Deadlocks Β· content lock

A state as staging post ↔ security as permanent control

Israelis fear a Palestinian state would be a base for the next attack; Palestinians fear Israeli 'security needs' mean control that never ends.

Check the effects of this card β†’ see which solutions this deadlock blocks, and how ready each is with your assumptions.

What many Israelis fear

Withdraw, and the territory becomes a launch pad, as Gaza did after 2005 and southern Lebanon after 2000.

What feeds it: Rockets after the Gaza disengagement; Hamas's 2007 takeover; October 7; Hezbollah's build-up after 2000. And the idea has a text: the PLO's 1974 political programme (12th Palestine National Council, 9 June 1974) set up an 'authority … over every part of Palestinian territory that is liberated' while refusing any entity 'the price of which is recognition, peace, secure frontiers', declared that 'Any step taken towards liberation is a step towards' the democratic Palestinian state of its earlier resolutions, and gave that authority the aim of 'completing the liberation of all Palestinian territory' (UNISPAL text). The PLO recognised Israel in 1993, which overtook the programme on paper; the fear it wrote down did not go away.

What many Palestinians fear

'Security' is the reason given for every checkpoint, settlement road and raid, so it will never end, whatever Palestinians do.

What feeds it: Nearly six decades of military rule in the West Bank; Israeli control of borders, airspace and the registry even after 2005; settlement growth during the Oslo years.

Which solutions it blocks

What could defuse it

  • Third-party security guarantees β€” An outside force or guarantor takes on part of the security burden, so that neither side has to trust the other with its safety on day one.
  • Phased steps, each verified before the next β€” Instead of one leap, small reciprocal steps, each checked by an independent body, so that moving first costs little and trust is built by evidence.
  • Regional anchoring β€” Embed a deal in the region: Arab states offer recognition, money and guarantees in return for Palestinian statehood, so both sides gain more than they give.
  • ⚠ Remove the other side's government β€” Destroy Hamas, topple the Iranian regime, or replace a Palestinian or Israeli leadership from outside, on the theory that the people underneath would then make peace.

Where a lock like this was broken

  • Sinai since 1982: demilitarised zones and the Multinational Force and Observers made withdrawal trustable, and it has held for more than 40 years.
  • Northern Ireland: weapons decommissioning verified by an independent international commission (the IRA's completed, as the commission announced on 26 September 2005; the UVF's in June 2009 and the UDA's in January 2010, and the commission's mandate ended on 8 February 2010 β€” CAIN, Ulster University) let both sides stop treating security as the reason for everything.

Questions to sit with

  • What verification would you trust if the other side's army or militias were involved?
  • Is there a security arrangement that the other side could see as ending, not permanent?