Deadlocks · defusion

A people's mandate

Ordinary Israelis and Palestinians, brought together, work out what they could accept, and their proposal is put to both sides' leaders as a mandate the leaders didn't have to invent.

Check the effects of this card → put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.

Randomly selected citizens' assemblies, deliberative polls or joint civil-society negotiations produce a proposal; the proposal is published, tested in polls or referendums, and presented to both leaderships, so that a solution arrives with public backing rather than waiting for leaders to risk their positions.

The deadlocks it addresses

Where it has been tried

  • Ireland's Citizens' Assembly (2016–18) — worked. Ninety-nine citizens, drawn by a polling firm as 'a representative sample' and 'selected at random … broadly representative of society as reflected in the Census', heard expert advice on five contested topics (the assembly's own page). One recommendation was to change the Eighth Amendment so parliament could legislate on abortion. Parliament then passed the Thirty-sixth Amendment Act, and the referendum of 25 May 2018 approved it 'with 66% of voters in favour' (Carnegie UK case study). The assembly only advised; parliament and the voters decided.
  • The Geneva Initiative (2003) — partly. Israeli and Palestinian negotiators acting without a government mandate drafted a full model agreement in 2003; its own materials describe it as a 'detailed blueprint'. It showed a deal was writable, but it had no mandate from either government (see the 'The Geneva Initiative' org page).
  • Joint Israeli–Palestinian polling (the Palestine/Israel Pulse) — partly. A joint PCPSR–Israeli poll that asks both publics the same questions. In July 2024 it found support for two states at 40% among Palestinians and 21% among Israeli Jews, 'the lowest since comparable questions were asked in the early 1990s'. It informs leaders but doesn't bind them.

What you have to believe for it to work

  • Most people on both sides want a solution more than any specific one
  • Participants, especially Palestinians, can take part safely

Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.

What has to happen first

  • Protection for participants from their own side's enforcers (see 'Who can afford to speak')
  • Leaders willing to receive the result, or a route to a referendum

How it can fail

  • Leaders ignore a mandate they didn't ask for
  • Spoilers target the participants
  • Selection is attacked as unrepresentative

Sources