Deadlocks Β· defusion Β· coercive

Replace the political system wholesale

Tear up the existing system (a revolution, an imposed constitution, a new order) instead of reforming it from within.

Check the effects of this card β†’ put it in a plan for each solution it serves, and see what that plan rests on.

Proposed from several directions: an externally imposed constitution for a Palestinian state, a new Israeli constitutional order (from either the 2023 overhaul's supporters or its opponents), or a revolutionary break with the whole arrangement.

The deadlocks it addresses

Where it has been tried

  • Iraq's post-2003 order β€” partly. After the invasion, power was apportioned by sect and ethnicity (muhasasa), a system 'only introduced by the United States after it occupied Iraq in 2003' on foundations laid by exiled opposition groups. By 2019 protesters called it 'at the heart of all our problems', and the scholar Fanar al-Haddad called it 'a byword for the political system and all its ills' that 'underpins the corruption, collusion and the patronage networks' (Al Jazeera).
  • Israel's 2023 judicial overhaul β€” failed. Pushed by one camp 'despite the lack of a broader consensus': polls showed 'most Israelis oppose the government's plan', while its right-wing supporters saw it 'as a step toward, and not away from, democracy'. The first law's passage in July 2023 brought mass protests and a growing number of reservists refusing to serve (CNN). It split the country months before the war. It shows why constitutional change needs broad consent.

What you have to believe for it to work

  • A new system can be created legitimately in a divided society
  • Those who lose power under the old system accept the new one

Set how likely you find each of these in the builder, and see what a plan using this card rests on.

What has to happen first

  • Broad consent across the society

How it can fail

  • The side that loses treats the new system as illegitimate
  • A crisis in the transition that enemies exploit

Sources