Trap Β· reasoning move
β Allies in destruction
Sounds like: βThe enemy of my enemy is my friend.β
Two movements with opposite visions, one for a secular classless society, one for a society under religious law, march together because they share an enemy. Each expects to use the other and discard it afterwards.
Signs
partners who would outlaw each other if either won; slogans shared, goals never discussed; embarrassing statements by an ally denied, reinterpreted or ignored; supporters who are welcome only while useful.
Questions to ask
What does each partner want the day after victory, and does the other survive it? Would my movement accept this ally's stated goals if they applied at home? Who gets dropped first when the alliance is tested?
Example
Western leftists marching with groups whose programmes would jail them.
The mirror
an Israeli government letting money reach Hamas to keep its rival weak.
How it works.
When two movements agree on almost nothing except who the enemy is, the alliance holds only as long as the enemy does, and each partner privately counts on coming out on top. The anarchist Mikhail Bakunin's line that 'the passion for destruction is a creative passion' (1842) names the attitude that makes it possible on the left: destroy first, build later. It explains a pattern visible in this conflict: support is valued for loyalty and usefulness, not for agreement, and allies who stop being useful are dropped (see 'The purity loop').
Traps here:β The purity loop
primary documentMikhail Bakunin, 'The Reaction in Germany: From the Notebooks of a Frenchman' (October 1842), English translation on the Marxists Internet Archive (1842) incident β
Read 2026-10-13. Closing lines: 'Let us therefore trust the eternal Spirit which destroys and annihilates only because it is the unfathomable and eternally creative source of all life. The passion for destruction is a creative passion, too.' Translation as published by the archive.
The term 'redβgreen alliance': who uses it, and how it is answered.
Scholars use the term descriptively: Emmanuel Karagiannis and Clark McCauley's 'The Emerging Red-Green Alliance: Where Political Islam Meets the Radical Left' (Terrorism and Political Violence, 2013) argues that radical leftists and Islamists 'have come closer in recent years', using the shared 'master frame of anti-globalization/anti-capitalism and the master frame of anti-colonialism/anti-imperialism' to build 'a Common Front against the United States and its allies'. The British Trotskyist rule 'with the Islamists sometimes, with the state never' (Chris Harman, 1994) is the left's own version of the bargain. A British example: after 'the biggest anti-war demonstration in British history', 'leftwing campaigners' banded together 'with members of Muslim organisations', which led 'in 2004 to the formation of Respect - the Unity Coalition' (BBC profile, 2010); by November 2007 it had split into two factions holding rival conferences, George Galloway and his supporters on one side and the Socialist Workers' Party on the other (BBC). The term is also used as an attack, and its critics call it a smear: Media Matters (a progressive US media watchdog, 2026) describes right-wing media's 'red-green alliance', 'a supposed pact between communists and Islamists', as part of a turn to 'Islamophobia and the threat of socialism' to hold a political coalition together. So the same phrase names a documented convergence in some groups and, in other hands, a charge against Muslims and leftists in general; which one is meant depends on whether it points to specific organisations and statements. Within such alliances, shared words can carry different programmes; 'resistance' (muqawama) is the clearest case (see the double meanings on 'What would you do if you were oppressed for 75 years? October 7 didn't come from nowhere.' and 'Same slogan, different goals').
historyEmmanuel Karagiannis & Clark McCauley, 'The Emerging Red-Green Alliance: Where Political Islam Meets the Radical Left', Terrorism and Political Violence 25 (2013), 167β182 β abstract on START (University of Maryland) (2013) finding β
Abstract read 2026-09-29 (academic; terrorism-studies journal). 'radical Leftists and Islamists have come closer in recent years β¦ building a Common Front against the United States and its allies'; both use 'the master frame of anti-globalization/anti-capitalism and the master frame of anti-colonialism/anti-imperialism'.
advocacy / viewChris Harman, 'The Prophet and the Proletariat', International Socialism Journal 2:64 (Autumn 1994) (1994) finding β
Read on the Marxists' Internet Archive: the rule 'with the Islamists sometimes, with the state never' (where the Islamists are in opposition), and its stated limit β defending 'women, gays, Berbers or Copts against some Islamists'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Where the Islamists are in opposition, our rule should be, "with the Islamists sometimes, with the state never". But even then we continue to disagree with the Islamists on basic issues'; 'as well as defending Islamists against the state we will also be involved in defending women, gays, Berbers or Copts against some Islamists'.
advocacy / viewMedia Matters for America, 'The MAGA media fixation on the "red-green alliance" is an attempt to hold a fracturing coalition together' (2026) (2026) finding β
Read 2026-09-29 (progressive US media watchdog; the page's date is unclear, August or September 2026). Right-wing media use 'the phrase "red-green alliance" β that is, a supposed pact between communists and Islamists', alongside 'Marxist jihadist'; argues MAGA media 'is going all in on Islamophobia and the threat of socialism as a way of binding their fracturing coalition together'.
pressBBC News, 'Profile: Respect Party' (5 April 2010) (2010) incident β
Read 2026-09-29. 'The Respect coalition was formed in the aftermath of the biggest anti-war demonstration in British history'; 'leftwing campaigners banding together with members of Muslim organisations, in many cases for the first time, under the Stop the War coalition banner β¦ leading in 2004 to the formation of Respect - the Unity Coalition.'
pressBBC News, 'Rival events for Respect factions' (17 November 2007) (2007) incident β
Read 2026-09-29. 'A split within the ranks of the anti-war Respect coalition has led to the party holding two separate conferences on the same day. The two factions comprise MP George Galloway and his supporters on one side and representatives of the Socialist Workers' Party on the other.'
The precedent: Iran, 1978β1988.
Communists (the Tudeh party), Marxist guerrillas (the Fedaian) and the Islamic-Marxist People's Mujahedin all joined Khomeini's revolution against the Shah, and some Western intellectuals backed it. Michel Foucault, reporting from Iran in 1978 for Corriere della Sera and Le Nouvel Observateur, met Khomeini and wrote in support of the Islamist movement, by the account of Janet Afary and Kevin B. Anderson; their book also prints the 'at times blistering responses' of contemporaneous critics such as the Middle East scholar Maxime Rodinson. The Tudeh collaborated with the Islamic regime. Then, in 1983, an estimated 1,500 of its members were arrested, and the party was outlawed in May 1983. Its secretary general, Nourreddine Kianouri, said in a television interview: 'With the help of our members within the armed forces, we used to prepare reports for the Soviet government.' An exiled member said the leaders 'had been tortured'; a diplomat who watched said they 'looked in good shape and in full control of themselves'. By then hundreds of the People's Mujahideen had been executed (Christian Science Monitor, July 1983). Between late July and early September 1988, 'at least 5,000 political dissidents were extrajudicially executed' on the orders of a secret fatwa by Khomeini, after an armed incursion by the Iraq-based People's Mojahedin. 'The majority of the victims were affiliated with the PMOI, but hundreds of prisoners affiliated with leftist political organizations and Kurdish opposition groups were also executed' (Amnesty International, 2018). Each side had seen the other as a tool; the Islamists won. In 1994 the British Trotskyist Chris Harman set out the tactic in 'The Prophet and the Proletariat' (International Socialism journal): 'Where the Islamists are in opposition, our rule should be, βwith the Islamists sometimes, with the state neverβ' β while adding that 'as well as defending Islamists against the state we will also be involved in defending women, gays, Berbers or Copts against some Islamists'. Asked by 'a member of an academic audience', 'a few years' before 2012 by her own account (a 2010 archive post places it at a 'Berkeley Teach-In Against War' on the 2006 IsraelβHezbollah war, held on 7 September; Radical Archives), 'whether I thought Hamas and Hezbollah belonged to "the global left"', the philosopher Judith Butler replied that 'understanding Hamas, Hezbollah as social movements that are progressive, that are on the left, that are part of a global left, is extremely important', adding that this 'does not stop us from being critical of certain dimensions of both movements' and does not stop 'those of us who are interested in non-violent politics from raising the question of whether there are other options besides violence'. In 2012 she wrote that the remarks had been 'taken out of context': her 'first point was merely descriptive' (the groups 'define themselves as anti-imperialist'), and 'I have always been in favor of non-violent political action'.
historyJanet Afary and Kevin B. Anderson, Foucault and the Iranian Revolution: Gender and the Seductions of Islamism (University of Chicago Press, 2005), publisher's description (2005) finding β
Publisher's page read 29 Sept 2026 (the book itself not read). In 1978 Foucault 'was working as a special correspondent for Corriere della Sera and le Nouvel Observateur', 'traveled to Iran, met with leaders like Ayatollah Khomeini, and wrote a series of articles on the revolution'; the book includes 'annotated translations of the Iran writings in their entirety and the at times blistering responses from such contemporaneous critics as Middle East scholar Maxime Rodinson'; the authors 'illuminate Foucault's support of the Islamist movement'. The publisher calls the account 'important and controversial'.
pressChristian Science Monitor, 'Iranian crackdown deals communist party a heavy blow' (22 July 1983) (1983) incident β
Read (2026-09-28). Claude van England, Brussels, 22 July 1983: 'the other estimated 1,500 Tudeh members officially arrested'; the party 'outlawed' five days after an arrest on 27 April; Kianouri in a television interview, 'With the help of our members within the armed forces, we used to prepare reports for the Soviet government'; an exiled militant: 'They had been tortured'; a diplomat: 'They looked in good shape and in full control of themselves'; 'Having collaborated with the Islamic regime for several months, Iranian communists are hated by the opponents of the Islamic Republic'; People's Mujahideen: 'Hundreds of their members have been executed'; 'Islamic fundamentalists have become the only political force in the country'.
primary documentJudith Butler, remarks to an academic audience (reported as a 2006 UC Berkeley teach-in), excerpt via Grabien News ('Flashback', 30 October 2023) (2006) incident β
Read 29 Sept 2026. Grabien's transcript of the clip: 'Similarly, I think yes, understanding Hamas, Hezbollah as social movements that are progressive, that are on the left, that are part of a global left, is extremely important. That does not stop us from being critical of certain dimensions of both movements. It doesn't stop those of us who are interested in non-violent politics from raising the question of whether there are other options besides violence.' The excerpt gives no date or venue; Radical Archives (28 March 2010, before the 2012 controversy) places it in the Q&A of the 'Berkeley Teach-In Against War', 145 Dwinelle, 7 September (2006), quoting the organisers' announcement (2026-10-02). The old grabien.com/story URL was the clip page.
primary documentJudith Butler, 'Judith Butler responds to attack: "I affirm a Judaism that is not associated with state violence"', Mondoweiss (27 August 2012) (2012) incident β
Read 29 Sept 2026. Her reply to a Jerusalem Post article on her Adorno Prize; Mondoweiss (a pro-Palestinian site) published it. 'My remarks on Hamas and Hezbollah have been taken out of context and badly distort my established and continuing views. I have always been in favor of non-violent political action.' 'My first point was merely descriptive: those political organizations define themselves as anti-imperialist, and anti-imperialism is one characteristic of the global left, so on that basis one could describe them as part of the global left. My second point was then critical β¦ I do not accept or endorse all groups on the global left.' Re-read 2026-10-02: 'I was asked by a member of an academic audience a few years ago whether I thought Hamas and Hezbollah belonged to "the global left" and I replied with two points' β her own dating of the remarks, used on the page in place of the '2006' given only by later reports.
advocacy / viewChris Harman, 'The Prophet and the Proletariat', International Socialism Journal 2:64 (Autumn 1994) (1994) finding β
Read on the Marxists' Internet Archive: the rule 'with the Islamists sometimes, with the state never' (where the Islamists are in opposition), and its stated limit β defending 'women, gays, Berbers or Copts against some Islamists'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Where the Islamists are in opposition, our rule should be, "with the Islamists sometimes, with the state never". But even then we continue to disagree with the Islamists on basic issues'; 'as well as defending Islamists against the state we will also be involved in defending women, gays, Berbers or Copts against some Islamists'.
advocacy / viewAmnesty International, 'Iran committing crimes against humanity by concealing fate of thousands of slaughtered political dissidents' (press release on the report 'Blood-soaked secrets', 4 December 2018) (2018) finding β
Read (2026-09-28): 'at least 5,000 political dissidents were extrajudicially executed in a co-ordinated effort to eliminate political opposition', 'on the orders of at least one secret fatwa issued by the then Supreme Leader of Iran, Rouhollah Khomeini, which followed an armed incursion into Iran by the People's Mojahedin Organization of Iran (PMOI)'; 'The majority of the victims were affiliated with the PMOI, but hundreds of prisoners affiliated with leftist political organizations and Kurdish opposition groups were also executed.'
primary documentRadical Archives, 'Judith Butler on Hamas, Hezbollah & the Israel Lobby (2006)' (28 March 2010) (2010) incident β
Read 2026-10-02. Posted two years before the 2012 controversy: Butler's 'reply to a bundle of four questions asked in Q&A during a 2006 teach-in at UC Berkeley about the war between Israel and Hezbollah', with the audience questions and her answer transcribed (same wording as the clip); 'Berkeley Teach-In Against War β Part VI β Question and Answer Session'; the organisers' announcement (speakers Butler, Beshara Doumani, Charles Hirschkind, Saba Mahmood, Zeina Zaatari); 'The teach-in took place in 145 Dwinelle on September 7th'.
The seam in the alliance.
One Western partner's line is 'anti-Zionism isn't antisemitism; nobody here says that'. Allied voices sometimes state classic antisemitic ideas openly and sincerely, for example the chant 'Khaybar, Khaybar, ya Yahud', which recalls Muhammad's campaign against the Jews of Khaybar: a protester in London chanted 'Khaybar, Khaybar, O Jews, the army of the Muhammad will return' in November 2023, and police said they were looking to arrest the group (PBS NewsHour). When the two meet, the Western side denies it was said, translates it into politics ('they mean Zionists') or looks away: each keeps the alliance and loses the argument. Jewish progressives can pay first: in 2017 the Chicago Dyke March asked three marchers carrying rainbow flags with a Star of David to leave; one said 'as a Jew, I am not welcome here', and the organizers said they had called them 'Israeli flags superimposed on rainbow flags' and acted after the three 'repeatedly expressed support for Zionism' (The Advocate). Queer people are a sharper test still, welcomed in Western solidarity movements whose allies abroad would persecute them (see ''Queers for Palestine' is like chickens for KFC.').
Traps here:β Which Zionism?
pressThe Advocate, 'Pride Flags Bearing Star of David Barred in Chicago Dyke March' (25 June 2017) incident β
Read 2026-10-02. 'Three marchers carrying pride flags adorned with the Star of David say they were asked to leave'; told the flags 'made people feel unsafe' (via Windy City Times). The organizers' side, as posted: 'our decision to ask three individuals carrying Israeli flags superimposed on rainbow flags to leave the rally β¦ was made after they repeatedly expressed support for Zionism during conversations with Dyke March Collective members.' Shoshany-Anderson: 'as a Jew, I am not welcome here.' One of the three, Laurel Grauer, is a manager at A Wider Bridge, which 'advocates for "equality in Israel"'. Re-read 2026-10-12: Shoshany-Anderson, who 'was also asked to leave the march': 'I was here as a proud Jew in all of my identities' (to the Windy City Times).
pressPBS NewsHour, 'Tensions rise in U.K. amid large-scale protests over Israel-Hamas war' (13 November 2023) incident β
Read 2026-10-02 (transcript). A protester (through interpreter): 'Khaybar, Khaybar, O Jews, the army of the Muhammad will return'; correspondent Malcolm Brabant: 'The police say they're looking to arrest this group'; 'The antisemitic chant threatens Jews with the return of Mohammed's army'; 'The government is considering outlawing this chant'. The same report notes police and some ministers blamed the home secretary for 'whipping up hatred before the demonstration'.
There is no single 'left', and the tool-use runs every way.
Most of the Arab left was secular and fought the Islamists: Nasser jailed and executed Muslim Brotherhood leaders, the Baath parties crushed them, and the Palestinian left (the PFLP, the DFLP) was a rival of Hamas. Much of the Western left has criticised Islamism sharply. And using Islamists as a tool isn't a leftist habit only: according to US officials quoted by UPI in 2002, Israel from the late 1970s gave 'direct and indirect financial aid' to the Islamists who became Hamas, 'as a counterbalance to the PLO' (the analyst Anthony Cordesman's words), and Gaza's former military governor Yitzhak Segev reportedly told US officials he had helped fund 'Islamic movements as a counterweight to the PLO and communists'; an Israeli defence official asked by UPI would not confirm it. Later Israeli governments allowed Qatari money into Hamas-run Gaza (CNN: from 2018 Qatar made monthly payments, some $15 million of it in cash-filled suitcases, approved by Israel's security cabinet that August; the former senior defence official Amos Gilad said there was 'some belief that it would "weaken Palestinian sovereignty"', while an Israeli official called the suggestion that Netanyahu wanted a 'moderately weakened' Hamas 'utterly false' and said the money was meant 'to prevent a humanitarian crisis'). Some Christian Zionist support also treats Jews as instruments of an end-times plan (see the end-times theme). Zionism itself began largely on the left, in the kibbutzim and the labour movement, and it was the post-1967 New Left that recast Israel from a socialist experiment into a colonial outpost.
Traps here:β "They allβ¦"
pressRichard Sale, 'Analysis: Hamas history tied to Israel', UPI (18 June 2002) finding β
Read 2026-10-02. 'according to several current and former U.S. intelligence officials, beginning in the late 1970s, Tel Aviv gave direct and indirect financial aid to Hamas over a period of years'; Tony Cordesman: Israel 'aided Hamas directly -- the Israelis wanted to use it as a counterbalance to the PLO'; a former senior CIA official: 'a direct attempt to divide and dilute support for a strong, secular PLO'; a US report that 'Brig. Gen. Yithaq Segev, the military governor of Gaza, had told U.S. officials he had helped fund "Islamic movements as a counterweight to the PLO and communists"'. Other half: an Israeli defence official asked whether Israel had aided Hamas: 'I am not able to answer that question'; he could confirm only that Segev had served in 1986. Most sources are anonymous US officials; no Israeli confirmation in the article.
pressCNN, 'Qatar sent millions to Gaza for years β with Israel's backing' (11 December 2023) incident β
Read 2026-10-02 (served from edition.cnn.com). 'In 2018, Qatar began making monthly payments to the Gaza Strip. Some $15 million were sent into Gaza in cash-filled suitcases'; 'Israel approved the deal in a security cabinet meeting in August 2018'. Amos Gilad, former senior Defence Ministry official: backed by the prime minister 'but not by the Israeli intelligence community'; 'some belief that it would "weaken Palestinian sovereignty"'. Other half: an Israeli official called any suggestion that Netanyahu wanted a 'moderately weakened' Hamas 'utterly false'; 'Successive Israeli governments β¦ enabled money to go to Gaza. Not in order to strengthen Hamas but to prevent a humanitarian crisis'. Naftali Bennett says he 'stopped the cash suitcases' in 2021.
Working it out: how long the alliances lasted, and who paid when they ended.
The card's question, 'does the other partner survive the day after victory?', has two cases on this page with dates, one from each direction. Iran: leftists and the People's Mujahedin joined the revolution of 1979. About four years later, in 1983, an estimated 1,500 members of the communist Tudeh party were arrested and the party outlawed, while 'hundreds' of the Mujahedin had already been executed; about nine years later, in 1988, 'at least 5,000 political dissidents' were executed, mostly Mujahedin and 'hundreds' from leftist and Kurdish groups (Amnesty). The junior partners paid with their lives. Israel and the Islamists: according to anonymous US officials quoted by UPI in 2002, Israel from the late 1970s gave aid to the Islamists who became Hamas, 'as a counterbalance to the PLO'; an Israeli defence official would not answer, and the article has no Israeli confirmation. Hamas emerged in 1987, about a decade later; in 2023 its militants 'killed about 1,200 people, mostly civilians' in Israel (AP); in 2018 Israel's cabinet approved Qatari cash into Gaza, which an Israeli official said was to avert a humanitarian crisis, not to strengthen Hamas. Here the patron paid. The pattern in both: a partner chosen for usefulness against a common enemy outgrew the plan of the one who chose it. The worst case for each side. For 'the left's alliance with Islamists is harmless': the best-documented precedent ended with the left's partners in prison or executed within a decade; the theory behind such alliances, 'with the Islamists sometimes, with the state never', named its own limit, defending 'women, gays, Berbers or Copts against some Islamists' (Chris Harman, 1994); and in Britain the Respect coalition, formed in 2004 by 'leftwing campaigners banding together with members of Muslim organisations', split in 2007 into two conferences on the same day (BBC), a far milder end, but an end. For 'only the left makes this mistake': the Israeli case, on the evidence as reported, ran the same way, with the partner becoming the enemy; and the label itself is a weapon too: a progressive media watchdog argues that right-wing media use 'red-green alliance', 'a supposed pact between communists and Islamists', to bind their own coalition together (Media Matters), so the phrase needs the named organisations and statements behind it. Holds on the evidence here: alliances of convenience against a common enemy have ended badly for the partner who misjudged the other's aims, on both sides of this conflict. Open, needs Israeli sources: the scale and intent of the early aid. Not supported: that every coalition with an ideological opponent ends this way, or that the Israeli aid created Hamas on its own; Hamas grew from the Muslim Brotherhood.
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable β¦) mean
pressChristian Science Monitor, 'Iranian crackdown deals communist party a heavy blow' (22 July 1983) (1983) incident β
Read (2026-09-28). Claude van England, Brussels, 22 July 1983: 'the other estimated 1,500 Tudeh members officially arrested'; the party 'outlawed' five days after an arrest on 27 April; Kianouri in a television interview, 'With the help of our members within the armed forces, we used to prepare reports for the Soviet government'; an exiled militant: 'They had been tortured'; a diplomat: 'They looked in good shape and in full control of themselves'; 'Having collaborated with the Islamic regime for several months, Iranian communists are hated by the opponents of the Islamic Republic'; People's Mujahideen: 'Hundreds of their members have been executed'; 'Islamic fundamentalists have become the only political force in the country'.
advocacy / viewAmnesty International, 'Iran committing crimes against humanity by concealing fate of thousands of slaughtered political dissidents' (press release on the report 'Blood-soaked secrets', 4 December 2018) (2018) finding β
Read (2026-09-28): 'at least 5,000 political dissidents were extrajudicially executed in a co-ordinated effort to eliminate political opposition', 'on the orders of at least one secret fatwa issued by the then Supreme Leader of Iran, Rouhollah Khomeini, which followed an armed incursion into Iran by the People's Mojahedin Organization of Iran (PMOI)'; 'The majority of the victims were affiliated with the PMOI, but hundreds of prisoners affiliated with leftist political organizations and Kurdish opposition groups were also executed.'
pressRichard Sale, 'Analysis: Hamas history tied to Israel', UPI (18 June 2002) finding β
Read 2026-10-02. 'according to several current and former U.S. intelligence officials, beginning in the late 1970s, Tel Aviv gave direct and indirect financial aid to Hamas over a period of years'; Tony Cordesman: Israel 'aided Hamas directly -- the Israelis wanted to use it as a counterbalance to the PLO'; a former senior CIA official: 'a direct attempt to divide and dilute support for a strong, secular PLO'; a US report that 'Brig. Gen. Yithaq Segev, the military governor of Gaza, had told U.S. officials he had helped fund "Islamic movements as a counterweight to the PLO and communists"'. Other half: an Israeli defence official asked whether Israel had aided Hamas: 'I am not able to answer that question'; he could confirm only that Segev had served in 1986. Most sources are anonymous US officials; no Israeli confirmation in the article.
primary documentPublic Safety Canada, 'Currently listed entities': Hamas and Hizballah (Hizballah entry last reviewed 4 June 2026) (2026) finding β
Read (cached 2026-09-29; re-read 2026-09-30). Hizballah: 'a Lebanon-based radical Shia Islamic terrorist group ideologically inspired by the Iranian revolution β¦ its goals are the establishment of a revolutionary Shia Islamic state in Lebanon, the liberation of Jerusalem, and the destruction of Israel. Formed in 1982 following Israel's invasion of Lebanon'. Hamas: 'emerged from the Palestinian branch of the Muslim Brotherhood in 1987'. A government terrorist listing: the Canadian government's own perspective.
pressCNN, 'Qatar sent millions to Gaza for years β with Israel's backing' (11 December 2023) incident β
Read 2026-10-02 (served from edition.cnn.com). 'In 2018, Qatar began making monthly payments to the Gaza Strip. Some $15 million were sent into Gaza in cash-filled suitcases'; 'Israel approved the deal in a security cabinet meeting in August 2018'. Amos Gilad, former senior Defence Ministry official: backed by the prime minister 'but not by the Israeli intelligence community'; 'some belief that it would "weaken Palestinian sovereignty"'. Other half: an Israeli official called any suggestion that Netanyahu wanted a 'moderately weakened' Hamas 'utterly false'; 'Successive Israeli governments β¦ enabled money to go to Gaza. Not in order to strengthen Hamas but to prevent a humanitarian crisis'. Naftali Bennett says he 'stopped the cash suitcases' in 2021.
pressAP (via PBS NewsHour), 'Videos of Israeli soldiers acting maliciously emerge amid international outcry against tactics in Gaza' (13 December 2023) (2023) incident β
Read 2026-10-02. Videos apparently uploaded by soldiers: ransacking a toy store, trying to burn food and water supplies, prayer rugs moved into a bathroom, a dance with the chant βthere are no people who are uninvolvedβ (AP verified backgrounds, uniforms and language). The army βpledged to take disciplinary action in what it says are a handful of isolated casesβ; spokesman Daniel Hagari: βIn any event that does not align with IDF values, command and disciplinary steps will be takenβ. BβTselemβs Dror Sadot: βThe dehumanization from the top is very much sinking down to the soldiersβ. Yinon Magal, who posted the dance video, defended it and condemned the toy-store video. The article also notes the U.S. and other militaries have had similar videos, and Hamasβs hostage and 7 October bodycam videos. The article's background lines (read 2026-10-02 re-check, 2026-10-10): Hamas militants 'killed about 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and took about 240 hostages'; 'About 90 percent of Gaza's 2.3 million people have been displaced'.
advocacy / viewChris Harman, 'The Prophet and the Proletariat', International Socialism Journal 2:64 (Autumn 1994) (1994) finding β
Read on the Marxists' Internet Archive: the rule 'with the Islamists sometimes, with the state never' (where the Islamists are in opposition), and its stated limit β defending 'women, gays, Berbers or Copts against some Islamists'. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Where the Islamists are in opposition, our rule should be, "with the Islamists sometimes, with the state never". But even then we continue to disagree with the Islamists on basic issues'; 'as well as defending Islamists against the state we will also be involved in defending women, gays, Berbers or Copts against some Islamists'.
pressBBC News, 'Profile: Respect Party' (5 April 2010) (2010) incident β
Read 2026-09-29. 'The Respect coalition was formed in the aftermath of the biggest anti-war demonstration in British history'; 'leftwing campaigners banding together with members of Muslim organisations, in many cases for the first time, under the Stop the War coalition banner β¦ leading in 2004 to the formation of Respect - the Unity Coalition.'
pressBBC News, 'Rival events for Respect factions' (17 November 2007) (2007) incident β
Read 2026-09-29. 'A split within the ranks of the anti-war Respect coalition has led to the party holding two separate conferences on the same day. The two factions comprise MP George Galloway and his supporters on one side and representatives of the Socialist Workers' Party on the other.'
advocacy / viewMedia Matters for America, 'The MAGA media fixation on the "red-green alliance" is an attempt to hold a fracturing coalition together' (2026) (2026) finding β
Read 2026-09-29 (progressive US media watchdog; the page's date is unclear, August or September 2026). Right-wing media use 'the phrase "red-green alliance" β that is, a supposed pact between communists and Islamists', alongside 'Marxist jihadist'; argues MAGA media 'is going all in on Islamophobia and the threat of socialism as a way of binding their fracturing coalition together'.
Why it works on us
- Coalitions against a common opponent are ordinary politics, and some have done good: the anti-apartheid movement joined very different forces.
- Both movements speak a language of liberation and resistance, so the overlap in slogans can look like an overlap in goals.
- A tradition on the revolutionary left holds that the old order has to be torn down before anything new can be built, which makes any force that tears down look like an ally.