the sub-districts that later became Israel than natural growth would give, which he says must be 'illegal immigration not accounted for in the British census and/or registered Arab Palestinians moving from outside' those sub-districts, so part of it is movement within Palestine. Joan Peters' From Time Immemorial (1984) pushed a far larger thesis, which the Israeli historian Yehoshua Porath summarised and rejected in a long review (New York Review of Books, 1986: 'most of the growth of the Palestinian Arab community resulted from a process of natural increase'); the data themselves are poor (incomplete Ottoman registers, unrecorded border crossings). So: some real Arab immigration, concentrated where the Jewish-driven economy grew; but, in Porath's reading of the two Mandate censuses, 'most of the growth of the Palestinian Arab community resulted from a process of natural increase'. The Palestinian national leadership came from old Jerusalem families (Husseini, Nashashibi, Khalidi, Nusseibeh), and surnames can record origins centuries old — Jerusalem's Mughrabi quarter dates to the 12th century: the 15th-century historian Mujir al-Din records that Saladin's son al-Afdal, while ruling Damascus, made it a waqf 'en faveur de la Communauté des Maghrébins' (in favour of the community of Maghrebis), in the French edition read here. The Hamas minister's 2012 remarks were a plea for Egyptian support, 'in order to continue to wage Jihad', in his words, and they rest on the same surname evidence as above: family names and family lore, not population records.
Traps here:◆ "They all…"◆ Judging by origin
historyYehoshua Porath, 'Mrs. Peters's Palestine', New York Review of Books (1986) finding ✓
Read in full (NYRB, 16 Jan 1986). Porath (Hebrew University) on Peters' thesis in his words: 'Much of Mrs. Peters's book argues that at the same time that Jewish immigration to Palestine was rising, Arab immigration to the parts of Palestine where Jews had settled also increased. Therefore, in her view, the Arab claim that an indigenous Arab population was displaced by Jewish immigrants must be false, since many Arabs only arrived with the Jews'; he answers with the Lovers of Zion settlers' writings 'filled with references to the Arabs surrounding them everywhere in Palestine'. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'in 1947 there were about 1.3 million Arabs living in Palestine'; 'most of the growth of the Palestinian Arab community resulted from a process of natural increase'; mid-19th century 'about four hundred thousand Arabs'. No '100,000 immigrants' figure in the review. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'It is true that in the middle of the nineteenth century there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity." But about four hundred thousand Arabs—the great majority of whom were Muslims—lived in Palestine, which was divided by the Ottomans into three districts.'
advocacy / viewFred M. Gottheil, 'The Smoking Gun: Arab Immigration into Palestine, 1922-31', Middle East Quarterly (Winter 2003) (2003) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29). Middle East Forum journal (pro-Israel-leaning). Applying a natural growth rate to the 1922 Arab population of the sub-districts with large Jewish populations 'generates an expected population size for 1931 of 398,498 or 64,790 less than the actual population recorded in the British census', which he attributes largely to immigration; citing Bachi, 'at least one-third of Palestine's population growth may be attributed to immigration'. He concedes that the census data themselves show growth 'generated by natural increase and legal migrations alone', and reports McCarthy's counter-argument (that immigrants' deaths would have been registered), which he disputes. Re-read 2026-09-30: the 'one-third' is his inference for 1800–1914 from Bachi's growth-rate differential (Bachi: 'It is possible that part of the growth of the Muslim population was due to immigration'); the 64,790 (1922–31) he attributes to 'illegal immigration … and/or registered Arab Palestinians moving from outside the Jewish-identified sub-districts'. Re-read 2026-10-02: McCarthy's numbers rest 'in part, on Bachi's reporting of 900 illegal Arab immigrants per year over the period 1931-45', which Gottheil says Bachi limited to those ‘discovered by the mandatory authorities’; Bachi: ‘in the present state of knowledge, we have been unable to even guess the size of total immigration’; a 2.5% natural rate on the 1922 stock gives 735,799, ‘97.6 percent of the 753,822 recorded in the 1931 census’. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'this unaccounted population increase must have been either illegal immigration not accounted for in the British census and/or registered Arab Palestinians moving from outside the Jewish-identified sub-districts to those sub-districts so identified'.
pressSenior Hamas Official: Palestinians Don't Come from Palestine (Algemeiner / Tazpit, 7 May 2012) (2012) incident ✓
Read 1 Oct 2026 (Aryeh Savir, Tazpit News Agency, in The Algemeiner, 7 May 2012). Fathi Hammad, Hamas interior minister, on Egypt's Al-Hekma TV 'In an attempt to gain Egyptian sympathy': 'Who are the Palestinians? We have many families named Al-Matzri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptians! … We are Egyptians. We are Arabs. We are Muslims. We are a part of you'; the report paraphrases him as saying half of Gazans came from Egypt and the other half from Saudi Arabia and Yemen. The broadcast itself and other translations are not read here; the broadcast date is not given in the article. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'When we seek their help, it is in order to continue to wage Jihad'.
historyMujir al-Din (Moudjir-ed-dyn), chronicle of Jerusalem and Hebron (c. 1495), in H. Sauvaire's French translation, Histoire de Jérusalem et d'Hébron (Paris, 1876), p. 163 (archive.org scan, University of Toronto copy) (1876) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-29; OCR text). On the Madraseh Afdaliyeh 'dans le quartier des Maghrébins': al-Malik al-Afdal, son of Salah al-Din, 'constitua aussi en waqf le quartier des Maghrébins en faveur de la Communauté des Maghrébins, sans distinction d'origine, hommes et femmes. La donation eut lieu à l'époque où ce prince régnait sur Damas dont Jérusalem formait une annexe.' The original deeds were lost and re-certified before the court after his death. No year is given for the quarter itself (the 589 AH/1193 date in the same passage is for a different mosque). English rendering on this site.
More context
Reading the numbers
The claim is about proportions ('most Palestinians'), so it can be tested with the census figures on this page, using growth arithmetic. (1) The start and end: the 1922 census counted 757,182 people, of whom 83,794 were Jews, leaving about 673,000 others (this page's arithmetic), mostly Arab Muslims and Christians; by 1947 there were 'about 1.3 million Arabs' (Porath). (2) Natural growth: at 2.5% a year, the rate Gottheil uses for his own country-wide check, 673,000 people in 1922 become about 1.25 million by 1947, about 96% of the 1947 figure, leaving roughly 50,000 for immigration (this page's arithmetic). (3) The worst case for the other side, that immigration was negligible: Gottheil finds 64,790 more Arabs in 1931 than natural growth predicts in the sub-districts that later became Israel, about 14% of their Arab population then; growth was concentrated where the Jewish economy was, whether from abroad or from elsewhere in Palestine. Contemporaries also reported unrecorded entry: Hope Simpson wrote in 1930 that 'illicit immigration through Syria and across the northern frontier of Palestine is material', and the Governor of the Hauran claimed in 1934 that '30,000 to 36,000 Hauranese had entered Palestine and settled there' (as discussed at the League's Mandates Commission). Even at its top, 36,000 sits inside the gap of roughly 50,000 to 190,000 that the growth arithmetic leaves, so it is consistent with the census figures rather than a challenge to them. (4) The worst case for the claim itself: the natural growth rate is uncertain. At a lower 2.0% a year, natural growth gives about 1.10 million, and the gap rises to roughly 195,000, about 15% of 1947's Arabs (this page's arithmetic: 673,000 × 1.02^25). Even then, and even if the whole gap were immigrants and their children, most of the 1947 Arab population would descend from those counted in 1922. This tests arrivals after 1922 only; earlier migration, such as the Egyptian peasants of the 1830s, is part of the population the 1922 census counted, and is discussed in the notes above. Holds on every reading: there was Arab immigration, concentrated in the areas of Jewish settlement, and most Arabs of Palestine in 1947 descended from people already there in 1922. Holds only with a much lower natural growth rate than either reading here: that immigrants and their children were more than about a sixth of the 1947 population. Not supported by any reading: that most Palestinians descend from recent immigrants; or that there was no immigration at all (see 'Reading war numbers').
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean
dataJ. B. Barron (Superintendent of Census), 'Palestine: Report and General Abstracts of the Census of 1922', taken on 23 October 1922 (Jerusalem, 1923) — scanned copy (1923) aggregate ✓
Read (2026-09-28; OCR of a scan). Para. 7: 'The total population of Palestine enumerated on the 23rd of October, 1922, was 757,182. This total includes the military, and persons of foreign nationality. Prior to the Census there existed no systematic arrangements for registering the population of Palestine.' Table I (with the report's erratum): Jews 83,794; Christians 73,024; Muslim total garbled in the OCR (reported elsewhere as 590,890, 78%, not relied on here). Table III (Population of Municipal Areas), Jerusalem: Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971 (OCR '33,t71'); Christians 14,699; total 62,578 (checked 2026-09-29). Jerusalem row (OCR, re-checked 2026-09-29): Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971; Christians 14,699; other columns 6, 484 and 5; total 62,578.
historyYehoshua Porath, 'Mrs. Peters's Palestine', New York Review of Books (1986) finding ✓
Read in full (NYRB, 16 Jan 1986). Porath (Hebrew University) on Peters' thesis in his words: 'Much of Mrs. Peters's book argues that at the same time that Jewish immigration to Palestine was rising, Arab immigration to the parts of Palestine where Jews had settled also increased. Therefore, in her view, the Arab claim that an indigenous Arab population was displaced by Jewish immigrants must be false, since many Arabs only arrived with the Jews'; he answers with the Lovers of Zion settlers' writings 'filled with references to the Arabs surrounding them everywhere in Palestine'. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'in 1947 there were about 1.3 million Arabs living in Palestine'; 'most of the growth of the Palestinian Arab community resulted from a process of natural increase'; mid-19th century 'about four hundred thousand Arabs'. No '100,000 immigrants' figure in the review. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'It is true that in the middle of the nineteenth century there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity." But about four hundred thousand Arabs—the great majority of whom were Muslims—lived in Palestine, which was divided by the Ottomans into three districts.'
advocacy / viewFred M. Gottheil, 'The Smoking Gun: Arab Immigration into Palestine, 1922-31', Middle East Quarterly (Winter 2003) (2003) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29). Middle East Forum journal (pro-Israel-leaning). Applying a natural growth rate to the 1922 Arab population of the sub-districts with large Jewish populations 'generates an expected population size for 1931 of 398,498 or 64,790 less than the actual population recorded in the British census', which he attributes largely to immigration; citing Bachi, 'at least one-third of Palestine's population growth may be attributed to immigration'. He concedes that the census data themselves show growth 'generated by natural increase and legal migrations alone', and reports McCarthy's counter-argument (that immigrants' deaths would have been registered), which he disputes. Re-read 2026-09-30: the 'one-third' is his inference for 1800–1914 from Bachi's growth-rate differential (Bachi: 'It is possible that part of the growth of the Muslim population was due to immigration'); the 64,790 (1922–31) he attributes to 'illegal immigration … and/or registered Arab Palestinians moving from outside the Jewish-identified sub-districts'. Re-read 2026-10-02: McCarthy's numbers rest 'in part, on Bachi's reporting of 900 illegal Arab immigrants per year over the period 1931-45', which Gottheil says Bachi limited to those ‘discovered by the mandatory authorities’; Bachi: ‘in the present state of knowledge, we have been unable to even guess the size of total immigration’; a 2.5% natural rate on the 1922 stock gives 735,799, ‘97.6 percent of the 753,822 recorded in the 1931 census’. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'this unaccounted population increase must have been either illegal immigration not accounted for in the British census and/or registered Arab Palestinians moving from outside the Jewish-identified sub-districts to those sub-districts so identified'.
primary documentSir John Hope Simpson, 'Palestine: Report on Immigration, Land Settlement and Development' (Cmd. 3686, 1930), UNISPAL copy (1930) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29). 'The Chief Immigration Officer has brought to notice that illicit immigration through Syria and across the northern frontier of Palestine is material … steps to this end must be taken … to prevent unemployment lists being swollen by immigrants from TransJordania.' Also: 7,800 travellers stayed without permission in 1927–30, and 'the number of persons who evade the frontier control'. The report does not break these figures down by community. Re-read 2026-09-30, on land: 'Very much has been done in the drainage of swamps and marshes, in great part by Jewish agency and in great part by the Government. The Supreme Moslem Council has also taken a share' (Wadi Rubin); the P.I.C.A.'s Kabbara swamp drainage; on the Vale of Esdraelon: 'It is a mistake to assume that the Vale of Esdraelon was a wilderness before the arrival of the Jewish settlers and that it is now a paradise'; the drainage and new methods 'highly valuable'; 'It is, however, unjust to the povertystricken fellah' who has been removed from these lands that the suggestion should continually be made that he was a useless cumberer of the ground'. Also (re-read 2026-10-12): 'At the time of writing, even with marked unemployment among Arabs, Egyptian labour is being employed in certain individual cases, and its ingress has been the subject of adverse comment in the Press.'
primary documentLeague of Nations, Permanent Mandates Commission, minutes of the sixth meeting (5 June 1935), examination of the annual report for 1934 on Palestine and Trans-Jordan — UNISPAL copy (1935) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-01. Lugard on the Governor of the Hauran's interview (La Syrie, 12 Aug 1934): '30,000 to 36,000 Hauranese had entered Palestine and settled there'; Orts: the claim 'caused some excitement among the Jews', who saw the mandatory 'closing its eyes to the entry of Hauranese, while it severely punished illicit Jewish immigration'; remittances; Moody: 'a gross exaggeration', frontier measures, no 'very serious problem' from infiltration through Trans-Jordan. (UNISPAL labels the document '27th session'; the text's header says thirty-fourth — not resolved here.) Re-read 2026-10-12: Lugard: the Governor of the Hauran 'said that in the last few months from 30,000 to 36,000 Hauranese had entered Palestine and settled there'; Orts: 'The Governor even referred to the large sums remitted by these immigrants to their families, who remained in the Hauran'; Moody: 'a gross exaggeration', 'because the Palestine Government had taken special measures on the eastern and north-eastern frontier with a view to keeping out undesirable people', and the Administration did not think 'there was any very serious problem resulting from the infiltration of Arabs into Palestine'.
How to talk about this.
Acknowledge first: there was real Arab migration into Palestine in the 19th and 20th centuries, partly drawn by the economy that Zionist immigration and the Mandate created. Ask one question: 'would the same test disqualify Israelis whose families arrived in the same decades?'; it applies to both. Share one checkable thing: the British census of October 1922 counted 757,182 people in Palestine, and by 1947 there were 'about 1.3 million Arabs' (Porath); how much of that growth was immigration is the disputed part, and the figures above are the evidence. What not to say: 'there were no Arabs here', which is false. From the other side: grant that some Palestinian families are recent arrivals, then ask why that would make their grandchildren less at home than anyone else's.
dataJ. B. Barron (Superintendent of Census), 'Palestine: Report and General Abstracts of the Census of 1922', taken on 23 October 1922 (Jerusalem, 1923) — scanned copy (1923) aggregate ✓
Read (2026-09-28; OCR of a scan). Para. 7: 'The total population of Palestine enumerated on the 23rd of October, 1922, was 757,182. This total includes the military, and persons of foreign nationality. Prior to the Census there existed no systematic arrangements for registering the population of Palestine.' Table I (with the report's erratum): Jews 83,794; Christians 73,024; Muslim total garbled in the OCR (reported elsewhere as 590,890, 78%, not relied on here). Table III (Population of Municipal Areas), Jerusalem: Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971 (OCR '33,t71'); Christians 14,699; total 62,578 (checked 2026-09-29). Jerusalem row (OCR, re-checked 2026-09-29): Muslims 13,413; Jews 33,971; Christians 14,699; other columns 6, 484 and 5; total 62,578.
historyYehoshua Porath, 'Mrs. Peters's Palestine', New York Review of Books (1986) finding ✓
Read in full (NYRB, 16 Jan 1986). Porath (Hebrew University) on Peters' thesis in his words: 'Much of Mrs. Peters's book argues that at the same time that Jewish immigration to Palestine was rising, Arab immigration to the parts of Palestine where Jews had settled also increased. Therefore, in her view, the Arab claim that an indigenous Arab population was displaced by Jewish immigrants must be false, since many Arabs only arrived with the Jews'; he answers with the Lovers of Zion settlers' writings 'filled with references to the Arabs surrounding them everywhere in Palestine'. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'in 1947 there were about 1.3 million Arabs living in Palestine'; 'most of the growth of the Palestinian Arab community resulted from a process of natural increase'; mid-19th century 'about four hundred thousand Arabs'. No '100,000 immigrants' figure in the review. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'It is true that in the middle of the nineteenth century there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity." But about four hundred thousand Arabs—the great majority of whom were Muslims—lived in Palestine, which was divided by the Ottomans into three districts.'
Where it leads if pressed
Descent-based legitimacy, the mirror image of the 'real descendants' argument.
It asks who arrived when, instead of what rights people who have lived somewhere for generations should have. If we reject 'modern Jews aren't really from there', we must reject 'Palestinians aren't really from there' by the same rule. Old families led rival camps, the Husseinis of the Mufti Hajj Amin al-Husseini and the Nashashibis, so long local descent did not settle which side a family took either (Raghib al-Nashashibi led 'what came to be known as the "opposition" to the majlisiyyun led by Haj Amin al-Husseini', and in 1931 answered the Mufti's Pan-Islamic Congress with 'a rival congress', in PalQuest's biography).
referencePalQuest (Institute for Palestine Studies), biography 'Raghib al-Nashashibi' ✓
Read 2026-10-02 (a Palestinian research institute's encyclopedia). Appointed mayor of Jerusalem in 1920 by Ronald Storrs, succeeding Musa Kazim Husseini; 'Nashashibi, together with some mayors, businessmen, and landowners, constituted what came to be known as the "opposition" to the majlisiyyun led by Haj Amin al-Husseini, Mufti of Jerusalem and head of the Supreme Moslem Council'; in December 1931 he answered the Mufti's Pan-Islamic Congress 'by convening a rival congress'; 'generally known as a moderate in his opposition to British policy and was close to Prince Abdullah'.
The usual reply — and its own traps
Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.
heard from pro-Palestinian voices“Only a small share of ancient Jews ever left; Palestinians are the real descendants of the ancient inhabitants, and today's Jews are mostly Europeans.”Where this argument points
This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions — for, against or around them: