Solutions

Parallel states: two states on the same land

Two states, Israel and Palestine, each covering the whole land between the river and the sea. Citizenship follows the person, not the territory: every resident belongs to one of the two states, wherever they live.

Check the effects of this card β†’ pick what you believe, choose the defusions you would use, and see where it leads.

What happens to Israeli Jews

Israeli Jews keep a Jewish-majority state with its own identity and Law of Return, and can live anywhere in the land, including the West Bank, as Israeli citizens.

What happens to Palestinians

Palestinians get a state of their own with its own citizenship and right of return to it, and can live anywhere in the land, including inside today's Israel, as Palestinian citizens.

What it requires

  • Separating sovereignty from territory: both states' laws apply across the whole land, each to its own citizens
  • Shared institutions for what can't be split: security, borders, water, infrastructure, the economy
  • Freedom of residence: settlers can stay in the West Bank as Israeli citizens, and Palestinian refugees can settle anywhere as Palestinian citizens, which, in the model's logic, changes neither state's demographic balance, since citizenship and not residence decides membership
  • Jerusalem as the capital of both, with equal status
  • Courts and rules for disputes between citizens of the two states living side by side

Who supports it

Worked out in a project at Lund University's Centre for Advanced Middle Eastern Studies: the Swedish diplomat Mathias Mossberg outlined 'the basic elements of a "parallel states" structure' in the Journal of Palestine Studies (2010), and the full proposal is 'One Land, Two States: Israel and Palestine as Parallel States', edited by Mark LeVine and Mathias Mossberg (University of California Press, 20 June 2014; per Lund University's research portal and the Crossref record). Not adopted by any government or major party; rarely polled ⚠.

What history says

  • The Ottoman millet system: communities with their own law living side by side on one territory (see 'A religion doesn't justify having a country')
  • Personal federalism, where cultural autonomy follows the person rather than the region (which states practise it, and how well, is not sourced here ⚠)
  • Belgium's language communities: overlapping community and regional governments (how well it works is not sourced here ⚠)

Where this can lead

Each outcome holds only under its conditions. The label is how likely those conditions look on the record, by the weakest of them; set your own in the builder.

Two states on one land β€” possible on the record

if the shared institutions hold and violence is contained (A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure; Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check)

Two sovereign states over the same territory; citizenship and many laws follow the person, not the place; shared institutions for security, water and courts between them.

  • The Ottoman millet system β€” lasted centuries. Communities with their own law living side by side on one territory (see 'Parallel states: two states on the same land').
  • Belgium's language communities β€” held. Since six state reforms (1970–2014) its constitution reads: 'Belgium is a federal state, composed of communities and regions'. Language communities that follow persons ('the bond that unifies them, namely their language and culture') overlap with three territorial regions (the Belgian government's own overview). Workable, but complex.

What it can slide into: If the shared institutions fail: a shared state that breaks down.

A shared state that breaks down β€” possible on the record

if the shared institutions fail (not: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure)

The institutions deadlock along national lines; each community arms or turns to outside patrons; the state survives on paper or not at all.

  • Lebanon β€” collapsed. A confessional power-sharing state that fell into civil war (1975–90). The 1989 Taif Agreement, which 'brought a formal end to the Lebanese civil war (1975–1990)', revised the shares, moving parliamentary seats from a '55:45 Christian-Muslim ratio' to 'an even 50:50', under Syrian supervision. A Conciliation Resources analysis argues it 'exacerbated confessional tension and competition' in practice.
  • Bosnia after Dayton (1995) β€” froze. Initialed at Dayton on 21 November 1995 and signed in Paris on 14 December, it kept one state made of 'two Entities, the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and Republika Srpska', with a demarcated boundary between them (the agreement's text, Office of the High Representative). That two-entity structure is still in place.

What it can slide into: Civil war, partition, or one group ruling the other.

The hard questions

  • Who has the final say on security when two sovereign states share one territory? A review in the Middle East Quarterly (Martin Sherman, Summer 2015) says the contributors 'show some awareness of the problems that arise with regard to taxation, traffic regulation, law enforcement, demilitarization, foreign policy decisions, and, of course, declarations of war', but 'offer no mechanics to resolve such conundrums', saying only that solutions would be 'worked out'.
  • What happens when citizens of the two states clash over the same piece of land, and whose court decides?
  • Does it solve the fear of losing a majority, or only postpone it, if millions of Palestinian citizens live inside today's Israel?

What stands in the way

Arguments that point here