Deadlocks · defusion

A truth commission

Investigate and publicly record what each side did, including massacres and expulsions, trading full testimony for a chance to move on.

Check the effects of this card → put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.

An independent body, with members from both peoples and outside, that hears victims and perpetrators, establishes the facts of disputed events (Deir Yassin, Hebron 1929, Lydda, Kfar Etzion, October 7, specific strikes in Gaza), and publishes an agreed record, with or without amnesty.

The deadlocks it addresses

Where it has been tried

  • South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission (1996–2002) — partly. Set up under the Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act (1995) 'to help deal with what happened under apartheid', it recorded 'violence and human rights abuses from all sides' through three committees: Amnesty, Reparation and Rehabilitation, and Human Rights Violations. The trade the card describes, testimony for amnesty, was built into its structure. Victims' families challenged that trade. In 1996 AZAPO and 'the families of slain activists Steve Biko, Griffiths Mxenge and Fabian Ribiero and his wife Florence' asked the Constitutional Court to strike down the amnesty, under which a perpetrator 'cannot be criminally or civilly liable'. The court upheld it unanimously, acknowledging that it limited their right to have disputes 'settled by a court of law', because 'without it there would be no incentive for offenders to disclose the truth'. It also noted that the amnesty was 'a crucial component of the negotiated settlement itself, without which the Constitution would not have come into being' (SAPA; Wits Law School summary). The ruling left the families 'no power to sue for compensation from the state or the alleged perpetrators'.
  • Colombia's truth commission (2018–22) — partly. Set up as 'a direct result of the 2016 peace accords' between the government and the FARC. Its June 2022 report denounced 'the concept of the "internal enemy" and the systematic victimization of Colombia's political left', and criticised US-backed counternarcotics policy (National Security Archive). Its reception split along the old lines. President-elect Gustavo Petro, a former guerrilla, received the report; President Iván Duque, who had campaigned against the peace deal, was abroad; and his party, led by Álvaro Uribe, said: 'We don't think it's appropriate that anybody established dogmatic or definitive truths in relation to the conflict as there are multiple versions' (CNN).

What you have to believe for it to work

  • Both societies can hear their own side's crimes named
  • The facts of the worst events can still be established

Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.

What has to happen first

  • A peace agreement or at least an end to the fighting
  • Access to archives on both sides

How it can fail

  • Each side uses it to prosecute the other's crimes and hide its own
  • Amnesty offends victims

Sources