Two states, one homeland (confederation)
Two sovereign states with open borders, shared institutions and a shared Jerusalem; citizenship and residence are separated.
Check the effects of this card β pick what you believe, choose the defusions you would use, and see where it leads.
What happens to Israeli Jews
Israeli citizens; settlers can remain in Palestine as permanent residents under Palestinian law.
What happens to Palestinians
Palestinian citizens; some refugees can live in Israel as residents without changing its citizenship balance.
What it requires
- Two states on roughly the 1967 lines
- Freedom of movement and residence across the border
- Settlers may stay as residents of Palestine; some refugees may live in Israel as residents, voting in Palestine
- Joint institutions for security, economy, water and Jerusalem
Who supports it
Palestinian-Israeli Pulse (PCPSR / Tel Aviv University), fieldwork July 2024, published September 2024 (pcpsr.org/en/node/989, read 28 September 2026: 'Support for an alternative two-state confederation β¦ 20% of all Israelis β¦ 35% [of Palestinians] in 2024 β¦ 12% of Israeli Jews β¦ but 52% of Arabs').
What history says
- The European Union, which A Land for All itself calls 'a good analogue' for shared institutions
- The 'A Land for All' plan (its US site, read): two states on 'a border based on the pre-1967 "Green Line"'; settlers 'could, if they wish, remain in the West Bank so long as they agree to be law-abiding residents under Palestinian sovereignty', voting in Israeli national elections; 1948 refugees and their descendants could 'move to Israel under the same terms β permanent residency' or 'receive agreed upon compensation or restitution'; Jerusalem 'an open city' and 'the capital of both states'. May Pundak of A Land for All adds the other half: 'People who do not accept the sovereign Palestinian state will have to leave' (The Nation, Q&A).
Where this can lead
Each outcome holds only under its conditions. The label is how likely those conditions look on the record, by the weakest of them; set your own in the builder.
Two states with open borders β unlikely on the record
if both publics accept open borders and violence is contained (Both publics would accept two states with open borders between them; Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check)
Two states, each with its own citizenship and government, and free movement between them; residents of one may live in the other; Jerusalem shared.
- The European Union β held. Open borders between former enemies (see 'Two states, one homeland (confederation)').
What it can slide into: If violence crosses the open border: closure, and two states at cold peace or worse.
Two states, cold peace β possible on the record
if the borders stay closed but the two states hold (not: Both publics would accept two states with open borders between them; Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check; An outside guarantor would stay and act when tested)
The agreement holds between governments β borders, security cooperation, some trade β while each public stays hostile and contact across the border is policed socially.
- Egypt and Jordan with Israel β held, cold. Armies cooperate and gas flows, while 'normalisation' is sanctioned by unions and syndicates and public opinion moved the other way (see 'Cold peace').
What it can slide into: It can warm with time and contact, or break at the next war.
A new state that becomes a front β possible on the record
if violence crosses the border (not: Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check)
The territory handed over becomes a base for attacks; the stronger side answers with closure and force; the withdrawal is read on both sides as having failed.
- Gaza after 2005 β collapsed. Rockets after the disengagement and Hamas's 2007 takeover (see the deadlock 'A state as staging post').
- Southern Lebanon after 2000 β collapsed. Hezbollah's build-up after the Israeli withdrawal (same deadlock).
What it can slide into: Renewed occupation or war, and a public on each side convinced that the other never wanted peace.
The hard questions
- Does open movement work while trust is this low?
- Who polices violence that crosses the border?
What stands in the way
- Each side reads the other through its worst quote β Open borders need trust that the other side accepts you exist.
- A state as staging post β security as permanent control β Open borders are exactly what the security fear forbids.
- Majority as safety β return as justice β Residence rights decide how many refugees could live in Israel.
- Recognise the Jewish state β recognise the Nakba β A shared homeland needs a shared account of how it was divided.
- Whoever moves first loses β Same, plus open borders.
- Distrust as premise β Same.