Deadlocks Β· trust lock
Each side reads the other through its worst quote
Israelis read Palestinian nationalism through 'we are only Palestinian for political reasons'; Palestinians read Zionism through 'there is no such thing as Palestinians'.
Check the effects of this card β see which solutions this deadlock blocks, and how ready each is with your assumptions.
What many Israelis fear
The Palestinian national movement is a weapon, not a people's wish: a state would be 'a new means to continue the struggle against Israel'.
What feeds it: Zuheir Mohsen of the PLO in Trouw (1977); the PLO Charter's claim to the whole land (1968); Hamas's charter; rejection of partition in 1937 and 1947.
What many Palestinians fear
Zionism's aim is to erase Palestinians as a people, so any deal is a step towards their disappearance.
What feeds it: Golda Meir's 'there was no such thing as Palestinians' (1969); Smotrich's 'there is no such thing as a Palestinian people' (2023); the Nakba; talk of 'voluntary emigration'.
Which solutions it blocks
- Two states β Each side sees the other's state as a staging post for its own destruction.
- Two states, one homeland (confederation) β Open borders need trust that the other side accepts you exist.
- Local rule: clans, cities and cantons β Local leaders who deal with the other side get branded as collaborators or traitors.
- One democratic state with equal rights β Sharing a state with a people whose movement denies yours feels suicidal.
- One state with equal rights that remains a Jewish state β Palestinians won't accept a state whose leaders said they don't exist.
- Hudna: a long-term truce without recognition β Hamas's own texts define a truce as temporary, so Israelis read the offer through its charter; Palestinians read Israel's refusal through 'no such thing as Palestinians'.
- Binationalism: one state shared by two nations β Parity needs each nation to believe the other accepts it exists; each reads the other's founding quotes as proof it doesn't.
- United Arabia: dissolving the conflict into a larger federation β A Jewish minority inside an Arab federation would be read through every quote about Jews in Arab lands.
What could defuse it
- A people's mandate β Ordinary Israelis and Palestinians, brought together, work out what they could accept, and their proposal is put to both sides' leaders as a mandate the leaders didn't have to invent.
- Reform the political system β Fix the systems that keep leaders from delivering: in Israel, the coalition rules that give small parties a veto; for Palestinians, the absence of elections and a divided leadership.
- A gesture that breaks the frame β One act so unexpected that the other side's picture of you can't absorb it: a leader going to the enemy's capital, an apology, a release, a visit.
- End the Ottoman remnants β Take personal status out of the religious courts, allow civil marriage, and modernise land law, removing inherited rules that no one chose and that give religious parties leverage.
- A shared history, told both ways β Teach each side's children the other side's story alongside their own, so that the other people's grief stops being invisible.
- A truth commission β Investigate and publicly record what each side did, including massacres and expulsions, trading full testimony for a chance to move on.
Where a lock like this was broken
- The 1993 letters of mutual recognition: Arafat recognised Israel's right to exist, and Rabin recognised the PLO as the representative of the Palestinian people. A founding quote was officially overwritten on both sides.
- Sadat's speech in the Knesset (1977): one act by the leader who had launched the 1973 war changed how Israelis saw Egypt.
Questions to sit with
- What would a leader on the other side have to say or do for you to stop reading them through that quote?
- Which of your own side's quotes does the other side read you through, and has anyone on your side overwritten it?