Argument Β· heard from pro-Israel voices

β€œJews can only be safe as a majority in their own state.”

History proves it: wherever Jews lived as a minority β€” however large, however integrated β€” they were eventually massacred or expelled. Only a state with a Jewish majority and its own army can guarantee that it doesn't happen again.

Common pro-Israel argument β€” made by Benjamin Netanyahu, Ehud Olmert, Bezalel Smotrich

Where it's been said

β€œTo all the Jews of France, all the Jews of Europe, I would like to say that Israel is not just the place in which you pray, the state of Israel is your home.”
Benjamin Netanyahu, Prime Minister of Israel β€” Statement after the Paris attacks, 2015-01-10 βœ“
β€œ[If the two-state solution collapsed, Israel would] face a South African-style struggle for equal voting rights, and as soon as that happens, the State of Israel is finished.”
Ehud Olmert, Prime Minister of Israel β€” Interview with Haaretz, 29 November 2007, as quoted by JTA (February 2008); the Haaretz original is walled here, 2007-11-29 βœ“
β€œEstablishing a Palestinian state will endanger the existence of the State of Israel; and granting full voting rights to the Arab residents of Judea and Samaria will create a significant deficit in the Jewish component of the State of Israel.”
Bezalel Smotrich, Israeli politician, later finance minister; leader of Religious Zionism β€” 'Israel's Decisive Plan', Hashiloach (English version), 2017-09 βœ“

Heard two ways

'Voluntary emigration' (of Gazans)

  • The milder meaning: People choosing to leave, with help: Itamar Ben-Gvir called it 'a solution to encourage the emigration of Gaza's residents', 'a correct, just, moral and humane solution' (January 2024).
  • The harder meaning: The same speaker put the aim in numbers: 'the migration of hundreds of thousands from Gaza will allow the (Israeli) residents of the envelope to return home', together with re-established settlements. The US State Department read it as 'advocating for the resettlement of Palestinians outside of Gaza' and called it 'inflammatory and irresponsible'.

Both meanings are sourced below. Neither is assumed for any given speaker; ask which one is meant. See one word, two meanings.

Who makes this argument, and what they say they want

  • Religious Zionism (Bezalel Smotrich's party) (originator) β€” fits its stated aim. The plan withholds the Knesset vote because 'granting full voting rights to the Arab residents of Judea and Samaria will create a significant deficit in the Jewish component of the State of Israel', which is the demographic logic of the argument.

From the organisations' own pages: each one's stated aim, sourced tests of it, and how this argument compares. Who repeats an argument is a separate question from who makes it: people who share it can have their own reasons, and polls of supporters show how far those differ (see same slogan, different goals).

Traps in play:β—† Proxy presented as outcomeβ—† The strict enemy frame

  1. Why people find it convincing

    • Large Jewish populations did not protect Jews. Kishinev (1903) had 'about 50,000 Jews' in a population of 147,962 (1904; Jewish Encyclopedia), Odessa (1905) about one-third, Baghdad (1941) had about 90,000 Jews β€” and each saw a pogrom: 49 killed in Kishinev and 'over 500 injured' (JewishGen, citing the Encyclopaedia Judaica; the 1906 Jewish Encyclopedia counts '47 Jews … killed, and 92 severely, and 500 slightly, injured'); in Odessa 'the police reported that at least 400 Jews and 100 non-Jews were killed', figures the historian Robert Weinberg calls an underestimate, in a city of 403,000 with about 138,000 Jews; 150 to 180 in the Farhud (the official commission of inquiry said 128; USHMM).
    • Integration didn't protect them either: by 1933 'Germany's Jews were well integrated and even assimilated into German society', about 400,000 of some 525,000 held German citizenship, and most 'considered themselves German'; even so, before 1933 'Jews faced discrimination in Germany', and 'not all Germans believed that Jews could be German' (US Holocaust Memorial Museum, 'Jews in Germany Before the Nazis').
    • Before 1948, Jews fleeing Nazi Europe found doors closed. At Γ‰vian in July 1938, delegates from 32 countries 'expressed sympathy', but 'With the exception of the tiny Dominican Republic, no country was willing to accept more refugees'; in 1939 the St. Louis, carrying Jewish refugees, 'was forced to return to Europe after Cuba refused to allow the refugees entry' (US Holocaust Memorial Museum); the same year Britain's White Paper capped Jewish immigration to Palestine at 75,000 over five years. A state of their own means one door that never closes.
    • Israel wrote the promise into a Basic Law in 2018. 'The State will be open for Jewish immigration and for the Ingathering of the Exiles', and it 'shall strive to ensure the safety of members of the Jewish People and of its citizens, who are in trouble and in captivity, due to their Jewishness or due to their citizenship' (Basic Law: Israel – the Nation State of the Jewish People, arts. 5 and 6A).
    • Jews of Arab countries lost homes where their communities had lived for centuries: a 2008 US House resolution counts 'approximately 850,000 Jews' 'displaced from Arab countries since the declaration of the State of Israel in 1948' (H.Res. 185); in Israel's first years alone, to the end of 1952, it took in 377,251 immigrants from 'Muslim countries', among them 124,226 from Iraq, 52,584 from Tunisia, Morocco and Algeria, 48,375 from Yemen and Aden, 32,129 from Libya and 17,114 from Egypt (Israel State Archives figures, via the Jewish Virtual Library).
    • The argument has a serious liberal-democratic version, not only a nationalist one. The legal scholar Ruth Gavison, a founder of the Association for Civil Rights in Israel and for many years its president, grounded the Jewish state's legitimacy in 'the right of peoples to national self-determination' (as the historian Alexander Yakobson put it in his tribute in Fathom, November 2020). In her own words ('The Jews' Right to Statehood: A Defense', Azure, 2003): 'so long as the majority prefers to maintain Israel's Jewish character (again, without violating the basic rights of Arab citizens), this choice is legitimate', and 'Israel's Jewish majority need not apologize for seeking to retain the Jewish identity of the state, but it must recognize the rights of Palestinians living between the Mediterranean and the Jordan', including 'an independent state of their own alongside Israel'. She also called Arab citizens' struggle to change Israel's character 'legitimate, even if I do not share their aspirations'. The idea goes back to Leon Pinsker's 'Auto-Emancipation' (1882), written after the pogroms of 1881: being tolerated was no safety β€” 'To be robbed as a Jew or to be protected as a Jew is equally humiliating' β€” and 'legal emancipation is not social emancipation', so Jews 'must become a nation'.
  2. What's true

    In the pogroms cited, numbers without power did not protect Jews β€” and a state gave them a refuge nobody could close.

    In these cases, size was not safety: Kishinev, Odessa and Baghdad had large, established Jewish communities, and the violence came anyway, at times with the authorities standing by. What changed after 1948 is not that Jews stopped being attacked, but that there was a state whose army, immigration law and diplomacy exist to defend them, and a Law of Return that opens its door to any Jew. That is the core of the case Pinsker made in 1882 and Gavison defended in its liberal form (see sources).

    historyThe Kishinev pogrom, 6–7 April 1903 (1903) incident βœ“

    JewishGen KehilaLinks, 'The Kishinev Pogrom of 1903' (a Jewish genealogy site; read 30 Sept 2026): 'During the pogrom, 49 people were killed, over 500 injured and some 1.5 thousand Jewish houses and shops were plundered and ruined', citing the Encyclopaedia Judaica. The earlier note of 'Jews ~46% of Kishinev's population (β‰ˆ50,000 of β‰ˆ110,000)' is not on that page; the Jewish Encyclopedia gives about 50,000 of 147,962 (1904), see je-kishinef-1906.

    Open source β†—

    historyRobert Weinberg, 'The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa: A Case Study', in John D. Klier and Shlomo Lambroza (eds.), Pogroms: Anti-Jewish Violence in Modern Russian History (Cambridge UP, 1992), 248–89 (1905) incident βœ“

    Read 30 Sept 2026 as reproduced on a University of Maryland course page (labelled as such): 'the police reported that at least 400 Jews and 100 non-Jews were killed and approximately 300 people, mostly Jews, were injured'; 'These official figures undoubtedly underestimate the true extent'; Odessa had 'a Jewish population of approximately 138,000 in a city with 403,000 inhabitants'.

    Open source β†—

    historyThe Farhud, Baghdad, 1–2 June 1941 (1941) incident βœ“

    USHMM Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'The Farhud' (read 30 Sept 2026): 'rioters murdered between 150 and 180 Jews, injured 600 others'; 'According to the official report of the commission investigating the incident, 128 Jews were killed, 210 were injured'; 'about 135,000 Jews lived in Iraq (nearly 3 percent of the total population), with about 90,000 in Baghdad'. The Jews' share of Baghdad's population is not given there. Also: about 1,500 stores and homes looted; the official commission's report: 128 killed, 210 injured. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Other Arab nationalists also perceived the Baghdad Jews as Zionists or Zionist sympathizers and justified the attacks as a response to Arab-Jewish conflict in Palestine. Nevertheless, killing helpless Jews, including women and children, was an unprecedented phenomenon that contradicted Muslim law. In this situation, antisemitic ideology, derived in part from Nazi propaganda, helped to legitimize murdering Jews in Iraq.'

    Open source β†—

    pressFathom, 'The Unique Voice of Ruth Gavison (1945–2020)' (2020) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28): tribute by Alexander Yakobson (November 2020). 'a founder of the Association for Civil Rights'; 'for many years was the president of the Israeli Civil Rights Association'; the Jewish state's legitimacy 'is based, as she rightly insisted, on … the right of peoples to national self-determination'. Does not set out her majority argument.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentLeon Pinsker, 'Auto-Emancipation' (1882) (1882) incident βœ“

    Read (English text on the Jewish Virtual Library): 'To be robbed as a Jew or to be protected as a Jew is equally humiliating'; 'legal emancipation is not social emancipation'; 'they must become a nation'.

    Open source β†—

  3. What's left out

    The argument proves that Jews need power and a refuge β€” it doesn't prove that they need a majority over others.

    The same history shows the pogroms came where Jews were powerless, not merely outnumbered. A majority is one way to hold power; others are self-government, one's own security forces, and guarantees that actually hold (see the local-rule and confederation solutions). And a majority is not a guarantee either: October 7 happened inside the sovereign Jewish state, with a Jewish majority and its own army. A majority of the world's Jews still live outside Israel, about 8.5 million of 15.7 million in 2023; when Netanyahu called on Europe's Jews in February 2015, after the Copenhagen attack, to come to Israel, Denmark's former chief rabbi answered that Danish Jews should come 'because they want to live in Israel, not because they're afraid of living in Denmark', and the ADL's Abraham Foxman said 'I don't think he should urge them'; the AJC's David Harris called the call 'understandable'. About 7,000 French Jews did move to Israel in 2014 (CNN). Gavison's own version (2003): 'so long as the majority prefers to maintain Israel's Jewish character (again, without violating the basic rights of Arab citizens), this choice is legitimate', and the Arabs' struggle to change that character 'is legitimate, even if I do not share their aspirations'. The liberal version has its own critics, among them +972 Magazine's 2020 assessment of Gavison ('For renowned legal scholar, Israeli democracy meant Jewish dominance'; its text is not yet read here ⚠). When the principle was written into law in 2018, the text showed what it left out. The Basic Law makes 'the exercise of the right to national self-determination in the State of Israel … unique to the Jewish people', names Hebrew 'the State language' while Arabic gets 'a special status', and 'views the development of Jewish settlement as a national value'. The word 'equality' does not appear in it.

    Traps here:β—† Proxy presented as outcome

    pressTimes of Israel, 'Netanyahu to French Jews: Israel is your home' (2015) incident βœ“

    10 January 2015, after the Hypercacher attack (read 2026-09-26).

    Open source β†—

    pressCNN, 'Jewish leaders rebuff Netanyahu's call for mass migration' (2015) incident βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28). After the February 2015 Copenhagen attack: former Danish Chief Rabbi Bent Lexner, 'if they are going to Israel, it's because they want to live in Israel, not because they're afraid of living in Denmark'; ADL's Abraham Foxman, 'I don't think he should urge them … I don't think we should so easily grant Hitler a posthumous victory'; AJC's David Harris, 'understandable'; 'About 7,000 Jews in France alone immigrated to Israel in 2014'. No French Jewish leader is quoted.

    Open source β†—

    press+972 Magazine, 'For renowned legal scholar, Israeli democracy meant Jewish dominance' (2020) (2020) ⚠

    Critical assessment of Gavison's position, by its title. Its page is behind a bot wall (403, 2026-09-29), so only the title is used; not yet read. Tried again 2026-10-01: Cloudflare 403; not yet read. The page's paraphrase of the article's argument was removed until the text is read.

    Not yet read at the source. Tried: 2026-09-29: 403; 2026-10-01: Cloudflare 403.

    Open source β†—

    law / courtBasic Law: Israel – the Nation State of the Jewish People (19 July 2018), unofficial translation by Susan Hattis Rolef, Journal of Palestine Studies 48:2 (2019), via PalQuest (2018) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28). Art. 1C: 'The exercise of the right to national self-determination in the State of Israel is unique to the Jewish people'; 4A–C: 'Hebrew is the State language'; 'The Arabic language has a special status in the State'; 'Nothing in this article shall affect the status given to the Arabic language before this law came into effect'; 5: 'open for Jewish immigration and for the Ingathering of the Exiles'; 6A: 'strive to ensure the safety of members of the Jewish People and of its citizens, who are in trouble and in captivity, due to their Jewishness or due to their citizenship'; 7A: 'Jewish settlement as a national value'. No provision on equality. Re-read 2026-10-13 on PalQuest, Art. 7A: 'The State views the development of Jewish settlement as a national value and shall act to encourage and promote its establishment and strengthening.' Arts. 5 and 6A (PalQuest's text, read 2026-10-13): '5 β€” Ingathering of the Exiles The State will be open for Jewish immigration and for the Ingathering of the Exiles'; '6 β€” The Connection with the Jewish People A. The State shall strive to ensure the safety of members of the Jewish People and of its citizens, who are in trouble and in captivity, due to their Jewishness or due to their citizenship.'

    Open source β†—

    dataThe Jewish Agency for Israel, 'Jewish Population Rises to 15.7 Million Worldwide in 2023' (press release, 19 September 2023) (2023) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28). 15.7 million Jews worldwide; 'the number of Jews in Israel is 7,200,000'; 'about 8.5 million live outside Israel, with approximately 6.3 million of them living in the United States'. Figures from Sergio DellaPergola (Hebrew University), for the American Jewish Year Book 2023. (Later releases, per search summaries: 15.8 million, 7.3 million in Israel, 2024.)

    Open source β†—

    advocacy / viewRuth Gavison, 'The Jews' Right to Statehood: A Defense', Azure 15 (2003), online text p. 6 (2003) finding βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28): 'so long as the majority prefers to maintain Israel's Jewish character (again, without violating the basic rights of Arab citizens), this choice is legitimate'; 'Israel's Jewish majority need not apologize for seeking to retain the Jewish identity of the state, but it must recognize the rights of Palestinians living between the Mediterranean and the Jordan … both through an independent state of their own alongside Israel, and as a minority within the Jewish state'; the Arabs' struggle to change Israel's character 'is legitimate, even if I do not share their aspirations'. The earlier secondary summary (a Jewish majority 'makes full equality for non-Jews possible') is not her wording here.

    Open source β†—

  4. More context

    How to talk about this.

    Acknowledge first: Jews were massacred as minorities, including in communities that were large and established (Kishinev, Odessa, Baghdad), and the wish never to depend on others' goodwill is legitimate. Ask one question: 'is it the majority that keeps Jews safe, or the power to defend themselves, and could the second exist without the first?'; it separates the need from one way of meeting it. Share one checkable thing: October 7 happened inside the Jewish-majority state. And about 8.5 million of the world's 15.7 million Jews lived outside Israel in 2023, most of them as minorities. What not to say: 'Jews are colonisers who don't need safety', which ignores the history the argument rests on. From the other side: grant that a 'demographic threat' frame turns people into a threat, then ask what security guarantees would answer the fear without it.

    historyThe Kishinev pogrom, 6–7 April 1903 (1903) incident βœ“

    JewishGen KehilaLinks, 'The Kishinev Pogrom of 1903' (a Jewish genealogy site; read 30 Sept 2026): 'During the pogrom, 49 people were killed, over 500 injured and some 1.5 thousand Jewish houses and shops were plundered and ruined', citing the Encyclopaedia Judaica. The earlier note of 'Jews ~46% of Kishinev's population (β‰ˆ50,000 of β‰ˆ110,000)' is not on that page; the Jewish Encyclopedia gives about 50,000 of 147,962 (1904), see je-kishinef-1906.

    Open source β†—

    historyRobert Weinberg, 'The Pogrom of 1905 in Odessa: A Case Study', in John D. Klier and Shlomo Lambroza (eds.), Pogroms: Anti-Jewish Violence in Modern Russian History (Cambridge UP, 1992), 248–89 (1905) incident βœ“

    Read 30 Sept 2026 as reproduced on a University of Maryland course page (labelled as such): 'the police reported that at least 400 Jews and 100 non-Jews were killed and approximately 300 people, mostly Jews, were injured'; 'These official figures undoubtedly underestimate the true extent'; Odessa had 'a Jewish population of approximately 138,000 in a city with 403,000 inhabitants'.

    Open source β†—

    historyThe Farhud, Baghdad, 1–2 June 1941 (1941) incident βœ“

    USHMM Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'The Farhud' (read 30 Sept 2026): 'rioters murdered between 150 and 180 Jews, injured 600 others'; 'According to the official report of the commission investigating the incident, 128 Jews were killed, 210 were injured'; 'about 135,000 Jews lived in Iraq (nearly 3 percent of the total population), with about 90,000 in Baghdad'. The Jews' share of Baghdad's population is not given there. Also: about 1,500 stores and homes looted; the official commission's report: 128 killed, 210 injured. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Other Arab nationalists also perceived the Baghdad Jews as Zionists or Zionist sympathizers and justified the attacks as a response to Arab-Jewish conflict in Palestine. Nevertheless, killing helpless Jews, including women and children, was an unprecedented phenomenon that contradicted Muslim law. In this situation, antisemitic ideology, derived in part from Nazi propaganda, helped to legitimize murdering Jews in Iraq.'

    Open source β†—

    dataThe Jewish Agency for Israel, 'Jewish Population Rises to 15.7 Million Worldwide in 2023' (press release, 19 September 2023) (2023) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28). 15.7 million Jews worldwide; 'the number of Jews in Israel is 7,200,000'; 'about 8.5 million live outside Israel, with approximately 6.3 million of them living in the United States'. Figures from Sergio DellaPergola (Hebrew University), for the American Jewish Year Book 2023. (Later releases, per search summaries: 15.8 million, 7.3 million in Israel, 2024.)

    Open source β†—

  5. Where it leads if pressed

    Working it out: share, power, and refuge β€” what the cases show.

    The claim ties safety to being a majority. The cases on this page let the share of the population be separated from power and from a place to flee. Share: in Kishinev in 1904 about 50,000 of 147,962 people were Jews, about a third (this page's arithmetic), and 'the police were in open sympathy with the rioters' in 1903, when 47 Jews were killed; in Germany in 1933 Jews were 'less than one percent', mostly citizens who 'considered themselves German'; in Baghdad in 1941 a large, old community suffered the Farhud. A third of a city did not protect Jews, and neither did integration. Power and refuge: in 1938 at Evian 'most countries … refused to admit more refugees'; the 1939 White Paper capped immigration to Palestine; after 1948 a state took in 738,891 immigrants by the end of 1952, many from Muslim countries. The test inside the majority: on 7 October 2023 attackers 'killed about 1,200 people' inside the Jewish-majority state, with its own army. So the cases support the need for power and a refuge nobody could close; they show a majority helps provide that, and that it is not by itself a guarantee. The worst case for each side. For 'only a majority keeps Jews safe': take the pogroms at their worst; what failed there was power and protection, not only numbers, and 7 October happened inside the majority; keeping a majority also has costs the claim leaves out, which an Israeli prime minister named in 2007: without two states, Israel would 'face a South African-style struggle for equal voting rights, and as soon as that happens, the State of Israel is finished' (Olmert, as quoted in JTA); and after the 2015 Copenhagen attack Denmark's former chief rabbi answered a call to move: 'if they are going to Israel, it's because they want to live in Israel, not because they're afraid of living in Denmark'. For 'Jews need no state': take every diaspora success; Evian and the White Paper show what happened when no country had to take them in, and about 7,000 Jews from France alone moved to Israel in 2014, before the attacks of 2015 (CNN). Holds on the evidence here: Jews were massacred where they lacked power, whatever their share; a state with its own army and open immigration changed that. Could happen, as the page's solutions explore: other arrangements that give power and refuge without depending on a majority. Not supported: that a majority alone guarantees safety, or that Jewish history gives no reason to want a refuge of one's own.

    What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean

    referenceJewish Encyclopedia (1901–1906), 'Kishinef (Kishinev)', by Herman Rosenthal and Max Rosenthal (1906) aggregate βœ“

    Read 2026-09-30. 'it has a population of 147,962 (1904), including about 50,000 Jews'; on the 1903 riots: '47 Jews were killed, and 92 severely, and 500 slightly, injured … 700 houses were destroyed; 600 stores were pillaged'; 'the police were in open sympathy with the rioters, and made no attempt to interfere'. A contemporary Jewish reference work.

    Open source β†—

    historyUS Holocaust Memorial Museum, Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'Jews in Germany Before the Nazis' finding βœ“

    Read 2026-10-01. 'By 1933, when the Nazis came to power, Germany's Jews were well integrated and even assimilated into German society.' 'In 1933, the Jewish population of Germany numbered about 525,000. This was less than one percent'; 'Most Jews in Germany (about 400,000 people) held German citizenship … Most considered themselves German. In some cases, they had intermarried with non-Jews'; about 100,000 without citizenship, mostly from eastern Europe. 'Despite being integrated into German society, Jews faced discrimination in Germany. For example, not all Germans believed that Jews could be German.'

    Open source β†—

    historyThe Farhud, Baghdad, 1–2 June 1941 (1941) incident βœ“

    USHMM Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'The Farhud' (read 30 Sept 2026): 'rioters murdered between 150 and 180 Jews, injured 600 others'; 'According to the official report of the commission investigating the incident, 128 Jews were killed, 210 were injured'; 'about 135,000 Jews lived in Iraq (nearly 3 percent of the total population), with about 90,000 in Baghdad'. The Jews' share of Baghdad's population is not given there. Also: about 1,500 stores and homes looted; the official commission's report: 128 killed, 210 injured. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Other Arab nationalists also perceived the Baghdad Jews as Zionists or Zionist sympathizers and justified the attacks as a response to Arab-Jewish conflict in Palestine. Nevertheless, killing helpless Jews, including women and children, was an unprecedented phenomenon that contradicted Muslim law. In this situation, antisemitic ideology, derived in part from Nazi propaganda, helped to legitimize murdering Jews in Iraq.'

    Open source β†—

    historyUS Holocaust Memorial Museum, Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'The Evian Conference' incident βœ“

    Read 2026-10-01. 'In July 1938, delegates from 32 countries met in Evian, France … The delegates expressed sympathy for the Jews who were seeking to flee Nazi persecution. Most countries, however, refused to admit more refugees.' Outcomes: 'With the exception of the tiny Dominican Republic, no country was willing to accept more refugees. However, one result of the conference was the establishment of the Intergovernmental Committee on Refugees (ICR)'. Caption: the St. Louis in 1939 'carried Jewish refugees seeking temporary refuge in Cuba. It was forced to return to Europe after Cuba refused to allow the refugees entry into the country.' The Wagner-Rogers bill to admit 20,000 refugee children 'was not supported by the Senate in 1939 and 1940'.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentBritish White Paper of 1939 (Cmd. 6019) (1939) βœ“

    75,000 Jewish immigrants over five years. Re-read 2026-10-12 (Avalon text): the quota 'would allow of the admission, as from the beginning of April this year, of some 75,000 immigrants over the next five years'; 'After the period of five years, no further Jewish immigration will be permitted unless the Arabs of Palestine are prepared to acquiesce in it.'

    Open source β†—

    dataJewish Virtual Library, 'Immigrants to Israel: 1948-1952' (table; source given as the Israel State Archives) aggregate βœ“

    Read 2026-10-02. 'By the end of 1952, 738,891 immigrants had arrived'; 'Muslim countries': Iraq 124,226; Iran 25,593; Yemen and Aden 48,375; Other Asian countries 7,597; Tunisia, Morocco, Algeria 52,584; Libya 32,129; Egypt 17,114; 'Total Muslim countries 377,251'; 'Total Comunist states 307,082'. 'Source: Israel State Archives'. Perspective: JVL is a project of the American-Israeli Cooperative Enterprise.

    Open source β†—

    pressAP (via PBS NewsHour), 'Videos of Israeli soldiers acting maliciously emerge amid international outcry against tactics in Gaza' (13 December 2023) (2023) incident βœ“

    Read 2026-10-02. Videos apparently uploaded by soldiers: ransacking a toy store, trying to burn food and water supplies, prayer rugs moved into a bathroom, a dance with the chant β€˜there are no people who are uninvolved’ (AP verified backgrounds, uniforms and language). The army β€˜pledged to take disciplinary action in what it says are a handful of isolated cases’; spokesman Daniel Hagari: β€˜In any event that does not align with IDF values, command and disciplinary steps will be taken’. B’Tselem’s Dror Sadot: β€˜The dehumanization from the top is very much sinking down to the soldiers’. Yinon Magal, who posted the dance video, defended it and condemned the toy-store video. The article also notes the U.S. and other militaries have had similar videos, and Hamas’s hostage and 7 October bodycam videos. The article's background lines (read 2026-10-02 re-check, 2026-10-10): Hamas militants 'killed about 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and took about 240 hostages'; 'About 90 percent of Gaza's 2.3 million people have been displaced'.

    Open source β†—

    pressEhud Olmert, interview with Haaretz (29 November 2007), as quoted by Ori Nir, 'Two-state solution, not apartheid', JTA (Ideas, 3 February 2008) (2007) incident βœ“

    Read 2026-10-01 (the Haaretz original is walled). Nir quotes the interview: if the two-state solution collapsed, Israel would 'face a South African-style struggle for equal voting rights, and as soon as that happens, the State of Israel is finished'; and Olmert at the January 2008 Herzliya Conference: 'we fought … in order to ensure that Israel exists as a Jewish and democratic state with a solid Jewish majority'. An opinion piece arguing that US Jews should promote a two-state solution 'to make sure Israel doesn't become an apartheid-like regime'.

    Open source β†—

    pressCNN, 'Jewish leaders rebuff Netanyahu's call for mass migration' (2015) incident βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28). After the February 2015 Copenhagen attack: former Danish Chief Rabbi Bent Lexner, 'if they are going to Israel, it's because they want to live in Israel, not because they're afraid of living in Denmark'; ADL's Abraham Foxman, 'I don't think he should urge them … I don't think we should so easily grant Hitler a posthumous victory'; AJC's David Harris, 'understandable'; 'About 7,000 Jews in France alone immigrated to Israel in 2014'. No French Jewish leader is quoted.

    Open source β†—

    If safety is the majority, demography becomes a security threat β€” and so do the people counted on the other side.

    Once the majority itself is the guarantee, every birth rate and every border becomes a security question: the 'demographic threat'. That logic can lead to separation (two states, so that Israel keeps a Jewish majority β€” Olmert warned in 2007 that if the two-state solution collapsed, Israel would 'face a South African-style struggle for equal voting rights, and as soon as that happens, the State of Israel is finished'), or to worse: annexation without rights, or 'voluntary emigration'. The underlying need β€” Jews must never again depend on others' goodwill for their lives β€” is legitimate. The question the argument forces is whether a majority is the only way to meet it, or whether power, self-defence and credible guarantees could do it without making another people the threat.

    Traps here:β—† The strict enemy frame

    pressEhud Olmert, interview with Haaretz (29 November 2007), as quoted by Ori Nir, 'Two-state solution, not apartheid', JTA (Ideas, 3 February 2008) (2007) incident βœ“

    Read 2026-10-01 (the Haaretz original is walled). Nir quotes the interview: if the two-state solution collapsed, Israel would 'face a South African-style struggle for equal voting rights, and as soon as that happens, the State of Israel is finished'; and Olmert at the January 2008 Herzliya Conference: 'we fought … in order to ensure that Israel exists as a Jewish and democratic state with a solid Jewish majority'. An opinion piece arguing that US Jews should promote a two-state solution 'to make sure Israel doesn't become an apartheid-like regime'.

    Open source β†—

The usual reply β€” and its own traps

Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.

heard from pro-Palestinian voicesβ€œIsrael is a settler-colonial state.” Its traps: β—† Which territory? β—† Which Zionism?

Where this argument points

This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions β€” for, against or around them:

On the timeline

Keep exploring

From the archive

How newspapers reported related events at the time β€” suggested by the archive's own tags, not yet reviewed for this argument. Open a scan and judge for yourself.

Scans: kvetch-of-the-day news archive.