Solutions · builder
From here to there
Pick the outcome you want. See what blocks it now, and what has loosened blocks like these elsewhere.
Each target below lists the deadlocks that stand in its way, how each one blocks it, and the defusions that address that deadlock, with the record of their precedents. Set what you believe about each side under What you have to believe and watch the picture change. To build your own plan, tick the defusions you would use: the builder then counts only those, names the deadlocks your plan leaves open, and lists every belief your plan rests on.
If nothing changes
No final settlement: occupation of the West Bank, separation from Gaza, periodic rounds of war.
Nothing blocks this path, which is why it persists. What it costs is where it leads:
- An interim that lasts — possible — while the quiet holds
- Managed calm that is shattered — possible — when it doesn't — as in 2007–2023, which ended on October 7
- Permanent war — possible — if no side can impose or settle, rounds of war continue
It rests on: Indefinite military rule over millions of West Bank Palestinians · Containment of Gaza · Accepting recurring wars as the price. Every plan below can be read against this baseline: what would it change, and what would it cost?
How it has been kept, and what each side calls it: ‘Mowing the grass’.
Play it
Pick a goal. Between you and it stand locks (the deadlocks); your cards are defusions (what has loosened locks like these elsewhere). Play cards onto the locks and see what opens. Below the game is the full view, with everything.
See everything ↓ — the full view: every goal, lock, card and belief on one page.
Two states
A Palestinian state alongside Israel, roughly on the 1967 lines with agreed land swaps.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- Two states at peace — unlikely — if both publics accept it, spoilers are contained a guarantor stays and settlers outside the new border accept evacuation
- Two states, cold peace — possible — if the governments and their guarantors hold it together, whatever the publics think
- A new state that becomes a front — possible — if spoilers are not contained and armed groups do not keep a truce
What stands in the way:
- Each side reads the other through its worst quote — Each side sees the other's state as a staging post for its own destruction.
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — Demilitarisation, border control and the Jordan Valley: each side's minimum is the other's red line.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — No agreed number of returnees: 'end of claims' against 'right of return'.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
- Recognise the Jewish state ↔ recognise the Nakba — 'End of conflict' requires both recognitions, and neither side will go first.
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
- Whoever moves first loses — Needs withdrawals and recognitions that each side has learned not to give first.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Distrust as premise — No agreement survives if every act of the other side is read as a trick.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
Two states, one homeland (confederation)
Two sovereign states with open borders, shared institutions and a shared Jerusalem; citizenship and residence are separated.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- Two states with open borders — unlikely — if both publics accept open borders and violence is contained
- Two states, cold peace — possible — if the borders stay closed but the two states hold
- A new state that becomes a front — possible — if violence crosses the border
What stands in the way:
- Each side reads the other through its worst quote — Open borders need trust that the other side accepts you exist.
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — Open borders are exactly what the security fear forbids.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — Residence rights decide how many refugees could live in Israel.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
- Recognise the Jewish state ↔ recognise the Nakba — A shared homeland needs a shared account of how it was divided.
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
- Whoever moves first loses — Same, plus open borders.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Distrust as premise — Same.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
Local rule: clans, cities and cantons
Instead of one national government per people, power lies with local communities that already govern themselves: Arab clans and cities, Jewish towns and communities, federated or coordinated above.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- Cantons that hold — unlikely — if local leaders are legitimate and the common centre holds
- An outside administration that loses legitimacy — likely — if local rule is seen as installed from outside, as the Village Leagues were
- A shared state that breaks down — unlikely — if the units are legitimate but the centre does not hold (the Bosnia pattern)
What stands in the way:
- Each side reads the other through its worst quote — Local leaders who deal with the other side get branded as collaborators or traitors.
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — Armed local units, and who disarms them, decide whether cantons are safe.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Whoever moves first loses — Handing power to local leaders is a concession each centre fears.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Distrust as premise — Same.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
Parallel states: two states on the same land
Two states, Israel and Palestine, each covering the whole land between the river and the sea. Citizenship follows the person, not the territory: every resident belongs to one of the two states, wherever they live.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- Two states on one land — possible — if the shared institutions hold and violence is contained
- A shared state that breaks down — possible — if the shared institutions fail
What stands in the way:
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — Two states on the same land defuse borders but not numbers: open residence revives both the demographic fear and the return demand.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
- Distrust as premise — Shared land with separate sovereignties needs trust on a daily basis, which is the scarcest thing.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
One democratic state with equal rights
One state from the river to the sea, every person an equal citizen.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- One state that holds — unlikely — if both publics accept it and its institutions hold
- A shared state that breaks down — possible — if the shared institutions fail under pressure
What stands in the way:
- Each side reads the other through its worst quote — Sharing a state with a people whose movement denies yours feels suicidal.
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — Who commands one army and one police force, and which side's fighters join them?
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — Return decides who is the majority, which is the whole question.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
- Recognise the Jewish state ↔ recognise the Nakba — Whose history goes into the constitution, the schoolbooks, the anthem?
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
- Whoever moves first loses — Both sides give up a state and trust the other not to exploit it.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Distrust as premise — Same.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
One state with equal rights that remains a Jewish state
Israel extends its sovereignty and full, equal citizenship to the Palestinians of the West Bank, and keeps its Jewish national character, as it does today with its Arab citizens.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- A Jewish nation-state with an equal national minority — unlikely — if Palestinians accept a permanent minority status and the numbers allow
- A long minority conflict — likely — if they don't, and force is not an option
- One state, ruled — unlikely — if they don't, and the state chooses its Jewish character over the vote
What stands in the way:
- Each side reads the other through its worst quote — Palestinians won't accept a state whose leaders said they don't exist.
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — It works only if refugees don't return, which Palestinians reject.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
- Recognise the Jewish state ↔ recognise the Nakba — It asks Palestinians to accept the Jewish character without any acknowledgement of their own story.
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
- Whoever moves first loses — Israel would grant citizenship first and hope for loyalty.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Distrust as premise — Same.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
The Trump plan: 'Peace to Prosperity' (2020)
A demilitarised Palestinian state on most of the West Bank, plus Gaza and land swaps; Israel annexes the settlements and the Jordan Valley, with 'the potential to facilitate more than $50 billion in new investment over ten years'.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- A state in enclaves — unlikely — if Palestinians accept less than earlier offers and Israelis accept a state at all
- An interim that lasts — possible — if Palestinians reject it, as in 2020: the regional part goes ahead without them
What stands in the way:
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — Israel keeps overall security control, the borders and the Jordan Valley around a demilitarised state: for Israel the minimum for safety, for Palestinians permanent control with a flag on top.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — It settles the refugee question on the majority side alone — no return to Israel, limited return to the Palestinian state subject to Israeli agreement — so it offers 'end of claims' without anything the other side counts as justice.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
- Recognise the Jewish state ↔ recognise the Nakba — It asked Palestinians to recognise Israel as the Jewish state and offered no recognition of the Nakba; Palestinians rejected it at once.
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
- Distrust as premise — Drafted with one side and presented to the other, it was read by Palestinians as confirmation that the process was never neutral, and its annexation map as the real plan behind the offer.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
The Gaza plan: Board of Peace and a technocratic Gaza (2025)
End the war, release the hostages, disarm Hamas, and run Gaza through a technocratic committee of Palestinians and international experts under an international Board of Peace, with an international force, while a Palestinian state stays a conditional 'pathway'.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- A transition that leads to self-government — unlikely — if Gazans accept the transition, armed groups are disarmed and the guarantors stay
- An outside administration that loses legitimacy — possible — if Gazans reject an administration they did not choose
- An interim that lasts — possible — if the quiet holds but the pathway to a state stalls
- A truce that ends in war — likely — if disarmament fails
What stands in the way:
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — Disarmament and a transitional authority are read as the precondition for safety by one side and as permanent control by the other.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Whoever moves first loses — Who disarms and who withdraws first is the plan's core dispute.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Distrust as premise — Every stage depends on believing the other side will do its part — Hamas disarming, the army withdrawing, the international force staying — and each side reads the other's delays as proof it never meant to.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
Regional land swap (the Eiland plan)
Make the land bigger: Egypt gives Sinai land to enlarge Gaza, the Palestinians give Israel part of the West Bank where settlements stand, and Israel gives Egypt land in the Negev.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- Borders redrawn between states, by agreement — unlikely — if Egypt gives up land and the Arab states back it
- An interim that lasts — likely — if Egypt refuses
- Forced displacement — unlikely — if 'a bigger Gaza in Sinai' becomes a way to push Gazans out
What stands in the way:
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — Enlarging Gaza into Sinai is read by Palestinians as a new displacement and by Egypt as a transfer onto its soil.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
Trading the 'Triangle': land and people swapped for settlement blocs
Israel keeps the West Bank settlement blocs; in exchange, Arab-majority towns inside Israel near the Green Line (the 'Triangle' around Wadi Ara and Umm al-Fahm) become part of a Palestinian state, with their residents.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- Borders redrawn between states, by agreement — unlikely — if the Triangle's residents consent
- Forced displacement — unlikely — if it is imposed over their heads, like the 1923 exchange
- An interim that lasts — likely — if they refuse and force is ruled out: they stay Israeli citizens and the plan stalls
What stands in the way:
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — The plan exists to shore up the Jewish majority, which is exactly what makes Arab citizens reject it.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
Shrinking the conflict: less control now, no final deal
Leave the final status open and make occupation lighter step by step: roads linking the Palestinian areas without checkpoints, more work permits and economic ties, more room for Palestinian self-rule, while Israel keeps security control.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- An interim that lasts — possible — if the quiet holds
- Managed calm that is shattered — possible — if armed groups break the calm
What stands in the way:
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — Every step that eases control is read by Israelis as a risk and by Palestinians as a way to make control permanent.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Whoever moves first loses — Easing steps that are reversed after the next attack teach both sides that moving first costs.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
Hudna: a long-term truce without recognition
A ceasefire for 10, 30 or more years in exchange for Israeli withdrawal to the 1967 lines, without recognising Israel or ending the claims. Hamas has offered versions of it since the 1990s.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- Armed quiet without peace — unlikely — if the truce is kept, rearmament is stopped and someone enforces it
- A truce that ends in war — likely — if the truce is used to rearm
What stands in the way:
- Each side reads the other through its worst quote — Hamas's own texts define a truce as temporary, so Israelis read the offer through its charter; Palestinians read Israel's refusal through 'no such thing as Palestinians'.
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — A truce without recognition looks to Israelis like the textbook staging post: withdrawal now, war later.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Distrust as premise — A long truce depends entirely on believing the other side will keep it.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
The Jordanian option: the West Bank back to Jordan, or a Jordanian–Palestinian federation
Instead of a separate Palestinian state, the populated parts of the West Bank return to Jordanian rule or join Jordan in a federation, while Israel keeps security zones such as the Jordan Valley.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- The West Bank under Jordan again — unlikely — if Jordan wants it back
- An interim that lasts — likely — if Jordan declines, as it did in 1988
What stands in the way:
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — Israel wants security zones on the Jordan; Palestinians see the plan as control through Amman.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Whoever moves first loses — Jordan walked away in 1988 after moving first; neither side wants to repeat the London Agreement's fate.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
International trusteeship: an outside administration for a transition
An international or regional body governs Gaza (or all the territories) for a set period, providing security and services while local institutions are rebuilt, before handing over to Palestinian self-government.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- A transition that leads to self-government — possible — if the trustees stay and act, and the population accepts the transition
- An outside force that stays but doesn't stop the fighters — possible — if the force stays but won't act when tested
- An outside administration that loses legitimacy — possible — if the population rejects outside rule
What stands in the way:
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — Israel fears an international force that won't stop rearmament (as in Lebanon); Palestinians fear a new occupation under another flag.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Whoever moves first loses — Israel would move first by handing security to outsiders; the 2005 Gaza withdrawal is the lesson it cites.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
Binationalism: one state shared by two nations
One state in which Jews and Arabs are recognised as two national communities with guaranteed shared power, not a majority ruling a minority; the idea behind Brit Shalom and Ihud before 1948.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- Cantons that hold — unlikely — if both nations accept sharing power and the institutions hold
- A shared state that breaks down — possible — if power-sharing freezes or breaks, as in Lebanon and Cyprus 1960
What stands in the way:
- Each side reads the other through its worst quote — Parity needs each nation to believe the other accepts it exists; each reads the other's founding quotes as proof it doesn't.
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
- Distrust as premise — Vetoes held by the other nation only work if you trust how it will use them.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
A Middle East union: solving it inside a regional framework
Israel and a Palestinian state, alongside their neighbours, join an EU-style regional framework, with open trade, shared infrastructure, security guarantees and eventually freedom of movement, so that borders matter less and the conflict is settled as part of a regional bargain.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- A region bound by shared interests — possible — if Arab states commit and the region's spoilers can be kept out
- An interim that lasts — possible — if governments integrate around the conflict, leaving it unsolved
- Managed calm that is shattered — possible — if spoilers strike to stop the integration
What stands in the way:
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — Freedom of movement in a regional union reopens both the majority fear and the return question.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
- Recognise the Jewish state ↔ recognise the Nakba — Arab states offered recognition of Israel in 2002 conditional on Palestinian statehood; the Accords separated the two, and each side reads that differently.
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
United Arabia: dissolving the conflict into a larger federation
A thought experiment: the whole region, Israel and Palestine included, joins one large federation of autonomous states, so that the question of who owns the land between the river and the sea stops being about sovereignty.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- A union that breaks up — possible — if it comes apart, as the Egypt–Syria union did in 1961
- Cantons that hold — unlikely — if it holds together — a thought experiment more than a plan
What stands in the way:
- Each side reads the other through its worst quote — A Jewish minority inside an Arab federation would be read through every quote about Jews in Arab lands.
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - End the Ottoman remnants — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does
- A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — It dissolves the majority into a much larger Arab one, which is the fear at its fullest.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
The original Mandate: a confederation on both banks of the Jordan
Go back to the map before 1922, when the Mandate for Palestine still included Transjordan: a confederation of Israel, a Palestinian state and Jordan across both banks of the river, in which Jews are a minority of the whole but keep their own state, army and immigration, and Palestinians gain room, a state and a shared economy.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- Cantons that hold — unlikely — if Jordan joins and the confederation's institutions hold
- An interim that lasts — likely — if Jordan declines, fearing it would become the Palestinian state
- A shared state that breaks down — unlikely — if it is tried and the member armies become each other's threat
What stands in the way:
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — The whole point is a Jewish minority with its own defence; it asks Israelis to drop the majority logic and Palestinians to give up return to Israel proper.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
- Distrust as premise — A confederation with separate armies can make each army the other's threat.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
Three Gazas: an annexed strip, a 'red zone' and a 'Gaza of Peace' (Wilf, 2026)
Split the Strip in three: a small symbolic area annexed to Israel, a Hamas-run 'red zone' for those choosing continued war, and an IDF-run 'Gaza of Peace' whose entrants renounce UNRWA refugee status — cutting the refugee card in a public ceremony — before reconstruction money flows.
Where it can lead (label: how likely its conditions are — on the record, or with your settings once you change them)
- A transition that leads to self-government — unlikely — if enough Gazans choose the Gaza of peace, the armed part is contained and the guarantors stay
- An outside administration that loses legitimacy — possible — if Gazans refuse the renunciation and see the scheme as imposed
- A truce that ends in war — likely — if the Gaza of war rearms
What stands in the way:
- A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control — The peace zone is IDF-run, which is the Palestinian fear of permanent control; the Hamas-run 'red zone' is the Israeli fear of a staging post, kept alive next door.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
- Majority as safety ↔ return as justice — It settles the return question by demanding its renunciation up front — as a condition of entry and of reconstruction — which is exactly what the other side experiences as giving up justice.
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status
- Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
- Recognise the Jewish state ↔ recognise the Nakba — Cutting the refugee card in a public ceremony asks Palestinians to renounce the claim that carries their memory of 1948, while nothing comparable is asked of the other side.
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Reparations and compensation — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A truth commission — precedents: 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - A refugee package: choices, not one right — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 failed · 1 untried or measured
depends on: Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real · Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status · Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed - Lower the stakes of belonging — precedents: 3 worked · 1 partly
depends on: Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Regional anchoring — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly · 1 untried or measured
- Distrust as premise — Gazans must trust that renouncing their refugee status brings real reconstruction and freedom; Israelis must trust that the peace zone won't become a front.
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested · A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees - Phased steps, each verified before the next — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested - A people's mandate — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Reform the political system — precedents: 1 partly · 2 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims - A gesture that breaks the frame — precedents: 2 worked · 1 partly
depends on: The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically - Remove the other population (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Remove the other side's government (coercive) — precedents: 1 worked · 3 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - Total military victory (extreme) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders · The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement - Replace the political system wholesale (coercive) — precedents: 1 partly · 1 failed
depends on: A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders - A shared history, told both ways — precedents: 1 worked · 2 partly
depends on: People can work with the other side without being punished at home · The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does - Plan for the spoilers — precedents: 1 worked · 1 failed
depends on: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check · A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically · Hamas would keep a long-term truce · Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal - Shared institutions for shared things — precedents: 2 worked
depends on: A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure · Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- Third-party security guarantees — precedents: 1 worked · 1 partly · 1 failed
Outcomes that need a people gone or ruled
These are proposed too, so they are here. No deadlock blocks them in this model, because what stands in their way is not a fear on the other side but the other side itself: millions of people who would have to leave, submit or die. Pick one only after reading what it has meant wherever it was tried.
One state under Jewish rule, without equal rights
Israel annexes the West Bank but does not give its Palestinians citizenship.
Where it can lead
- One state, ruled — unlikely — if the ruled accept it and the world tolerates it
- Forced displacement — unlikely — if the ruled refuse and the world tolerates force
- Permanent war — likely — if the ruled refuse and the world does not accept force
Palestinians leave ('transfer' / 'voluntary emigration')
The land becomes Jewish by moving Palestinians out — to Jordan, Egypt, or elsewhere.
Where it can lead
- Forced displacement — unlikely — if the world tolerates it
- Permanent war — likely — if the world and the targeted people do not accept it
One Arab (or Islamic) state from the river to the sea
Israel ends; Palestine covers the whole land as an Arab state (PLO Charter 1968) or an Islamic one (Hamas).
Where it can lead
- Forced displacement — unlikely — if the world tolerates it
- Permanent war — likely — if the world and the targeted people do not accept it
What you have to believe
Every defusion rests on beliefs about the other side, about outsiders, or about your own leaders. Here they are by name, with what the record or the polls say. Set each one yourself and watch the picture change — what you think is possible depends on what you assume. Your settings stay in this browser.
Start from:
A defusion needs all its beliefs, so it is only as ready as its weakest one. A target needs one working defusion for each deadlock in its way, so it is only as ready as its hardest deadlock. The presets are this site's reading of the evidence, shown under each belief; set your own and compare.
- A majority of Israeli Jews would accept a Palestinian state with security guarantees (Israelis)
- Two states: 21% of Israeli Jews in the Palestinian-Israeli Pulse, September 2024 — the lowest since polling began (see 'Two states'). →
Record preset: unlikely — 21% of Israeli Jews support two states (Pulse, Sept 2024).
Needed by: Third-party security guarantees · Regional anchoring - A majority of Palestinians would accept a state beside Israel as the end of claims (Palestinians)
- Two states: 40% of Palestinians in the same Pulse poll, September 2024 (see 'Two states'). →
Record preset: possible — 40% of Palestinians support two states (Pulse, Sept 2024): a large minority, not a majority.
Needed by: Reform the political system · Reparations and compensation - Hamas would keep a long-term truce (Hamas)
- Hudna offers since 1994: up to 30 years (1997, via King Hussein), 10 years (Mashaal, 2008). Hamas members in Gaza told a PRIO researcher the length matters less than 'letting the next generation decide', while Hamas's 2017 document 'rejects any alternative to the full and complete liberation of Palestine, from the river to the sea' (see 'Hudna: a long-term truce without recognition' and 'Negotiation as a weapon'). →
Record preset: possible — Hamas has offered long truces, and describes a hudna as temporary.
Needed by: Plan for the spoilers - Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check (Both)
- Omagh 1998 isolated its authors; in 1994–96 the Hebron massacre, the bombings and Rabin's assassination did not (see 'Plan for the spoilers'). →
Record preset: possible — Omagh 1998 was contained; the Oslo years were not.
Needed by: Phased steps, each verified before the next · Plan for the spoilers · Shared institutions for shared things - A leader who makes a real concession survives it politically (Both)
- Sadat (1981) and Rabin (1995) were assassinated by opponents of their peace moves (see 'A gesture that breaks the frame'). →
Record preset: possible — Sadat and Rabin were killed; King Hussein's gesture of 1997 held.
Needed by: Reform the political system · A gesture that breaks the frame · Replace the political system wholesale · End the Ottoman remnants · Plan for the spoilers - An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested (Outsiders)
- See the precedents on 'Third-party security guarantees' (one worked, one partly, one failed). →
Record preset: possible — The guarantee precedents are mixed: one worked, one partly, one failed.
Needed by: Third-party security guarantees · Phased steps, each verified before the next - Arab states would pay for and guarantee a deal, not only recognise it (Arab states)
- See 'Regional anchoring' and its precedents. →
Record preset: possible — Arab states have offered recognition (2002) and a Gaza reconstruction plan (2025); guarantees untested.
Needed by: Regional anchoring - Iran and its allies could be kept from wrecking a deal (Iran and allies)
- See 'Iran is the head of the octopus — cut it off and Hamas and Hezbollah fall.' for the case and its limits. →
Record preset: possible — No precedent either way on this card; left at 'possible'.
Needed by: Plan for the spoilers - Settlers would accept evacuation with compensation (Israelis)
- Gaza 2005: every settlement dismantled 'against fierce resistance from the settler movement' (see 'Israel left Gaza in 2005 — there has been no occupation there since.'). →
Record preset: possible — Gaza 2005 happened, against fierce resistance. - Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real (Palestinians)
- PSR 2003: 10% of 4,506 refugee families chose return to Israel first (see 'A refugee package: choices, not one right'). →
Record preset: likely — In PSR's 2003 survey 10% chose return to Israel first.
Needed by: A refugee package: choices, not one right - Host states would give refugees citizenship or a secure status (Arab states)
- Jordan, Lebanon, Syria and Egypt are party to neither statelessness convention; Lebanon bars Palestinians from owning property (see 'Lower the stakes of belonging'). →
Record preset: unlikely — No main host state is party to either statelessness convention; Lebanon bars property.
Needed by: A refugee package: choices, not one right · Lower the stakes of belonging - People can work with the other side without being punished at home (Both)
- See 'Who can afford to speak' and the anti-normalisation 'purity loop'. →
Record preset: unlikely — Anti-normalisation sanctions and PA and Hamas repression of dissent (see freedom-to-dissent).
Needed by: A people's mandate · A shared history, told both ways · A truth commission - The public on each side can be moved by what the other side does (Both)
- Sadat's 1977 visit 'changed Israeli public opinion almost overnight and led to the 1979 treaty' (see 'A gesture that breaks the frame'). →
Record preset: possible — Sadat's visit changed Israeli opinion 'almost overnight'; such moments are rare.
Needed by: A people's mandate · A gesture that breaks the frame · A shared history, told both ways · A truth commission - Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders (Force)
- See the record on 'Remove the government' (Iraq 2003, Libya 2011, Lebanon 1982). →
Record preset: unlikely — Iraq 2003, Libya 2011, Lebanon 1982: leaders removed, movements not.
Needed by: Remove the other side's government · Total military victory · Replace the political system wholesale - Donors would fund compensation and reconstruction at the scale needed (Outsiders)
- See 'Reparations and compensation funds'. →
Record preset: possible — The German reparations were paid; large refugee funds have not been raised yet.
Needed by: Reparations and compensation · A refugee package: choices, not one right - The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement (Outsiders)
- The Arab League's Cairo summit (March 2025): 'categorical rejection of any form of displacement' (see 'Remove the population'). →
Record preset: unlikely — The Arab League and most states reject displacement 'under any pretext' (Cairo, 2025).
Needed by: Remove the other population · Total military victory - Both publics would accept one shared state (Both)
- One democratic state with equal rights: 25% of Palestinians and 14% of Israeli Jews (Pulse, September 2024). →
Record preset: unlikely — Minorities on both sides support it (Pulse, Sept 2024). - A shared state's institutions would hold under pressure (Both)
- Northern Ireland's power-sharing has held since 1998; Lebanon's fell into civil war (1975–90); Bosnia's froze into division (see 'One democratic state with equal rights'). →
Record preset: possible — The power-sharing precedents are split: one held, one collapsed, one froze.
Needed by: Shared institutions for shared things - Rearmament could be prevented during a long truce (Outsiders)
- Israel–Hamas ceasefires in Gaza (2008–2021) were each followed by a rebuilt arsenal and another war (see 'Hudna: a long-term truce without recognition'). →
Record preset: unlikely — Every Gaza ceasefire from 2008 to 2021 was followed by rearmament and another war. - Both publics would accept two states with open borders between them (Both)
- Two states, one homeland (confederation): 35% of Palestinians and 12% of Israeli Jews (Pulse, September 2024). →
Record preset: unlikely — Support is low on both sides, lowest among Israeli Jews (Pulse, Sept 2024). - A people ruled without equal rights would accept it (Palestinians)
- The annexation card's own warning: 'when a ruled people refuses to accept permanent subordination, “emigration” becomes the proposed answer' (see 'One state under Jewish rule, without equal rights'). →
Record preset: unlikely — No precedent on the card shows a ruled people accepting permanent subordination; South Africa's system ended in 1994. - Jordan would take responsibility for the West Bank again (Arab states)
- King Hussein's 1988 disengagement: 'Jordan is not Palestine and the independent Palestinian state will be established on the occupied Palestinian territory' (see 'Jordan is Palestine — the Palestinians already have their state.'). →
Record preset: unlikely — Jordan has refused since its 1988 disengagement. - Gazans would accept an administration no Palestinian voted for, for a transition (Palestinians)
- The Gaza plan's own hard question: 'Can a technocratic committee have legitimacy with Gazans if no Palestinian has voted for it?' (see 'The Gaza plan: Board of Peace and a technocratic Gaza (2025)'). →
Record preset: possible — No poll on this card; the precedents are mixed (Kosovo and East Timor vs Iraq 2003–04). - Palestinians would accept being a permanent national minority in a Jewish state (Palestinians)
- The card's own hard question: 'Why would Palestinians accept being a permanent national minority, when their national movement exists to avoid exactly that?' (see 'One state with equal rights that remains a Jewish state'). →
Record preset: unlikely — The Palestinian national movement exists to avoid exactly that; the minority precedents are split (Finland's Swedes vs Turkey's Kurds). - Local leaders would be seen as legitimate, not installed from outside (Palestinians)
- Israel's 'Village Leagues' (1978 to the mid-1980s) were rejected as collaboration and abandoned (see 'Local rule: clans, cities and cantons'). →
Record preset: unlikely — The closest precedent, the Village Leagues, was rejected as collaboration. - Egypt would give up sovereign land in Sinai for a larger Gaza (Arab states)
- The Taba arbitration (1988): 'even a square kilometre of Sinai was fought over to the end' (see 'Regional land swap (the Eiland plan)'). →
Record preset: unlikely — Egypt has fought for every square kilometre of Sinai since 1967. - Arab citizens of the Triangle would consent to being moved to a Palestinian state (Palestinians)
- In a 2000 poll, 11% of Umm al-Fahm residents favoured transfer to Palestinian rule and 83% opposed it (see 'Trading the 'Triangle': land and people swapped for settlement blocs'). →
Record preset: unlikely — 83% of Umm al-Fahm residents opposed it in the 2000 poll. - Gazans would formally renounce refugee status and the right of return in exchange for reconstruction (Palestinians)
- In PSR's 2003 refugee survey only 10% chose return to Israel first — but a formal renunciation was not what was asked (see 'A refugee package: choices, not one right'). →
Record preset: possible — Most refugees in the 2003 survey did not choose return to Israel first; whether they would formally renounce the claim has not been measured.