One state under Jewish rule, without equal rights
Israel annexes the West Bank but does not give its Palestinians citizenship.
Check the effects of this card β pick what you believe, choose the defusions you would use, and see where it leads.
What happens to Israeli Jews
Keep sovereignty over the whole land.
What happens to Palestinians
Permanent subjects without political rights, or pressure to leave.
What it requires
- Permanent rule over millions without the vote
- Two legal systems by nationality β formalised
Its own advocates build the next step into it: Smotrich's plan offers those who keep 'their national ambitions' 'aid to emigrate', and those who fight 'a strong hand'; it also floats full citizenship 'as a third option', conditioned on 'the declaration of complete loyalty to the Jewish State by serving in the armed forces'. When a ruled people refuses permanent subordination, emigration is the answer the plan already names.
Who supports it
Rooted in the Likud platform of 1977 ('between the Sea and the Jordan there will only be Israeli sovereignty') and later right-wing plans. Its political support is now visible in votes rather than polls: in July 2025 the Knesset passed, 71 to 13, a non-binding motion 'applying Israeli sovereignty to Judea, Samaria and the Jordan Valley' (Al Jazeera, 23 July 2025), and in February 2026 the security cabinet eased Israeli purchases of West Bank land, measures the pro-Israel Israel Policy Forum says 'eroded the legal and practical distinctions between Israel and the West Bank' (February 2026). Neither says what status the territory's Palestinians would have, which is the question this card turns on. Polls have asked it directly: in the joint Palestinian-Israeli Pulse (PCPSR, Ramallah, with Tel Aviv University; fieldwork July 2024, published September 2024), 42% of Israeli Jews supported 'annexation of the West Bank without equal rights for Palestinians', 'the highest ever recorded in the Pulse', up from 37% in 2022, when it first overtook support for two states (34%). The mirror question, one state without equal rights for Jews, drew 33% of Palestinians. Only 14% of Israeli Jews backed one state with equal rights. Its best-known advocate text is Bezalel Smotrich's 'Decisive Plan' (Hashiloach, 2017): West Bank Arabs 'will be able to conduct their daily life in freedom and peace, but not to vote for the Israeli Knesset at the first stage. This will preserve the Jewish majority'; he calls it 'an imperfect situation in terms of civil rights' and writes that 'this graduated arrangement does not make the State of Israel into an "apartheid state."'
What history says
- South Africa's apartheid and 'homelands': the comparison its critics draw; the Rome Statute defines apartheid as inhumane acts 'committed in the context of an institutionalized regime of systematic oppression and domination by one racial group over any other racial group or groups'. Its advocates reject the label (see the support line)
Where this can lead
Each outcome holds only under its conditions. The label is how likely those conditions look on the record, by the weakest of them; set your own in the builder.
One state, ruled β unlikely on the record
if the ruled accept it and the world tolerates it (A people ruled without equal rights would accept it; The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement)
One sovereignty from the river to the sea; one people votes for the government, the other lives under it without a vote or equal rights.
- South Africa's apartheid and 'homelands' β ended in 1994. The system this would resemble by definition (see 'One state under Jewish rule, without equal rights').
What it can slide into: When the ruled refuse permanent subordination, 'emigration' becomes the proposed answer β forced displacement.
Forced displacement β unlikely on the record
if the ruled refuse and the world tolerates force (not: A people ruled without equal rights would accept it; The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement)
Millions leave under pressure or at gunpoint, their homes taken or destroyed; the land is emptied for the other people.
- 1948 β permanent. Expulsion and flight, return barred (see 'Transfer the Palestinians out').
- Jews of Arab lands, 1948β1970s β permanent. Around 850,000 left or were driven out (see 'One Arab state from the river to the sea').
- The Balkans in the 1990s β permanent. The UN Commission of Experts called the expression 'relatively new' and defined it, for the former Yugoslavia, as 'rendering an area ethnically homogenous by using force or intimidation to remove persons of given groups from the area' (Final Report, S/1994/674, para. 129, quoting its first interim report).
What it can slide into: A new refugee question that outlives everyone who caused it, and the next war; for those who refuse to go, worse.
Permanent war β likely on the record
if the ruled refuse and the world does not accept force (not: A people ruled without equal rights would accept it; not: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement)
No side wins or leaves; rounds of war separated by armed quiet; each generation inherits the dead of the last.
- IsraelβHamas wars in Gaza (2008β2021) β repeated. Ceasefires each followed by a rebuilt arsenal and another war (see 'Hudna: a long-term truce without recognition'). Read from the other side, it was a round of strikes every few years under a closure that stayed in place between them. Both readings describe the same years (see 'Mowing the grass').
What it can slide into: Whatever the next atrocity makes thinkable.
The hard questions
- In what sense is this not apartheid?
- What do the Palestinians do β accept, leave, or fight? And what does each of those answers require of Israel?