Deadlocks · defusion

Plan for the spoilers

Expect violence timed to wreck an agreement, and build the process so that an atrocity isolates its authors instead of halting the talks.

Check the effects of this card → put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.

Every peace process has groups on both sides who lose by it, and an attack at the right moment can make a deal look impossible to the public on the other side. The defusion is to agree in advance that violence by opponents of the deal will not stop it: joint condemnation, including by the side the attackers claim to act for; security cooperation against them; and timetables that don't hand them a veto.

The deadlocks it addresses

Where it has been tried

  • The Omagh bombing, Northern Ireland (15 August 1998) — worked. Four months after the Good Friday Agreement, a bomb by the 'real' IRA killed 29 people — the worst single incident of the conflict. Condemnation came 'by all sections of the community and all shades of political opinion'; Sinn Féin's president 'condemned it without equivocation', which CAIN notes was 'the first time any member of SF has used the word "condemnation" in connection with any act of Republican violence'; the group suspended operations (and later returned to violence). The agreement held.
  • The Oslo years (1994–96) — failed. The Hebron mosque massacre by a Kahanist settler (25 February 1994) was met with an attempt to contain it: the Security Council, 'Determined to overcome the adverse impact of the massacre on the peace process', condemned it and 'its aftermath which took the lives of more than fifty Palestinian civilians', called on Israel to disarm violent settlers, and called for a temporary international presence (Resolution 904). Prime Minister Rabin was assassinated by a Jewish opponent of the process in November 1995. Then, in 1996, Hamas suicide bombings in Jerusalem and Ashkelon (25 February), on a Jerusalem bus (3 March) and in Tel Aviv (4 March) killed 55 Israelis by Israel's count to the UN, which said they were 'intended not only to kill Israelis, but to derail the peace process'; a new government under Prime Minister Netanyahu took office in May, and the PLO charged that its guidelines contradicted the Oslo agreements (UN Yearbook 1996). Violence from both directions achieved what its authors wanted.

What you have to believe for it to work

  • The leaders on both sides actually want the deal to survive the attack
  • The side the attackers claim to act for is willing to condemn them in its own words
  • The public reads the attack as the work of a fringe rather than of the other side as a whole

Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.

What has to happen first

  • Leaders with enough standing to condemn their own side's extremists
  • Security cooperation that continues through a crisis

How it can fail

  • Condemnation without action reads as cover
  • A government that needs the extremists' votes cannot move against them
  • Each attack raises the price of the next concession

Sources