Deadlocks Β· defusion
Reform the political system
Fix the systems that keep leaders from delivering: in Israel, the coalition rules that give small parties a veto; for Palestinians, the absence of elections and a divided leadership.
Check the effects of this card β put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.
In Israel: changes to the electoral threshold and coalition rules, a written constitution settling the courts' role, and personal law separated from religious courts. For Palestinians: national elections (none since 2006), an agreed succession, and ending the split between Hamas and Fatah. The loop to break: reform keeps being postponed because the state is under constant challenge, and the unreformed system in turn blocks the solutions that would reduce the challenge.
The deadlocks it addresses
Where it has been tried
- Israel ends its military administration over Arab citizens (1966) β partly. Prime Minister Eshkol announced its abolition to the Knesset in November 1966, after attempts to end it had failed in 1962 and, by one vote, in 1963. Over the next two years 'its repressive powers were transferred to the police and intelligence services' (PalQuest). A reform from within that moved part of the control rather than ending it (see 'What the Ottomans and the British left behind').
- Israel's direct election of the prime minister (1996β2001) β failed. Meant to strengthen the government against small parties, it did the opposite: 'Many Israelis split their votes'. The two largest lists fell from 76 seats in 1992 to 45 in 1999, and the system 'made it difficult for the government to pursue and advance coherent policy' (Israel Democracy Institute). It was repealed in 2001.
- The cancelled Palestinian elections of 2021 β failed. They would have been the first national elections in 15 years. Weeks before the May 2021 vote, President Abbas postponed it 'until the participation of Jerusalem and its people is guaranteed'. Critics said Jerusalem was an excuse to avoid a vote that a divided Fatah might lose to Hamas (Al Jazeera).
What you have to believe for it to work
- Reform can happen during a conflict, not only after it
- Palestinian elections would produce a leadership able to negotiate
Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.
What has to happen first
- A governing coalition not dependent on the parties that benefit from the current rules
- For Palestinians, an election both factions would accept the result of
How it can fail
- Reform is captured by one camp, as the 2023 judicial overhaul fight showed
- Elections could empower the movements that reject any deal
Sources
- Israel Democracy Institute, 'The Return of Direct Elections for Prime Minister?'
- Al Jazeera, 'Abbas delays Palestinian parliamentary polls, blaming Israel' (30 April 2021)
- ECF, 'Abolition of the Military Governance of Arab-Populated Areas in Israel (1966)'
- PalQuest, 'Palestinians Under Military Rule in Israel, 1948-1966'