Trap Β· reasoning move
β "What about you?"
Sounds like: βBut what aboutβ¦ / You did it too.β
A criticism is answered by pointing to the critic's (or their side's) own inconsistency or wrongdoing, instead of by addressing the criticism.
Signs
the reply changes subject to the critic's side; 'what aboutβ¦' before the original point is answered; a list of other countries offered instead of an answer.
Questions to ask
Is the original criticism true or false, regardless of who makes it? Would I accept this answer if the roles were reversed? What would a consistent standard say about both cases?
Example
'You backed sanctions on Iran, so you can't call pressure on Israel collective punishment' β hypocrisy doesn't settle the case.
The mirror
'Arab states treat Palestinians worse, so Israel's policies are fine' β the same move from the other side.
What it is.
'You too' (Latin tu quoque) points at hypocrisy. Hypocrisy matters for judging a critic's credibility, but it doesn't make the criticism false: an inconsistent person can still be right. In this debate both sides use it β sanctions on Iran vs pressure on Israel; Western colonial histories vs Israel; Arab states' treatment of refugees vs Israel's. The honest use is a consistency test: 'apply this standard everywhere' β and then actually apply it.
Worked examples: the true charge, and what it doesn't settle.
A tu quoque usually points at something real. That is what makes it work, and why the answer is never to deny the charge but to separate it from the question. Two examples, one from each side. From the pro-Palestinian side: 'The people who backed sanctions on Iran call pressure on Israel illegitimate.' Both halves are documented at state level: 38 US states have adopted laws, orders or resolutions 'designed to discourage boycotts against Israel', and by 2015 'nearly half of the states' had Iran divestment laws or procurement bans (Steptoe, a law firm's compliance note); which states have both is not counted here. What it doesn't settle: whether a given measure against Israel is right. The two regimes differ in target and aim (Resolution 1737 targets Iran's enrichment programme and named persons and entities), and the honest test is one rule for both: what is targeted, what the aim is, and how civilians are spared (see 'The people who cheered crippling sanctions on Iran suddenly call economic pressure on Israel 'collective punishment'.'). From the pro-Israel side: 'Arab states treat Palestinians worse, so why single out Israel?' The charge is documented too: in Lebanon, 'around 93 percent of Palestinian refugees β¦ live in poverty, according to UNICEF, and continue to face restrictions on their right to work and own property' (Human Rights Watch, 2026). What it doesn't settle: whether any particular Israeli policy is justified. Applied consistently, the standard condemns Lebanon's restrictions and judges Israel's policies on their own terms; it never lets one excuse the other. In both cases the person making the tu quoque is right about the inconsistency and wrong about what follows from it. The consistency test is the useful part: apply it, out loud, to both cases.
referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'State Anti-BDS Legislation' β
Read (2026-09-29): 'To date, 38 states have adopted laws, executive orders, or resolutions designed to discourage boycotts against Israel'; the Supreme Court 'refused to hear a challenge to an appeals court ruling that the anti-boycott law in Arkansas was not unconstitutional'; Tennessee's SB 1993 requires contractors to certify they will not boycott Israel, and 'Israel' includes 'Israeli-controlled territories'; Illinois was first (July 2015). Re-read 30 Sept 2026: Tennessee's SJR-170 (123β1) calls BDS 'one of the main vehicles for spreading anti-Semitism and advocating the elimination of the Jewish state' and 'deeply damaging to the causes of peace, justice, equality, democracy and human rights for all the peoples in the Middle East'; Governor Cuomo's 2016 executive order, 'If you boycott against Israel, New York will boycott you'; New York (2021), Illinois (Dec 2021) and Colorado (Mar 2022) divested from Unilever over Ben & Jerry's West Bank decision.
law / courtUN Security Council Resolution 1737 (and successors 1747, 1803, 1929) (2006) β
S/RES/1737 (2006), adopted 23 December 2006 (read on the IAEA's copy of the UN document). 'Acting under Article 41 of Chapter VII'; Iran 'shall without further delay suspend β¦ all enrichment-related and reprocessing activities' and heavy-water work; all states to prevent the supply of items that could contribute to those activities or to nuclear weapon delivery systems; all states to 'freeze the funds, other financial assets and economic resources' of designated persons and entities. Successor resolutions 1747, 1803 and 1929 not read here.
pressHuman Rights Watch, World Report 2026: Lebanon (2026) aggregate β
Read 2026-09-30. 'Around 93 percent of Palestinian refugees in Lebanon live in poverty, according to UNICEF, and continue to face restrictions on their right to work and own property.' (The 2025 chapter: 'nearly 520,000 Palestinian refugees β¦ living in Lebanon'.)
law / courtSteptoe & Johnson, International Compliance Blog, 'The JCPOA and State Sanctions Laws, Part 2' (14 August 2015) (2015) β
Read (2026-10-12). A law firm's compliance note: the federal CISADA (2010) 'authorizes states to enact laws' requiring public funds to divest from companies doing certain business in Iran and barring procurement contracts with them; 'To date, nearly half of the states have enacted various forms of these divestment laws and procurement bans'; California 'one of the first states'; the JCPOA does not override them.
Why it works on us
- Inconsistency is real and worth exposing β double standards are a genuine problem.
- If the critic does the same thing, their outrage seems insincere.
- It feels unfair to be judged by people who don't apply their standard to themselves.
Where this trap shows up
Your side does it too β look at both columns.