Deadlocks · defusion

Third-party security guarantees

An outside force or guarantor takes on part of the security burden, so that neither side has to trust the other with its safety on day one.

Check the effects of this card → put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.

Monitors, peacekeepers or a guaranteeing power stand between the parties and verify that commitments are kept: demilitarised zones, early-warning stations, joint patrols, a guarantor with the will to act.

The deadlocks it addresses

Where it has been tried

  • The Multinational Force and Observers in Sinai (since 1982) — worked. Set up by a 1981 Protocol to the Egypt–Israel peace treaty as 'an independent, international organization outside the UN framework' (22 supporting states), to 'supervise the implementation of the security provisions of the Treaty of Peace and employ best efforts to prevent violations of its terms': checkpoints, patrols and observation posts in Sinai's Zone C, and verification of the treaty's limits on forces (MFO). Both sides wanted the treaty to hold, and the force observes rather than enforces.
  • UNIFIL in southern Lebanon (since 1978) — failed. It did not prevent Hezbollah from arming in its area. The UN Secretary-General reported in 2024 that the exchanges of fire 'demonstrate the possession of weapons outside the authority of the State in the area between the Litani River and the Blue Line by Hizbullah and other non-State armed groups in violation of resolution 1701'; over four months UNIFIL, 'independently or in close coordination with the Lebanese Armed Forces', found unauthorized weapons on 17 occasions, and the report asked Lebanon to give it access to sites, including those linked to tunnels crossing the Blue Line (S/2024/548). That Israel draws its distrust of international forces from this record is not yet sourced here ⚠.
  • The Temporary International Presence in Hebron (1997–2019) — partly. Set up under the Oslo arrangements after the 1994 Hebron massacre to monitor and report 'the efforts to maintain normal life in the City of Hebron, thus creating a feeling of security among Palestinians'; it could report but not act. Its mandate could be renewed only 'with the consent of both sides', and in January 2019 Netanyahu declined, saying 'we will not allow an international force to act against us'; the five contributing states called the decision one that 'undermines one of the few established mechanisms for conflict resolution', and the UN Secretary-General hoped an agreement could preserve it (Mitvim, February 2019; UN News, 2 February 2019).

What you have to believe for it to work

  • A guarantor would stay and act when tested
  • The weaker side would accept outside forces on its territory

Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.

What has to happen first

  • A political agreement the guarantee serves
  • A guarantor both sides accept, with a clear mandate and staying power

How it can fail

  • A force that watches but can't act becomes cover for rearmament
  • Its first casualties can end its mandate

Sources