Argument Β· heard from pro-Israel voices
βJordan is Palestine β the Palestinians already have their state.β
Britain cut Transjordan out of the Palestine Mandate in 1922 β most of the Mandate's territory β and handed it to an Arab emir. Most Jordanians are of Palestinian origin. So the Arab state of Palestine already exists east of the river; the West Bank question is solved by Amman.
Made publicly as a pro-Israel argument by Geert Wilders and Ariel Sharon
Where it's been said
βThere has been an independent Palestinian state since 1946, and it is the kingdom of Jordan.β
βWhat counts for me is that a Palestine already exists, so there is no need to create another one.β
Traps in play:β Which territory?β Which Palestine?
Why people find it convincing
- Transjordan was part of the British Mandate for Palestine until 1921β22, when Britain set it up as an emirate under Abdullah and exempted it from the Jewish national home clauses (Article 25). It was the larger part of the Mandate's area.
- Jordan annexed the West Bank in 1950 and gave its Palestinians Jordanian citizenship; for 17 years 'Palestine' west of the river was ruled from Amman, and nobody founded a Palestinian state there.
- 'More than half of the 6.3 million population of Jordan is of Palestinian origin', Human Rights Watch wrote in 2010, and 'with the exception of persons from Gaza, the vast majority' of them hold Jordanian citizenship.
- The PLO itself once tried to take over Jordan (1970), which shows that its leaders saw Jordan as part of their arena.
What's true
The Mandate once included Jordan, and Jordan and the Palestinians are deeply intertwined.
Transjordan was separated from the Jewish national home by British decision (Cairo 1921). The memorandum the League Council approved on 16 September 1922 declared the national-home provisions 'not applicable to the territory known as Transjordan', east of the Jordan and the Wadi Araba, while Britain kept 'full responsibility as Mandatory for Transjordan'. That is why some Zionists β Jabotinsky's Revisionists above all ('two banks has the Jordan') β regarded the split as a first partition. Jordan ruled and annexed the West Bank from 1948/1950 to 1967, and a large part of its population is of Palestinian origin. Ariel Sharon's 1982 interview with Oriana Fallaci is cited for a 'Jordan is Palestine' argument (the interview is not yet checked against the original β ).
primary documentLeague of Nations Council, Article 25 of the Palestine Mandate: memorandum by the British representative (Geneva, 16 September 1922), text on PalQuest (1922) β
Read (2026-09-28). 'The following provisions of the Mandate for Palestine are not applicable to the territory known as Transjordan, which comprises all territory lying to the east of a line drawn from a point two miles west of the town of Akaba β¦ up the centre of the Wady Araba, Dead Sea and River Jordan to its junction with the River Yarmuk'; listed: Preamble recitals 2 and 3; art. 2's words on 'the establishment of the Jewish National Home'; arts. 4, 6; art. 7's sentence on Palestinian citizenship for Jews; part of art. 11; arts. 13, 14, 22, 23. 'His Majesty's Government accept full responsibility as Mandatory for Transjordan.' Source given: League of Nations, 1926 (LoC and UNISPAL copies).
pressOriana Fallaci, interview with Ariel Sharon (1982) incident β
'β¦a Palestine already exists, so there is no need to create another one'. Not yet checked against the original. Tried 2026-10-01: a Time archive page found by search ('Interview with Israel's ARIEL SHARON: Never! Never! Never!') is captcha-walled, and Wayback returned 429; not yet read.
Not yet read at the source. Tried: 2026-10-01: Time archive page captcha-walled; Wayback unavailable.
What's left out
Neither Jordan nor the Palestinians accept it β and people are attached to places, not acreage.
Jordan is a Hashemite kingdom with its own national identity; its king has rejected the 'alternative homeland' (al-watan al-badil) idea in so many words: 'For 25 years, I have been saying no to displacement, no to resettlement, no to the alternative homeland' (King Abdullah II, February 2025, via the Royal Court as reported by Anadolu). In 1988 King Hussein formally cut Jordan's legal and administrative ties to the West Bank, leaving it to the PLO, and said it in so many words: 'Jordan is not Palestine and the independent Palestinian state will be established on the occupied Palestinian territory after its liberation'. The same speech promised that Jordanian citizens of Palestinian origin keep 'the full rights of citizenship' β the assurance that Human Rights Watch later found broken in the nationality withdrawals of 2004β08. In 1970 ('Black September'), after the PLO had built 'what amounted to a state within a state in Jordan', which King Hussein 'saw increasingly as a threat to his regime', his forces 'drove the PLO out of his country' (Jewish Virtual Library). And the Palestinian claim is to a particular place: King Hussein's own 1988 speech put the Palestinian state 'on the occupied Palestinian territory', not elsewhere in the region. The share of Jordanians of Palestinian origin is politically sensitive; Human Rights Watch put it at 'More than half' of the population in 2010, without saying there how it was counted. The Arab states moved the question from Jordan to the PLO: the Arab League's Rabat summit (28 October 1974), after hearing King Hussein and Yasser Arafat, affirmed the right of the Palestinian people to 'an independent national authority under the command of the Palestine Liberation Organization, the sole legitimate representative of the Palestinian people in any Palestinian territory that is liberated'. Jordan then moved people from 'Jordanian' to 'Palestinian'. After King Hussein's 1988 disengagement, West Bank residents 'lost their Jordanian nationality and citizenship rights, becoming instead stateless Palestinians under Israeli occupation'; and despite the King's assurance that the step did 'not relate in any way to the Jordanian citizens of Palestinian origin', Jordan withdrew nationality from 'over 2,700' of them 'between 2004 and 2008 alone', citing the disengagement (Human Rights Watch, 'Stateless Again', 2010). The same people have been counted as Jordanian in one argument and as Palestinian in another β and some ended up neither.
Traps here:β Which territory?β Which Palestine?
primary documentKing Hussein, address on disengagement from the West Bank, 31 July 1988 (1988) incident β
Full English text on the late king's official site. Jordan cuts legal and administrative ties with the West Bank; 'Jordan is not Palestine'; Jordanian citizens of Palestinian origin keep 'the full rights of citizenship and all its obligations'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'our measures regarding the West Bank concern only the occupied Palestinian land and its people. They naturally do not relate in any way to the Jordanian citizens of Palestinian origin in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan'; 'Jordan is not Palestine and the independent Palestinian state will be established on the occupied Palestinian territory after its liberation, God willing.'
advocacy / viewHuman Rights Watch, 'Stateless Again: Palestinian-Origin Jordanians Deprived of their Nationality' (1 February 2010) (2010) finding β
Read: West Bank residents lost Jordanian nationality under the 1988 disengagement instructions; 'over 2,700' withdrawals 2004β08 from Palestinian-origin Jordanians, officials citing 'the 1988 severance of ties with the West Bank'; King Hussein's 1988 assurance quoted. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'More than half of the 6.3 million population of Jordan is of Palestinian origin β¦ With the exception of persons from Gaza, the vast majority of those persons of Palestinian origin have Jordanian citizenship.' Re-read 2026-10-12: 'residents of the West Bank at the time lost their Jordanian nationality and citizenship rights, becoming instead stateless Palestinians under Israeli occupation'; Jordanians of West Bank origin then living on the East Bank or abroad 'generally maintained their Jordanian nationality'. Also: the 1954 nationality law 'gives nationality to all Palestinians resident in Jordan between December 20, 1949, and the issuance of the law in 1954, as long as they were not Jewish'.
primary documentSeventh Arab League Summit Conference, Resolution on Palestine (Rabat, 28 October 1974), UNISPAL copy (1974) β
Read: point 2 β 'an independent national authority under the command of the Palestine Liberation Organization, the sole legitimate representative of the Palestinian people in any Palestinian territory that is liberated'; adopted after statements by King Hussein and Arafat.
pressAnadolu Agency, Laith Al-jnaidi and Rania Abu Shamala, 'Jordan's king reaffirms rejection of Palestinian displacement' (17 February 2025) (2025) incident β
Read 1 Oct 2026 (also used on the jordanian-option solution card, 2026-10-01). At a meeting with military retirees, per a Royal Court statement: King Abdullah II, 'For 25 years, I have been saying no to displacement, no to resettlement, no to the alternative homeland'; 'achieving just peace on the basis of the two-state solution is the only way'.
referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO): History & Overview' β
Read 2026-09-29 (pro-Israel reference site). 'By 1970, the PLO had established what amounted to a state within a state in Jordan, which King Hussein saw increasingly as a threat to his regime. In what came to be known among Palestinians as Black September, Hussein's forces drove the PLO out of his country. They later settled in Lebanon.'
More context
How to talk about this.
Acknowledge first: a large share of Jordan's citizens are of Palestinian origin, and Jordan was carved from the same Mandate. Ask one question: 'do the Palestinians of the West Bank and Gaza want to be Jordanian, and does Jordan want them?'; Jordan disengaged from the West Bank in 1988 and its king rejected 'the alternative homeland' again in 2025, and Palestinian leaders have insisted on a state of their own. Palestinian opinion on a confederation with Jordan is split: in September 2013, 48% opposed one 'now or in the future' (49% in 2008, 52% in 2007), 25% supported one now and 19% only after a Palestinian state is established (PSR; later polls may differ). Share one checkable thing: Jordan's 1988 disengagement from the West Bank, and its refusal of the 'alternative homeland' idea. What not to say: 'they should all go to Jordan', which is a transfer plan in other words (see 'Palestinians leave ('transfer' / 'voluntary emigration')'). From the other side: grant the historical and demographic link, then ask what role Jordan could play in a solution Palestinians accept.
dataPSR (Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research), Public Opinion Poll No. 49 (19β21 September 2013) (2013) aggregate β
Read (2026-09-28): 'an increase in opposition to a confederation with Jordan now or in the future from 40% three months ago to 48% in this poll β¦ similar to those obtained in previous years: 49% in 2008 and 52% in 2007. 25% support a confederation with Jordan now and 19% support it if established in the future after the end of occupation and the establishment of a Palestinian state.' Opposition higher in the West Bank (54%) than Gaza (38%).
pressAnadolu Agency, Laith Al-jnaidi and Rania Abu Shamala, 'Jordan's king reaffirms rejection of Palestinian displacement' (17 February 2025) (2025) incident β
Read 1 Oct 2026 (also used on the jordanian-option solution card, 2026-10-01). At a meeting with military retirees, per a Royal Court statement: King Abdullah II, 'For 25 years, I have been saying no to displacement, no to resettlement, no to the alternative homeland'; 'achieving just peace on the basis of the two-state solution is the only way'.
Where it leads if pressed
Working it out: history, consent, and what the claim asks of people.
The claim mixes a historical point, a political one and a practical one, and the evidence answers each separately. The history: Transjordan was carved out of the same Mandate, and the League Council approved in 1922 that the national-home provisions were 'not applicable to the territory known as Transjordan'. Some Revisionist Zionists treated that as a first partition. And many of Jordan's people are of Palestinian origin: by Amnesty's account, more than 2 million registered refugees live there, around three quarters of them with full Jordanian citizenship. The consent: neither of the parties the claim speaks for accepts it. King Hussein in 1988: 'Jordan is not Palestine and the independent Palestinian state will be established on the occupied Palestinian territory'; King Abdullah II in 2025: 'no to displacement, no to resettlement, no to the alternative homeland'; Arab states at Rabat in 1974 named the PLO the 'sole legitimate representative of the Palestinian people'. Palestinian opinion on even a confederation was split: in 2013, 48% opposed one now or later, 25% supported one now and 19% only after a Palestinian state (PSR). What it asks of people: the argument's practical consequence concerns the Palestinians of the West Bank and Gaza. Either Jordanian citizenship where they live, which Jordan refuses and which, since 1988, it has been withdrawing from some Palestinian-origin citizens (over 2,700 withdrawals in 2004β08, by Human Rights Watch's count), or moving them, which is transfer by another name. The worst case for each side. For 'Jordan is Palestine': grant the 1922 history and the demography; it still needs the consent of Jordan and of the Palestinians, which both have refused in so many words, and the one time the PLO built 'a state within a state' in Jordan, King Hussein's forces drove it out in 1970, the 'Black September' of Palestinian memory (Jewish Virtual Library). One prominent Israeli use shows what it could be for: Ariel Sharon in 1982, 'a Palestine already exists, so there is no need to create another one. And I tell you: we shall never permit another Palestinian state' (as quoted from his Washington Post interview by Sam Bahour; the interview itself is not checked here). For 'Jordan has nothing to do with Palestine': grant the separate identities; the shared Mandate, the 1948β67 annexation and a citizenry largely of Palestinian origin are on the record. Holds on the evidence here: Jordan and Palestine share a Mandate history and many families; both Jordan's kings and Palestinian representatives reject Jordan as the Palestinian state. Could happen if both sides agreed: a confederation, which polls show Palestinians split on. Not supported: that the Palestinians already have their state in Jordan.
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable β¦) mean
primary documentLeague of Nations Council, Article 25 of the Palestine Mandate: memorandum by the British representative (Geneva, 16 September 1922), text on PalQuest (1922) β
Read (2026-09-28). 'The following provisions of the Mandate for Palestine are not applicable to the territory known as Transjordan, which comprises all territory lying to the east of a line drawn from a point two miles west of the town of Akaba β¦ up the centre of the Wady Araba, Dead Sea and River Jordan to its junction with the River Yarmuk'; listed: Preamble recitals 2 and 3; art. 2's words on 'the establishment of the Jewish National Home'; arts. 4, 6; art. 7's sentence on Palestinian citizenship for Jews; part of art. 11; arts. 13, 14, 22, 23. 'His Majesty's Government accept full responsibility as Mandatory for Transjordan.' Source given: League of Nations, 1926 (LoC and UNISPAL copies).
pressAmnesty International, 'Seventy+ Years of Suffocation', Chapter 2: Jordan finding β
Read 2026-10-01. Undated; latest event cited 3 December 2018. 'According to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA), more than 2 million registered Palestinian refugees now live in Jordan β¦ 370,000 live in camps'; 'Around three quarters of the over 2 million Palestinian refugees in Jordan hold full Jordanian citizenship'; 'a significant minority, most of whom arrived in Jordan from the Gaza Strip β¦ do not possess Jordanian citizenship. A national census carried out by Jordan's Department of Statistics in 2016 put their number at 634,182'; refugees from Gaza 'were never given Jordanian citizenship and have consequently remained stateless'; the 1954 nationality law extended citizenship to 'any person who, not being Jewish, possessed Palestinian nationality before 15 May 1948' and was resident 1949β54; after the 1988 disengagement Jordan revoked the citizenship of West Bank Palestinians, and 'in the 2000s, Jordan arbitrarily cancelled the national identity documents of thousands'.
primary documentKing Hussein, address on disengagement from the West Bank, 31 July 1988 (1988) incident β
Full English text on the late king's official site. Jordan cuts legal and administrative ties with the West Bank; 'Jordan is not Palestine'; Jordanian citizens of Palestinian origin keep 'the full rights of citizenship and all its obligations'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'our measures regarding the West Bank concern only the occupied Palestinian land and its people. They naturally do not relate in any way to the Jordanian citizens of Palestinian origin in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan'; 'Jordan is not Palestine and the independent Palestinian state will be established on the occupied Palestinian territory after its liberation, God willing.'
pressAnadolu Agency, Laith Al-jnaidi and Rania Abu Shamala, 'Jordan's king reaffirms rejection of Palestinian displacement' (17 February 2025) (2025) incident β
Read 1 Oct 2026 (also used on the jordanian-option solution card, 2026-10-01). At a meeting with military retirees, per a Royal Court statement: King Abdullah II, 'For 25 years, I have been saying no to displacement, no to resettlement, no to the alternative homeland'; 'achieving just peace on the basis of the two-state solution is the only way'.
primary documentSeventh Arab League Summit Conference, Resolution on Palestine (Rabat, 28 October 1974), UNISPAL copy (1974) β
Read: point 2 β 'an independent national authority under the command of the Palestine Liberation Organization, the sole legitimate representative of the Palestinian people in any Palestinian territory that is liberated'; adopted after statements by King Hussein and Arafat.
dataPSR (Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research), Public Opinion Poll No. 49 (19β21 September 2013) (2013) aggregate β
Read (2026-09-28): 'an increase in opposition to a confederation with Jordan now or in the future from 40% three months ago to 48% in this poll β¦ similar to those obtained in previous years: 49% in 2008 and 52% in 2007. 25% support a confederation with Jordan now and 19% support it if established in the future after the end of occupation and the establishment of a Palestinian state.' Opposition higher in the West Bank (54%) than Gaza (38%).
advocacy / viewHuman Rights Watch, 'Stateless Again: Palestinian-Origin Jordanians Deprived of their Nationality' (1 February 2010) (2010) finding β
Read: West Bank residents lost Jordanian nationality under the 1988 disengagement instructions; 'over 2,700' withdrawals 2004β08 from Palestinian-origin Jordanians, officials citing 'the 1988 severance of ties with the West Bank'; King Hussein's 1988 assurance quoted. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'More than half of the 6.3 million population of Jordan is of Palestinian origin β¦ With the exception of persons from Gaza, the vast majority of those persons of Palestinian origin have Jordanian citizenship.' Re-read 2026-10-12: 'residents of the West Bank at the time lost their Jordanian nationality and citizenship rights, becoming instead stateless Palestinians under Israeli occupation'; Jordanians of West Bank origin then living on the East Bank or abroad 'generally maintained their Jordanian nationality'. Also: the 1954 nationality law 'gives nationality to all Palestinians resident in Jordan between December 20, 1949, and the issuance of the law in 1954, as long as they were not Jewish'.
referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO): History & Overview' β
Read 2026-09-29 (pro-Israel reference site). 'By 1970, the PLO had established what amounted to a state within a state in Jordan, which King Hussein saw increasingly as a threat to his regime. In what came to be known among Palestinians as Black September, Hussein's forces drove the PLO out of his country. They later settled in Lebanon.'
advocacy / viewSam Bahour, 'Israel's Jordan is Palestine Option', Foreign Policy in Focus (1 May 2001) (2001) β
Read (2026-09-28). Quotes Sharon to Oriana Fallaci (Washington Post, 29 August 1982): 'But they get a homeland. It is the Palestine that is called Jordan β¦ What counts for me is that a Palestine already exists, so there is no need to create another one. And I tell you: we shall never permit another Palestinian state.' Bahour is a Palestinian-American writer.
Citizenship in place, or transfer β the argument has to say which.
The argument's practical consequence is not a renamed map but a population question: what happens to the Palestinians of the West Bank (and Gaza)? If their state is Jordan, there are two ways to read it: Jordanian citizenship for Palestinians where they live, as in the 'The Jordanian option: the West Bank back to Jordan, or a JordanianβPalestinian federation' proposals, or pressure to move there β 'transfer' by another name, which Jordan's king has publicly rejected ('no to displacement', 2025). When the argument doesn't say which, asking is the test. Taken seriously as history, the 1922 split does raise a fair point: every border in this conflict was a choice, including the river as the line in 'from the river to the sea'. But that point opens a discussion about the whole Mandate β including options where Jews and Palestinians share a far larger frame β rather than closing one by declaring the Palestinians already housed.
Traps here:β Which territory?
pressAnadolu Agency, Laith Al-jnaidi and Rania Abu Shamala, 'Jordan's king reaffirms rejection of Palestinian displacement' (17 February 2025) (2025) incident β
Read 1 Oct 2026 (also used on the jordanian-option solution card, 2026-10-01). At a meeting with military retirees, per a Royal Court statement: King Abdullah II, 'For 25 years, I have been saying no to displacement, no to resettlement, no to the alternative homeland'; 'achieving just peace on the basis of the two-state solution is the only way'.
The usual reply β and its own traps
Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.
heard from pro-Palestinian voicesβFrom the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.βWhere this argument points
This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions β for, against or around them:
On the timeline
Keep exploring
From the archive
How newspapers reported related events at the time β suggested by the archive's own tags, not yet reviewed for this argument. Open a scan and judge for yourself.
Scans: kvetch-of-the-day news archive.
