Deadlocks Β· defusion Β· coercive

Remove the other side's government

Destroy Hamas, topple the Iranian regime, or replace a Palestinian or Israeli leadership from outside, on the theory that the people underneath would then make peace.

Check the effects of this card β†’ put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.

A stated Israeli war aim of the Gaza war (in Netanyahu's words to the US Congress in July 2024, to 'destroy Hamas's military capabilities, end its rule in Gaza'; for the day after, 'Israel does not seek to resettle Gaza, but for the foreseeable future, we must retain overriding security control there'), and a long-standing argument about Iran's regime; its mirror is the hope that outside pressure will bring down an Israeli government. It rests on a real observation: many Gazans distrusted Hamas and many Iranians oppose their regime (see 'Who speaks for them?').

The deadlocks it addresses

Where it has been tried

  • Iraq, 2003 β€” failed. Removing the regime without a plan for what followed produced insurgency, sectarian war and ISIS.
  • Libya, 2011 β€” failed. The regime fell; the state fell with it.
  • Lebanon, 1982 β€” failed. Israel expelled the PLO from Beirut and backed a friendly president, who was assassinated; Hezbollah rose in the vacuum.
  • Germany and Japan, 1945 β€” worked. Total defeat followed by years of occupation and massive reconstruction, a scale of commitment no one proposes here.

What you have to believe for it to work

  • Something better is ready to take over
  • Military force can remove a movement, not only its leaders

Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.

What has to happen first

  • A governing alternative with local legitimacy
  • A long, costly commitment to what comes after

How it can fail

  • A vacuum filled by something worse
  • Martyrdom that strengthens the movement
  • Civilian cost that recruits the next generation

Sources