Deadlocks · defusion
Reparations and compensation
Acknowledge a historical wrong with money and material help, so that justice can be done without undoing the present: compensation instead of reversal.
Check the effects of this card → put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.
A fund, paid by the responsible state and by international donors, compensating people for property and lives lost: Palestinians for 1948 and after, Jews expelled from Arab countries for theirs. It separates the moral acknowledgement from the demand to reverse history on the ground.
The deadlocks it addresses
Where it has been tried
- The Luxembourg Agreement between West Germany and Israel (1952) — worked. Signed in Luxembourg on 10 September 1952 by Chancellor Adenauer and Foreign Minister Sharett: 'three billion DM … as compensation for the costs of integrating Jewish refugees into Israeli life', plus 450 million DM to the Claims Conference (German History in Documents and Images, with the official communiqué). It went through against opposition on both sides. In Israel, Menachem Begin argued in the Knesset that no price could be put on the lives lost (Center for Israel Education's summary of his speech). In West Germany it was signed 'despite massive opposition within the cabinet, in the coalition's parliamentary faction, and among the West German public' (GHDI). The Claims Conference itself stressed that no amount of money 'can make good the destruction of human life and cultural values' (Claims Conference, history page). The goods were bought through Israel's Purchasing Mission in Cologne, 'the official and exclusive commercial representative of the Government of Israel' in West Germany, which operated from 1953 until the two states established diplomatic relations in August 1965 (Leo Baeck Institute Jerusalem research group). The goods bought under the agreement 'represented between 12 and 14 percent of Israel's annual imports over the decade, thus making an important contribution to Israel's growing economy' (Encyclopaedia Judaica, via the Jewish Virtual Library).
- The Clinton Parameters (2000) — partly. Clinton's text says 'Israel is prepared to acknowledge the moral and material suffering caused to the Palestinian people as a result of the 1948 war and the need to assist the international community in addressing the problem'. It lists five homes for refugees, with return to the Palestinian state 'right to all Palestinian refugees' and absorption into Israel left to 'Israeli sovereign decision'. It was never implemented because the wider deal failed. The full text (PalQuest) adds: 'An international commission should be established to implement all the aspects that flow from your agreement: compensation, resettlement, rehabilitation, etc. The US is prepared to lead an international effort to help the refugees.' It does not mention Jewish refugees from Arab countries; Clinton raised a fund for them separately, in an interview (see 'There was a Jewish Nakba too — it was a population exchange, so the Palestinian refugee question is settled.').
What you have to believe for it to work
- Compensation can be accepted as justice rather than as a bribe
- Donors will fund it at the needed scale
Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.
What has to happen first
- A settlement in which compensation is part of the answer to return
- Agreement on who pays: Israel, Arab states for Jewish property, international donors
How it can fail
- It's rejected as 'selling the right of return'
- Arab states refuse to count the Jewish claims