Argument Β· heard from pro-Palestinian voices
βThe people who cheered crippling sanctions on Iran suddenly call economic pressure on Israel 'collective punishment'.β
Pro-Israel voices are hypocrites: they support sanctions and blockades against others but call boycotts and sanctions against Israel illegitimate or antisemitic.
Made publicly as a pro-Palestinian argument by Palestinian civil society organisations (BDS National Committee)
Where it's been said
βin the spirit of international solidarity, moral consistency and resistance to injustice and oppression, We, representatives of Palestinian civil society, call upon international civil society organizations and People of Conscience all over the world to impose broad boycotts and implement divestment initiatives against Israel similar to those applied to South Africa in the apartheid era.β
Who makes this argument, and what they say they want
- BDS (Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions) (originator) β fits its stated aim. The argument defends economic pressure on Israel, which is what the call asks for.
From the organisations' own pages: each one's stated aim, sourced tests of it, and how this argument compares. Who repeats an argument is a separate question from who makes it: people who share it can have their own reasons, and polls of supporters show how far those differ (see same slogan, different goals).
Traps in play:β "What about you?"
Why people find it convincing
- Many strong supporters of Israel also back sanctions on Iran and supported the Gaza blockade, yet treat boycotts or sanctions against Israel as beyond the pale.
- The International Committee of the Red Cross said in June 2010 that the Gaza closure, 'about to enter its fourth year', was 'choking off any real possibility of economic development'; its own wording: 'The whole of Gaza's civilian population is being punished for acts for which they bear no responsibility. The closure therefore constitutes a collective punishment imposed in clear violation of Israel's obligations under international humanitarian law.' The same release said 'Israel's right to deal with its legitimate security concerns must be balanced against the Palestinians' right to live normal, dignified lives', and faulted Hamas for rebuffing requests to visit the captive soldier Gilad Shalit, 'in violation of international humanitarian law' (ICRC news release 10/103, 14 June 2010, as reposted by AUPHR).
- Economic pressure helped end South African apartheid; singling Israel out as immune looks like special treatment.
- Anti-boycott measures are widespread in the US: '38 states have adopted laws, executive orders, or resolutions designed to discourage boycotts against Israel', many requiring state contractors to certify they will not boycott Israel. Some, like Tennessee's, extend 'Israel' to 'Israeli-controlled territories' (Jewish Virtual Library, a pro-Israel reference site). Challenges on First Amendment grounds have so far failed: the Supreme Court declined to hear a challenge to Arkansas's law.
What's true
Inconsistency is real, and the Gaza closure has been called collective punishment by humanitarian bodies.
The strongest version is about institutions, not individuals. By the Jewish Virtual Library's count, 38 US states have adopted laws, orders or resolutions 'designed to discourage boycotts against Israel', and several use divestment, one of the tools BDS asks for, against companies that boycott Israel: New York, Illinois and Colorado divested from Unilever after its Ben & Jerry's subsidiary stopped selling in the West Bank. New York's governor put it as 'If you boycott against Israel, New York will boycott you', and Tennessee's legislature called BDS 'one of the main vehicles for spreading anti-Semitism'. Using economic pressure while condemning economic pressure is the inconsistency the argument points to, and naming it is fair. The same legislatures give their own reason: Tennessee's resolution calls BDS 'deeply damaging to the causes of peace, justice, equality, democracy and human rights for all the peoples in the Middle East' (all as recorded by the Jewish Virtual Library). The ICRC described the Gaza closure in 2010 as 'a collective punishment imposed in clear violation of Israel's obligations under international humanitarian law', while saying that 'Israel's right to deal with its legitimate security concerns must be balanced against the Palestinians' right to live normal, dignified lives'. Economic pressure is a non-violent political tool; whether anti-boycott laws aimed at one country raise free-speech problems is contested in US courts: Arkansas's law requiring contractors to certify they are not boycotting Israel was upheld by the full Eighth Circuit, which 'held that boycotts are not "expressive" enough to merit First Amendment protection', and in February 2023 the Supreme Court declined to review it; the ACLU, which brought the case, calls boycotts 'a powerful way to speak'.
referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'State Anti-BDS Legislation' β
Read (2026-09-29): 'To date, 38 states have adopted laws, executive orders, or resolutions designed to discourage boycotts against Israel'; the Supreme Court 'refused to hear a challenge to an appeals court ruling that the anti-boycott law in Arkansas was not unconstitutional'; Tennessee's SB 1993 requires contractors to certify they will not boycott Israel, and 'Israel' includes 'Israeli-controlled territories'; Illinois was first (July 2015). Re-read 30 Sept 2026: Tennessee's SJR-170 (123β1) calls BDS 'one of the main vehicles for spreading anti-Semitism and advocating the elimination of the Jewish state' and 'deeply damaging to the causes of peace, justice, equality, democracy and human rights for all the peoples in the Middle East'; Governor Cuomo's 2016 executive order, 'If you boycott against Israel, New York will boycott you'; New York (2021), Illinois (Dec 2021) and Colorado (Mar 2022) divested from Unilever over Ben & Jerry's West Bank decision.
primary documentICRC, 'Gaza closure: not another year!', news release 10/103 (Geneva/Jerusalem, 14 June 2010), as reposted by AUPHR (2010) incident β
Read (2026-09-29) in a full repost; the ICRC's own archive page timed out and the casebook copy is walled. 'The closure imposed on the Gaza Strip is about to enter its fourth year, choking off any real possibility of economic development'; 'The whole of Gaza's civilian population is being punished for acts for which they bear no responsibility. The closure therefore constitutes a collective punishment imposed in clear violation of Israel's obligations under international humanitarian law'; 'Israel's right to deal with its legitimate security concerns must be balanced against the Palestinians' right to live normal, dignified lives'; Hamas 'has continued to rebuff the ICRC's requests to let it visit Gilad Shalit β¦ In violation of international humanitarian law, it has also refused to allow him to get in touch with his family'.
primary documentICRC statement 'Gaza closure: not another year!' (14 June 2010), as reported by Al Jazeera (2010) incident β
Read (2026-09-29), Al Jazeera, 14 June 2010: headline summary '"Collective punishment" of Gazans by Israel termed violation of Geneva Conventions'; ICRC quoted: 'The closure imposed on the Gaza Strip is about to enter its fourth year, choking off any real possibility of economic development'; on Shalit: 'In violation of international humanitarian law, [Hamas] has also refused to allow him to get in touch with his family'; Israeli officials 'insist that they provide enough "humanitarian aid"'. The ICRC's own text (casebook.icrc.org) is walled.
advocacy / viewACLU, 'Supreme Court Declines to Review Challenge to Law Restricting Israel Boycotts' (press release, 21 February 2023) incident β
Read 2026-10-02. Arkansas law 'requiring government contractors to certify that they are not boycotting Israel or "Israeli-controlled territories"'; the Supreme Court's denial 'leaves in place a previous ruling from the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, which held that boycotts are not "expressive" enough to merit First Amendment protection'; the Arkansas Times 'is not boycotting Israel' but refused to sign on principle; ACLU of Arkansas: 'boycotts are a powerful way to speak and create change'. The ACLU was counsel for the plaintiff; the court's reasoning is given in the ACLU's summary.
What's left out
A tu quoque answers nothing β and some objections are to the aim, not the tool.
Pointing at the other side's inconsistency doesn't show that pressure on Israel is right or wrong; each case has to be judged on target, aim and proportionality. The UN sanctions on Iran began with Security Council Resolution 1737 (23 December 2006), adopted under Chapter VII and tied to its nuclear programme: Iran was to suspend 'all enrichment-related and reprocessing activities', states were to block the supply of items that could contribute to its nuclear and missile programmes, and assets of named persons and entities were frozen. BDS's own founding call (2005) has three demands, one being return of refugees under UNGA 194 β which, applied to the ~5.9 million refugees UNRWA serves (UN News, 2026), could end the Jewish majority (Israel had 7.2 million Jews in 2023, per the Jewish Agency), which is the dispute on 'The 'right of return' is a backdoor to ending Israel β by making Jews a minority.'; and 'Ending its occupation and colonization of all Arab lands' does not say which borders it means. Opposition to BDS can be to those aims rather than to economic pressure as such; Tennessee's resolution, above, objects to the movement as a whole. The consistency test also cuts the other way: calling sanctions on Iran collective punishment of the Iranian people while backing sanctions on Israel is the same double standard in reverse.
Traps here:β "What about you?"
law / courtUN Security Council Resolution 1737 (and successors 1747, 1803, 1929) (2006) β
S/RES/1737 (2006), adopted 23 December 2006 (read on the IAEA's copy of the UN document). 'Acting under Article 41 of Chapter VII'; Iran 'shall without further delay suspend β¦ all enrichment-related and reprocessing activities' and heavy-water work; all states to prevent the supply of items that could contribute to those activities or to nuclear weapon delivery systems; all states to 'freeze the funds, other financial assets and economic resources' of designated persons and entities. Successor resolutions 1747, 1803 and 1929 not read here.
primary documentPalestinian Civil Society Call for BDS (2005) incident β
9 July 2005 (read 2026-09-30). Calls for measures until Israel complies 'by: Ending its occupation and colonization of all Arab lands and dismantling the Wall; Recognizing the fundamental rights of the Arab-Palestinian citizens of Israel to full equality; and Respecting, protecting and promoting the rights of Palestinian refugees to return to their homes and properties as stipulated in UN Resolution 194'. Also read on bdsmovement.net.
primary documentUN General Assembly resolution 194 (III), 11 December 1948 (1948) β
Para. 11 as quoted in the UN study 'The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem', part II (UNISPAL): 'the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date'.
pressUN News, 'Despite record $100 million shortfall, Palestine relief agency still "a critical platform" for Gaza recovery' (30 June 2026) (2026) aggregate β
Read (2026-09-30). UN's own news service: 'The UN agency serving 5.9 million Palestine refugees, UNRWA, continues to strive to deliver on its mandate while facing an unprecedented' funding shortfall.
dataThe Jewish Agency for Israel, 'Jewish Population Rises to 15.7 Million Worldwide in 2023' (press release, 19 September 2023) (2023) aggregate β
Read (2026-09-28). 15.7 million Jews worldwide; 'the number of Jews in Israel is 7,200,000'; 'about 8.5 million live outside Israel, with approximately 6.3 million of them living in the United States'. Figures from Sergio DellaPergola (Hebrew University), for the American Jewish Year Book 2023. (Later releases, per search summaries: 15.8 million, 7.3 million in Israel, 2024.)
More context
How to talk about this.
Acknowledge first: sanctions can be applied selectively, backed against one country and called collective punishment when aimed at another. Ask one question: 'what standard would you apply to both?'; a consistent standard is the only answer to a double standard. Share one checkable thing: the stated grounds for each sanctions regime, and who is targeted (a government's programme, or a whole population). What not to say: 'Israel is different', which is the double standard in reverse. From the other side: grant the inconsistency, then ask whether boycotts that target Israelis as such, rather than specific policies, pass the same test.
Where it leads if pressed
Working it out: one test, four cases.
A double standard can only be shown by applying one standard to every case. Take three questions for each case: who is targeted, what the stated aim is, and what would end it. The UN sanctions on Iran (Resolution 1737, 2006): they targeted a programme, with named persons and entities' assets frozen and supplies for nuclear and missile work blocked, and an aim that could be met by suspending enrichment. Their effect on ordinary Iranians is not sourced on this page, so the test is applied here only to how they were designed. The Gaza closure: the ICRC said 'the whole of Gaza's civilian population is being punished for acts for which they bear no responsibility' and called it collective punishment (2010); Israel's stated aim was security, and its officials said they let in enough humanitarian goods. BDS (2005): it targets Israel broadly, with three demands, one being refugees' return under Resolution 194; with about 5.9 million refugees registered with UNRWA and 7.2 million Jews in Israel (2023), a full return would be a population about four-fifths the size of Israel's Jewish population (this page's arithmetic; how many would return is unknown), which is why Einat Wilf and Adi Schwartz argue that the demand that the refugees 'and their descendants be allowed to return constitutes a refusal to accept a Jewish state on any part of the former mandate' (as Quillette's review of their book summarises it), and why BDS's co-founder can describe the outcome as 'a Palestinian majority of what is today called Israel' (see the worst cases below). US anti-boycott laws: 38 states use economic pressure on companies and contractors that boycott Israel, a court let one such law stand, and the ACLU argues 'boycotts are a powerful way to speak'. The worst case for each side. For 'sanctions on Iran, but not on Israel, are legitimate': on this test the Gaza closure, which the ICRC called collective punishment, fails the 'who is targeted' question that the Iran sanctions were designed to pass. For 'pressure on Israel is like pressure on Iran': the Iran sanctions had an aim a government could meet; one of BDS's three aims, return 'as stipulated in UN Resolution 194', is described by the movement's own co-founder as ending the Jewish majority: 'There won't be any Zionist state like the one we speak about β¦ The Palestinian minority will become a Palestinian majority of what is today called Israel' (Omar Barghouti, in JNS's translation of an Arabic interview). Holds on the evidence here: both camps use economic pressure and condemn the other's; the test of target, aim and exit separates the cases better than who is doing it. Holds only case by case: targeted measures on either side that pass the test. Not supported: that pointing at the other side's inconsistency settles whether any particular measure is right.
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable β¦) mean
law / courtUN Security Council Resolution 1737 (and successors 1747, 1803, 1929) (2006) β
S/RES/1737 (2006), adopted 23 December 2006 (read on the IAEA's copy of the UN document). 'Acting under Article 41 of Chapter VII'; Iran 'shall without further delay suspend β¦ all enrichment-related and reprocessing activities' and heavy-water work; all states to prevent the supply of items that could contribute to those activities or to nuclear weapon delivery systems; all states to 'freeze the funds, other financial assets and economic resources' of designated persons and entities. Successor resolutions 1747, 1803 and 1929 not read here.
primary documentICRC, 'Gaza closure: not another year!', news release 10/103 (Geneva/Jerusalem, 14 June 2010), as reposted by AUPHR (2010) incident β
Read (2026-09-29) in a full repost; the ICRC's own archive page timed out and the casebook copy is walled. 'The closure imposed on the Gaza Strip is about to enter its fourth year, choking off any real possibility of economic development'; 'The whole of Gaza's civilian population is being punished for acts for which they bear no responsibility. The closure therefore constitutes a collective punishment imposed in clear violation of Israel's obligations under international humanitarian law'; 'Israel's right to deal with its legitimate security concerns must be balanced against the Palestinians' right to live normal, dignified lives'; Hamas 'has continued to rebuff the ICRC's requests to let it visit Gilad Shalit β¦ In violation of international humanitarian law, it has also refused to allow him to get in touch with his family'.
primary documentICRC statement 'Gaza closure: not another year!' (14 June 2010), as reported by Al Jazeera (2010) incident β
Read (2026-09-29), Al Jazeera, 14 June 2010: headline summary '"Collective punishment" of Gazans by Israel termed violation of Geneva Conventions'; ICRC quoted: 'The closure imposed on the Gaza Strip is about to enter its fourth year, choking off any real possibility of economic development'; on Shalit: 'In violation of international humanitarian law, [Hamas] has also refused to allow him to get in touch with his family'; Israeli officials 'insist that they provide enough "humanitarian aid"'. The ICRC's own text (casebook.icrc.org) is walled.
primary documentPalestinian Civil Society Call for BDS (2005) incident β
9 July 2005 (read 2026-09-30). Calls for measures until Israel complies 'by: Ending its occupation and colonization of all Arab lands and dismantling the Wall; Recognizing the fundamental rights of the Arab-Palestinian citizens of Israel to full equality; and Respecting, protecting and promoting the rights of Palestinian refugees to return to their homes and properties as stipulated in UN Resolution 194'. Also read on bdsmovement.net.
primary documentUN General Assembly resolution 194 (III), 11 December 1948 (1948) β
Para. 11 as quoted in the UN study 'The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem', part II (UNISPAL): 'the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date'.
pressUN News, 'Despite record $100 million shortfall, Palestine relief agency still "a critical platform" for Gaza recovery' (30 June 2026) (2026) aggregate β
Read (2026-09-30). UN's own news service: 'The UN agency serving 5.9 million Palestine refugees, UNRWA, continues to strive to deliver on its mandate while facing an unprecedented' funding shortfall.
dataThe Jewish Agency for Israel, 'Jewish Population Rises to 15.7 Million Worldwide in 2023' (press release, 19 September 2023) (2023) aggregate β
Read (2026-09-28). 15.7 million Jews worldwide; 'the number of Jews in Israel is 7,200,000'; 'about 8.5 million live outside Israel, with approximately 6.3 million of them living in the United States'. Figures from Sergio DellaPergola (Hebrew University), for the American Jewish Year Book 2023. (Later releases, per search summaries: 15.8 million, 7.3 million in Israel, 2024.)
referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'State Anti-BDS Legislation' β
Read (2026-09-29): 'To date, 38 states have adopted laws, executive orders, or resolutions designed to discourage boycotts against Israel'; the Supreme Court 'refused to hear a challenge to an appeals court ruling that the anti-boycott law in Arkansas was not unconstitutional'; Tennessee's SB 1993 requires contractors to certify they will not boycott Israel, and 'Israel' includes 'Israeli-controlled territories'; Illinois was first (July 2015). Re-read 30 Sept 2026: Tennessee's SJR-170 (123β1) calls BDS 'one of the main vehicles for spreading anti-Semitism and advocating the elimination of the Jewish state' and 'deeply damaging to the causes of peace, justice, equality, democracy and human rights for all the peoples in the Middle East'; Governor Cuomo's 2016 executive order, 'If you boycott against Israel, New York will boycott you'; New York (2021), Illinois (Dec 2021) and Colorado (Mar 2022) divested from Unilever over Ben & Jerry's West Bank decision.
advocacy / viewACLU, 'Supreme Court Declines to Review Challenge to Law Restricting Israel Boycotts' (press release, 21 February 2023) incident β
Read 2026-10-02. Arkansas law 'requiring government contractors to certify that they are not boycotting Israel or "Israeli-controlled territories"'; the Supreme Court's denial 'leaves in place a previous ruling from the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, which held that boycotts are not "expressive" enough to merit First Amendment protection'; the Arkansas Times 'is not boycotting Israel' but refused to sign on principle; ACLU of Arkansas: 'boycotts are a powerful way to speak and create change'. The ACLU was counsel for the plaintiff; the court's reasoning is given in the ACLU's summary.
pressJNS, 'BDS co-founder says goal of movement is end of Israel' (1 June 2020), on Omar Barghouti's Gazan Voice interview of 21 May 2020 (2020) incident β
Read (2026-09-28). JNS translation of the Arabic interview: 'There won't be any Zionist state like the one we speak about β¦ There will be two states: One democratic for all its citizens here and one democratic for all its citizens there. The Palestinian minority will become a Palestinian majority of what is today called Israel.' The Arabic interview itself is not checked here; the English is JNS's own translation.
advocacy / viewAdi Schwartz and Einat Wilf, The War of Return (St. Martin's Press, 2020), as reviewed by Benjamin Kerstein, Quillette (28 April 2020) (2020) finding β
Read 2026-10-01 (the book itself not read). Kerstein: 'former Israeli Knesset Member Einat Wilf and journalist Adi Schwartz' argue the 'right of return' is at the heart of the conflict, the demand for return of refugees 'and their descendants' being 'a refusal to accept a Jewish state on any part of the former mandate'; that the General Assembly 'does not have the power to create a "right"' and the Arab states opposed Resolution 194; a section on 'UNRWA's baleful influence'. A favourable review; the book's critics are not represented in it. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'the persistent demand that they and their descendants be allowed to return constitutes a refusal to accept a Jewish state on any part of the former mandate' (Kerstein's summary).
One rule for every case.
A consistent position is available: economic pressure is legitimate when it targets specific policies, with clear, achievable aims, and minimises harm to civilians β applied to Iran, Israel, Russia and everyone else alike. Measured that way, targeted measures against West Bank settlement activity look very different from a boycott whose three demands are ending 'occupation and colonization of all Arab lands', 'full equality' for Palestinian citizens of Israel, and refugees' return 'as stipulated in UN Resolution 194'. Whether that return would end Israel as a Jewish-majority state is the dispute on 'The 'right of return' is a backdoor to ending Israel β by making Jews a minority.'.
primary documentPalestinian Civil Society Call for BDS (2005) incident β
9 July 2005 (read 2026-09-30). Calls for measures until Israel complies 'by: Ending its occupation and colonization of all Arab lands and dismantling the Wall; Recognizing the fundamental rights of the Arab-Palestinian citizens of Israel to full equality; and Respecting, protecting and promoting the rights of Palestinian refugees to return to their homes and properties as stipulated in UN Resolution 194'. Also read on bdsmovement.net.