Deadlocks · defusion
Phased steps, each verified before the next
Instead of one leap, small reciprocal steps, each checked by an independent body, so that moving first costs little and trust is built by evidence.
Check the effects of this card → put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.
A sequence of commitments (a ceasefire, prisoner releases, weapons handed in, withdrawals, elections) where each step is verified before the next, and a stalled step pauses rather than ends the process.
The deadlocks it addresses
Where it has been tried
- Northern Ireland, 1998–2007 — worked. The Good Friday Agreement (1998) was implemented in stages. An independent commission, set up by the British and Irish governments in 1997, watched the IRA destroy its weapons and reported on 26 September 2005: 'We believe with confidence that the arms decommissioned represent the totality of the IRA arsenal.' Devolved power-sharing government resumed at Stormont on 8 May 2007, with Sinn Féin's Martin McGuinness as deputy first minister.
- The Oslo interim process (1993–2000) — failed. Compliance was checked only by the two parties themselves. Oslo II (1995) set up joint committees; the Liaison Committee 'shall reach its decisions by agreement'; unresolved disputes 'may be settled by a mechanism of conciliation to be agreed between the Parties', and arbitration needed 'the agreement of both Parties'. No outside body could rule on a violation. As the US negotiator Aaron David Miller put it: 'From Israel's perspective, land was transferred to the Palestinians, yet the terrorism continued … From the Palestinian perspective … Israel was appropriating land'. What was missing was 'a monitoring mechanism to hold each side to the commitments they had made and, if necessary, impose costs for a breach'.
What you have to believe for it to work
- Leaders on both sides can keep their own spoilers in check
- An independent verifier is accepted by both
Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.
What has to happen first
- An agreed end point, or at least a direction, that makes the steps worth taking
- An independent verifier with a public record
How it can fail
- Spoilers attack at each step to stop the next one
- Interim arrangements can become permanent, as Oslo's did
Sources
- Erin Creegan, 'IRA Disarms After 36 Years', Arms Control Today (Arms Control Association), November 2005
- Israeli–Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip ('Oslo II'), 28 September 1995, arts. XXI and XXVI — UNISPAL
- CAIN (Ulster University), 'Speech by Martin McGuinness on the resumption of devolved government in Northern Ireland, Stormont, Belfast (8 May 2007)'
- Aaron David Miller, 'Why the Oslo Peace Process Failed', Foreign Policy (13 September 2023)