Argument · heard from pro-Palestinian voices
“Zionists are the modern Nazis.”
Israel's treatment of Palestinians is equated with Nazi Germany's treatment of Jews — ghetto, extermination, 'the victims became the perpetrators'.
Made publicly as a pro-Palestinian argument by Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva
Where it's been said
“You know, what is happening in the Gaza Strip to the Palestinian people has not happened at any other moment in history. Actually, it did happen: when Hitler decided to kill the Jews.”
Traps in play:◆ The strict enemy frame◆ "They all…"◆ DARVO: deny, attack, reverse◆ Holocaust inversion◆ The argument that isn't meant to win
Why people find it convincing
- Gaza has been under restrictions since 2007, when Israel's security cabinet declared it 'hostile territory' and decided to 'restrict the passage of various goods', 'reduce the supply of fuel and electricity' and restrict 'the movement of people', while stating 'the intention to avoid a humanitarian crisis' (Prime Minister's Office, 19 September 2007); images of mass destruction, hunger and dead children evoke the worst of the 20th century.
- Senior Israeli officials have used dehumanising language, and a UN commission and South Africa's ICJ filing treat it as evidence of intent. The UN Commission of Inquiry quotes Defence Minister Gallant on 9 October 2023, announcing 'a complete siege… no electricity, no water, no food, no fuel. We are fighting human animals, and we act accordingly' (A/HRC/60/CRP.3, 2025); South Africa's ICJ filing lists Netanyahu's 28 October 2023 'You must remember what Amalek has done to you, says our Holy Bible. And we do remember' among 'Expressions of Genocidal Intent'. The other half: the Prime Minister's Office called that 'not an incitement to genocide of Palestinians, but a description of the utterly evil actions perpetrated by the genocidal terrorists of Hamas on October 7th' (ABC News, 31 January 2024).
- Settler violence and calls from far-right ministers to 'encourage emigration' from Gaza sound like ethnic cleansing to their critics: in January 2024 Ben-Gvir called 'a solution to encourage the emigration of Gaza's residents' 'a correct, just, moral and humane solution', and the US State Department called such statements 'inflammatory and irresponsible' (France 24, 3 January 2024). Settler violence is documented on 'Settler violence is a handful of extremists — the 'hilltop youth' — and Israel deals with them.'.
- The comparison has been approached from inside Israel's own establishment. On Holocaust Remembrance Day 2016 the IDF's deputy chief of staff, Yair Golan, said that what frightened him was 'seeing the abhorrent processes that took place in Europe, and Germany in particular, some 70, 80 or 90 years ago, and finding manifestations of these processes here among us in 2016'. The IDF then stated that he 'had no intention to compare the IDF and the State of Israel to the process that took place in Germany', calling such a comparison 'absurd' (Ynet/Reuters, 5 May 2016). He spoke of social processes, not of Israel as a Nazi state.
- It feels morally urgent to use the strongest historical comparison available, especially toward a state founded after the Holocaust.
What's true
The suffering is real, some official rhetoric was dehumanising, and both can be condemned without any Nazi comparison.
Mass civilian death, displacement and hunger in Gaza, settler violence in the West Bank, and dehumanising statements by senior officials are real and documented. They can be criticised in the strongest terms — as war crimes where the evidence supports it — on their own merits.
law / courtSouth Africa v. Israel, Application instituting proceedings (29 December 2023) (2023) ✓
Application of 29 December 2023, as quoted in ICJ Press Release 2023/77 (UNISPAL copy read). Compiles statements by Israeli officials cited as evidence of intent.
What's left out
Nazism was an ideology plus an industrial apparatus for exterminating every Jew everywhere.
The Nazi project was defined by racial ideology and a state machinery built to kill all Jews wherever they could be reached — ~6 million murdered, industrial death camps, the Wannsee protocol (1942) coordinating it continent-wide. The comparison has to show a comparable aim or apparatus here, and the record cuts against it in one plain way: Arab citizens, 'about 20 percent of the population', hold Israeli citizenship and political rights, though they 'face political discrimination' (Freedom House, 2025); and the population has grown: 'in 1947 there were about 1.3 million Arabs living in Palestine' (the historian Yehoshua Porath, 1986), while the 1948 refugees and their descendants alone now number 'some 6 million' (AP, 2024); population growth does not by itself settle what happened in any particular war; a full count of Palestinians today is not sourced on this page ⚠. Whether the Gaza war meets the legal definition of genocide is a separate question, still open in court (see 'Israel is committing genocide in Gaza.'). A finding of genocide would still not make the two the same: the Nazi aim was every Jew, everywhere. The army version ('the IDF is the Waffen-SS, same thing, different name') compares a state's army to the SS's military branch, which the US Holocaust Memorial Museum says was 'heavily involved in the commission of the Holocaust through their participation in mass shootings, anti-partisan warfare, and in supplying guards for Nazi concentration camps'. Crimes by Israeli soldiers are documented and can be judged on their own evidence (see 'The IDF is a terrorist army that targets Palestinian civilians on purpose.'); the comparison measures them against the Holocaust's apparatus instead.
Traps here:◆ The strict enemy frame◆ "They all…"◆ DARVO: deny, attack, reverse
primary documentMinutes of the Wannsee Conference, 20 January 1942 (Avalon Project, US government translation for Nuremberg) (1942) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28). 'the final solution of the Jewish question'; table of Jews to be included, 'Total over 11,000,000', listing countries outside German control (e.g. Sweden 8,000, Switzerland 18,000, Spain 6,000, Turkey (European portion) 55,500); 'Europe will be combed through from west to east'.
advocacy / viewFreedom House, 'Israel: Freedom in the World 2025 Country Report' (2025) finding ✓
Read 2026-09-30. Status 'Free', 73/100 (Political Rights 34/40, Civil Liberties 39/60; previous year 74); 'a parliamentary democracy with a multiparty system and independent institutions that generally guarantee political rights and civil liberties for the population within its borders'; 'Arab citizens of Israel, who often identify as Palestinian and make up about 20 percent of the population, face political discrimination'; 'de facto discrimination in education, social services, personal security, and access to housing and related permits'; related territories: West Bank 22/100 and Gaza Strip 2/100, 'Not Free'. A US-based democracy-rating NGO. Also: 'LGBT+ Israelis also have full political rights and have secured representation in the Knesset and the political system more broadly. The current parliament speaker and some other lawmakers are openly gay.'
historyYehoshua Porath, 'Mrs. Peters's Palestine', New York Review of Books (1986) finding ✓
Read in full (NYRB, 16 Jan 1986). Porath (Hebrew University) on Peters' thesis in his words: 'Much of Mrs. Peters's book argues that at the same time that Jewish immigration to Palestine was rising, Arab immigration to the parts of Palestine where Jews had settled also increased. Therefore, in her view, the Arab claim that an indigenous Arab population was displaced by Jewish immigrants must be false, since many Arabs only arrived with the Jews'; he answers with the Lovers of Zion settlers' writings 'filled with references to the Arabs surrounding them everywhere in Palestine'. Re-read 2026-09-30: 'in 1947 there were about 1.3 million Arabs living in Palestine'; 'most of the growth of the Palestinian Arab community resulted from a process of natural increase'; mid-19th century 'about four hundred thousand Arabs'. No '100,000 immigrants' figure in the review. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'It is true that in the middle of the nineteenth century there was neither a "Palestinian nation" nor a "Palestinian identity." But about four hundred thousand Arabs—the great majority of whom were Muslims—lived in Palestine, which was divided by the Ottomans into three districts.'
pressAP (via PBS NewsHour), 'Palestinians mark 76 years of dispossession as yet another catastrophe unfolds in Gaza' (May 2024) (2024) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. 'Some 700,000 Palestinians — a majority of the prewar population — fled or were driven from their homes'; the refugee community 'now numbers some 6 million, with most living in slum-like urban refugee camps in Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and the Israeli-occupied West Bank'; in Gaza refugees and descendants are 'around three-quarters of the population'. Israel's position: refugees should be absorbed by host countries; it 'points to the hundreds of thousands of Jews who came to Israel from Arab countries'.
referenceUS Holocaust Memorial Museum, Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'Waffen-SS' ✓
Read 2026-09-29. 'The Waffen-SS was the military branch of the SS … heavily involved in the commission of the Holocaust through their participation in mass shootings, anti-partisan warfare, and in supplying guards for Nazi concentration camps. They were also responsible for many other war crimes.' Set up after Himmler 'persuaded Adolf Hitler in late 1939'.
More context
Why this comparison, of all comparisons: it turns the Jews' defining trauma back on them.
Whatever the speaker intends, the comparison can turn the Holocaust into an accusation against its victims' descendants. The IHRA working definition lists 'drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis' as an example of antisemitism; that definition is itself contested.
referenceIHRA Working Definition of Antisemitism (2016) (2016) ✓
Checked 2026-09-29 against the full text as published by the Swiss Federal Commission against Racism (the IHRA's own page is walled to this fetcher). Adopted in Bucharest, 26 May 2016: 'Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews.' Its examples of what could, 'taking into account the overall context', be antisemitic include 'Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis' and 'Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination'; it also states that 'criticism of Israel similar to that leveled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic'. Contested; see the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism (2021) for a rival definition. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'However, criticism of Israel similar to that leveled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic.'
A historical irony, documented in contemporary newspapers.
The leading Palestinian Arab figure of the Mandate era, Hajj Amin al-Husseini, the Mufti of Jerusalem, met Hitler on 28 November 1941 and collaborated with the Nazi regime during the war. The kvetch-of-the-day news archive holds dated clippings on him, e.g. 'mufti called axis partner' (NYT, 1947-05-12). This does not make today's Palestinians responsible for him — they aren't — but it complicates the story the comparison tells.
primary documentkvetch-of-the-day news-articles-backup: NYT clipping 'mufti called axis partner' (12 May 1947) ✓
Checked 2026-09-30 against the site's resolved clippings: the 1947-05-12 NYT clipping 'mufti called axis partner' is a verified scan. The earlier '67 clippings tagged Mufti' count came from the archive's tags and could not be checked locally, so the note no longer gives it; the other example (1946-08-19) is not among the resolved clippings.
historyUS Holocaust Memorial Museum, Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'Hajj Amin al-Husayni: Key Dates' incident ✓
Read 2026-10-01. 18 Dec 1942: at the Central Islamic Institute in Berlin he 'denounces the Jews as the bitterest enemies of Islam'; speech broadcast to the Middle East 23 Dec. 13 Feb 1943: 'Hitler agrees to create the 13th Waffen-SS Mountain Division, later also known as "Handschar." SS chief Heinrich Himmler authorizes recruitment of Bosnian Muslims for the division. In March and April, the SS Main Office sends al-Husayni to assist in recruitment efforts.' July 1943: SS imam school; al-Husayni: Muslims would 'never have a better or more loyal ally than the Greater German Reich.' Feb 1944: the division deployed 'in western Croatia and northeastern Bosnia'. Re-read 2026-10-12: al-Husayni 'meets Hitler for the first time on November 28, 1941 in Berlin, Germany. During the meeting, held in the Reich chancellery, Hitler declined to grant al-Husayni's request for a public statement—or a secret but formal treaty—in which Germany would: 1) pledge not to occupy Arab land, 2) recognize Arab striving for …' (film caption).
Reading the numbers: what the comparison would need the figures to show.
A comparison with Nazism is a claim about aim and reach, so the numbers have to be read for those, not only for size. The aim, in the Nazis' own document: the Wannsee protocol (1942) lists 'over 11,000,000' Jews for 'the final solution', including those in countries Germany did not control, Sweden's 8,000, Switzerland's 18,000, Spain's 6,000, with 'Europe … combed through from west to east'. The target was every Jew, wherever they lived, whatever they did. Gaza's toll, read at each bound: a household survey in The Lancet Global Health estimates 75,200 violent deaths (63,600–86,800) from October 2023 to early January 2025; against Gaza's population of about 2.3 million (AP), that is about 3.3% (this page's arithmetic), between 2.8% and 3.8% at the survey's bounds, in about fifteen months (this page's arithmetic). It is a very large toll, and 56.2% of the dead were women, children or over-64s. The reach: Palestinians inside Israel are citizens, not targets: Arab citizens are 'about 20 percent' of Israel's population, with citizenship and political rights though they 'face political discrimination' (Freedom House). The worst case for each side. For 'Zionists are Nazis': take the highest estimate, 3.8% of Gaza, and the most dehumanising official statements quoted in South Africa's filing; add the heaviest formal finding on this site, the UN Commission of Inquiry's 2025 conclusion of genocide in Gaza, which Israel rejects. These are evidence for the questions of war crimes and genocidal intent before the courts, but nothing in them matches a plan to kill a people everywhere, citizens included; the Commission's own chair, Navi Pillay, drew her parallel with Rwanda, not with the Nazi project (the West Bank, where settler violence is documented, is a separate question with its own entry). For 'the comparison is only hatred': take the lowest bound, 2.8% (63,600 of 2.3 million); it is still tens of thousands of dead, and the anger behind the comparison answers to a real toll. The warning has also come from inside Israel's establishment: in 2016 the deputy chief of staff, Yair Golan, spoke of 'finding manifestations of these processes here among us', before the army said he had 'no intention to compare the IDF and the State of Israel' to Germany. Holds on the evidence here: the toll is very large, and the Nazi aim of killing every Jew everywhere has no counterpart in the record here. Open until the courts rule: genocidal intent in Gaza, which is a different and narrower claim than an equation with Nazism. Not supported: that the figures show a Nazi-style project, or that rejecting the comparison means the toll is small.
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean
primary documentMinutes of the Wannsee Conference, 20 January 1942 (Avalon Project, US government translation for Nuremberg) (1942) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28). 'the final solution of the Jewish question'; table of Jews to be included, 'Total over 11,000,000', listing countries outside German control (e.g. Sweden 8,000, Switzerland 18,000, Spain 6,000, Turkey (European portion) 55,500); 'Europe will be combed through from west to east'.
data'Violent and non-violent death tolls for the Gaza conflict: new primary evidence from a population-representative field survey', The Lancet Global Health (2026) (2026) aggregate ✓
Spagat, Pedersen, Shikaki, Robbins, Bendavid, Hegre, Guha-Sapir, The Lancet Global Health 14 (April 2026). Read in full: 2,000 households, 30 Dec 2024 – 5 Jan 2025; 75,200 (63,600–86,800) violent deaths; 56.2% women, children, over-64s; 12,200 missing; 16,300 non-violent deaths, 8,540 excess; MoH 34.7% below the central estimate. Abstract re-read via OpenAlex 2026-10-12: 'The MoH figure for this period (49 090 violent deaths) was 34·7% below our central estimate'; 'violent deaths have substantially exceeded official figures whereas the demographic composition of casualties aligns with MoH reporting. Non-violent excess deaths, although substantial, are lower than some projections have suggested.' From the abstract: women, children and over-64s were '56·2% (95% CI 50·4-61·9) of violent deaths, totalling 42 200 deaths (95% CI 33 100-51 300)'. The age-and-sex figures used on counting-the-dead (32,900 men and 16,600 women aged 18–64 killed; 8,470 of the 12,200 missing being men of that age) come from the earlier full reading; the full text is walled today (2026-10-12) and they are not re-checked.
pressAP (via PBS NewsHour), 'Videos of Israeli soldiers acting maliciously emerge amid international outcry against tactics in Gaza' (13 December 2023) (2023) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. Videos apparently uploaded by soldiers: ransacking a toy store, trying to burn food and water supplies, prayer rugs moved into a bathroom, a dance with the chant ‘there are no people who are uninvolved’ (AP verified backgrounds, uniforms and language). The army ‘pledged to take disciplinary action in what it says are a handful of isolated cases’; spokesman Daniel Hagari: ‘In any event that does not align with IDF values, command and disciplinary steps will be taken’. B’Tselem’s Dror Sadot: ‘The dehumanization from the top is very much sinking down to the soldiers’. Yinon Magal, who posted the dance video, defended it and condemned the toy-store video. The article also notes the U.S. and other militaries have had similar videos, and Hamas’s hostage and 7 October bodycam videos. The article's background lines (read 2026-10-02 re-check, 2026-10-10): Hamas militants 'killed about 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and took about 240 hostages'; 'About 90 percent of Gaza's 2.3 million people have been displaced'.
advocacy / viewFreedom House, 'Israel: Freedom in the World 2025 Country Report' (2025) finding ✓
Read 2026-09-30. Status 'Free', 73/100 (Political Rights 34/40, Civil Liberties 39/60; previous year 74); 'a parliamentary democracy with a multiparty system and independent institutions that generally guarantee political rights and civil liberties for the population within its borders'; 'Arab citizens of Israel, who often identify as Palestinian and make up about 20 percent of the population, face political discrimination'; 'de facto discrimination in education, social services, personal security, and access to housing and related permits'; related territories: West Bank 22/100 and Gaza Strip 2/100, 'Not Free'. A US-based democracy-rating NGO. Also: 'LGBT+ Israelis also have full political rights and have secured representation in the Knesset and the political system more broadly. The current parliament speaker and some other lawmakers are openly gay.'
law / courtSouth Africa v. Israel, Application instituting proceedings (29 December 2023) (2023) ✓
Application of 29 December 2023, as quoted in ICJ Press Release 2023/77 (UNISPAL copy read). Compiles statements by Israeli officials cited as evidence of intent.
law / courtUN Commission of Inquiry, 'Legal analysis of the conduct of Israel in Gaza pursuant to the Genocide Convention', A/HRC/60/CRP.3 (advance version, 16 September 2025) (2025) finding ✓
Full report read. Standard of proof 'reasonable grounds to conclude' (para 7); statements quoted at paras 111 and 170–172. Searched in full 2026-10-10 (text of the PDF): 'urban warfare' does not occur; 'military expert' occurs once, an unnamed quote ('Israel is dropping in less than a week what the United States was dropping in Afghanistan in a year, in a much smaller, much more densely populated area') footnoted to the Commission's earlier report A/HRC/56/CRP.4 and a Washington Post article of 12 October 2023; a witness testified that 'munitions experts consulted' concluded a clinic had been 'under significant direct attack'. Its recommendations ask Israel to '(h) Allow the Commission access to Israel and the occupied Palestinian territory, including East Jerusalem, to continue its investigations'. Re-read 2026-10-12: para. 111, 'Gallant framed the siege as a measure of retribution, announcing "a complete siege… no electricity, no water, no food, no fuel. We are fighting human animals, and we act accordingly."'; para. 170, Herzog on 13 October 2023: '"it's an entire nation out there that is responsible. It is not true, this rhetoric about civilians who were not aware and not involved. It is absolutely not true."'; para. 172, Netanyahu's letter of 3 November 2023 to soldiers: '"Remember what Amalek did to you... This is a war between the sons of light and the sons of darkness…"'.
pressAFP interview with Navi Pillay, as published by Malay Mail, ''It's so painful to watch': UN Gaza investigator draws Rwanda parallels, urges prosecution of Israeli leaders for genocide' (18 September 2025) (2025) incident ✓
Read 2026-09-29 (AFP copy). Pillay, former head of the Rwanda tribunal and chair of the UN Commission of Inquiry, 'sees parallels with the butchery in Rwanda'; 'all the evidence (indicates) it is Palestinians as a group that is being targeted'; she compared Israeli leaders calling Palestinians 'animals' with Tutsis labelled 'cockroaches'. Israel rejects the Commission's genocide finding (see genocide-claim).
pressYnetnews (Reuters), 'Deputy IDF chief's Holocaust Remembrance Day speech raises ire' (5 May 2016) (2016) incident ✓
Read 30 Sept 2026. Yair Golan at the Masua Holocaust Institute: 'If there is something that frightens me about the memory of the Holocaust, it is seeing the abhorrent processes that took place in Europe, and Germany in particular, some 70, 80 or 90 years ago, and finding manifestations of these processes here among us in 2016.' IDF Spokesperson: 'The deputy chief of staff would like to clarify that he had no intention to compare the IDF and the State of Israel to the process that took place in Germany 70 years ago. The absurd comparison is entirely without foundation'. Education Minister Bennett: he 'has erred, and he must rectify it immediately.'
How to talk about this.
Acknowledge first: the anger behind the comparison is real, and some Israeli officials have used dehumanising language. Ask one question: 'what exactly is being compared: an ideology of racial extermination, or a war with terrible civilian costs?'; the specifics are where the comparison is tested. Share one checkable thing: the Nazi goal was the extermination of every Jew everywhere; the comparison asks the listener to see that in Israel. What not to say: 'you're an antisemite' before hearing the grievance, even if the comparison is one (see 'Holocaust inversion'). From the other side: the same care applies to comparing Palestinians or Hamas to Nazis.
Where it leads if pressed
The comparison ends conversation instead of informing it.
Once one side is 'the Nazis', compromise with them can come to seem unthinkable and any means against them justified; that is the comparison's risk, whatever the speaker intends. The criticism it tries to express survives without it.
The usual reply — and its own traps
Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.
the reply“Israel is doing to the Palestinians what the Nazis did to the Jews” heard from pro-Israel voices“The Mufti was Hitler's ally — Palestinian nationalism has Nazi roots.”Where this argument points
This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions — for, against or around them: