Argument · heard from pro-Israel voices

“There's no such thing as a Palestinian people — it was invented in 1964.”

Palestinian identity is a recent political invention of the PLO; before that, the Arabs of the land were just Arabs, so they have no national claim.

Made publicly as a pro-Israel argument by Golda Meir and Bezalel Smotrich

Where it's been said

“There were no such thing as Palestinians. When was there an independent Palestinian people with a Palestinian state? … It was not as though there was a Palestinian people in Palestine considering itself as a Palestinian people and we came and threw them out and took their country away from them. They did not exist.”
Golda Meir, Prime Minister of Israel — Interview with Frank Giles, The Sunday Times (London), 1969-06-15 ✓
“Who was the first Palestinian king? What language do the Palestinians have? Was there ever a Palestinian currency? Is there a Palestinian history or culture? Nothing. There is no such thing as a Palestinian people.”
Bezalel Smotrich, Israeli Finance Minister — Speech in Paris (CNN, 21 March 2023; the US National Security Council said it 'utterly' objected to the language), 2023-03-19 ✓
Context
“There is no Palestinian people. There are Palestinian refugees.”
Golda Meir, former Prime Minister (later clarification) — Op-ed, The New York Times (as quoted by aish.com), 1976-01-14 ✓
Context
“The Palestinians are those Arab nationals who, until 1947, normally resided in Palestine”
Palestinian National Charter (PLO), founding document (the 1964/68 codification the argument points to) — Art. 5, 1968 ✓
The mirror, from the other side
“Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit. (Only for political reasons do we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity.)”
Zuheir Mohsen, head of as-Sa'iqa, PLO Executive Committee member — Interview with James Dorsey, Trouw (Netherlands), 1977-03-31 ✓

Who makes this argument, and what they say they want

  • Religious Zionism (Bezalel Smotrich's party) (originator) — fits its stated aim. The plan aims to 'dismantle the Palestinian national collective' through regional administrations, and in 2023 Smotrich said 'there's no such thing as the Palestinian people'. The plan also says 'We have no pretense of erasing or changing this national identity', only its realisation 'between the Jordan and the Sea'.

From the organisations' own pages: each one's stated aim, sourced tests of it, and how this argument compares. Who repeats an argument is a separate question from who makes it: people who share it can have their own reasons, and polls of supporters show how far those differ (see same slogan, different goals).

Traps in play:◆ Which Palestine?◆ "They all…"◆ The exception as proof◆ The argument that isn't meant to win

  1. Why people find it convincing

    • There was never an independent Palestinian Arab state before 1948, and under the Mandate the unmarked name 'Palestine' was carried by Jewish institutions: today's Jerusalem Post was 'Founded by Gershon Agron in 1932 as The Palestine Post and rebranded in 1950' (The Jerusalem Post, 13 December 2025), and in 1936 Bronisław Huberman 'founded the Palestine Symphony Orchestra (later, the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra)', a refuge for 'scores of Jewish musicians and their families in Nazi-occupied Europe' (Leo Baeck Institute). How common that usage was, against Arab uses such as the newspaper Filastin below, is not counted here ⚠.
    • Golda Meir told The Sunday Times in June 1969, in the version usually quoted, that 'There were no such thing as Palestinians … They did not exist' (as relayed by Wikipedia; the newspaper's original is not read here ⚠). In a 1976 New York Times op-ed she wrote that her 'actual words were: "There is no Palestinian people. There are Palestinian refugees."', explaining that when she came in 1921 'we, the Jewish pioneers, were the avowed Palestinians', while Arab nationalists rejected the name; the same op-ed also says that 'both the people involved and the territory on which they live are Palestinian'. In 1977 a senior PLO figure, Zuheir Mohsen, head of the Syrian-backed as-Sa'iqa faction, told the Dutch daily Trouw (this site's translation): 'Between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese there are no differences. We are part of one people, the Arab nation. … Only for political reasons do we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity' (Trouw, 31 March 1977, p. 7; the whole Dutch passage is on the card, transcribed from the Delpher scan; the English often quoted, 'We are one people', compresses the Dutch 'Wij maken deel uit van één volk', 'we are part of one people').
    • Pan-Arab nationalism before 1948 at times saw the land as southern Syria rather than a separate nation. The Syrian Arab Congress of 2 July 1919, attended by delegates from Palestine, rejected a Jewish commonwealth 'in that part of southern Syria which is known as Palestine' and asked for 'no separation of Palestine … from the mother country'; the same resolution said 'Our Jewish fellow-citizens shall continue to enjoy the rights and to bear the responsibilities which are ours in common' (text from James Parkes, 1946, via the Center for Online Judaic Studies).
    • Palestinian national identity as a political movement did consolidate in the 20th century, in interaction with Zionism; how far it predates Zionism is argued among historians. Rashid Khalidi's Palestinian Identity (1997) argues, in a reviewer's summary, 'that a Palestinian national identity developed prior to the British mandate' and that its origins 'are not reducible to the conflict with Zionism'; the same reviewer found that the book's 'Data presented from the Arabic press, however, only emphasize the centrality of Zionism to the Palestinian narrative' (Niall Ó Murchú, The Middle East Journal, 1998).
    • On this reading the Mohsen quote isn't about solutions. It's a lens for reading Palestinian nationalism as a whole: if a Palestinian state is, in his words (translated from the Dutch, 'een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten'), 'a new means to continue the struggle against Israel and for Arab unity', then every offer of statehood sounds like a staging post rather than an end of claims.
  2. What's true

    No pre-1948 state, overlapping identities, and a nationalism shaped by conflict with Zionism.

    There was no sovereign Palestinian Arab state; identities were layered (family, village, religion, Arab, Ottoman, Syrian); and the national movement consolidated in the 20th century. The pre-1948 English usage of 'Palestinian' for Jewish institutions is real (see 'Which Palestine?'). The most-quoted Palestinian source for the claim is itself revealing: in 1977 Zuheir Mohsen, head of as-Sa'iqa, a PLO faction controlled by Ba'athist Syria, called a separate Palestinian identity 'only for tactical reasons', a means to fight Israel and to pursue Arab unity (Trouw, 31 March 1977). He also said: 'Because Golda Meir says that there is no Palestinian people, I say that there is a Palestinian people, one that is distinct from Jordan' (this site's translation from the Dutch). Each side's denial fed the other's assertion.

    pressJames Dorsey, “'Wij zijn alleen Palestijn om politieke reden'” (interview with Zuheir Mohsen), Trouw, 31 March 1977, p. 7 (1977) incident ✓

    Trouw, 31 March 1977, p. 7. Checked against the KB/Delpher scan text: 'Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit. … het bestaan van een aparte Palestijnse identiteit is er alleen om tactische redenen. De stichting van een Palestijnse staat is een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten.' In the same interview: 'Omdat Golda Meir stelt dat er geen Palestijns volk bestaat, zeg ik dat er wel een Palestijns volk bestaat' — and he claims Haifa, Jaffa, Jerusalem and Beersheba. This site's translations of the Dutch quoted in English on its pages: 'a new means to continue the struggle against Israel and for Arab unity' ('een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten'); 'Only for political reasons do we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity' ('Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit'). The full passage, transcribed from the Delpher scan by the editor on 2026-10-15 (spelling as in the transcription): 'Tussen Jordaniërs, Palestijnen, Syriërs en Libanezen bestaan er geen verschillen. Wij maken deel uit van één volk, de Arabische natie. Kijk maar, ik heb familieleden met het Palestijnse Libanese, Jordaanse en Syrische staatsburgerschap. Wij zijn één volk. Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit. Het is namelijk van nationaal belang voor de Arabieren om het bestaan van de Palestijnen aan te moedigen tegenover het zionisme. Ja, het bestaan van een aparte Palestijnse identiteit is er alleen om tactische redenen. De stichting van een Palestijnse staat is een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten.' This site's translation: 'Between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese there are no differences. We are part of one people, the Arab nation. Look, I have relatives with Palestinian, Lebanese, Jordanian and Syrian citizenship. We are one people. Only for political reasons do we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity. For it is of national interest for the Arabs to encourage the existence of the Palestinians against Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity is there only for tactical reasons. The establishment of a Palestinian state is a new means to continue the struggle against Israel and for Arab unity.' The English in wide circulation renders 'Wij maken deel uit van één volk' as 'We are one people'; the Dutch says 'part of one people'. The Golda Meir sentence in full, as transcribed by the editor from the scan on 2026-10-15: 'Omdat Golda Meir stelt dat er geen Palestijns volk bestaat, zeg ik dat er wel een Palestijns volk bestaat, dat zich van Jordanië onderscheidt' (this site's translation: 'Because Golda Meir says that there is no Palestinian people, I say that there is a Palestinian people, one that is distinct from Jordan'). Read from the scan image the editor supplied (2026-10-15). Article by James Dorsey, headline “'Wij zijn alleen Palestijn om politieke reden'”, subhead 'Mohsen vertrouwt alleen op Syrië'. Under 'Strategie': '„Een aparte Palestijnse entiteit moet voor de nationale rechten opkomen in de dan nog overgebleven bezette gebieden. De Jordaanse regering kan niet namens de Palestijnen in Israël, Libanon of Syrië spreken. Jordanië is een staat met bepaalde grenzen. Het kan geen aanspraak maken op bijvoorbeeld Haifa of Jaffa, terwijl ik wèl recht heb op Haifa, Jaffa, Jeruzalem en Beërsheva. Jordanië kan alleen spreken namens de Jordaniërs en de Palestijnen in Jordanië. De Palestijnse staat zou het recht hebben om op te treden namens alle Palestijnen in de Arabische wereld en elders. Als wij eenmaal al onze rechten in geheel Palestina hebben verworven, moeten wij de hereniging van Jordanië en Palestina geen moment uitstellen.”' This site's translation: 'A separate Palestinian entity must stand up for the national rights in the occupied territories that then still remain. The Jordanian government cannot speak on behalf of the Palestinians in Israel, Lebanon or Syria. Jordan is a state with fixed borders. It cannot lay claim to, for example, Haifa or Jaffa, whereas I do have a right to Haifa, Jaffa, Jerusalem and Beersheba. Jordan can only speak for the Jordanians and the Palestinians in Jordan. The Palestinian state would have the right to act on behalf of all Palestinians in the Arab world and elsewhere. Once we have acquired all our rights in all of Palestine, we must not postpone the reunification of Jordan and Palestine for a moment.' The reporter's own placing: Mohsen, through 'het Baäthistisch gekleurde Arabische nationalisme', stands 'veel dichterbij de aanhangers van het Palestijnse afwijzingsfront … dan bij de ideologische opstelling van bijvoorbeeld Al Fatach' (much closer to the supporters of the Palestinian rejection front than to the ideological position of, for example, Fatah). Against the scan, two words of the earlier transcription read 'staatsburgerschap' and 'onderscheidt'.

    Open source ↗

  3. What's left out

    A regional identity of the Arabs of Palestine is visible long before 1964 — marked as Arab.

    The Jaffa newspaper Filastin ('Palestine', 1911) was named after the region; it 'began as a twice-weekly publication and was principally concerned with the welfare of the Orthodox community; later it warned of the dangers of Zionism' (PalQuest); by 1933 'the various Palestinian political parties and groupings had united to form an Arab Executive Committee', and in 1936 'a widespread revolt' began, with a new Arab Higher Committee calling 'a general strike to support the demand for national government' (UN study, The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem, part I). Note the wording: these bodies called themselves the Arabs of Palestine — the qualifier 'Arab' is in the name — while in English institutional usage the unmarked 'Palestine' was also carried by Jewish or Mandate bodies, such as the Palestine Post and the Palestine Symphony Orchestra. Israel's Foreign Minister in August 1948 spoke of 'the Palestinian Arab exodus' (NYT, 2 August 1948). What this shows: 'invented in 1964' is wrong; a regional Arab identity tied to this land existed and organised politically. What it does not show: an unmarked Palestinian nation in today's sense stretching back centuries — identities were layered (Arab, Ottoman, Syrian, religious, local), and the national identity consolidated in the 20th century. A people's existence doesn't depend on having had a state, and identity formed in response to a rival is still identity; the careful claim is strong enough without the inflated one. What 1964 did create — and this is the defensible core of 'invented in 1964' — is the exclusive national claim on the whole term. The PLO's Charter defined Palestinians as 'those Arab nationals who, until 1947, normally resided in Palestine' (1968, Art. 5); Jews counted only individually — in 1964 'Jews of Palestinian origin' 'if they are willing to live peacefully and loyally in Palestine' (Art. 7), in 1968 only if resident 'until the beginning of the Zionist invasion' (Art. 6) — and 'Judaism, being a religion, is not an independent nationality' (1968, Art. 20); Articles 6 and 20 were among those Arafat declared 'nullified' in his letter to President Clinton of January 1998. After 1948 the Jewish side had dropped the word itself (the Palestine Post became the Jerusalem Post in 1950); the Charter filled that space with an Arab-only definition that denies Jews peoplehood. So: a regional Arab identity is older; the coherent national identity that owns 'Palestinian' and excludes Jews as a people was codified in 1964/68. Mohsen led a faction controlled by Ba'athist Syria (above); the 1968 Charter holds both at once: 'The Palestinian identity is a genuine, essential, and inherent characteristic' (Art. 4), and 'the Palestinian people are an integral part of the Arab nation' (Art. 1); the interviewer himself placed Mohsen, through his Ba'athist Arab nationalism, 'much closer to the supporters of the Palestinian rejection front' than to 'the ideological position of, for example, Fatah' (James Dorsey in Trouw; this site's translation); how far Fatah's own movement rested on the separate identity is not otherwise sourced on this page ⚠. One faction leader's view of what identity was for doesn't show that the people didn't exist, any more than a Zionist leader's tactics would show that Jews aren't a people.

    Traps here:◆ Which Palestine?◆ "They all…"

    referenceInstitute for Palestine Studies, PalQuest, 'Isa al-Isa' (biography) (1911) ✓

    Read (2026-09-28): 'In January 1911, he founded the newspaper Filastin, which began as a twice-weekly publication and was principally concerned with the welfare of the Orthodox community; later it warned of the dangers of Zionism'; closed by the Ottoman authorities in October 1913; signed the statement of 12 December 1918 to the Paris Peace Conference and the British Foreign Office 'protesting the Zionist movement's attempt to turn Palestine into a Jewish National Home'; co-founded the Muslim-Christian Association in Jaffa to oppose the Balfour Declaration. Archive issues of Filastin: National Library of Israel's historical Arabic press collection (not consulted here). Re-read 2026-10-12: 'In October 1913, the Ottoman authorities closed down his newspaper, claiming that it had published articles inciting ethnic prejudice.'

    Open source ↗

    newspaper'Bars Repatriation Now' by Gene Currivan (1948) incident ✓

    The New York Times · 1948-08-02 · checked against the scan

    Newspaper clipping scan

    Scan from the kvetch-of-the-day news archive.

    NYT 1948-08-02; vision-verified; Shertok's reply to the UN Mediator.

    primary documentPalestinian National Charter (1964, Art. 7) and Palestinian National Charter (1968, Arts. 5, 6, 20) (1968) incident ✓

    1968 text read on the Avalon Project (Arts. 5, 6, 20 match the quotes on this site); 1964 text read on PalQuest (2026-09-28): Art. 6 'The Palestinians are those Arab citizens who were living normally in Palestine up to 1947'; Art. 7 'Jews of Palestinian origin are considered Palestinians if they are willing to live peacefully and loyally in Palestine'. Arts. 1 and 4 (re-read 2026-10-02): 'Palestine is the homeland of the Arab Palestinian people; it is an indivisible part of the Arab homeland, and the Palestinian people are an integral part of the Arab nation'; 'The Palestinian identity is a genuine, essential, and inherent characteristic; it is transmitted from parents to children'. 1968 text re-read 2026-10-12 (Avalon): Art. 6 'The Jews who had normally resided in Palestine until the beginning of the Zionist invasion will be considered Palestinians'; Art. 20 'Claims of historical or religious ties of Jews with Palestine are incompatible with the facts of history and the true conception of what constitutes statehood. Judaism, being a religion, is not an independent nationality. Nor do Jews constitute a single nation with an identity of its own'.

    Open source ↗

    primary documentYasser Arafat, letter to President Clinton (January 1998; dated 13 January on MIFTAH, 18 January on another copy), text on MIFTAH (1998) incident ✓

    Read 2026-09-30 (MIFTAH, a Palestinian NGO established in 1998 whose board Hanan Ashrawi chairs, hosts the text; see its org page, 'MIFTAH'). The PNC 'held in Gaza city between 22-25 of April 1996 … decided that the "Palestine National Charter is hereby amended by canceling the articles that are contrary to the letters exchanged between the P.L.O and the Government of Israel on 9/10 September 1993"'; 'As a result, Articles 6-10,15, 19-23, and 30 have been nullified, and the parts in Articles 1-5, 11-14, 16-18, 25-27 and 29 that are inconsistent with the above mentioned commitments have also been nullified.' Another copy (pac-usa.org, 'Arafat's Letter to Clinton on the Amendments to the Palestine National Charter', read 2026-09-30) has the same text dated 18 January 1998; MIFTAH dates it 13 January; the US Secretary of State said Clinton received it on 22 January 1998 (briefing that day), so which date the letter bears is unresolved ⚠. Re-read 2026-10-13: 'As a result, Articles 6-10,15, 19-23, and 30 have been nullified, and the parts in Articles 1-5, 11-14, 16-l8 [sic], 25-27 and 29 that are inconsistent …'.

    Open source ↗

    pressDanielle Greyman-Kennard and Shir Perets, ''The Jerusalem Post': 93 years of journalism', The Jerusalem Post (13 December 2025) (2025) ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. The paper's own history: 'Founded by Gershon Agron in 1932 as The Palestine Post and rebranded in 1950 as The Jerusalem Post, the newspaper predates the State of Israel itself.'

    Open source ↗

    primary documentLeo Baeck Institute, Edythe Griffinger Portal, 'Palestine Orchestra, Tel Aviv' (record 210514, Bronislaw Hubermann Collection AR 1593) (1936) incident ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. 'A signed photograph of Bronislaw Hubermann and Arturo Toscanini with the Palestine Symphony Orchestra in Tel Aviv on Dec. 25, 1936.' Collection note: 'In 1936, he founded the Palestine Symphony Orchestra (later, the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra), giving refuge to scores of Jewish musicians and their families in Nazi-occupied Europe. The orchestra's opening concert was conducted in Tel Aviv by Arturo Toscanini on Dec. 25, 1936'.

    Open source ↗

    referenceUnited Nations (prepared for the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People), 'The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem', Part I: 1917–1947 ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). Quotes Balfour's memorandum to Curzon of 11 August 1919: 'For in Palestine we do not propose even to go through the form of consulting the wishes of the present inhabitants of the country'; 'The four Great Powers are committed to zionism … of far profounder import than the desires and prejudices of the 700,000 Arabs who now inhabit that ancient land'; 'I do not think that zionism will hurt the Arabs, but they will never say they want it.' The study was prepared under a UN committee on Palestinian rights. Re-read 2026-10-01 (1936–39): 'In April 1936, what started as minor Arab-Jewish clashes quickly flared into a widespread revolt. A new union of Palestinian political parties was formed, the Arab Higher Committee, headed by the Mufti of Jerusalem … The Committee called for a general strike to support the demand for national government'; 1938 casualties 'reached a total of 3,717, as against 246 in 1937'; 'the Jewish side also conducted its own retaliations and reprisals'; by 1933 'the various Palestinian political parties and groupings had united to form an Arab Executive Committee'. The study's own framing ('Palestinian resistance to foreign rule and to foreign colonization'). Re-read 2026-10-01: it quotes 'an official British document': 'On the 22nd July 1946, the campaign conducted by terrorist organizations reached a new climax with an explosion which wrecked a wing of the King David Hotel in Jerusalem, containing the offices of the Government Secretariat as well as part of military headquarters, and killed 86 public servants, Arab, Jewish and British, as well as five members of the public'; and 'That the Irgun Tzeva'i Leumi and the Stern Group have worked since last autumn in co-operation with the Haganah High Command on certain of these operations'. Re-read 2026-10-01 (immigration): the population rose 'from the 750,000 of the 1922 census to almost 1,850,000 at the end of 1946'; the Jewish population 'from 56,000 after the First World War to 84,000 in 1922 to 608,000 in 1946'; 'A good part of this was due to births within Palestine but legal immigration alone accounted for over 376,000, with illegal immigration being estimated at another 65,000 – a total of 440,000'; the Jewish community 'in 1947 constituted nearly a third'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Compared to the 100,000 in the 1920s, Palestine received about 232,000 legal immigrants in the 1930s. The Jewish population in 1939 numbered over 445,000 out of a total of about 1,500,000 – nearly 30 per cent compared to the less than 10 per cent 20 years before'; 1936 revolt: attacks 'on British troops and police posts as well as on Jewish settlements, sabotage of roads, railways, pipelines'; 'The British administration imposed curfews, called in troop reinforcements from Britain, Egypt and Malta, and resorted to mass arrests, collective fines, and internments in concentration camps and other emergency measures'.

    Open source ↗

    pressJames Dorsey, “'Wij zijn alleen Palestijn om politieke reden'” (interview with Zuheir Mohsen), Trouw, 31 March 1977, p. 7 (1977) incident ✓

    Trouw, 31 March 1977, p. 7. Checked against the KB/Delpher scan text: 'Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit. … het bestaan van een aparte Palestijnse identiteit is er alleen om tactische redenen. De stichting van een Palestijnse staat is een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten.' In the same interview: 'Omdat Golda Meir stelt dat er geen Palestijns volk bestaat, zeg ik dat er wel een Palestijns volk bestaat' — and he claims Haifa, Jaffa, Jerusalem and Beersheba. This site's translations of the Dutch quoted in English on its pages: 'a new means to continue the struggle against Israel and for Arab unity' ('een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten'); 'Only for political reasons do we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity' ('Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit'). The full passage, transcribed from the Delpher scan by the editor on 2026-10-15 (spelling as in the transcription): 'Tussen Jordaniërs, Palestijnen, Syriërs en Libanezen bestaan er geen verschillen. Wij maken deel uit van één volk, de Arabische natie. Kijk maar, ik heb familieleden met het Palestijnse Libanese, Jordaanse en Syrische staatsburgerschap. Wij zijn één volk. Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit. Het is namelijk van nationaal belang voor de Arabieren om het bestaan van de Palestijnen aan te moedigen tegenover het zionisme. Ja, het bestaan van een aparte Palestijnse identiteit is er alleen om tactische redenen. De stichting van een Palestijnse staat is een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten.' This site's translation: 'Between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese there are no differences. We are part of one people, the Arab nation. Look, I have relatives with Palestinian, Lebanese, Jordanian and Syrian citizenship. We are one people. Only for political reasons do we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity. For it is of national interest for the Arabs to encourage the existence of the Palestinians against Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity is there only for tactical reasons. The establishment of a Palestinian state is a new means to continue the struggle against Israel and for Arab unity.' The English in wide circulation renders 'Wij maken deel uit van één volk' as 'We are one people'; the Dutch says 'part of one people'. The Golda Meir sentence in full, as transcribed by the editor from the scan on 2026-10-15: 'Omdat Golda Meir stelt dat er geen Palestijns volk bestaat, zeg ik dat er wel een Palestijns volk bestaat, dat zich van Jordanië onderscheidt' (this site's translation: 'Because Golda Meir says that there is no Palestinian people, I say that there is a Palestinian people, one that is distinct from Jordan'). Read from the scan image the editor supplied (2026-10-15). Article by James Dorsey, headline “'Wij zijn alleen Palestijn om politieke reden'”, subhead 'Mohsen vertrouwt alleen op Syrië'. Under 'Strategie': '„Een aparte Palestijnse entiteit moet voor de nationale rechten opkomen in de dan nog overgebleven bezette gebieden. De Jordaanse regering kan niet namens de Palestijnen in Israël, Libanon of Syrië spreken. Jordanië is een staat met bepaalde grenzen. Het kan geen aanspraak maken op bijvoorbeeld Haifa of Jaffa, terwijl ik wèl recht heb op Haifa, Jaffa, Jeruzalem en Beërsheva. Jordanië kan alleen spreken namens de Jordaniërs en de Palestijnen in Jordanië. De Palestijnse staat zou het recht hebben om op te treden namens alle Palestijnen in de Arabische wereld en elders. Als wij eenmaal al onze rechten in geheel Palestina hebben verworven, moeten wij de hereniging van Jordanië en Palestina geen moment uitstellen.”' This site's translation: 'A separate Palestinian entity must stand up for the national rights in the occupied territories that then still remain. The Jordanian government cannot speak on behalf of the Palestinians in Israel, Lebanon or Syria. Jordan is a state with fixed borders. It cannot lay claim to, for example, Haifa or Jaffa, whereas I do have a right to Haifa, Jaffa, Jerusalem and Beersheba. Jordan can only speak for the Jordanians and the Palestinians in Jordan. The Palestinian state would have the right to act on behalf of all Palestinians in the Arab world and elsewhere. Once we have acquired all our rights in all of Palestine, we must not postpone the reunification of Jordan and Palestine for a moment.' The reporter's own placing: Mohsen, through 'het Baäthistisch gekleurde Arabische nationalisme', stands 'veel dichterbij de aanhangers van het Palestijnse afwijzingsfront … dan bij de ideologische opstelling van bijvoorbeeld Al Fatach' (much closer to the supporters of the Palestinian rejection front than to the ideological position of, for example, Fatah). Against the scan, two words of the earlier transcription read 'staatsburgerschap' and 'onderscheidt'.

    Open source ↗

  4. More context

    How to talk about this.

    Acknowledge first: Palestinian national identity took its modern shape in the 20th century, and before 1948 'Palestinian' was also used for Jewish institutions, such as the Palestine Post. Ask one question: 'when did Israeli national identity take its modern shape, and does that make it less real?' Share one checkable thing: the newspaper Filastin, founded in Jaffa in 1911. What not to say: 'they're just Arabs who came for jobs', which erases people whose families have lived there for centuries. From the other side: grant the Mohsen interview and the political uses of the identity that pro-Israel voices point to, then ask what follows from them for the people who hold that identity today.

    pressDanielle Greyman-Kennard and Shir Perets, ''The Jerusalem Post': 93 years of journalism', The Jerusalem Post (13 December 2025) (2025) ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. The paper's own history: 'Founded by Gershon Agron in 1932 as The Palestine Post and rebranded in 1950 as The Jerusalem Post, the newspaper predates the State of Israel itself.'

    Open source ↗

    referenceInstitute for Palestine Studies, PalQuest, 'Isa al-Isa' (biography) (1911) ✓

    Read (2026-09-28): 'In January 1911, he founded the newspaper Filastin, which began as a twice-weekly publication and was principally concerned with the welfare of the Orthodox community; later it warned of the dangers of Zionism'; closed by the Ottoman authorities in October 1913; signed the statement of 12 December 1918 to the Paris Peace Conference and the British Foreign Office 'protesting the Zionist movement's attempt to turn Palestine into a Jewish National Home'; co-founded the Muslim-Christian Association in Jaffa to oppose the Balfour Declaration. Archive issues of Filastin: National Library of Israel's historical Arabic press collection (not consulted here). Re-read 2026-10-12: 'In October 1913, the Ottoman authorities closed down his newspaper, claiming that it had published articles inciting ethnic prejudice.'

    Open source ↗

    pressJames Dorsey, “'Wij zijn alleen Palestijn om politieke reden'” (interview with Zuheir Mohsen), Trouw, 31 March 1977, p. 7 (1977) incident ✓

    Trouw, 31 March 1977, p. 7. Checked against the KB/Delpher scan text: 'Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit. … het bestaan van een aparte Palestijnse identiteit is er alleen om tactische redenen. De stichting van een Palestijnse staat is een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten.' In the same interview: 'Omdat Golda Meir stelt dat er geen Palestijns volk bestaat, zeg ik dat er wel een Palestijns volk bestaat' — and he claims Haifa, Jaffa, Jerusalem and Beersheba. This site's translations of the Dutch quoted in English on its pages: 'a new means to continue the struggle against Israel and for Arab unity' ('een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten'); 'Only for political reasons do we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity' ('Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit'). The full passage, transcribed from the Delpher scan by the editor on 2026-10-15 (spelling as in the transcription): 'Tussen Jordaniërs, Palestijnen, Syriërs en Libanezen bestaan er geen verschillen. Wij maken deel uit van één volk, de Arabische natie. Kijk maar, ik heb familieleden met het Palestijnse Libanese, Jordaanse en Syrische staatsburgerschap. Wij zijn één volk. Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit. Het is namelijk van nationaal belang voor de Arabieren om het bestaan van de Palestijnen aan te moedigen tegenover het zionisme. Ja, het bestaan van een aparte Palestijnse identiteit is er alleen om tactische redenen. De stichting van een Palestijnse staat is een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten.' This site's translation: 'Between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese there are no differences. We are part of one people, the Arab nation. Look, I have relatives with Palestinian, Lebanese, Jordanian and Syrian citizenship. We are one people. Only for political reasons do we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity. For it is of national interest for the Arabs to encourage the existence of the Palestinians against Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity is there only for tactical reasons. The establishment of a Palestinian state is a new means to continue the struggle against Israel and for Arab unity.' The English in wide circulation renders 'Wij maken deel uit van één volk' as 'We are one people'; the Dutch says 'part of one people'. The Golda Meir sentence in full, as transcribed by the editor from the scan on 2026-10-15: 'Omdat Golda Meir stelt dat er geen Palestijns volk bestaat, zeg ik dat er wel een Palestijns volk bestaat, dat zich van Jordanië onderscheidt' (this site's translation: 'Because Golda Meir says that there is no Palestinian people, I say that there is a Palestinian people, one that is distinct from Jordan'). Read from the scan image the editor supplied (2026-10-15). Article by James Dorsey, headline “'Wij zijn alleen Palestijn om politieke reden'”, subhead 'Mohsen vertrouwt alleen op Syrië'. Under 'Strategie': '„Een aparte Palestijnse entiteit moet voor de nationale rechten opkomen in de dan nog overgebleven bezette gebieden. De Jordaanse regering kan niet namens de Palestijnen in Israël, Libanon of Syrië spreken. Jordanië is een staat met bepaalde grenzen. Het kan geen aanspraak maken op bijvoorbeeld Haifa of Jaffa, terwijl ik wèl recht heb op Haifa, Jaffa, Jeruzalem en Beërsheva. Jordanië kan alleen spreken namens de Jordaniërs en de Palestijnen in Jordanië. De Palestijnse staat zou het recht hebben om op te treden namens alle Palestijnen in de Arabische wereld en elders. Als wij eenmaal al onze rechten in geheel Palestina hebben verworven, moeten wij de hereniging van Jordanië en Palestina geen moment uitstellen.”' This site's translation: 'A separate Palestinian entity must stand up for the national rights in the occupied territories that then still remain. The Jordanian government cannot speak on behalf of the Palestinians in Israel, Lebanon or Syria. Jordan is a state with fixed borders. It cannot lay claim to, for example, Haifa or Jaffa, whereas I do have a right to Haifa, Jaffa, Jerusalem and Beersheba. Jordan can only speak for the Jordanians and the Palestinians in Jordan. The Palestinian state would have the right to act on behalf of all Palestinians in the Arab world and elsewhere. Once we have acquired all our rights in all of Palestine, we must not postpone the reunification of Jordan and Palestine for a moment.' The reporter's own placing: Mohsen, through 'het Baäthistisch gekleurde Arabische nationalisme', stands 'veel dichterbij de aanhangers van het Palestijnse afwijzingsfront … dan bij de ideologische opstelling van bijvoorbeeld Al Fatach' (much closer to the supporters of the Palestinian rejection front than to the ideological position of, for example, Fatah). Against the scan, two words of the earlier transcription read 'staatsburgerschap' and 'onderscheidt'.

    Open source ↗

  5. Where it leads if pressed

    Working it out: when a people exists, and who gets to say.

    The claim mixes a date question with a legitimacy question. The date: a regional identity of the Arabs of Palestine is on record well before 1964. The newspaper Filastin was founded in Jaffa in 1911 and 'later … warned of the dangers of Zionism'; in 1919 the Syrian Congress spoke of 'that part of southern Syria which is known as Palestine', still as part of a Syrian whole; the 1936 revolt was led by an 'Arab Higher Committee' demanding national government. Rashid Khalidi's book argues for a national identity before the Mandate, and a reviewer found the thesis 'sustained well' while noting how central Zionism was to the Arabic press of the time. So identity was layered (Arab, Syrian, Palestinian) and became a distinct national movement over the 20th century, in part in reaction to Zionism. Not 1964, and not timeless either. The quotations: Golda Meir in 1976, in her own account: 'There is no Palestinian people. There are Palestinian refugees'; in the same text, 'we, the Jewish pioneers, were the avowed Palestinians'. Zuheir Mohsen of a Syrian-backed PLO faction in 1977: a separate identity exists 'only for tactical reasons', and in the same interview, 'because Golda Meir says that there is no Palestinian people, I say that there is a Palestinian people, one that is distinct from Jordan' (this site's translation from the Dutch). Each quotation is used as a gotcha by the other side; each shows a political use of the identity question, not its answer. The worst case for each side. For 'no such thing': grant Mohsen's words at face value; Filastin, the 1919 and 1936 records, and the people who call themselves Palestinian today remain, and one faction leader cannot cancel them. For 'a people since time immemorial': grant every early source; they show a regional identity inside wider Arab and Syrian ones, crystallising into a national one in the 20th century, and under the Mandate the name was shared: 'Palestine' also named Jewish institutions, from The Palestine Post, founded in 1932 and renamed The Jerusalem Post in 1950, to the Palestine Symphony Orchestra, founded in 1936, which fits Meir's 'we, the Jewish pioneers, were the avowed Palestinians'. Holds on the evidence here: a Palestinian Arab identity existed before 1964 and became a national movement over the 20th century. Arguable, as historians argue: how far it predates Zionism. Not supported: that it was invented in 1964, or that a people's existence depends on how old its national movement is (a test that would also reach Israeli national identity).

    What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean

    referenceInstitute for Palestine Studies, PalQuest, 'Isa al-Isa' (biography) (1911) ✓

    Read (2026-09-28): 'In January 1911, he founded the newspaper Filastin, which began as a twice-weekly publication and was principally concerned with the welfare of the Orthodox community; later it warned of the dangers of Zionism'; closed by the Ottoman authorities in October 1913; signed the statement of 12 December 1918 to the Paris Peace Conference and the British Foreign Office 'protesting the Zionist movement's attempt to turn Palestine into a Jewish National Home'; co-founded the Muslim-Christian Association in Jaffa to oppose the Balfour Declaration. Archive issues of Filastin: National Library of Israel's historical Arabic press collection (not consulted here). Re-read 2026-10-12: 'In October 1913, the Ottoman authorities closed down his newspaper, claiming that it had published articles inciting ethnic prejudice.'

    Open source ↗

    primary documentCenter for Online Judaic Studies, 'July 2, 1919: The Syrian Arab Congress' (resolutions as printed in James Parkes, The Emergence of the Jewish Problem 1878–1939, Oxford UP, 1946) (1919) incident ✓

    Read 29 Sept 2026. Perspective: a Jewish history education site, headlining it 'Arabs Say No to Jewish Homeland'. Resolutions: 'We reject the claims of the Zionists for the establishment of a Jewish commonwealth in that part of southern Syria which is known as Palestine, and we are opposed to Jewish immigration into any part of the country'; 'Our Jewish fellow-citizens shall continue to enjoy the rights and to bear the responsibilities which are ours in common'; 'no dismemberment of Syria, and no separation of Palestine or the coastal regions in the west or the Lebanon from the mother country'.

    Open source ↗

    referenceUnited Nations (prepared for the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People), 'The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem', Part I: 1917–1947 ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). Quotes Balfour's memorandum to Curzon of 11 August 1919: 'For in Palestine we do not propose even to go through the form of consulting the wishes of the present inhabitants of the country'; 'The four Great Powers are committed to zionism … of far profounder import than the desires and prejudices of the 700,000 Arabs who now inhabit that ancient land'; 'I do not think that zionism will hurt the Arabs, but they will never say they want it.' The study was prepared under a UN committee on Palestinian rights. Re-read 2026-10-01 (1936–39): 'In April 1936, what started as minor Arab-Jewish clashes quickly flared into a widespread revolt. A new union of Palestinian political parties was formed, the Arab Higher Committee, headed by the Mufti of Jerusalem … The Committee called for a general strike to support the demand for national government'; 1938 casualties 'reached a total of 3,717, as against 246 in 1937'; 'the Jewish side also conducted its own retaliations and reprisals'; by 1933 'the various Palestinian political parties and groupings had united to form an Arab Executive Committee'. The study's own framing ('Palestinian resistance to foreign rule and to foreign colonization'). Re-read 2026-10-01: it quotes 'an official British document': 'On the 22nd July 1946, the campaign conducted by terrorist organizations reached a new climax with an explosion which wrecked a wing of the King David Hotel in Jerusalem, containing the offices of the Government Secretariat as well as part of military headquarters, and killed 86 public servants, Arab, Jewish and British, as well as five members of the public'; and 'That the Irgun Tzeva'i Leumi and the Stern Group have worked since last autumn in co-operation with the Haganah High Command on certain of these operations'. Re-read 2026-10-01 (immigration): the population rose 'from the 750,000 of the 1922 census to almost 1,850,000 at the end of 1946'; the Jewish population 'from 56,000 after the First World War to 84,000 in 1922 to 608,000 in 1946'; 'A good part of this was due to births within Palestine but legal immigration alone accounted for over 376,000, with illegal immigration being estimated at another 65,000 – a total of 440,000'; the Jewish community 'in 1947 constituted nearly a third'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Compared to the 100,000 in the 1920s, Palestine received about 232,000 legal immigrants in the 1930s. The Jewish population in 1939 numbered over 445,000 out of a total of about 1,500,000 – nearly 30 per cent compared to the less than 10 per cent 20 years before'; 1936 revolt: attacks 'on British troops and police posts as well as on Jewish settlements, sabotage of roads, railways, pipelines'; 'The British administration imposed curfews, called in troop reinforcements from Britain, Egypt and Malta, and resorted to mass arrests, collective fines, and internments in concentration camps and other emergency measures'.

    Open source ↗

    historyNiall Ó Murchú, review of Rashid Khalidi, Palestinian Identity: The Construction of Modern National Consciousness (Columbia UP, 1997), The Middle East Journal (1998) (1998) finding ✓

    Opening of the review read via OpenAlex (29 Sept 2026): 'This book argues, using original research and secondary sources, that a Palestinian national identity developed prior to the British mandate. It also asserts that the origins of that identity are not reducible to the conflict with Zionism as recent works may suggest.' 'the principal thesis is sustained well, but requires more attention to the history of Ottoman state building. Data presented from the Arabic press, however, only emphasize the centrality of Zionism to the Palestinian narrative.' Khalidi's book itself is not read.

    Open source ↗

    primary documentGolda Meir, op-ed in The New York Times (14 January 1976), as reprinted by Aish (1976) incident ✓

    Read 2026-09-29 (Meir's own text, reprinted by Aish, a pro-Israel Orthodox outreach organisation; NYT original not checked here). 'I am supposed to have said, "There are no Palestinians." My actual words were: "There is no Palestinian people. There are Palestinian refugees."'; 'When in 1921 I came to Palestine … we, the Jewish pioneers, were the avowed Palestinians'; 'Whatever nomenclature is used, both the people involved and the territory on which they live are Palestinian.' Also contains her contested claims, e.g. 'We dispossessed no Arabs' and 'the original 550,000 Arabs who in 1948 joined the exodus' (compare the UNCCP's ~711,000 on unrwa-refugees).

    Open source ↗

    pressJames Dorsey, “'Wij zijn alleen Palestijn om politieke reden'” (interview with Zuheir Mohsen), Trouw, 31 March 1977, p. 7 (1977) incident ✓

    Trouw, 31 March 1977, p. 7. Checked against the KB/Delpher scan text: 'Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit. … het bestaan van een aparte Palestijnse identiteit is er alleen om tactische redenen. De stichting van een Palestijnse staat is een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten.' In the same interview: 'Omdat Golda Meir stelt dat er geen Palestijns volk bestaat, zeg ik dat er wel een Palestijns volk bestaat' — and he claims Haifa, Jaffa, Jerusalem and Beersheba. This site's translations of the Dutch quoted in English on its pages: 'a new means to continue the struggle against Israel and for Arab unity' ('een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten'); 'Only for political reasons do we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity' ('Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit'). The full passage, transcribed from the Delpher scan by the editor on 2026-10-15 (spelling as in the transcription): 'Tussen Jordaniërs, Palestijnen, Syriërs en Libanezen bestaan er geen verschillen. Wij maken deel uit van één volk, de Arabische natie. Kijk maar, ik heb familieleden met het Palestijnse Libanese, Jordaanse en Syrische staatsburgerschap. Wij zijn één volk. Alleen maar om politieke redenen onderschrijven wij zorgvuldig onze Palestijnse identiteit. Het is namelijk van nationaal belang voor de Arabieren om het bestaan van de Palestijnen aan te moedigen tegenover het zionisme. Ja, het bestaan van een aparte Palestijnse identiteit is er alleen om tactische redenen. De stichting van een Palestijnse staat is een nieuw middel om de strijd tegen Israël en voor de Arabische eenheid voort te zetten.' This site's translation: 'Between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese there are no differences. We are part of one people, the Arab nation. Look, I have relatives with Palestinian, Lebanese, Jordanian and Syrian citizenship. We are one people. Only for political reasons do we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity. For it is of national interest for the Arabs to encourage the existence of the Palestinians against Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity is there only for tactical reasons. The establishment of a Palestinian state is a new means to continue the struggle against Israel and for Arab unity.' The English in wide circulation renders 'Wij maken deel uit van één volk' as 'We are one people'; the Dutch says 'part of one people'. The Golda Meir sentence in full, as transcribed by the editor from the scan on 2026-10-15: 'Omdat Golda Meir stelt dat er geen Palestijns volk bestaat, zeg ik dat er wel een Palestijns volk bestaat, dat zich van Jordanië onderscheidt' (this site's translation: 'Because Golda Meir says that there is no Palestinian people, I say that there is a Palestinian people, one that is distinct from Jordan'). Read from the scan image the editor supplied (2026-10-15). Article by James Dorsey, headline “'Wij zijn alleen Palestijn om politieke reden'”, subhead 'Mohsen vertrouwt alleen op Syrië'. Under 'Strategie': '„Een aparte Palestijnse entiteit moet voor de nationale rechten opkomen in de dan nog overgebleven bezette gebieden. De Jordaanse regering kan niet namens de Palestijnen in Israël, Libanon of Syrië spreken. Jordanië is een staat met bepaalde grenzen. Het kan geen aanspraak maken op bijvoorbeeld Haifa of Jaffa, terwijl ik wèl recht heb op Haifa, Jaffa, Jeruzalem en Beërsheva. Jordanië kan alleen spreken namens de Jordaniërs en de Palestijnen in Jordanië. De Palestijnse staat zou het recht hebben om op te treden namens alle Palestijnen in de Arabische wereld en elders. Als wij eenmaal al onze rechten in geheel Palestina hebben verworven, moeten wij de hereniging van Jordanië en Palestina geen moment uitstellen.”' This site's translation: 'A separate Palestinian entity must stand up for the national rights in the occupied territories that then still remain. The Jordanian government cannot speak on behalf of the Palestinians in Israel, Lebanon or Syria. Jordan is a state with fixed borders. It cannot lay claim to, for example, Haifa or Jaffa, whereas I do have a right to Haifa, Jaffa, Jerusalem and Beersheba. Jordan can only speak for the Jordanians and the Palestinians in Jordan. The Palestinian state would have the right to act on behalf of all Palestinians in the Arab world and elsewhere. Once we have acquired all our rights in all of Palestine, we must not postpone the reunification of Jordan and Palestine for a moment.' The reporter's own placing: Mohsen, through 'het Baäthistisch gekleurde Arabische nationalisme', stands 'veel dichterbij de aanhangers van het Palestijnse afwijzingsfront … dan bij de ideologische opstelling van bijvoorbeeld Al Fatach' (much closer to the supporters of the Palestinian rejection front than to the ideological position of, for example, Fatah). Against the scan, two words of the earlier transcription read 'staatsburgerschap' and 'onderscheidt'.

    Open source ↗

    pressDanielle Greyman-Kennard and Shir Perets, ''The Jerusalem Post': 93 years of journalism', The Jerusalem Post (13 December 2025) (2025) ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. The paper's own history: 'Founded by Gershon Agron in 1932 as The Palestine Post and rebranded in 1950 as The Jerusalem Post, the newspaper predates the State of Israel itself.'

    Open source ↗

    primary documentLeo Baeck Institute, Edythe Griffinger Portal, 'Palestine Orchestra, Tel Aviv' (record 210514, Bronislaw Hubermann Collection AR 1593) (1936) incident ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. 'A signed photograph of Bronislaw Hubermann and Arturo Toscanini with the Palestine Symphony Orchestra in Tel Aviv on Dec. 25, 1936.' Collection note: 'In 1936, he founded the Palestine Symphony Orchestra (later, the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra), giving refuge to scores of Jewish musicians and their families in Nazi-occupied Europe. The orchestra's opening concert was conducted in Tel Aviv by Arturo Toscanini on Dec. 25, 1936'.

    Open source ↗

    The mirror of 'Jews are just a religion'.

    Telling a people it doesn't exist is the same move as telling Jews they are 'only a religion' with no national claim (see 'A religion doesn't justify having a country.'). Both deny the other side's self-understanding instead of dealing with its claims. The careful point — that Palestinian nationalism is modern and was shaped partly in reaction to Zionism — is defensible and interesting; the reckless one is easy to rebut. In pro-Israel argument the line is also used as a gotcha that quotes Mohsen back ('even the PLO admitted it'). As a gotcha it proves only that one faction leader said it in 1977. When officials state it as a conviction, as Smotrich did in Paris in 2023, it becomes a claim about millions of living people, and it leads where the mirror claim leads. The mirror: some Palestinians read Zionism through Meir's 1969 line and Smotrich's 2023 one, as proof that Israel's aim is to erase them. Each side has its founding quote from the other, and each reads the other's national movement through it. Both quotes are real. How far each describes the other side can be measured. In the joint Palestinian-Israeli Pulse of July 2024, 42% of Israeli Jews backed annexing the West Bank without equal rights for Palestinians, and 33% of Palestinians backed one state without equal rights for Jews (see 'One state under Jewish rule, without equal rights'). These are large minorities, not majorities. The recognition question ('Recognising a state vs a people') is where the two lenses meet.

    Traps here:◆ The exception as proof◆ Recognising a state vs a people

    pressTimes of Israel, 'Jordan summons Israeli envoy over racist Smotrich speech, Greater Israel map' (2023) incident ✓

    Speech in Paris, 19 March 2023; report of 20 March 2023 (read 2026-09-26).

    Open source ↗

The usual reply — and its own traps

Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.

heard from pro-Palestinian voices“Palestine was definitely a thing — there was even a newspaper called Filastin in 1911 — and almost no Jews lived there, so Israel was a hostile takeover.” Both lean on: ◆ Which Palestine? ◆ The exception as proof heard from pro-Palestinian voices“A religion doesn't justify having a country.” Its traps: ◆ Which Zionism? ◆ "What about you?"

Where this argument points

This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions — for, against or around them:

On the timeline

Keep exploring

From the archive

How newspapers reported related events at the time — suggested by the archive's own tags, not yet reviewed for this argument. Open a scan and judge for yourself.

Scans: kvetch-of-the-day news archive.