Deadlocks · defusion

End the Ottoman remnants

Take personal status out of the religious courts, allow civil marriage, and modernise land law, removing inherited rules that no one chose and that give religious parties leverage.

Check the effects of this card → put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.

Israel's marriage and divorce still run through each community's religious authorities, a system inherited from the Ottoman millets: 'Israel does not allow civil marriage, and Jewish marriages conducted in Israel must be sanctioned by Orthodox rabbis', though 'civil marriages that take place in other countries are legally recognized' (Pew Research Center, 2016). Land law in the West Bank still has 'features of Ottoman, British and Israeli law', in the words of the settlers' Yesha Council, whose own guide defines miri land (state-owned, cultivated by individuals) by the reach of villages 'as it was in 1858' (Yesha Council, 'Basic Information on the Status of Land in Judea and Samaria'). Israel based its West Bank 'state land' declarations on the 1858 Land Code, saying it was 'required to respect it under international law'; B'Tselem, which documented 908,000 dunams declared in 1979–1992 (the state comptroller's figure), calls the policy unlawful (B'Tselem, 'Under the Guise of Legality', 2012). Reform would give citizens choices they don't have and reduce the coalition leverage of parties whose power depends on the religious monopoly (see 'What the Ottomans and the British left behind').

The deadlocks it addresses

Where it has been tried

  • Turkey's 1926 civil code — worked. In 1926 the Ottoman Empire's successor state took 'a bold step by adopting the Swiss Civil Code', a textbook 'legal transplant' that replaced the Islamic-law-based Mecelle (British Association of Comparative Law). It abolished polygamy (art. 130) and made civil marriage compulsory (art. 143), with any religious ceremony to follow civil registration. It held: in 2016, 97% of marriages were first registered civilly, and 1.1% 'performed solely the religious marriage'. It is still contested: a later law allowing muftis to perform civil marriages was challenged as a threat to that secular rule (Reset DOC).
  • Israel's recognition of civil marriages performed abroad — partly. A workaround that shows the demand. In 2006 the Supreme Court (Ben-Ari) held 6–1 that a foreign marriage certificate of a same-sex couple must be registered, the registry being statistical, not recognition as such; in March 2023 it rejected the state's appeal against registering online civil marriages performed through Utah, about 600 couples in three years, including 'members of the LGBT community, interfaith couples' (JNS). How many couples marry abroad in person (e.g. in Cyprus) is not yet sourced here ⚠.

What you have to believe for it to work

  • A coalition without the religious parties' veto can be formed
  • Changes to personal law can be separated from the national conflict

Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.

What has to happen first

  • A governing majority not dependent on the religious parties

How it can fail

  • It is fought as a culture war and blocks everything else
  • Religious communities, Jewish and Muslim alike, see it as an attack

Sources