Trap · reasoning move

◆ Negotiation as a weapon

Sounds like: “They're only negotiating to buy time. / The ceasefire is a trick.”

Talks, truces and agreements treated as tactics rather than commitments — by the side accused, and as a reason by the accusing side never to negotiate at all.

Signs

a quote about a truce being tactical used to prove that no agreement with a whole people is possible; ceasefire violations counted for one side only; 'they only understand force' as the conclusion.

Questions to ask

Who said it, with what authority, and did their side's policy follow it? Which violations are counted, by whom? Has any agreement between these parties ever held — and what made it hold?

Example

an Oslo-as-Hudaybiyyah quote used to reject any Palestinian state.

The mirror

the 2001 recording used to argue Israel never negotiates in good faith.

Both sides have leaders on record treating the process as a weapon.

Palestinian side: in a taped speech at a closed meeting in a Johannesburg mosque (May 1994), Yasser Arafat called for 'jihad' for Jerusalem (JTA), and in Tunis weeks later, by the Christian Science Monitor's account, 'repeated the very words', drawing 'parallels between the autonomy agreement he signed with Israel and a 7th-century pact that the Prophet Muhammed reached with the Quraysh clan', the Hudaybiyyah pact. 'Some Israelis saw' in it 'proof that the Palestinian leader would renege'; the Monitor read it as 'mainly an unsuccessful attempt to clarify' Johannesburg, and Arafat said 'it was the Quraysh who breached the pact'; Faisal Husseini, in an interview the Egyptian weekly Al-Arabi published on 24 June 2001 as his last, is reported (in MEMRI's translation, not read here ⚠) to have called Oslo a 'Trojan horse' — an interview Haaretz headlined as surrounded by 'mystery'; Hamas describes a hudna as a temporary truce. Israeli side: a 2001 recording of Benjamin Netanyahu, made when he held no office and aired in 2010, has him telling settlers 'I'm going to interpret the accords in such a way that would allow me to put an end to this galloping forward to the '67 borders' (Al Jazeera). The broader charge, that talks covered settlement growth: an unsigned data summary in the Palestine-Israel Journal in 2000, citing Israel's Central Bureau of Statistics and Peace Now, counts settlers in the West Bank and Gaza rising from 115,700 at the end of 1993 to 176,973 by mid-1999, and construction begun on 17,190 housing units between September 1993 and July 2000; it grants 'violations of the Oslo Accords on both sides', and notes that for most Israelis '1993-2000 were years of peace'. Israel's case is that nothing was promised: Alan Baker, who took part in drafting the Oslo Accords, writes that the agreements contain 'no specific provision either restricting planning, zoning, and continued construction by either party, of towns, settlements, and villages, or freezing such construction', and that Israel's presence in Area C pending permanent-status talks 'enjoys the sanction of the PLO' (Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, 2011). The kvetch-of-the-day archive holds 59 clippings tagged 'Ceasefire Violations'. One, an AP report in The New York Times of 14 August 1948, is headlined 'Holy City Fight On As Zionists Balk' over the Israeli rejection of mediator Folke Bernadotte's plea for a cease-fire in Jerusalem, while its text reports Israeli army sources on Arab Legion shelling of Israeli positions on Mount Zion: each side's charge against the other in the same report.

pressJTA, 'Remarks Attributed to Arafat Could Derail the Peace Process' (18 May 1994), on the taped Johannesburg mosque speech (1994) incident ✓

Read 2026-09-30. The tape, broadcast on Israel Radio, 'called upon the Arab world to enter upon a "jihad," or holy war, to gain control of Jerusalem'; '"Jerusalem is not for the Palestinian people, it is for all the Muslim people," a voice sounding like Arafat's said. "Our main battle is Jerusalem."'; 'made during a closed meeting in a mosque, but a tape of it was sent to Israel Radio by a local Jewish resident'. Rabin: it 'would put a question mark over the continuation of the peace process'; Peres 'horrified', would ask for 'a clarification'. The Hudaybiyyah comparison is not in this report.

Open source ↗

pressFaisal Husseini's 'last' interview, Al-Arabi (Egypt), 24 June 2001 — as reported by Danny Rubinstein, 'Mystery Surrounds Faisal Husseini's "Last" Interview', Haaretz (24 July 2001) (2001) incident ✓

Read 1 Oct 2026 (Haaretz opening only; the rest is paywalled): 'on June 24, the Egyptian weekly Al-Arabi published an interview Faisal Husseini gave to its reporter Shafiq Ahmad Ali. "This was the final conversation with him before his death," states the sub-heading'. The headline calls it a 'mystery'; what Haaretz questions is not read here. The 'Trojan horse' wording is known from MEMRI's translation (its dispatch number is given in search results only), which is walled (403) and not read here.

Open source ↗

primary documentNetanyahu recorded at Ofra (2001), aired on Israel's Channel 10 in 2010 (2001) incident ✓

Al Jazeera, 18 July 2010, on the Channel 10 broadcast of the 2001 Ofra video; the two lines quoted on the page are from this report. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'America is a thing you can move very easily, move it in the right direction'; 'I'm going to interpret the accords in such a way that would allow me to put an end to this galloping forward to the '67 borders'; Netanyahu 'did not hold political office when the recording was made'; he 'was speaking with settlers who lost family members to Palestinian attacks'. The report does not name the settlement (Ofra in other reports, e.g. Gideon Levy's Haaretz column 'Tricky Bibi', not read here); the video was shot 'apparently without Netanyahu's knowledge'. Also: 'Nobody said what defined military zones were. Defined military zones are security zones; as far as I'm concerned, the entire Jordan Valley is a defined military zone.'

Open source ↗

press'Holy City Fight On As Zionists Balk' (1948) incident ✓

NYT 1948-08-14 (Jerusalem, Aug. 13, AP); vision-verified 2026-10-01 from the archive's scan. Subhead 'Rejection of Mediator's Plea for Cease-Fire Precipitates Intensified Struggle'; 'Israeli and Arab forces battled in Jerusalem today—the day Count Folke Bernadotte … had set for a cease-fire'; 'The Legion troops fired six-pounder and twenty-five-pounder shells in a vain attempt to penetrate Israeli positions, these sources said'. One of 59 clippings tagged 'Ceasefire Violations' in the archive.

pressLamis Andoni, 'Palestinian Leader Attempts To Explain His Remarks', Christian Science Monitor (3 June 1994) (1994) incident ✓

Read (2026-09-28). On Arafat's Johannesburg and Tunis remarks (jihad for Jerusalem; the Hudaybiyyah comparison). Walid Sadiq: 'In Arabic, jihad is mainly struggle through different forms, but in Israel and most of the West, jihad is connoted with violent struggle … Arafat should know better. He is a politician, and he is responsible for the choice of his words.' The reporter: 'Jihad, broadly defined in Arabic, means both struggle and holy war - or struggle for the sake of God.' Re-read 2026-10-02 (Tunis speech, after Johannesburg): Arafat 'drew parallels between the autonomy agreement he signed with Israel and a 7th-century pact that the Prophet Muhammed reached with the Quraysh clan'; 'Arafat had repeated the very words he used in a mosque in South Africa less than three weeks earlier'; 'Some Israelis saw in Arafat's reference to the Hudaybiyyah pact proof that the Palestinian leader would renege on his agreement with Israel. But a reading of the full text indicates that it was mainly an unsuccessful attempt to clarify his statements in Johannesburg'; 'The chairman explained that it was the Quraysh who breached the pact with the prophet.'

Open source ↗

data'Facts on the Ground since the Oslo Agreement, September 1993', Palestine-Israel Journal 7(4), 2000 ('Settlements or Peace') (2000) aggregate ✓

Read 2026-10-02. Unsigned data summary; its own call is for ‘our government’ to freeze settlement expansion and negotiate ‘a return to the 1967 borders with minor territorial exchanges’. Opens: ‘There were clearly violations of the Oslo Accords on both sides’. Data (Central Bureau of Statistics; Peace Now): settlers in the West Bank and Gaza 115,700 at end-1993, 176,973 in mid-1999; construction begun on 17,190 housing units September 1993–July 2000; housing stock up 52.49%; bypass roads; 740 house demolitions; closure days. Says most Israelis saw 1993–2000 as ‘years of peace’.

Open source ↗

advocacy / viewAlan Baker, 'Israel's Rights Regarding Territories and the Settlements', Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs (1 January 2011) (2011) finding ✓

Read 2026-10-02 (the site now redirects to jcfa.org). Baker, the article says, ‘participated in the negotiation and drafting of the Oslo Accords’. The agreements created ‘a special regime – a lex specialis’; ‘there is no specific provision either restricting planning, zoning, and continued construction by either party, of towns, settlements, and villages, or freezing such construction’ (citing Art. 27 of Annex III of the 1995 agreement); ‘the Oslo Accords contain no requirement that prohibits, limits, or freezes construction by Israel in Area C’; Israel's presence in Area C ‘enjoys the sanction of the PLO’ and ‘cannot … be considered “occupied territory”’. An advocacy argument; the UN usage it rejects is set out elsewhere on the site.

Open source ↗

'they'll cheat' is true of some actors some of the time — and is also the easiest excuse never to try.

Agreements have held: the Egypt–Israel peace treaty (1979) and the Jordan–Israel treaty (1994) have lasted decades despite hostile public opinion. Oslo produced the Palestinian Authority and security coordination that operated for years. The lesson of the broken truces is not 'never negotiate' but 'design deals that don't depend on trust'.

law / courtEgypt–Israel Peace Treaty (1979) ✓

Treaty of 26 March 1979, read on Yale's Avalon Project. Art. I(2): 'Israel will withdraw all its armed forces and civilians from the Sinai behind the international boundary … and Egypt will resume the exercise of its full sovereignty over the Sinai.'

Open source ↗

primary documentTreaty of Peace between Israel and Jordan (26 October 1994), Avalon Project (1994) ✓

Read (2026-09-28). Art. 3(2): 'the permanent, secure and recognised international boundary between Israel and Jordan, without prejudice to the status of any territories that came under Israeli military government control in 1967'; Art. 3(3): each other's territory 'inviolable'.

Open source ↗

Working it out: what each side's evidence of bad faith shows, and what has held.

Each side has a favourite proof that the other negotiates only to buy time, and each proof can be checked. The Israeli proof: in May 1994, months after Oslo, Arafat was taped in a Johannesburg mosque calling for 'jihad' for Jerusalem, and in Tunis weeks later drew 'parallels between the autonomy agreement' and the Prophet's Hudaybiyyah pact with the Quraysh; the Christian Science Monitor read the Tunis remarks as 'mainly an unsuccessful attempt to clarify', and a commentator it quoted noted that jihad in Arabic is 'mainly struggle through different forms'. The Palestinian proof: in a 2001 video, Netanyahu said 'I'm going to interpret the accords in such a way' that would let him stop the withdrawals; and settlement grew through the process, from about 110,000 settlers in the West Bank in 1993 to about 465,000 today, roughly four times as many, and from about 140,000 to 230,000 in East Jerusalem (Peace Now; this page's arithmetic). What held: the Egypt–Israel treaty of 1979, 47 years, and the Jordan–Israel treaty of 1994, 32 years, both despite hostile publics (see 'Cold peace'); both were between states, with clear borders and verifiable withdrawals. The worst case for each side. For 'the Palestinians will never keep a deal': take Arafat's Hudaybiyyah remark at its worst; one leader's speech is evidence about his intentions, and Israel's two treaties with Arab states show deals with hostile neighbours can hold when they are verifiable. For 'Israel only negotiates to grab land': take the settlement figures (from 115,700 settlers at the end of 1993 to 176,973 by mid-1999, by an Israeli journal's count from official statistics and Peace Now), the Ofra video, and the Gaza plan's architect Dov Weisglass in 2004 ('It supplies the amount of formaldehyde that is necessary so there will not be a political process with the Palestinians'; he later said the intention was not to hold one with the PNA 'in its present state') at their worst; Israel withdrew from all of Sinai under the 1979 treaty and has kept the Jordan treaty for three decades. Holds on the evidence here: leaders on both sides have spoken of agreements as tactics, and settlement expanded during Oslo; treaties with verifiable terms have lasted decades. Could happen with verification and staged steps: agreements that do not depend on trust. Not supported: that either side is incapable of keeping an agreement, or that one leader's words settle a people's intentions.

What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean

pressJTA, 'Remarks Attributed to Arafat Could Derail the Peace Process' (18 May 1994), on the taped Johannesburg mosque speech (1994) incident ✓

Read 2026-09-30. The tape, broadcast on Israel Radio, 'called upon the Arab world to enter upon a "jihad," or holy war, to gain control of Jerusalem'; '"Jerusalem is not for the Palestinian people, it is for all the Muslim people," a voice sounding like Arafat's said. "Our main battle is Jerusalem."'; 'made during a closed meeting in a mosque, but a tape of it was sent to Israel Radio by a local Jewish resident'. Rabin: it 'would put a question mark over the continuation of the peace process'; Peres 'horrified', would ask for 'a clarification'. The Hudaybiyyah comparison is not in this report.

Open source ↗

pressLamis Andoni, 'Palestinian Leader Attempts To Explain His Remarks', Christian Science Monitor (3 June 1994) (1994) incident ✓

Read (2026-09-28). On Arafat's Johannesburg and Tunis remarks (jihad for Jerusalem; the Hudaybiyyah comparison). Walid Sadiq: 'In Arabic, jihad is mainly struggle through different forms, but in Israel and most of the West, jihad is connoted with violent struggle … Arafat should know better. He is a politician, and he is responsible for the choice of his words.' The reporter: 'Jihad, broadly defined in Arabic, means both struggle and holy war - or struggle for the sake of God.' Re-read 2026-10-02 (Tunis speech, after Johannesburg): Arafat 'drew parallels between the autonomy agreement he signed with Israel and a 7th-century pact that the Prophet Muhammed reached with the Quraysh clan'; 'Arafat had repeated the very words he used in a mosque in South Africa less than three weeks earlier'; 'Some Israelis saw in Arafat's reference to the Hudaybiyyah pact proof that the Palestinian leader would renege on his agreement with Israel. But a reading of the full text indicates that it was mainly an unsuccessful attempt to clarify his statements in Johannesburg'; 'The chairman explained that it was the Quraysh who breached the pact with the prophet.'

Open source ↗

primary documentNetanyahu recorded at Ofra (2001), aired on Israel's Channel 10 in 2010 (2001) incident ✓

Al Jazeera, 18 July 2010, on the Channel 10 broadcast of the 2001 Ofra video; the two lines quoted on the page are from this report. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'America is a thing you can move very easily, move it in the right direction'; 'I'm going to interpret the accords in such a way that would allow me to put an end to this galloping forward to the '67 borders'; Netanyahu 'did not hold political office when the recording was made'; he 'was speaking with settlers who lost family members to Palestinian attacks'. The report does not name the settlement (Ofra in other reports, e.g. Gideon Levy's Haaretz column 'Tricky Bibi', not read here); the video was shot 'apparently without Netanyahu's knowledge'. Also: 'Nobody said what defined military zones were. Defined military zones are security zones; as far as I'm concerned, the entire Jordan Valley is a defined military zone.'

Open source ↗

dataPeace Now, '30 Years After Oslo – The data that shows how the settlements proliferated following the Oslo Accords' (2023) (2023) aggregate ✓

Read (2026-09-28): 1993, 'approximately 110,000 settlers in the West Bank' and 'around 140,000 in East Jerusalem'; today about 465,000 and 230,000; Rabin 'decided to freeze most of the construction in the settlements, but after his assassination and the rise of Benjamin Netanyahu to the prime minister's office, this policy changed drastically'; 'The settlement enterprise did not suffer from the Oslo Accords but rather thrived'. No figure for 2000 is given there. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'The settlement enterprise did not suffer from the Oslo Accords but rather thrived. Israel continued to expand, develop, and authorize settlements in the West Bank unabated. Even in years when few new settlements were established (1993-1997), infrastructure work continued.'

Open source ↗

law / courtEgypt–Israel Peace Treaty (1979) ✓

Treaty of 26 March 1979, read on Yale's Avalon Project. Art. I(2): 'Israel will withdraw all its armed forces and civilians from the Sinai behind the international boundary … and Egypt will resume the exercise of its full sovereignty over the Sinai.'

Open source ↗

primary documentTreaty of Peace between Israel and Jordan (26 October 1994), Avalon Project (1994) ✓

Read (2026-09-28). Art. 3(2): 'the permanent, secure and recognised international boundary between Israel and Jordan, without prejudice to the status of any territories that came under Israeli military government control in 1967'; Art. 3(3): each other's territory 'inviolable'.

Open source ↗

data'Facts on the Ground since the Oslo Agreement, September 1993', Palestine-Israel Journal 7(4), 2000 ('Settlements or Peace') (2000) aggregate ✓

Read 2026-10-02. Unsigned data summary; its own call is for ‘our government’ to freeze settlement expansion and negotiate ‘a return to the 1967 borders with minor territorial exchanges’. Opens: ‘There were clearly violations of the Oslo Accords on both sides’. Data (Central Bureau of Statistics; Peace Now): settlers in the West Bank and Gaza 115,700 at end-1993, 176,973 in mid-1999; construction begun on 17,190 housing units September 1993–July 2000; housing stock up 52.49%; bypass roads; 740 house demolitions; closure days. Says most Israelis saw 1993–2000 as ‘years of peace’.

Open source ↗

pressBBC News, 'Sharon plan "blocked peace talks"' (6 October 2004) (2004) incident ✓

Read 2026-09-30. Weisglass to Haaretz: 'The significance of the plan is the freezing of the peace process'; 'It supplies the amount of formaldehyde that is necessary so there will not be a political process with the Palestinians'; 'this whole package called the Palestinian state … has been removed indefinitely from our agenda'. Later, on Israeli radio: no intention to freeze the 'political process as such', 'But there was definitely an intention not to hold a political process with the PNA in its present state'. Sharon's office: the roadmap is 'the only plan liable to help progress towards a viable political agreement', Palestinian violence to blame for any freeze. Re-read 2026-10-12: after the interview 'he said there had been no intention to freeze the "political process as such". "But there was definitely an intention not to hold a political process with the PNA [Palestinian National Authority] in its present state,"'; Sharon's office: 'the Palestinian violence should be blamed for any freeze'.

Open source ↗

Trust that can't be faked.

If signatures can be weaponised, what counts is verification, small reversible steps each side can watch the other keep, and third-party guarantees — and, underneath all of that, contact between ordinary people over years, which can't be signed in bad faith (see 'coexistence where there's contact').

Why it works on us

  • There are documented statements on both sides describing agreements as tactical.
  • Every ceasefire in this conflict's history has been broken at some point, often within days.
  • People who were hurt after trusting an agreement have good reason not to trust the next one.

Where this trap shows up

Your side does it too — look at both columns.

Related