Solutions

One Arab (or Islamic) state from the river to the sea

Israel ends; Palestine covers the whole land as an Arab state (PLO Charter 1968) or an Islamic one (Hamas).

Check the effects of this card β†’ pick what you believe, choose the defusions you would use, and see where it leads.

What happens to Israeli Jews

Not recognised as a people. 'Go back to Europe' β€” but about half of Israeli Jews identify as Sephardi or Mizrahi, with roots mostly around the Mediterranean or in the Middle East (Pew, 2016); for them there is nowhere in Europe to go back to.

What happens to Palestinians

Sovereignty over the whole land.

What it requires

  • Defeating or dissolving Israel
  • Deciding what happens to Israel's 7.2 million Jews (Jewish Agency, 2023) β€” the 1968 PLO Charter recognised as Palestinians only Jews resident before 'the Zionist invasion' (Art. 6; declared 'nullified' by Arafat in 1998), and Hamas's 2017 document defines Palestinians as 'the Arabs who lived in Palestine until 1947' (Art. 4)
  • Denying Jewish peoplehood (the 1968 Charter: 'Judaism, being a religion, is not an independent nationality', Art. 20, also among the articles declared 'nullified' in 1998)

Who supports it

Palestinians33%
Arab citizens of Israel17%

Program of Hamas (2017 document, Art. 20) and of the 1968 PLO Charter. In a small 2023 survey of US college students who supported 'from the river to the sea', 67.8% dropped the slogan 'after learning a handful of basic facts', among them what this outcome would mean for Israel's Jews and Arabs (Hassner 2023). Among Palestinians, 33% supported 'a one-state solution without equal rights for Israeli Jews' in the joint Palestinian-Israeli Pulse (PCPSR with Tel Aviv University, July 2024); 17% of Israeli Arabs did.

What history says

  • Jews of Arab lands after 1948 β€” 'approximately 850,000 Jews have been displaced from Arab countries', in the words of a 2008 US House resolution (H.Res. 185)
  • Algeria 1962 β€” nearly 700,000 people were 'repatriated' to France that year; harkis (Algerians who had sided with France) were killed in reprisals, in numbers that 'remain undetermined': a report to the UN spoke of 150,000 dead, historians estimate 'several tens of thousands' (French government site on the harkis, harkis.gouv.fr, our translation)
  • Rwanda 1994 β€” see 'When a solution needs a people to disappear' on this page
  • October 7, 2023 β€” Hamas's 2017 document calls 'Resisting the occupation with all means and methods' 'a legitimate right' (Art. 25); October 7 is what its armed wing did under that banner

Where this can lead

Each outcome holds only under its conditions. The label is how likely those conditions look on the record, by the weakest of them; set your own in the builder.

Forced displacement β€” unlikely on the record

if the world tolerates it (The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement)

Millions leave under pressure or at gunpoint, their homes taken or destroyed; the land is emptied for the other people.

  • 1948 β€” permanent. Expulsion and flight, return barred (see 'Transfer the Palestinians out').
  • Jews of Arab lands, 1948–1970s β€” permanent. Around 850,000 left or were driven out (see 'One Arab state from the river to the sea').
  • The Balkans in the 1990s β€” permanent. The UN Commission of Experts called the expression 'relatively new' and defined it, for the former Yugoslavia, as 'rendering an area ethnically homogenous by using force or intimidation to remove persons of given groups from the area' (Final Report, S/1994/674, para. 129, quoting its first interim report).

What it can slide into: A new refugee question that outlives everyone who caused it, and the next war; for those who refuse to go, worse.

Permanent war β€” likely on the record

if the world and the targeted people do not accept it (not: The rest of the world would accept a solution imposed by force or displacement)

No side wins or leaves; rounds of war separated by armed quiet; each generation inherits the dead of the last.

  • Israel–Hamas wars in Gaza (2008–2021) β€” repeated. Ceasefires each followed by a rebuilt arsenal and another war (see 'Hudna: a long-term truce without recognition'). Read from the other side, it was a round of strikes every few years under a closure that stayed in place between them. Both readings describe the same years (see 'Mowing the grass').

What it can slide into: Whatever the next atrocity makes thinkable.

The hard questions

  • What happens to 7 million people who have no other homeland?
  • Who decides who may stay?
  • Does calling a people 'colonisers' or 'Nazis' make their removal feel justified β€” and where has that led before?

Arguments that point here