Argument · heard from pro-Israel voices
“The Arab world loves Palestine in words and abandons Palestinians in deeds.”
Palestinians are refused everywhere in the Arab world. Gaza's most closed border is the one with Egypt; Lebanon won't let them work; Kuwait threw them out. The Arab states keep them stateless as a weapon against Israel — they care about the cause, not the people.
Made publicly as a pro-Israel argument by Richard Goldberg
Where it's been said
“Jordan has withdrawn its nationality from thousands of its citizens of Palestinian origin-over 2,700 between 2004 and 2008 alone”
“The hypocrisy of Arab governments who criticize Israel and empower Hamas is on full display for the world to see. Why is it that Israel cares more about saving Palestinian lives than the entire Arab world?”
Traps in play:◆ The exception as proof◆ "What about you?"
Why people find it convincing
- In August 1959 nine Arab states rejected UN Secretary-General Hammarskjöld's plan to spend $1.5–2 billion over five years creating jobs for about a million refugees in Arab lands, insisting on return instead (NYT, 19 August 1959).
- Lebanon still bars Palestinians from many professions and, since 2001, from owning property; generations born there remain stateless ('hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are stateless and over half live in overcrowded camps', Human Rights Watch, c. 2000).
- Kuwait expelled or refused re-entry to most of its large Palestinian community after the PLO sided with Saddam Hussein in 1990–91.
- Syria's government besieged the Yarmouk refugee camp from 2013, with deaths from starvation.
- Egypt kept the Rafah crossing largely closed for years, and in 2023–25 refused to let Gazans flee into Sinai.
What's true
Arab states kept the refugees as a cause while restricting them as people.
The 1959 rejection of Hammarskjöld's integration plan is on the record, in the refugees' name: the states would 'unanimously support the refugees' demand to return' instead (NYT, 19 August 1959). Lebanon's legal restrictions (a 2001 law barring 'any person who is not a national of a recognized state' from acquiring property, and bars on over 20 professions), After Kuwait's liberation in 1991, 'Stateless Bedoons and Palestinians have been expelled without any provision being made for their acceptance by another country', Palestinian children 'were barred from enrolling in public schools', and of the 'around 180,000 Palestinians' who had left during the occupation, 'with very few exceptions, Kuwait has refused to allow any of them to return'; the government's stated pretext was 'a government-inspired quest to root out those who had collaborated with the Iraqi occupiers' (Human Rights Watch, World Report 1992). In Syria, the Yarmouk camp's 18,000 Palestinian refugees and Syrians endured 'more than two years of a merciless siege', by 2015 caught between 'members of ISIL and other extremist groups inside the camp and Government forces outside', a camp the UN Secretary-General called 'the deepest circle of hell' (UN News, April 2015). In October 2023 Egypt rejected safe corridors for civilians leaving Gaza, to protect, in an Egyptian security source's words, 'the right of Palestinians to hold on to their cause and their land' (Al Jazeera, citing Reuters); Israel's ambassador in Cairo said Israel had 'no intentions in relation to Sinai'. In 2022, by UNRWA's figures as reported by Al Jazeera, the United States, Germany, the EU and Sweden were the largest donors, together 61.4% of its funding, and EU member states gave 44.3% of pledges; no Arab state was among those four. By UNRWA's own donor tables, Arab states other than the host states pledged 4.2% of its funding in 2022, 2.5% in 2023, 11.4% in 2024 and 1.8% in 2025 (this page's arithmetic; see 'Reading the numbers'). The pattern had exceptions: when the US stopped funding UNRWA in 2018, its own statement named 'Jordan, Egypt, Sweden, Qatar, and the UAE' among the countries that had 'shown leadership' in covering the gap. The gap between rhetoric and treatment is real.
newspaper'Arab States Bar Refugee Aid Plan' by Richard P. Hunt (1959) incident ✓
Scan from the kvetch-of-the-day news archive.
NYT 1959-08-19, Beirut; vision-verified. Nine Arab states reject Hammarskjöld's $1.5–2bn five-year jobs plan for ~1,000,000 refugees.
law / courtLebanon, Law 296 (2001) amending the foreign property ownership law (2001) ✓
As reported by IRIN (24 December 2013; UNISPAL copy, read): the law prohibits 'any person who is not a national of a recognized state… acquiring real estate property of any kind', which bars Palestinians from buying or selling their homes; Palestinians are also 'legally prevented from working in over 20 professions'. The law text itself not yet read.
dataUNRWA, pledges and contributions by donor (annual tables) ✓
UNRWA's funding-trends page. The donor tables themselves, 2022–2025, were read on 14 October 2026 from copies the editor supplied; their figures are on the card 'unrwa-donor-tables-2022-2025'.
primary documentUS State Department, press statement 'On U.S. Assistance to UNRWA' (Heather Nauert, 31 August 2018), UNISPAL copy (2018) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28). 'the fundamental business model and fiscal practices that have marked UNRWA for years – tied to UNRWA's endlessly and exponentially expanding community of entitled beneficiaries – is simply unsustainable'; 'this irredeemably flawed operation'; 'deeply concerned regarding the impact upon innocent Palestinians, especially school children'; US gave $60 million in January 2018; 'Jordan, Egypt, Sweden, Qatar, and the UAE have shown leadership' on funding.
pressAl Jazeera, 'Which countries have cut funding to UNRWA, and why?' (28 January 2024, updated 31 January) (2024) aggregate ✓
Read 2026-10-01. Citing UNRWA: states and the EU 'represented 94.9 percent of all contributions in 2022'; 'In 2022, 44.3 percent of the agency's total pledges, or $1.17bn, came from the EU member states'; 'The United States, Germany, the EU and Sweden were the largest individual donors … contributing 61.4 percent of the agency's overall funding in total'. No per-country figures for Arab states.
pressHuman Rights Watch (Middle East Watch), World Report 1992, 'Kuwait' (1992) finding ✓
Read 2026-10-01. The reinstated government 'disregarded those standards as soon as it returned from exile on February 26, 1991. The pretext for these abuses was a government-inspired quest to root out those who had collaborated with the Iraqi occupiers'; 'Between May and August, as the trials of suspected collaborators inflamed anti-Palestinian and anti-Bedoon hostility, large-scale arrests and forced deportations became the predominant abuse'; 'Stateless Bedoons and Palestinians have been expelled without any provision being made for their acceptance by another country'; 'Between March and August, more than 1,500 residents of Kuwait were deported, including Bedoons, Iraqis and Palestinians'; 'During the Iraqi occupation of Kuwait, around 180,000 Palestinians left Kuwait … After liberation, with very few exceptions, Kuwait has refused to allow any of them' back; Palestinian and Bedoon children 'barred from enrolling in public schools after liberation'. Also: conditions 'gradually improved as the year progressed'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Like Palestinian children, Bedoon children were barred from enrolling in public schools after liberation'; 'around 180,000 Palestinians left Kuwait to avoid the hardships of occupation and war … After liberation, with very few exceptions, Kuwait has refused to allow any of them to return.'
pressUN News, 'UN chief urges "concerted action to save lives, restore measure of humanity" in besieged Yarmouk camp' (April 2015) (2015) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-01. Ban Ki-moon on 'the 18,000 Palestinian refugees and Syrians being held hostage by extremist militants in Yarmouk camp': 'In the horror that is Syria, the Yarmouk refugee camp is the deepest circle of hell … A refugee camp is beginning to resemble a death camp. The residents of Yarmouk – including 3,500 children – are being turned into human shields.' 'After more than two years of a merciless siege, residents now faced a "double-edged sword", with members of ISIL and other extremist groups inside the camp and Government forces outside.' UNRWA ran a health point there 'when staff and supplies are allowed into the area'.
pressAl Jazeera, 'Egypt says Israel seeks to empty Gaza, rejects corridors for civilians' (12 October 2023) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. Egypt 'rejects any move to set up safe corridors for refugees fleeing the enclave, according to Egyptian security sources'; one told Reuters it was to protect 'the right of Palestinians to hold on to their cause and their land'; the Rafah crossing 'closed since Tuesday after Israeli bombardments hit on the Palestinian side'; Egypt warned against displacement 'onto Egyptian territory'. Other half: Israel's ambassador Amira Oron, Israel had 'no intentions in relation to Sinai, and has not asked Palestinians to move there'.
dataUNRWA, pledges by all donors: '2022 Pledges towards UNRWA's Programmes', '2023 Confirmed Pledges', '2024 Confirmed pledges and received (cash and in-kind)', '2025 Confirmed pledges and received (cash and in-kind)', each as of 31 December (2025) aggregate ✓
Read 2026-10-14 (PDFs supplied by the editor). Totals pledged: 2022 $1,174,647,272; 2023 $1,463,868,250; 2024 $1,399,670,708 (received $1,297,077,144); 2025 $887,176,894 (received $839,732,065). United States: 2022 $343,937,718; 2023 $422,004,945; 2024 $70,597,571; 2025 not listed. Arab states as listed (grand totals pledged): 2022 Saudi Arabia 27,000,000; Kuwait (incl. Kuwait Fund) 12,000,000; Qatar 10,500,000; Oman 316,422; Bahrain 50,000. 2023 Saudi Arabia 2,000,000 and King Salman Humanitarian Aid and Relief Centre 15,000,000; Qatar 9,000,000; Oman 3,266,422; Bahrain 3,050,000; Djibouti 2,094,747; Kuwait 2,000,000. 2024 Qatar (incl. Qatar Charity and Qatar Red Crescent) 50,664,265; Saudi Arabia (incl. King Salman Centre) 42,279,765; Kuwait 27,000,000; Iraq 25,000,000; Algeria 15,000,000; Oman 216,421. 2025 Qatar 10,000,000; Saudi Arabia (incl. King Salman Centre) 2,396,398; Kuwait 2,000,000; Oman 1,216,421. Host states, mainly in-kind: Jordan (2022 4,241,081; 2023 7,876,424; 2024 8,626,299; 2025 11,671,380), Lebanon (818,204; 1,128,280; 1,140,002; 1,126,019), Syria (448,072; 437,665; 410,150; 2,366,043), Palestine (5,760,830; 2,751,649; 130,018; 166,891 + 20,000). No row for Egypt or the UAE in any of the four years.
What's left out
The stated reason, the exceptions, and a great deal of state aid.
Arab governments have rejected resettlement on principle: in October 1959 ten Arab states, answering a UN Secretary-General's report whose economic part they said 'prescribes a basis for resettlement', affirmed 'their rejection of every project which might, even indirectly, aim at the settlement of refugees outside their country, and their demand to return to their homes' (as recorded in the UN Conciliation Commission's historical survey). It is a political reason they give, the right of return, not simple indifference by their own account; among the refugees themselves, PSR's 2003 surveys in the West Bank, Gaza, Jordan and Lebanon reported 'more than 95%' insisting on the right of return as 'a sacred right', yet, offered a negotiated menu, only 10% chose return to Israel as their first option and 13% refused all options (PSR, 2003). Jordan gave most Palestinians full citizenship, and Syria, while keeping them stateless, 'afforded them the same economic and social rights enjoyed by Syrian citizens' (Human Rights Watch, c. 2000). Egypt's stated reason is the cause itself (above). Arab states also gave aid: Jordan has run a field hospital in Gaza since 2009 and, in November 2023, airdropped 'urgent medical aid' to it, an airdrop Jordan and Israel announced together (Al Jazeera); in 2024 the United States, Jordan, the UAE and Egypt carried out airdrops, which aid agencies criticised as 'a costly and ineffective way' of delivering food (Al Jazeera). In October 2023 aid planes from Turkey, the UAE, Qatar, Jordan and Tunisia landed at El Arish for Gaza, and the Egyptian Red Crescent coordinated the transfer from the Egyptian side of Rafah, while trucks waited 'for Israeli approval to drive into Gaza' (Al Jazeera). Saudi Arabia's aid is not yet sourced on this page ⚠. None of this cancels the hypocrisy point. It shows that political reasons were given, and that there was more than indifference.
Traps here:◆ The exception as proof
advocacy / viewHuman Rights Watch, 'Treatment and Rights in Arab Host States' (right-of-return campaign briefing, undated, c. 2000) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29); undated, latest year cited 1999. 'In Jordan … most of the 1.5 million Palestinians have citizenship and are well integrated'; 'Syria has maintained the stateless status of its Palestinians but has afforded them the same economic and social rights enjoyed by Syrian citizens'; 'In Lebanon, in sharp contrast, hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are stateless and over half live in overcrowded camps.'
pressAl Jazeera, 'Egypt says Israel seeks to empty Gaza, rejects corridors for civilians' (12 October 2023) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. Egypt 'rejects any move to set up safe corridors for refugees fleeing the enclave, according to Egyptian security sources'; one told Reuters it was to protect 'the right of Palestinians to hold on to their cause and their land'; the Rafah crossing 'closed since Tuesday after Israeli bombardments hit on the Palestinian side'; Egypt warned against displacement 'onto Egyptian territory'. Other half: Israel's ambassador Amira Oron, Israel had 'no intentions in relation to Sinai, and has not asked Palestinians to move there'.
primary documentUN Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 'Historical Survey of Efforts of UNCCP to secure implementation of para 11 of General Assembly resolution 194 (III)', working paper (revised), UNISPAL incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. Paras. 101–102: 'On 6 October 1959, the Arab States of Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Libya, Morocco, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Tunisia, the United Arab Republic and Yemen transmitted a report adopted unanimously' on the Secretary-General's proposals; point (11): 'The economic part of the report should not be taken into account because it prescribes a basis for resettlement'; point (12): 'their rejection of every project which might, even indirectly, aim at the settlement of refugees outside their country, and their demand to return to their homes'. Para. 97: the Secretary-General's report 'would involve integration of refugees into the productive life of Israel as well as of the Arab countries in accordance with the choice of the refugees themselves'.
pressAl Jazeera, 'Jordan, Israel announce airdrop of urgent medical aid to Gaza hospital' (6 November 2023) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. 'Jordan and Israel have announced the airdrop of urgent medical supplies to a field hospital in the Gaza Strip'; King Abdullah II: the air force 'had dropped "urgent medical aid" to the field hospital operated by the kingdom in the enclave since 2009'.
pressAl Jazeera, 'Aid airdrop kills five people in Gaza after parachute fails' (8 March 2024) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. 'a number of countries – including the United States, Jordan, the United Arab Emirates and Egypt – have conducted airdrops, which have been criticised by aid agencies as a costly and ineffective way of delivering food and medical supplies'; Gaza's government media office called them 'flashy propaganda'; US Central Command denied the fatal drop was American.
pressAl Jazeera, 'Israel-Hamas war: Which countries have sent aid to Gaza so far?' (23 October 2023) pattern ✓
Read 2026-10-02. 'At least eight planes carrying aid from Turkey, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Jordan and Tunisia have landed at El Arish International Airport'; 'The Egyptian Red Crescent is coordinating the transfer of aid from the Egyptian side of the Rafah border crossing to Gaza' (caption); 'More than 200 trucks … waiting for Israeli approval to drive into Gaza'; UNICEF: 'at least 100, 200 trucks going in per day' needed; Israel said it 'will not prevent humanitarian aid from entering Gaza through Egypt'.
dataPSR, 'Results of PSR Refugees' Polls in the West Bank/Gaza Strip, Jordan and Lebanon on Refugees' Preferences and Behavior in a Palestinian-Israeli Permanent Refugee Agreement' (January–June 2003) (2003) aggregate ✓
Read in full: 4,506 interviews, margin of error 3%; first choices under a Taba-style five-option menu; 10% return to Israel overall; 13% refuse all; most who would return to Israel refuse Israeli citizenship. Re-read 2026-10-02: the page opens 'Based on several previous surveys showing that the overwhelming majority of the refugees (more than 95%) insist on maintaining the "right of return" as a sacred right that can never be given up'. Re-read 2026-10-12, exact wording: 'The overwhelming majority of the refugees wishing to exercise the right of return in Israel refuse to become Israeli citizenship and prefer to stay refugees or select other options if carrying Israeli citizenship is mandatory.'
More context
Reading the numbers
'Abandons in deeds' is a claim about proportion: how much Arab states give and do, compared with what they say and with what others do. The figures on this page answer part of it and leave a gap. (1) Money through UNRWA, from the agency's own donor tables (pledges as of 31 December each year): Arab states other than the host states pledged $49.9 million of $1,174.6 million in 2022 (4.2%), $36.4 million of $1,463.9 million in 2023 (2.5%), $160.2 million of $1,399.7 million in 2024 (11.4%) and $15.6 million of $887.2 million in 2025 (1.8%) (this page's arithmetic, counting Saudi Arabia with the King Salman centre, Qatar, Kuwait, Oman, Bahrain, Djibouti, Algeria and Iraq as each year lists them; the host states, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria and Palestine, appear with in-kind contributions, a different kind of support). For scale, the United States pledged $343.9 million (29.3%) in 2022 and $422.0 million (28.8%) in 2023, then $70.6 million (5.0%) in 2024, and none is listed for 2025. So the Arab share is small in most years, but in 2024, as the American figure fell, Arab states pledged more than twice as much as the United States ($160.2 million against $70.6 million). An earlier version of this note put UNRWA's 2022 total at about $2.6 billion, from an Al Jazeera sentence that reads as if $1.17 billion were the EU members' share; UNRWA's own table gives $1.17 billion as the year's total. Nor is UNRWA the only channel (Jordan's field hospital in Gaza has run since 2009, and Turkish, Emirati, Qatari, Jordanian and Tunisian aid flights landed at El Arish in October 2023). (2) Treatment, which differs by state: in Jordan, by Human Rights Watch's account, 'most of the 1.5 million Palestinians have citizenship and are well integrated'; in Lebanon, Palestinians are barred from owning property and from over 20 professions, and 'around 93 percent' of refugees live in poverty (HRW, 2026); after 1991 Kuwait expelled Palestinians and, of about 180,000 who had left, let very few return. 'The Arab world' averages over all three. The worst case for each side. For 'they abandon them': take the gaps at their worst; Jordan still gave most of its 1.5 million Palestinians citizenship, Arab states flew in aid and Jordan, the UAE and Egypt airdropped food in 2024 (criticised by aid agencies as 'costly and ineffective'), and when Egypt and Jordan refused to take refugees from Gaza in October 2023, King Abdullah calling it 'a red line', Egyptian sources gave the reason as protecting 'the right of Palestinians to hold on to their cause and their land' — refusal framed as refusing a second displacement, which an FDD analyst answered with 'Why is it that Israel cares more about saving Palestinian lives than the entire Arab world?' For 'Arab states support them': take the aid at its best; the largest UNRWA funding still comes from Western donors, Lebanon bars Palestinians from property and professions, Kuwait expelled them after 1991, Syria and Lebanon kept their Palestinians stateless (HRW) in line with the 1959 rejection of 'every project' of resettlement, and in Syria's war the UN Secretary-General called the besieged Yarmouk camp, with 18,000 Palestinian refugees and Syrians, 'the deepest circle of hell' (2015). Holds on every reading: Western donors fund most of UNRWA; treatment of Palestinians varies sharply between Arab states, from citizenship to legal exclusion. Open, needs donor data not read here: how far Arab states' giving falls short of their rhetoric. Not supported by any reading: that 'the Arab world' as a whole abandoned Palestinians, or that it stood by them (see 'Reading war numbers' and '"They all…"').
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean
pressAl Jazeera, 'Which countries have cut funding to UNRWA, and why?' (28 January 2024, updated 31 January) (2024) aggregate ✓
Read 2026-10-01. Citing UNRWA: states and the EU 'represented 94.9 percent of all contributions in 2022'; 'In 2022, 44.3 percent of the agency's total pledges, or $1.17bn, came from the EU member states'; 'The United States, Germany, the EU and Sweden were the largest individual donors … contributing 61.4 percent of the agency's overall funding in total'. No per-country figures for Arab states.
dataUNRWA, pledges and contributions by donor (annual tables) ✓
UNRWA's funding-trends page. The donor tables themselves, 2022–2025, were read on 14 October 2026 from copies the editor supplied; their figures are on the card 'unrwa-donor-tables-2022-2025'.
pressAl Jazeera, 'Jordan, Israel announce airdrop of urgent medical aid to Gaza hospital' (6 November 2023) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. 'Jordan and Israel have announced the airdrop of urgent medical supplies to a field hospital in the Gaza Strip'; King Abdullah II: the air force 'had dropped "urgent medical aid" to the field hospital operated by the kingdom in the enclave since 2009'.
pressAl Jazeera, 'Israel-Hamas war: Which countries have sent aid to Gaza so far?' (23 October 2023) pattern ✓
Read 2026-10-02. 'At least eight planes carrying aid from Turkey, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Jordan and Tunisia have landed at El Arish International Airport'; 'The Egyptian Red Crescent is coordinating the transfer of aid from the Egyptian side of the Rafah border crossing to Gaza' (caption); 'More than 200 trucks … waiting for Israeli approval to drive into Gaza'; UNICEF: 'at least 100, 200 trucks going in per day' needed; Israel said it 'will not prevent humanitarian aid from entering Gaza through Egypt'.
advocacy / viewHuman Rights Watch, 'Treatment and Rights in Arab Host States' (right-of-return campaign briefing, undated, c. 2000) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29); undated, latest year cited 1999. 'In Jordan … most of the 1.5 million Palestinians have citizenship and are well integrated'; 'Syria has maintained the stateless status of its Palestinians but has afforded them the same economic and social rights enjoyed by Syrian citizens'; 'In Lebanon, in sharp contrast, hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are stateless and over half live in overcrowded camps.'
law / courtLebanon, Law 296 (2001) amending the foreign property ownership law (2001) ✓
As reported by IRIN (24 December 2013; UNISPAL copy, read): the law prohibits 'any person who is not a national of a recognized state… acquiring real estate property of any kind', which bars Palestinians from buying or selling their homes; Palestinians are also 'legally prevented from working in over 20 professions'. The law text itself not yet read.
pressHuman Rights Watch, World Report 2026: Lebanon (2026) aggregate ✓
Read 2026-09-30. 'Around 93 percent of Palestinian refugees in Lebanon live in poverty, according to UNICEF, and continue to face restrictions on their right to work and own property.' (The 2025 chapter: 'nearly 520,000 Palestinian refugees … living in Lebanon'.)
pressHuman Rights Watch (Middle East Watch), World Report 1992, 'Kuwait' (1992) finding ✓
Read 2026-10-01. The reinstated government 'disregarded those standards as soon as it returned from exile on February 26, 1991. The pretext for these abuses was a government-inspired quest to root out those who had collaborated with the Iraqi occupiers'; 'Between May and August, as the trials of suspected collaborators inflamed anti-Palestinian and anti-Bedoon hostility, large-scale arrests and forced deportations became the predominant abuse'; 'Stateless Bedoons and Palestinians have been expelled without any provision being made for their acceptance by another country'; 'Between March and August, more than 1,500 residents of Kuwait were deported, including Bedoons, Iraqis and Palestinians'; 'During the Iraqi occupation of Kuwait, around 180,000 Palestinians left Kuwait … After liberation, with very few exceptions, Kuwait has refused to allow any of them' back; Palestinian and Bedoon children 'barred from enrolling in public schools after liberation'. Also: conditions 'gradually improved as the year progressed'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Like Palestinian children, Bedoon children were barred from enrolling in public schools after liberation'; 'around 180,000 Palestinians left Kuwait to avoid the hardships of occupation and war … After liberation, with very few exceptions, Kuwait has refused to allow any of them to return.'
primary documentUN Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 'Historical Survey of Efforts of UNCCP to secure implementation of para 11 of General Assembly resolution 194 (III)', working paper (revised), UNISPAL incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. Paras. 101–102: 'On 6 October 1959, the Arab States of Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Libya, Morocco, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Tunisia, the United Arab Republic and Yemen transmitted a report adopted unanimously' on the Secretary-General's proposals; point (11): 'The economic part of the report should not be taken into account because it prescribes a basis for resettlement'; point (12): 'their rejection of every project which might, even indirectly, aim at the settlement of refugees outside their country, and their demand to return to their homes'. Para. 97: the Secretary-General's report 'would involve integration of refugees into the productive life of Israel as well as of the Arab countries in accordance with the choice of the refugees themselves'.
advocacy / viewFoundation for Defense of Democracies, Flash Brief 'Egypt, Jordan, and Other Arab Governments Reject Gazan Refugees' (17 October 2023) (2023) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28). King Abdullah (17 Oct 2023): no refugees from Gaza in Jordan or Egypt, 'That is a red line'; Turkey and Qatar 'refusing to take refugees even as both countries express support for the Palestinians'. Jonathan Schanzer: Egypt 'does not want to alter facts on the ground that might weaken Palestinian claims on the territory'. Richard Goldberg: 'Why is it that Israel cares more about saving Palestinian lives than the entire Arab world?'
pressAl Jazeera, 'Egypt says Israel seeks to empty Gaza, rejects corridors for civilians' (12 October 2023) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. Egypt 'rejects any move to set up safe corridors for refugees fleeing the enclave, according to Egyptian security sources'; one told Reuters it was to protect 'the right of Palestinians to hold on to their cause and their land'; the Rafah crossing 'closed since Tuesday after Israeli bombardments hit on the Palestinian side'; Egypt warned against displacement 'onto Egyptian territory'. Other half: Israel's ambassador Amira Oron, Israel had 'no intentions in relation to Sinai, and has not asked Palestinians to move there'.
pressAl Jazeera, 'Aid airdrop kills five people in Gaza after parachute fails' (8 March 2024) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. 'a number of countries – including the United States, Jordan, the United Arab Emirates and Egypt – have conducted airdrops, which have been criticised by aid agencies as a costly and ineffective way of delivering food and medical supplies'; Gaza's government media office called them 'flashy propaganda'; US Central Command denied the fatal drop was American.
pressUN News, 'UN chief urges "concerted action to save lives, restore measure of humanity" in besieged Yarmouk camp' (April 2015) (2015) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-01. Ban Ki-moon on 'the 18,000 Palestinian refugees and Syrians being held hostage by extremist militants in Yarmouk camp': 'In the horror that is Syria, the Yarmouk refugee camp is the deepest circle of hell … A refugee camp is beginning to resemble a death camp. The residents of Yarmouk – including 3,500 children – are being turned into human shields.' 'After more than two years of a merciless siege, residents now faced a "double-edged sword", with members of ISIL and other extremist groups inside the camp and Government forces outside.' UNRWA ran a health point there 'when staff and supplies are allowed into the area'.
dataUNRWA, pledges by all donors: '2022 Pledges towards UNRWA's Programmes', '2023 Confirmed Pledges', '2024 Confirmed pledges and received (cash and in-kind)', '2025 Confirmed pledges and received (cash and in-kind)', each as of 31 December (2025) aggregate ✓
Read 2026-10-14 (PDFs supplied by the editor). Totals pledged: 2022 $1,174,647,272; 2023 $1,463,868,250; 2024 $1,399,670,708 (received $1,297,077,144); 2025 $887,176,894 (received $839,732,065). United States: 2022 $343,937,718; 2023 $422,004,945; 2024 $70,597,571; 2025 not listed. Arab states as listed (grand totals pledged): 2022 Saudi Arabia 27,000,000; Kuwait (incl. Kuwait Fund) 12,000,000; Qatar 10,500,000; Oman 316,422; Bahrain 50,000. 2023 Saudi Arabia 2,000,000 and King Salman Humanitarian Aid and Relief Centre 15,000,000; Qatar 9,000,000; Oman 3,266,422; Bahrain 3,050,000; Djibouti 2,094,747; Kuwait 2,000,000. 2024 Qatar (incl. Qatar Charity and Qatar Red Crescent) 50,664,265; Saudi Arabia (incl. King Salman Centre) 42,279,765; Kuwait 27,000,000; Iraq 25,000,000; Algeria 15,000,000; Oman 216,421. 2025 Qatar 10,000,000; Saudi Arabia (incl. King Salman Centre) 2,396,398; Kuwait 2,000,000; Oman 1,216,421. Host states, mainly in-kind: Jordan (2022 4,241,081; 2023 7,876,424; 2024 8,626,299; 2025 11,671,380), Lebanon (818,204; 1,128,280; 1,140,002; 1,126,019), Syria (448,072; 437,665; 410,150; 2,366,043), Palestine (5,760,830; 2,751,649; 130,018; 166,891 + 20,000). No row for Egypt or the UAE in any of the four years.
How to talk about this.
Acknowledge first: the hypocrisy is real: Syria and Lebanon, unlike Jordan, kept the refugees stateless (HRW), and Lebanon restricts their property rights by law. Ask one question: 'does that change what Israelis and Palestinians owe each other?'; it's true and it doesn't settle anything between them. Share one checkable thing: the 1959 rejection of Hammarskjöld's refugee-integration plan by nine Arab states. What not to say: 'only Israel really cares about Palestinians', which picks the flattering facts. From the other side: grant Jordan's citizenship for Palestinians and the large state aid from Arab governments, then ask why the refugee question was kept open for seventy years.
advocacy / viewHuman Rights Watch, 'Treatment and Rights in Arab Host States' (right-of-return campaign briefing, undated, c. 2000) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-29); undated, latest year cited 1999. 'In Jordan … most of the 1.5 million Palestinians have citizenship and are well integrated'; 'Syria has maintained the stateless status of its Palestinians but has afforded them the same economic and social rights enjoyed by Syrian citizens'; 'In Lebanon, in sharp contrast, hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are stateless and over half live in overcrowded camps.'
law / courtLebanon, Law 296 (2001) amending the foreign property ownership law (2001) ✓
As reported by IRIN (24 December 2013; UNISPAL copy, read): the law prohibits 'any person who is not a national of a recognized state… acquiring real estate property of any kind', which bars Palestinians from buying or selling their homes; Palestinians are also 'legally prevented from working in over 20 professions'. The law text itself not yet read.
Where it leads if pressed
The hypocrisy is real, but it doesn't settle anything between Israelis and Palestinians.
'The Arab states treat them badly too' is true and worth knowing: it shows how the refugees became a political instrument, including for the states that speak loudest for them. Pushed further, it slides into two traps. One is tu quoque ('others are worse, so our part doesn't count'). The other is its ironic conclusion, 'in deeds only Israel really cares', which picks the flattering facts and drops the rest. The strong version needs neither. The refugee question was kept open from more than one side: Arab states refused resettlement (1959) to keep the claim to return alive, and Israel barred return before a peace (see 'The Palestinians left voluntarily in 1948 — their own leaders told them to go.'). Any real solution has to close it with the Arab states taking part.
Traps here:◆ "What about you?"
The usual reply — and its own traps
Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.
heard on both sides“UNRWA keeps millions of Palestinians as refugees forever — a problem kept alive on purpose.”Where this argument points
This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions — for, against or around them:
On the timeline
Keep exploring
From the archive
How newspapers reported related events at the time — suggested by the archive's own tags, not yet reviewed for this argument. Open a scan and judge for yourself.
1949-08-21 · The New York Times · ✓Egyptians Moving Refugees to Gaza
1949-09-14 · The New York Times · ✓Jordan and Israel in Refugee PlansScans: kvetch-of-the-day news archive.
