Deadlocks Β· trust lock
Distrust as premise
When the other side is evil by definition, nothing it does can count in its favour, and no agreement is possible.
Check the effects of this card β see which solutions this deadlock blocks, and how ready each is with your assumptions.
What many Israelis fear
Every Palestinian gesture is taqiyya or a ruse; 'they only want to kill Jews'.
What feeds it: October 7; celebrations of attacks; payments to prisoners' families; incitement in media and schools.
What many Palestinians fear
Every Israeli warning, aid convoy or withdrawal is PR, pinkwashing or hasbara; Israel is evil and can't be trusted.
What feeds it: Civilian deaths in Gaza; settler violence; officials' statements; decades of occupation.
Which solutions it blocks
- Two states β No agreement survives if every act of the other side is read as a trick.
- Two states, one homeland (confederation) β Same.
- Local rule: clans, cities and cantons β Same.
- One democratic state with equal rights β Same.
- One state with equal rights that remains a Jewish state β Same.
- Parallel states: two states on the same land β Shared land with separate sovereignties needs trust on a daily basis, which is the scarcest thing.
- Binationalism: one state shared by two nations β Vetoes held by the other nation only work if you trust how it will use them.
- Hudna: a long-term truce without recognition β A long truce depends entirely on believing the other side will keep it.
- The original Mandate: a confederation on both banks of the Jordan β A confederation with separate armies can make each army the other's threat.
- The Gaza plan: Board of Peace and a technocratic Gaza (2025) β Every stage depends on believing the other side will do its part β Hamas disarming, the army withdrawing, the international force staying β and each side reads the other's delays as proof it never meant to.
- The Trump plan: 'Peace to Prosperity' (2020) β Drafted with one side and presented to the other, it was read by Palestinians as confirmation that the process was never neutral, and its annexation map as the real plan behind the offer.
- Three Gazas: an annexed strip, a 'red zone' and a 'Gaza of Peace' (Wilf, 2026) β Gazans must trust that renouncing their refugee status brings real reconstruction and freedom; Israelis must trust that the peace zone won't become a front.
What could defuse it
- Third-party security guarantees β An outside force or guarantor takes on part of the security burden, so that neither side has to trust the other with its safety on day one.
- Phased steps, each verified before the next β Instead of one leap, small reciprocal steps, each checked by an independent body, so that moving first costs little and trust is built by evidence.
- A people's mandate β Ordinary Israelis and Palestinians, brought together, work out what they could accept, and their proposal is put to both sides' leaders as a mandate the leaders didn't have to invent.
- Reform the political system β Fix the systems that keep leaders from delivering: in Israel, the coalition rules that give small parties a veto; for Palestinians, the absence of elections and a divided leadership.
- A gesture that breaks the frame β One act so unexpected that the other side's picture of you can't absorb it: a leader going to the enemy's capital, an apology, a release, a visit.
- β Remove the other population β 'Defuse' the demographic deadlock by making the other people leave: 'voluntary emigration' of Gazans, or 'go back to Europe' for Israeli Jews.
- β Remove the other side's government β Destroy Hamas, topple the Iranian regime, or replace a Palestinian or Israeli leadership from outside, on the theory that the people underneath would then make peace.
- β Total military victory β One side defeats the other so completely that it gives up its aims: 'total victory' on the Israeli side, 'liberation from the river to the sea' on the other.
- β Replace the political system wholesale β Tear up the existing system (a revolution, an imposed constitution, a new order) instead of reforming it from within.
- A shared history, told both ways β Teach each side's children the other side's story alongside their own, so that the other people's grief stops being invisible.
- Plan for the spoilers β Expect violence timed to wreck an agreement, and build the process so that an atrocity isolates its authors instead of halting the talks.
- Shared institutions for shared things β Give the two sides joint bodies for what neither can manage alone β water, energy, trade, crossings β with decisions by agreement, so cooperation becomes routine before trust exists.
Where a lock like this was broken
- People who met: the Parents Circle β Families Forum (bereaved Israeli and Palestinian families) and Combatants for Peace show that contact breaks the premise where arguments can't.
- Where there's contact, there's coexistence (see the theme).
Questions to sit with
- What could the other side do that would count in its favour, for you?
- If the answer is 'nothing', is your distrust a conclusion, or your starting point?