Deadlocks · defusion · extreme
Remove the other population
'Defuse' the demographic deadlock by making the other people leave: 'voluntary emigration' of Gazans, or 'go back to Europe' for Israeli Jews.
Check the effects of this card → put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.
Proposed in both directions. In October 2023 Israel's Intelligence Ministry drafted a ten-page policy paper recommending to 'evacuate the civilian population to Sinai' and prevent its return; the ministry confirmed it was authentic and 'distributed to the defense establishment', and such papers are 'not binding' on the government (as reported by +972 Magazine and Local Call). In 2024 a group of retired senior officers put forward what became known as the 'Generals' Plan' for northern Gaza. B'Tselem, which argues Israel's war is genocide, writes that 'Though never officially adopted by the Israeli military, the plan did inform its conduct on the ground', with 'some 100,000 people' displaced from northern Gaza by November 2024; 'informed' is B'Tselem's inference, not an admission. CNN reported both sides of that in October 2024. Four sources said the cabinet 'has not adopted the siege proposal put forward by retired general Giora Eiland', while a former senior military official said it had adopted 'a version of' it. Eiland called that 'quite true' but said there were 'significant differences' from what was being done on the ground. According to the broadcaster Kan, Netanyahu told a closed Knesset committee that the plan 'makes a lot of sense' (CNN, 12 October 2024). As the Forum of Commanders and Reserve Fighters presented it (reported by Arutz Sheva, a Religious-Zionist outlet; see its org page): the area north of the Netzarim Corridor would become a closed military zone whose population, 'estimated by the army to be approximately 250,000 people, would be required to leave immediately'; after a week 'a full military siege would be imposed'. The forum said this 'complies with the rules of international law because it allows the population to evacuate', with exit corridors where 'those who leave will receive food and water'. Eiland said the fighters left inside 'would in this situation either surrender or starve to death'. The plan document itself is still not read here ⚠. On the Israeli far right, ministers attended a January 2024 conference calling for resettling Gaza and encouraging Gazans to leave, and on 4 February 2025, beside Israel's prime minister, the US president said 'The U.S. will take over the Gaza Strip … We'll own it', that the '1.8 million Palestinians living in Gaza' should instead occupy 'various domains' to be built in 'other countries of interest with humanitarian hearts', and that the rebuilt strip could be 'the Riviera of the Middle East'. He framed it as humane: 'the people will be able to live in comfort and peace', and 'The only reason the Palestinians want to go back to Gaza is, they have no alternative' (news conference transcript, American Presidency Project). On the other side, the slogans and charters that envisage Israel's end leave Israeli Jews nowhere to go (see 'One Arab (or Islamic) state from the river to the sea'). Advocates present it as humane ('voluntary') or as justice ('return to where they came from'). Arab states answered with a plan of their own: the League of Arab States' Cairo summit (March 2025) reaffirmed 'categorical rejection of any form of displacement of the Palestinian people from or within their land, under any pretext', calling it 'a crime against humanity, and a form of ethnic cleansing', and adopted a reconstruction plan meant to be carried out with Gazans staying in place.
The deadlocks it addresses
Where it has been tried
- The Nakba (1948) and the exodus of Jews from Arab countries (1948–1970s) — failed. Both 'solved' a demographic question for one side and created refugee problems that still drive the conflict three generations later.
- The Greek–Turkish population exchange (1923) — partly. It ended a conflict at the cost of more than a million people uprooted, by treaty between states, not by pressure on a population under bombardment.
What you have to believe for it to work
- A people can be made to leave 'voluntarily' under war conditions
- The rest of the world will accept it
Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.
How it can fail
- It is ethnic cleansing under international law, whatever it's called
- It creates the next generation of refugees and the next war
Sources
- Cairo Statement and Arab Plan for early recovery, reconstruction and development in Gaza (League of Arab States summit, March 2025), transmitted to the UN as A/79/820–S/2025/151
- +972 Magazine / Local Call, report on the Intelligence Ministry's Sinai relocation paper (October 2023)
- CNN, 'Gaza: After mulling siege plan, Israel ramps up military push in north of enclave' (12 October 2024): four sources say the cabinet 'has not adopted the siege proposal put forward by retired general Giora Eiland'; a former senior military official says 'a version of' it; Eiland: 'quite true' but 'significant differences'; Kan: Netanyahu said it 'makes a lot of sense'
- Arutz Sheva / Israel National News, 'Siege on northern Gaza: The "Generals Plan" for the war' (4 September 2024): the Forum of Commanders and Reserve Fighters' plan in its own terms (~250,000 'required to leave immediately'; 'a full military siege'; 'complies with the rules of international law'); Eiland: 'either surrender or starve to death'. A Religious-Zionist outlet (see its org page).
- B'Tselem, 'Our Genocide' (July 2025), section on forced displacement (northern Gaza, October–November 2024)
- The President's News Conference With Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel, 4 February 2025 (American Presidency Project transcript)