Organisations and sources Β· Israeli religious-nationalist party; its leader Bezalel Smotrich is finance minister in the government formed in December 2022
Religious Zionism (Bezalel Smotrich's party)
What it is
Founding details not read here β .
Led by Bezalel Smotrich.
Who funds it
A political party; its finances are not covered here.
What it wants
The party platform is not read here β . Its leader's programme is: 'Israel's Decisive Plan' ('One Hope'), published in Hashiloach in September 2017 and quoted below.
Why it makes its arguments
Originator: it makes these arguments as part of its own programme.
Stated aim, in its own words: 'Winning and ending' the conflict by 'creating and cementing the awareness β¦ that there is room for only one expression of national self-determination west of the Jordan River: that of the Jewish nation'; 'our national ambition for a Jewish State from the river to the sea is an accomplished fact, a fact not open to discussion or negotiation'. (Smotrich, 'Israel's Decisive Plan' (Hashiloach, 2017))
Is there reason to doubt it?
- Is the stated aim the whole story? (see 'one-word-two-meanings') No evidence found that the stated aim hides another one: the harder elements are in the text itself. It offers 'the maximum of democratic rights' and 'aid to emigrate', and in the same text says Palestinians would 'not β¦ vote for the Israeli Knesset at the first stage', calls this 'an imperfect situation in terms of civil rights', and aims to 'dismantle the Palestinian national collective'. Here the milder words and the harder aim are stated together by the speaker. (Smotrich, 'Israel's Decisive Plan' (Hashiloach, 2017))
Its arguments, measured against its stated aim
- There's no such thing as a Palestinian people β it was invented in 1964. β fits the stated aim. The plan aims to 'dismantle the Palestinian national collective' through regional administrations, and in 2023 Smotrich said 'there's no such thing as the Palestinian people'. The plan also says 'We have no pretense of erasing or changing this national identity', only its realisation 'between the Jordan and the Sea'. (Hashiloach (2017); Times of Israel (2023))
- Israel's real goal is 'Greater Israel' β from the Nile to the Euphrates. β goes beyond the stated aim. The plan's stated aim is the land 'west of the Jordan River'. 'The future of Jerusalem is to expand to Damascus' (2024) and the 2023 map that included Jordan go beyond that aim. (Middle East Eye (2024); Times of Israel (2023))
- Jews can only be safe as a majority in their own state. β fits the stated aim. The plan withholds the Knesset vote because 'granting full voting rights to the Arab residents of Judea and Samaria will create a significant deficit in the Jewish component of the State of Israel', which is the demographic logic of the argument. (Hashiloach (2017))
Only what is documented: stated aims in the actor's own words, and sourced tests of them. 'No evidence found' is a finding too. See the argument that isn't meant to win.
Its record
- 2017: the 'Decisive Plan'. 'There is room for only one expression of national self-determination west of the Jordan River: that of the Jewish nation.' Palestinians in the West Bank would choose between staying 'as individuals in the Jewish State', with six regional municipal administrations but 'not to vote for the Israeli Knesset at the first stage', and aid 'to emigrate'. Those who keep fighting 'will be dealt with by the security forces with a strong hand'. (Hashiloach)
- March 2023: in Paris, speaking from a podium draped with a map of Israel that included Jordan, Smotrich said 'there's no such thing as the Palestinian people'; Jordan summoned Israel's envoy. (Times of Israel)
- 2024: in ARTE's documentary, 'It is written that the future of Jerusalem is to expand to Damascus', 'little by little' (Middle East Eye; the list of countries in that report is its paraphrase).
Citation cluster
A partner in the governing coalition formed in December 2022 (see 'Likud' and 'Otzma Yehudit (Jewish Power)').
How to read a claim sourced from here
Its programme states its aims openly, so read it whole: the offer of 'maximum of democratic rights' sits in the same text as no Knesset vote and the dismantling of 'the Palestinian national collective'. Quote both parts.
Where it comes up
Sources
- Bezalel Smotrich, 'Israel's Decisive Plan', Hashiloach (September 2017), English version β
What was read
Read (2026-09-28). 'This will be life with the maximum of democratic rights: life, liberty, and property; a life of freedom of religion and expression β¦ It will also contain the right to vote for the system which runs their everyday lives.' 'The Arabs of Judea and Samaria will be able to conduct their daily life in freedom and peace, but not to vote for the Israeli Knesset at the first stage. This will preserve the Jewish majority in decision making in the State of Israel.' 'this is, albeit, an imperfect situation in terms of civil rights'. 'And no, this graduated arrangement does not make the State of Israel into an "apartheid state."' Re-read 2026-09-30: the plan's options: residency without the Knesset vote for those who 'let go of their national ambitions'; 'Those who choose not to let go of their national ambitions will receive aid to emigrate'; those who fight 'will be dealt with by the security forces with a strong hand'; and 'It will be possible to consider granting full citizenship as a third option, including voting for the Knesset', 'alongside the declaration of complete loyalty to the Jewish State by serving in the armed forces'. - Times of Israel, 'Jordan summons Israeli envoy over racist Smotrich speech, Greater Israel map' (20 March 2023) β
What was read
Speech in Paris, 19 March 2023; report of 20 March 2023 (read 2026-09-26). - Middle East Eye, 'Bezalel Smotrich calls for Israel's borders to extend to Damascus' (11 October 2024) β
What was read
Read. Quotes Smotrich from ARTE's documentary: 'It is written that the future of Jerusalem is to expand to Damascus'; 'little by little' is quoted too; the list of countries (Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt, Syria, Iraq, Saudi Arabia) is MEE's paraphrase, not his words. Jordan's foreign ministry condemned the remarks. The documentary itself not viewed.