One state with equal rights that remains a Jewish state
Israel extends its sovereignty and full, equal citizenship to the Palestinians of the West Bank, and keeps its Jewish national character, as it does today with its Arab citizens.
Check the effects of this card β pick what you believe, choose the defusions you would use, and see where it leads.
What happens to Israeli Jews
Keep a Jewish state, and in these versions the whole of the West Bank, with Jerusalem united.
What happens to Palestinians
Full individual rights and the vote as a national minority, like Arab citizens of Israel today. No state and no national self-determination of their own; refugees don't return.
What it requires
- Annexing the West Bank and giving its Palestinians full citizenship and the vote. Peace Now, citing Israeli and Palestinian statistics for the end of 2023, counts more than 3 million people in the West Bank, 85% of them Palestinians
- A lasting Jewish majority. With the West Bank but without Gaza, advocates say Jews would keep a clear majority of citizens: Glick writes that 'even if all the Palestinians living in Judea and Samaria are granted Israeli citizenship, Jews would still remain a two-thirds majority of the citizens of Israel', using 2005 figures from the American-Israel Demographic Research Group; a review of her book in The National (Rayyan Al Shawaf, 3 April 2014) notes that she omits Israeli demographers 'such as Sergio DellaPergola and Arnon Soffer' who are 'in substantial agreement with the Palestinians' findings'. They dispute the Palestinian population figures: Glick's publisher says the book argues that the 1997 Palestinian census 'wildly exaggerated the numbers of Palestinians living in the West Bank and Gaza'. Include Gaza and the majority is in question
- An answer for Gaza, which most versions leave out
- Palestinians accepting citizenship in a state whose symbols, anthem and Law of Return are Jewish, with no national state of their own
- Real equality in land, planning, budgets and policing, which Israel's Arab citizens still don't fully have
This model depends on demography. It stays both equal and Jewish only as long as the numbers allow. If they don't, it has to choose, and choosing the Jewish character over the vote turns it into "one state under Jewish rule, without equal rights".
Who supports it
Proposed on the Israeli right, e.g. Caroline Glick, 'The Israeli Solution: A One-State Plan for Peace in the Middle East' (Crown Forum, 2014; Open Library record, read), which in its publisher's words 'offers an alternative path to stability in the Middle East based on Israeli sovereignty over Judea and Samaria' and calls the two-state policy 'one of the most irrational and failed policies the United States has ever adopted'. The book is not read here; by the same review's account she 'urges Israel to offer citizenship to West Bank Palestinians' and forecasts that Palestinians 'will have the same legal and civil rights as the rest of the residents and citizens of Israel'. It is rarely polled as its own option, so there is no reliable figure for its support. The nearest measured option is annexation of the West Bank without equal rights for Palestinians, which 42% of Israeli Jews supported in July 2024 (see 'Annexation without rights'). That is the opposite of this card, which gives citizenship and the vote.
What history says
- Arab citizens of Israel since 1948: the model in miniature, with the vote, Knesset seats and, in June 2021, the first Arab party to join an Israeli government (Reuters; see 'Arab citizens of Israel have full equality β they vote, sit in the Knesset and on the Supreme Court.'), but military rule in the early decades: the government announced its abolition as of 1 December 1966, after Prime Minister Levi Eshkol assured the cabinet 'that the security of the state could be ensured without' it, leaving about 250 men on a 'blacklist' under military rule (JTA, 8 November 1966); it was installed when the state was founded, its powers drawn from the British 'Defence (Emergency) Regulations 1945', and after the mixed cities were released left 'about 85% of Arabs living in Israel under Military Government rule' (Akevot Institute, from Israel State Archives file GL-17005/6), and lasting inequality
- Nation-states with large national minorities: Finland's Swedish speakers, Turkey's Kurds (how each has fared is not sourced here yet β )
- Northern Ireland: a nationalist minority with equal votes but no national self-determination; the 1998 Good Friday Agreement gave both identities a stake, recognising 'the birthright of all the people of Northern Ireland to identify themselves and be accepted as Irish or British, or both, as they may so choose' (as quoted in the UK's explanatory notes to the Northern Ireland (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2014, s. 15); the length and toll of the conflict before it are not yet sourced here β
Where this can lead
Each outcome holds only under its conditions. The label is how likely those conditions look on the record, by the weakest of them; set your own in the builder.
A Jewish nation-state with an equal national minority β unlikely on the record
if Palestinians accept a permanent minority status and the numbers allow (Palestinians would accept being a permanent national minority in a Jewish state)
One state, Jewish in its symbols and immigration law, where Palestinians vote and hold office as equal citizens but have no state of their own.
- Finland's Swedish speakers β held. A national minority inside a nation-state, a success (see 'One state with equal rights that remains a Jewish state').
- Arab citizens of Israel since 1948 β mixed. The model in miniature: the vote, Knesset seats, and in 2021 Ra'am became 'the first party drawn from the country's 21% Arab minority β¦ to join an Israeli government' (CSM/Reuters); but military rule until 1966, with its powers then 'transferred to the police and intelligence services' (PalQuest), and lasting distance: in 2024 only 26.8% of Arab citizens trusted the security forces (IDI). See 'Arab citizens of Israel have full equality β they vote, sit in the Knesset and on the Supreme Court.'.
What it can slide into: If the numbers change and the state chooses its Jewish character over the vote: one state, ruled.
A long minority conflict β likely on the record
if they don't, and force is not an option (not: Palestinians would accept being a permanent national minority in a Jewish state; not: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement)
The minority has equal votes but no national self-determination, and its national movement fights on, politically or with arms.
- Turkey's Kurds β long conflict. A national minority in a nation-state and a long armed conflict: the PKK 'took up arms in 1984', in a conflict 'that cost more than 40,000 lives'. On 12 May 2025 it announced it would dissolve and end its armed struggle (France 24). Whether that holds, and what it brings Kurdish rights, is still open.
- Northern Ireland β 30 years of violence. Equal votes without national self-determination, until the 1998 Agreement recognised 'the birthright of the people of Northern Ireland to identify and be accepted as British or Irish, or both, and to hold both British and Irish citizenship' (UK government page on the Belfast Agreement).
What it can slide into: Repression, partition, or a settlement that gives both identities a stake.
One state, ruled β unlikely on the record
if they don't, and the state chooses its Jewish character over the vote (not: Palestinians would accept being a permanent national minority in a Jewish state; The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement)
One sovereignty from the river to the sea; one people votes for the government, the other lives under it without a vote or equal rights.
- South Africa's apartheid and 'homelands' β ended in 1994. The system this would resemble by definition (see 'One state under Jewish rule, without equal rights').
What it can slide into: When the ruled refuse permanent subordination, 'emigration' becomes the proposed answer β forced displacement.
The hard questions
- What happens to Gaza, and to the Jewish majority if Gaza is ever included?
- If the Jewish majority shrinks, which gives way: equal votes or the Jewish character? If it's the votes, this becomes annexation without rights.
- Why would Palestinians accept being a permanent national minority, when their national movement exists to avoid exactly that?
- Can Israel close the inequality its Arab citizens already face, before it takes in the West Bank's Palestinians as citizens too?
What stands in the way
- Each side reads the other through its worst quote β Palestinians won't accept a state whose leaders said they don't exist.
- Majority as safety β return as justice β It works only if refugees don't return, which Palestinians reject.
- Recognise the Jewish state β recognise the Nakba β It asks Palestinians to accept the Jewish character without any acknowledgement of their own story.
- Whoever moves first loses β Israel would grant citizenship first and hope for loyalty.
- Distrust as premise β Same.