Deadlocks Β· defusion
A refugee package: choices, not one right
Answer the refugee question with a menu: return to the Palestinian state, limited return or family reunification to Israel, resettlement where people live now or in third countries, and compensation.
Check the effects of this card β put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.
Each refugee family chooses among options, with international funding, so that the right of return is honoured as a choice rather than as a demographic weapon, and Israel's majority isn't put at stake. A variant conditions return itself on the returnee: individual vetting and acceptance of the state's law and citizenship, as other countries do for any newcomer. That condition is already in the founding text: Resolution 194 (1948) speaks of 'the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours' β a qualification that the BDS call and the Hamas document, as quoted on this site, both leave out (see 'The 'right of return' is a backdoor to ending Israel β by making Jews a minority.').
The deadlocks it addresses
Where it has been tried
- Israel's '100,000' offer at Lausanne (August 1949) β failed. Israel offered to take back 100,000 refugees, beyond the Arabs already there β 'a maximum of 250,000' in all β on condition that they be settled 'where they would not come in contact with possible enemies of Israel' and placed according to its development plan, as part of a UN-run resettlement plan. The Conciliation Commission found it 'unsatisfactory' and passed it on only unofficially; the Arab delegations called it contrary to Resolution 194 and objected to making return depend on 'economic and strategic considerations'. (UN Yearbook 1948β49, summarising the Commission's fourth progress report).
- The Clinton Parameters and the Taba talks (2000β01) β partly. President Clinton's parameters of 23 December 2000 proposed 'the five possible homes for the refugees': the State of Palestine, areas in Israel transferred in the land swap, rehabilitation in the host country, resettlement in a third country, and admission to Israel. Return to the West Bank, Gaza and swapped areas 'would be right to all Palestinian refugees', while absorption into Israel would be 'consistent with Israeli sovereign decision' (text as published by the Center for Israel Education). At the Taba talks that followed (January 2001), Israel informally suggested a 15-year absorption programme, with a non-paper 'referring to 25,000 in the first three years', while the Palestinian side 'did not present a number'; nothing was agreed (EU envoy Moratinos's non-paper, UNISPAL).
- The Geneva Initiative (2003) β partly. The unofficial 2003 draft gives refugees five places of permanent residence to choose from: the State of Palestine and the areas swapped to it (a right for all), third countries, present host countries, and Israel. Return to Israel is 'at the sovereign discretion of Israel' and capped by 'a number that Israel will submit to the International Commission', which 'shall represent the total number of Palestinian refugees that Israel shall accept' β 'As a basis, Israel will consider the average of the total numbers submitted by the different third countries' (Refugees annex).
- Germany's integration of the expellees after 1945 β worked. Millions of expellees were resettled and compensated through a burden-sharing law (1952); the right to return became symbolic.
- PSR's refugee surveys (2003) β measured in a survey. Offered a five-option menu based on the Taba talks, 10% of 4,506 refugee families chose return to Israel first, 31% the Palestinian state, 23% swapped areas, 17% staying with host-country citizenship, 2% emigration; 13% refused all. Most who chose Israel would not accept Israeli citizenship β so a citizenship condition would itself shrink the numbers.
What you have to believe for it to work
- Most refugees would choose options other than return to Israel if the others were real
- Host countries would allow resettlement and citizenship
- A conditioned return (vetting, commitment to live at peace under the state's law) would be accepted by Palestinians as honouring the right rather than hollowing it out
Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.
What has to happen first
- A Palestinian state to return to
- Arab host states offering citizenship
How it can fail
- It's attacked as abolishing the right of return
- Host states refuse and the refugees stay stateless
- Vetting criteria become a tool to exclude almost everyone, or are rejected as a loyalty test
Sources
- UN General Assembly resolution 194 (III), 11 December 1948, para. 11 β as quoted in the UN study 'The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem', part II (UNISPAL)
- Geneva Initiative, 'The Accord' (summary page)
- PSR refugee surveys, 2003
- Yearbook of the United Nations 1948β49 (excerpts), on the Conciliation Commission's fourth progress report (A/922)
- Geneva Initiative, Refugees annex (PDF) β options for permanent residence and the Israeli number