Argument ยท heard from pro-Palestinian voices
โA religion doesn't justify having a country.โ
Jews are a religion, like Christians or Muslims; religions don't get states; so a 'Jewish state' is illegitimate in principle.
Made publicly as a pro-Palestinian argument by Palestine National Council (PLO)
Where it's been said
โClaims of historical or religious ties of Jews with Palestine are incompatible with the facts of history and the true conception of what constitutes statehood. Judaism, being a religion, is not an independent nationality. Nor do Jews constitute a single nation with an identity of its own; they are citizens of the states to which they belong.โ
Traps in play:โ Which Zionism?โ "What about you?"
Why people find it convincing
- Modern liberal democracies separate religion and state; a state defined by a faith looks like a step backwards.
- In Israel, marriage and divorce for Jews fall under the rabbinical courts (a 1953 law) โ there is no civil marriage โ so religion does shape citizens' lives there.
- Religious-nationalist parties are part of Israeli governments and push religious law into public life.
- For Palestinians, being ruled or displaced in the name of another people's religion feels like religious domination.
- A Tel Aviv University historian, Shlomo Sand, wrote a book called The Invention of the Jewish People that was a bestseller in Israel (by his own account), so the claim that Jews are not a people seems to come from inside Israel too, not only from its enemies.
What's true
Religion shapes Israeli law more than in most democracies, and that is fair to criticise.
Jewish marriage and divorce in Israel fall under rabbinical courts (Rabbinical Courts Jurisdiction (Marriage and Divorce) Law, 1953), so there is no civil marriage inside the country; Agudat Israel 'supports governing coalitions and is rewarded with ample budgets for its Orthodox schooling system', and for religious Zionists 'the state is part of an unfolding divine plan', which 'explains their prominence among West Bank settlers' (Benjamin Beit-Hallahmi, Middle East Report, November 1992). Secular Israelis criticise this; it is a live domestic fight, not a fringe complaint.
law / courtRabbinical Courts Jurisdiction (Marriage and Divorce) Law, 5713-1953 (Israel) (1953) โ
Knesset open-data record (IsraelLawID 2001233, read 2026-09-30): 'ืืืง ืฉืืคืื ืืชื ืืื ืจืื ืืื (ื ืืฉืืืื ืืืืจืืฉืื), ืืชืฉื"ื-1953', 2nd Knesset, published 4 September 1953, status 'ืชืงืฃ' (in force). The record confirms the law and its title, which gives rabbinical courts jurisdiction over marriage and divorce; the law's text itself is not read here.
pressBenjamin Beit-Hallahmi, 'Israel's Ultra-Orthodox', Middle East Report (MERIP), 1 November 1992 (1992) finding โ
Read 2026-10-01. 'The ultra-Orthodox have not accepted the Zionist definition of the Jews as a nation in search of a homeland'; 'In May 1912, some 200 Orthodox leaders from Germany and Eastern Europe met in Kattowitz (Katowice) to start Orthodoxy's first organized response to Zionism, Agudat Israel'; 'Since 1948, the party has been pragmatically involved in state institutions. It supports governing coalitions and is rewarded with ample budgets for its Orthodox schooling system. Agudat Israel accepts the state of Israel de facto'; Orthodox Zionists: 'the state is part of an unfolding divine plan โฆ That explains their prominence among West Bank settlers'. Other half in the same article: 'The leadership of the state is totally secular'; Orthodox parties 'have always been excluded from discussions about peace, war or the economy' (as of 1992).
What's left out
Jews are a people, not only a faith โ and Zionism was mostly secular.
A secular or atheist Jew is still a Jew; converts join a people ('your people shall be my people', Ruth 1:16), not only a creed. Orthodox opposition was organised early: 'In May 1912, some 200 Orthodox leaders from Germany and Eastern Europe met in Kattowitz โฆ to start Orthodoxy's first organized response to Zionism, Agudat Israel', and the ultra-Orthodox 'have not accepted the Zionist definition of the Jews as a nation in search of a homeland' (Beit-Hallahmi, 1992); and the movement itself was mostly secular: of early Zionism's 'four major streamsโreligious, political, cultural, and labor-socialist', 'All except the first constitute the different types of secular Zionism', and Herzl was 'an assimilated Jew' who 'showed little interest in Jewish subjects until the early 1890s' (My Jewish Learning). The claim was national self-determination of a people โ the same basis as Polish, Czech, Armenian or Arab national movements โ not 'a religion gets a country'. The Declaration of Independence promises equal rights 'irrespective of religion'.
Traps here:โ Which Zionism?โ "What about you?"
primary documentDeclaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel (1948) โ
Includes 'complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex'. Re-read 2026-10-12: the signatories assembled 'on the day of the termination of the British Mandate over Eretz-Israel'. Operative sentence (Avalon, re-read 2026-10-12): 'by virtue of our natural and historic right and on the strength of the resolution of the United Nations General Assembly, hereby declare the establishment of a Jewish state in Eretz-Israel'.
pressBenjamin Beit-Hallahmi, 'Israel's Ultra-Orthodox', Middle East Report (MERIP), 1 November 1992 (1992) finding โ
Read 2026-10-01. 'The ultra-Orthodox have not accepted the Zionist definition of the Jews as a nation in search of a homeland'; 'In May 1912, some 200 Orthodox leaders from Germany and Eastern Europe met in Kattowitz (Katowice) to start Orthodoxy's first organized response to Zionism, Agudat Israel'; 'Since 1948, the party has been pragmatically involved in state institutions. It supports governing coalitions and is rewarded with ample budgets for its Orthodox schooling system. Agudat Israel accepts the state of Israel de facto'; Orthodox Zionists: 'the state is part of an unfolding divine plan โฆ That explains their prominence among West Bank settlers'. Other half in the same article: 'The leadership of the state is totally secular'; Orthodox parties 'have always been excluded from discussions about peace, war or the economy' (as of 1992).
referenceMy Jewish Learning, 'Secular Zionism' โ
Read 2026-10-02 (Jewish educational site). 'Early Zionism was divided into four major streamsโreligious, political, cultural, and labor-socialist. All except the first constitute the different types of secular Zionism'; 'Hovevei Zion joined together secular and religious Jews'; 'Theodor Herzl, an assimilated Jew who lived in Vienna โฆ showed little interest in Jewish subjects until the early 1890s'.
More context
The consistency test: is this standard applied to anyone else?
Pakistan was founded in 1947 as a homeland for the Muslims of British India: the Muslim League's Lahore Resolution (1940) demanded that 'the areas in which the Muslims are numerically in a majority' be 'grouped to constitute "independent states"', and Jinnah argued it as nationhood, not only faith: 'Mussalmans are a nation according to any definition of a nation, and they must have their homelands, their territory, and their state' (both as quoted by Dawn). Iran, Mauritania, Afghanistan and Pakistan are Islamic republics; many Arab constitutions make Islam the state religion and sharia a source of law (e.g. Egypt's constitution, Article 2); Denmark and England have established churches. If religion can't be grounds for a state, the principle has to apply to them too, and whether it is raised about them is a fair test of consistency.
primary documentLahore Resolution (All-India Muslim League, March 1940) and Jinnah's Lahore address, as quoted in Dawn, 'The Resolution: Pakistan's constitutional blueprint' (supplement) (1940) โ
Read 1 Oct 2026. Resolution: 'that geographically contiguous units are demarcated into regions which should be constituted, with such territorial readjustments as may be necessary that the areas in which the Muslims are numerically in a majority as in the North Western and Eastern Zones of India should be grouped to constitute "independent states" in which the constituent units should be autonomous and sovereign.' Jinnah: 'Mussalmans are not a minority as it is commonly known and understoodโฆ. Mussalmans are a nation according to any definition of a nation, and they must have their homelands, their territory, and their state.' The supplement's own view: 'a precise demand for self-determination and not a cry for separatism'. Columbia's copies (Pritchett) walled. Pakistani newspaper.
law / courtConstitution of the Arab Republic of Egypt (2014, as amended 2019), Articles 2โ3 (2014) โ
Read 2026-09-30 (Constitute Project English translation). Art. 2: 'Islam is the religion of the state and Arabic is its official language. The principles of Islamic Sharia are the principle source of legislation.' Art. 3: 'The principles of the laws of Egyptian Christians and Jews are the main source of laws regulating their personal status, religious affairs, and selection of spiritual leaders.'
The Ottoman millet system Israel inherited, and why Israel has Sharia courts.
Much of what looks like 'Jewish theocracy' is an Ottoman inheritance. Under the millet system each recognised religious community ran its own personal-status law (marriage, divorce, often inheritance) through its own courts. The British Mandate kept the arrangement (Palestine Order in Council, 1922), and Israel kept it again. Jews marry and divorce before rabbinical courts. Muslims go to Sharia courts, whose qadis are state-appointed and state-paid. The recognised Christian churches have their own ecclesiastical courts, and the Druze gained theirs in 1962. So, yes, Israel has Sharia: it is the state law of personal status for its Muslim citizens. It cuts both ways. On one reading it shows a state that lets each community's religious law govern family life rather than a Jewish theocracy (Lebanon does the same: its constitution's Article 9 requires the state to 'respect religious interests and personal status laws' of its communities, in a Library of Congress summary; and Jordan's constitution gives 'The Sharia Courts alone' jurisdiction over the 'personal status of Moslems' (Art. 105) and 'Tribunals of Religious Communities' that of recognised non-Muslim communities). It also means there is no civil marriage for anyone, so couples of different religions, or of none, must marry abroad to be recognised at home. Other Ottoman law lingers too. The 1858 Land Code still underpins land law in the West Bank: Israel based its 'state land' declarations on it, saying that as the law in force when it occupied the territory it was 'required to respect it under international law'; by the state comptroller's count 908,000 dunams were declared in 1979โ1992, and B'Tselem, which documented this, calls the policy unlawful. The Ottoman civil code, the Mejelle, 'was rescinded in 1984 by a special Israeli law'; until then 'usage and custom were also formal sources of law, by virtue of the Mejelle' (Globalex, NYU Law's guide to Israeli legal research).
Traps here:โ "What about you?"
law / courtThe Palestine Order in Council (Palestine Constitution), 10 August 1922, arts. 51โ54 โ text on PalQuest (1922) โ
Read 1 Oct 2026. Art. 51: 'jurisdiction In matters of personal status shall be exercised โฆ by the Courts of the religious communities established and exercising jurisdiction at the date of this Order' (personal status: marriage or divorce, alimony, maintenance, guardianship, legitimation and adoption of minors, successions, wills and legacies โฆ). Art. 52: 'Moslem Religious Courts shall have exclusive jurisdiction in matters of personal status of Moslems'. Art. 53: the Rabbinical Courts have 'Exclusive jurisdiction in matters of marriage and divorce, alimony and confirmation of wills', other personal-status matters only where all parties consent. Art. 54: the same for 'the several Christian communities'.
law / courtRabbinical Courts Jurisdiction (Marriage and Divorce) Law, 5713-1953 (Israel) (1953) โ
Knesset open-data record (IsraelLawID 2001233, read 2026-09-30): 'ืืืง ืฉืืคืื ืืชื ืืื ืจืื ืืื (ื ืืฉืืืื ืืืืจืืฉืื), ืืชืฉื"ื-1953', 2nd Knesset, published 4 September 1953, status 'ืชืงืฃ' (in force). The record confirms the law and its title, which gives rabbinical courts jurisdiction over marriage and divorce; the law's text itself is not read here.
law / courtIsrael's religious-court laws for Muslims and Druze: Qadis Law, 5721-1961; Sharia Courts (Validation of Appointments) Law, 5714-1953; Druze Religious Courts Law, 5723-1962 (1961) โ
Knesset open-data records (read 2026-09-30): 'ืืืง ืืงืืืื, ืืชืฉื"ื-1961' (IsraelLawID 2000514; 4th Knesset; published 31 May 1961; status 'ืชืงืฃ', in force); 'ืืืง ืืชื ืืื ืืฉืจืขืืื (ืืืฉืืจ ืืื ืืืื), ืืชืฉื"ื-1953' (IsraelLawID 2000133; 2nd Knesset; published 17 December 1953; status 'ื ืืฉื', spent); 'ืืืง ืืชื ืืืื ืืืชืืื ืืืจืืืืื, ืืชืฉื"ื-1962' (IsraelLawID 2000136; 5th Knesset; published 3 January 1963; in force). The records confirm the laws and their titles; the texts themselves are not read here.
advocacy / viewB'Tselem, 'Under the Guise of Legality: Israel's Declarations of State Land in the West Bank' (March 2012), on the Ottoman Land Code of 1858 (2012) finding โ
Read 1 Oct 2026 (full PDF). 'According to Israel, the declaration policy was based on the land laws applying in the West Bank in general, and on the Ottoman Land Code of 1858 โฆ in particular. Since the Code was in force at the time Israel occupied the West Bank, Israeli authorities claimed that they are required to respect it under international law'; per the state comptroller, 'from 1979 to 1992, the Custodian declared 908,000 dunams' as state land, raising state land from about 9.1 to about 25 percent of the West Bank (excl. East Jerusalem). B'Tselem's own conclusion: the policy 'was unlawful', on due-process and discrimination grounds. Israeli human-rights NGO. The Mejelle's 1984 repeal is not in this source.
referenceGlobalex (NYU Law), 'Overview of Legal Research in Israel' โ
Read 1 Oct 2026. 'The Mejelle, an Ottoman codification of civil law โฆ published in 1867-1877 by the Ottoman Sultan'; 'The Mejelle was rescinded in 1984 by a special Israeli law'; 'The Mandate government and the subsequent Israeli legislature rescinded most of the Ottoman laws, leaving only a few remainders'; 'Until 1984, usage and custom were also formal sources of law, by virtue of the Mejelle'.
referenceLibrary of Congress, Global Legal Research Center, 'Lebanon: Constitutional Law and the Political Rights of Religious Communities' (December 2010; prepared by Issam Saliba) โ
Read 2026-10-02. 'Article 9 stipulates that the freedom of belief is absolute and the State shall respect all religions and denominations, ensure free exercise of religious rites, and respect religious interests and personal status laws'; 'Article 10 specifically provides for the right of religious communities to have their own schools'.
primary documentConstitution of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan (1952, rev. 2011), English translation via the Constitute Project โ
Read 2026-10-02. Art. 105: 'The Sharia Courts alone shall have the jurisdiction - in accordance with their own laws - in the following matters: Matters of personal status of Moslems', and blood money and waqfs; Art. 108: 'The Tribunals of Religious Communities are the tribunals of the non-Moslem religious communities that have been or will be recognised by the Government'; Art. 109: they apply the provisions on personal status 'which are not considered matters of personal status of Moslems'.
'Read Shlomo Sand': what the book argues, what the genetics says both ways, and what Sand himself concludes.
Shlomo Sand, a historian at Tel Aviv University, argues in The Invention of the Jewish People (2008; English edition Verso) that there was no forced Jewish exile at the hands of the Romans in the first century, and that 'most modern Jews descend from converts, whose native lands were scattered across the Middle East and Eastern Europe' (Verso's description). Sand says the book spent ten weeks as a bestseller in Israel and was attacked by other historians, including Simon Schama (Sand interview, Review 31). The genetic studies split. Elhaik (Genome Biology and Evolution, 2012) wrote that his findings 'support the Khazarian hypothesis' and described the European Jewish genome as a mosaic of Near Eastern-Caucasus, European and Semitic ancestries. Behar et al. (Human Biology, 2013), using 1,774 samples from 106 populations including the Caucasus and the Khazar region, found Ashkenazi Jews 'derive their ancestry primarily from populations of the Middle East and Europe' and 'no indication of a significant genetic contribution either from within or from north of the Caucasus region'. Earlier genome-wide studies traced 'the origins of most Jewish Diaspora communities to the Levant' (Behar et al., Nature 2010), and the same authors' 2013 paper describes Ashkenazi ancestry as a combination of European and Middle Eastern sources, so both descent from converts and Levantine descent find some support. Sand's own political conclusion is narrower than 'no state': 'I am not against the existence of the Israeli state, in the 1967 borders', he told Review 31, adding that he wants a Palestinian state beside it and an Israel that is 'the state of all its citizens'. A book about where Jews' ancestors came from does not by itself answer whether a Jewish people exists now, or what kind of state Israel should be; Sand's own answer to the second question is a civic state beside a Palestinian one.
advocacy / viewShlomo Sand, The Invention of the Jewish People (Verso, English edition; Hebrew original 2008) โ publisher's page (2008) finding โ
Publisher's description read: 'Exploding the myth that there was a forced Jewish exile in the first century at the hands of the Romans, Israeli historian Shlomo Sand argues that most modern Jews descend from converts, whose native lands were scattered across the Middle East and Eastern Europe.' The author's thesis (a critic of Zionism), described by his publisher; not a neutral summary.
primary documentBehar et al., 'No evidence from genome-wide data of a Khazar origin for the Ashkenazi Jews', Human Biology 85 (2013) finding โ
Abstract read via Europe PMC: 1,774 samples from 106 Jewish and non-Jewish populations, including 261 from the Caucasus and the region north of it. Ashkenazi Jews 'derive their ancestry primarily from populations of the Middle East and Europe', share 'considerable shared ancestry with other Jewish populations', with 'no indication of a significant genetic contribution either from within or from north of the Caucasus region'. A reply to Elhaik 2012 by authors whose data he reanalysed.
primary documentBehar et al., 'The genome-wide structure of the Jewish people', Nature 466 (2010) finding โ
Abstract read via Europe PMC: traces 'the origins of most Jewish Diaspora communities to the Levant'; most Jewish samples cluster with Druze and Cypriots 'but not samples from other Levantine populations'.
advocacy / view'It's not your homeland': an interview with Shlomo Sand (Lewis Turner, Review 31) incident โ
Undated interview, given after The Invention of the Land of Israel (the follow-up book) was published by Verso. Sand: the Jewish People book 'was a bestseller for ten weeks' and was attacked by a Haifa University historian; Simon Schama criticised him in the Financial Times. 'I am not against the existence of the Israeli state, in the 1967 borders, but Tel Aviv is for me a homeland without historical justification'; he wants a Palestinian state beside Israel and 'the state of all its citizens'. Sand's own view.
How to talk about this.
Acknowledge first: a religious promise can't settle a modern political dispute, and states founded on scripture raise real problems for minorities. Ask one question: 'is Israel's claim really only religious, and would the same test apply to states that call themselves Islamic?' Share one checkable thing: Israel's Declaration of Independence promises 'complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex'. If someone says 'read Shlomo Sand': grant that he is a real Israeli historian with a real thesis, then share his own line that he is 'not against the existence of the Israeli state, in the 1967 borders'. What not to say: 'Jews aren't a people, just a religion', which tells Jews what they are. From the other side: grant the religious claims some Israelis do make, then ask what place they should have in a state that also has Muslim, Christian and Druze citizens.
primary documentDeclaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel (1948) โ
Includes 'complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex'. Re-read 2026-10-12: the signatories assembled 'on the day of the termination of the British Mandate over Eretz-Israel'. Operative sentence (Avalon, re-read 2026-10-12): 'by virtue of our natural and historic right and on the strength of the resolution of the United Nations General Assembly, hereby declare the establishment of a Jewish state in Eretz-Israel'.
advocacy / view'It's not your homeland': an interview with Shlomo Sand (Lewis Turner, Review 31) incident โ
Undated interview, given after The Invention of the Land of Israel (the follow-up book) was published by Verso. Sand: the Jewish People book 'was a bestseller for ten weeks' and was attacked by a Haifa University historian; Simon Schama criticised him in the Financial Times. 'I am not against the existence of the Israeli state, in the 1967 borders, but Tel Aviv is for me a homeland without historical justification'; he wants a Palestinian state beside Israel and 'the state of all its citizens'. Sand's own view.
Where it leads if pressed
Working it out: is Israel's claim religious, and is the test applied to anyone else?
The claim rests on a premise and a standard, and each can be checked. The premise, that Israel's claim is religious: early Zionism had 'four major streamsโreligious, political, cultural, and labor-socialist. All except the first constitute the different types of secular Zionism'; much of the organised Orthodox world opposed it, founding Agudat Israel in 1912 as its 'first organized response to Zionism'; and Jews are a people one can join, not only a faith ('your people shall be my people'). Whether that peoplehood includes descent is argued in genetics too: Behar and colleagues (2010) trace 'the origins of most Jewish Diaspora communities to the Levant', while the historian Shlomo Sand argues that most modern Jews descend from converts and a 2012 paper by Eran Elhaik supported a Khazar origin for European Jews, a minority reading among geneticists (see 'Only a small share of ancient Jews ever left; Palestinians are the real descendants of the ancient inhabitants, and today's Jews are mostly Europeans.'). So the movement that built the state argued mainly from peoplehood and safety, not scripture, though religious Zionists today read the state as 'part of an unfolding divine plan'. The religious law Israel does apply is largely inherited: personal status by religious courts goes back to the Ottoman millets and the Mandate's 1922 order, and Israel runs Sharia courts for Muslims too. The standard: Pakistan was founded in 1947 as a homeland for India's Muslims, argued as nationhood ('Mussalmans are a nation'); Egypt's constitution says 'Islam is the religion of the state' and Sharia 'the principle source of legislation'; Jordan's gives Sharia courts personal-status jurisdiction. The worst case for each side. For 'a religion doesn't justify a country': grant the religious-Zionist reading at its strongest; it is one current in a mostly secular movement, whose founding declaration promised equal rights 'irrespective of religion, race or sex', and the same standard would reach Pakistan and constitutions that name a state religion. For 'Israel has no religious problem': grant the secular founding; there is still no civil marriage for Jews in Israel, rabbinical courts hold that jurisdiction by law, and religious Zionists are prominent among settlers. Holds on the evidence here: Zionism was mostly secular and argued from peoplehood; Israel applies religious personal-status law inherited from Ottoman and Mandate rule, for all communities. Arguable, as a domestic argument many Israelis make: separating religious law from citizenship. Not supported: that Israel's existence rests only on a religious claim, or that the standard is applied to other states that name a religion.
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable โฆ) mean
referenceMy Jewish Learning, 'Secular Zionism' โ
Read 2026-10-02 (Jewish educational site). 'Early Zionism was divided into four major streamsโreligious, political, cultural, and labor-socialist. All except the first constitute the different types of secular Zionism'; 'Hovevei Zion joined together secular and religious Jews'; 'Theodor Herzl, an assimilated Jew who lived in Vienna โฆ showed little interest in Jewish subjects until the early 1890s'.
pressBenjamin Beit-Hallahmi, 'Israel's Ultra-Orthodox', Middle East Report (MERIP), 1 November 1992 (1992) finding โ
Read 2026-10-01. 'The ultra-Orthodox have not accepted the Zionist definition of the Jews as a nation in search of a homeland'; 'In May 1912, some 200 Orthodox leaders from Germany and Eastern Europe met in Kattowitz (Katowice) to start Orthodoxy's first organized response to Zionism, Agudat Israel'; 'Since 1948, the party has been pragmatically involved in state institutions. It supports governing coalitions and is rewarded with ample budgets for its Orthodox schooling system. Agudat Israel accepts the state of Israel de facto'; Orthodox Zionists: 'the state is part of an unfolding divine plan โฆ That explains their prominence among West Bank settlers'. Other half in the same article: 'The leadership of the state is totally secular'; Orthodox parties 'have always been excluded from discussions about peace, war or the economy' (as of 1992).
law / courtThe Palestine Order in Council (Palestine Constitution), 10 August 1922, arts. 51โ54 โ text on PalQuest (1922) โ
Read 1 Oct 2026. Art. 51: 'jurisdiction In matters of personal status shall be exercised โฆ by the Courts of the religious communities established and exercising jurisdiction at the date of this Order' (personal status: marriage or divorce, alimony, maintenance, guardianship, legitimation and adoption of minors, successions, wills and legacies โฆ). Art. 52: 'Moslem Religious Courts shall have exclusive jurisdiction in matters of personal status of Moslems'. Art. 53: the Rabbinical Courts have 'Exclusive jurisdiction in matters of marriage and divorce, alimony and confirmation of wills', other personal-status matters only where all parties consent. Art. 54: the same for 'the several Christian communities'.
law / courtIsrael's religious-court laws for Muslims and Druze: Qadis Law, 5721-1961; Sharia Courts (Validation of Appointments) Law, 5714-1953; Druze Religious Courts Law, 5723-1962 (1961) โ
Knesset open-data records (read 2026-09-30): 'ืืืง ืืงืืืื, ืืชืฉื"ื-1961' (IsraelLawID 2000514; 4th Knesset; published 31 May 1961; status 'ืชืงืฃ', in force); 'ืืืง ืืชื ืืื ืืฉืจืขืืื (ืืืฉืืจ ืืื ืืืื), ืืชืฉื"ื-1953' (IsraelLawID 2000133; 2nd Knesset; published 17 December 1953; status 'ื ืืฉื', spent); 'ืืืง ืืชื ืืืื ืืืชืืื ืืืจืืืืื, ืืชืฉื"ื-1962' (IsraelLawID 2000136; 5th Knesset; published 3 January 1963; in force). The records confirm the laws and their titles; the texts themselves are not read here.
primary documentLahore Resolution (All-India Muslim League, March 1940) and Jinnah's Lahore address, as quoted in Dawn, 'The Resolution: Pakistan's constitutional blueprint' (supplement) (1940) โ
Read 1 Oct 2026. Resolution: 'that geographically contiguous units are demarcated into regions which should be constituted, with such territorial readjustments as may be necessary that the areas in which the Muslims are numerically in a majority as in the North Western and Eastern Zones of India should be grouped to constitute "independent states" in which the constituent units should be autonomous and sovereign.' Jinnah: 'Mussalmans are not a minority as it is commonly known and understoodโฆ. Mussalmans are a nation according to any definition of a nation, and they must have their homelands, their territory, and their state.' The supplement's own view: 'a precise demand for self-determination and not a cry for separatism'. Columbia's copies (Pritchett) walled. Pakistani newspaper.
law / courtConstitution of the Arab Republic of Egypt (2014, as amended 2019), Articles 2โ3 (2014) โ
Read 2026-09-30 (Constitute Project English translation). Art. 2: 'Islam is the religion of the state and Arabic is its official language. The principles of Islamic Sharia are the principle source of legislation.' Art. 3: 'The principles of the laws of Egyptian Christians and Jews are the main source of laws regulating their personal status, religious affairs, and selection of spiritual leaders.'
primary documentConstitution of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan (1952, rev. 2011), English translation via the Constitute Project โ
Read 2026-10-02. Art. 105: 'The Sharia Courts alone shall have the jurisdiction - in accordance with their own laws - in the following matters: Matters of personal status of Moslems', and blood money and waqfs; Art. 108: 'The Tribunals of Religious Communities are the tribunals of the non-Moslem religious communities that have been or will be recognised by the Government'; Art. 109: they apply the provisions on personal status 'which are not considered matters of personal status of Moslems'.
law / courtRabbinical Courts Jurisdiction (Marriage and Divorce) Law, 5713-1953 (Israel) (1953) โ
Knesset open-data record (IsraelLawID 2001233, read 2026-09-30): 'ืืืง ืฉืืคืื ืืชื ืืื ืจืื ืืื (ื ืืฉืืืื ืืืืจืืฉืื), ืืชืฉื"ื-1953', 2nd Knesset, published 4 September 1953, status 'ืชืงืฃ' (in force). The record confirms the law and its title, which gives rabbinical courts jurisdiction over marriage and divorce; the law's text itself is not read here.
primary documentBehar et al., 'The genome-wide structure of the Jewish people', Nature 466 (2010) finding โ
Abstract read via Europe PMC: traces 'the origins of most Jewish Diaspora communities to the Levant'; most Jewish samples cluster with Druze and Cypriots 'but not samples from other Levantine populations'.
advocacy / viewShlomo Sand, The Invention of the Jewish People (Verso, English edition; Hebrew original 2008) โ publisher's page (2008) finding โ
Publisher's description read: 'Exploding the myth that there was a forced Jewish exile in the first century at the hands of the Romans, Israeli historian Shlomo Sand argues that most modern Jews descend from converts, whose native lands were scattered across the Middle East and Eastern Europe.' The author's thesis (a critic of Zionism), described by his publisher; not a neutral summary.
primary documentEran Elhaik, 'The Missing Link of Jewish European Ancestry: Contrasting the Rhineland and the Khazarian Hypotheses', Genome Biology and Evolution 5(1) (2012) finding โ
Abstract read on PMC: 'Our findings support the Khazarian hypothesis and portray the European Jewish genome as a mosaic of Near Eastern-Caucasus, European, and Semitic ancestries.' The journal ran a commentary alongside it; the minority reading among the genome studies, rebutted by Behar et al. 2013.
primary documentDeclaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel (1948) โ
Includes 'complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex'. Re-read 2026-10-12: the signatories assembled 'on the day of the termination of the British Mandate over Eretz-Israel'. Operative sentence (Avalon, re-read 2026-10-12): 'by virtue of our natural and historic right and on the strength of the resolution of the United Nations General Assembly, hereby declare the establishment of a Jewish state in Eretz-Israel'.
Either a general secularism argument โ or a rule for Jews only.
Applied consistently, the argument becomes a case for secular states everywhere, which one can make and which some Israelis make about their own country. Applied only to Israel, it denies Jewish peoplehood itself โ telling Jews what they are, which is its own problem. The productive version is the domestic one: civil marriage, equal treatment, separating religious law from citizenship.
The usual reply โ and its own traps
Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.
heard from pro-Israel voicesโThere's no such thing as a Palestinian people โ it was invented in 1964.โ heard from pro-Palestinian voicesโIsrael is an ethnostate.โ