Theme

β€œAnti-Zionism before 1948: a real debate”

Before Israel existed, opposing a Jewish state was a respectable position, held by many Jews and by the land's Arabs. After 1948 the same word came to mean undoing a state where millions live.

  1. Why people find it convincing

    • Many of the most prominent Jewish voices of the late 19th and early 20th centuries opposed Zionism, for religious, political or patriotic reasons.
    • The Arabs of Palestine opposed a Jewish national home in their country from the start, as most peoples would.
    • Today's anti-Zionists, including some Jewish groups, point to this history as their pedigree.
  2. The picture

    Jewish anti-Zionism was mainstream.

    Reform Judaism's Pittsburgh Platform (1885) declared: 'We consider ourselves no longer a nation, but a religious community, and therefore expect neither a return to Palestine … nor the restoration of any of the laws concerning the Jewish state.' The Bund, the Jewish socialist party founded in Vilna in 1897 (the same year as Herzl's Basel congress), fought for Jewish rights and Yiddish culture where Jews lived, doykeit or 'hereness', and saw Zionism as escapism. Much of Orthodoxy held that only the Messiah could restore Zion; the Talmud's 'Three Oaths' (Ketubot 110b–111a) include that the Jews 'should not return to the Land of Israel be-homah – "like a wall"', which Rashi reads as 'by force, all together'; the Maharsha reads it as building an actual wall, a rebellion, which 'could not be done without the permission of the nations that ruled over the land', as with Ezra and Nehemiah (Steinsaltz Center). Anti-Zionist Haredi groups still cite the oath as forbidding a return 'en masse, by force of arms or organized political conquest' (torahjews.org). Agudat Yisrael was founded in Poland in 1912 'to serve as a political tool that would assist in preserving the ultra-Orthodox lifestyle and in insulating that lifestyle from modernity and Zionism'; after the Second World War it 'even cooperated with state institutions to some extent', and a minister from its ranks sat in Israel's first governments until 1952 (Israel Democracy Institute). In 1917 Edwin Montagu, a Jewish member of the British government, wrote in a memorandum submitted to the cabinet that the policy behind the Balfour Declaration was 'anti-Semitic in result and will prove a rallying ground for Anti-Semites in every country in the world' β€” not deliberately so, he stressed β€” fearing it would mark British Jews as foreigners, and predicting that 'every country will immediately desire to get rid of its Jewish citizens, and you will find a population in Palestine driving out its present inhabitants'.

    primary documentCentral Conference of American Rabbis, 'Declaration of Principles' ('The Pittsburgh Platform', 1885) (1885) βœ“

    Read 2026-09-30 on the CCAR's own site. Point 5: 'We consider ourselves no longer a nation, but a religious community, and therefore expect neither a return to Palestine, nor a sacrificial worship under the sons of Aaron, nor the restoration of any of the laws concerning the Jewish state.' Adopted by Reform rabbis meeting 16–19 November 1885, Isaac Mayer Wise presiding. Also on the Jewish Virtual Library (https://jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-pittsburgh-platform), read earlier.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentEdwin Montagu, 'The Anti-Semitism of the Present Government' (cabinet memorandum, 23 August 1917) (1917) incident βœ“

    Read (JVL text): the policy is 'anti-Semitic in result and will prove a rallying ground for Anti-Semites in every country in the world'; 'not … suggesting that the Government is deliberately anti-Semitic'; Zionism 'a mischievous political creed'. Re-read 2026-10-10: page title 'Memorandum of Edwin Montagu on the Anti-Semitism of the Present (British) Government - Submitted to the British Cabinet, August 1917'; Montagu: 'before I became a member of the Government'; 'I assert that there is not a Jewish nation'; 'When the Jews are told that Palestine is their national home, every country will immediately desire to get rid of its Jewish citizens'. The page does not say he was the only Jewish member of the cabinet. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'When the Jews are told that Palestine is their national home, every country will immediately desire to get rid of its Jewish citizens, and you will find a population in Palestine driving out its present inhabitants, taking all the best in the country'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Bund' (from the Encyclopaedia Judaica) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-29). Jewish socialist party founded in Russia in 1897, associated with 'devotion to Yiddish, autonomism, and secular Jewish nationalism'; 'defined Zionism as reactionary and bourgeois'; 'pursued its relentless campaign against Zionism and religious Orthodoxy'; 'The Polish Bund achieved its greatest political influence between 1936 and 1939, on the eve of the Holocaust'; after the war the Bund in the US 'did not recognize the special importance of the State of Israel'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceIsrael Democracy Institute, 'Agudat Yisrael' (party profile) βœ“

    Read 29 Sept 2026. 'Agudat Yisrael was founded in Poland in 1912 and was intended to serve as a political tool that would assist in preserving the ultra-Orthodox lifestyle and in insulating that lifestyle from modernity and Zionism. After World War II, the party's center of operations moved to Israel, where Agudat Yisrael even cooperated with state institutions to some extent.' 'a minister from its ranks served in the first governments of Israel until 1952'.

    Open source β†—

    scriptureSteinsaltz Center, 'Ketubot 111a-b: Oaths That Bind' (daf yomi commentary) βœ“

    Read 29 Sept 2026. Rabbi Yosei bar Hanina's three oaths from Song of Songs: the Jews 'should not return to the Land of Israel be-homah – "like a wall"'; 'should not rebel against the nations'; the nations 'should not oppress the Jewish people overmuch'. 'Rashi interprets the first oath to mean that the Jewish people should not return to Israel by force, all together'; 'The Maharsha argues that it refers to the actual building of a wall – which would indicate a rebellion against the ruling nation. Such building could not be done without the permission of the nations that ruled over the land, as took place with the return of Ezra and Nehemia'.

    Open source β†—

    advocacy / viewTorah Jews (torahjews.org), 'The Three Oaths' incident βœ“

    Read 29 Sept 2026. Perspective: an anti-Zionist Haredi site that also presents Vayoel Moshe. 'Oath the first: Not to ascend as a wall. Israel shall not return to the Land en masse, by force of arms or organized political conquest.'

    Open source β†—

    Arab opposition was the natural position of the people already there.

    The land's Arab majority opposed large-scale Jewish immigration and a Jewish national home from the first years. The Jaffa newspaper Filastin (1911) and the Palestine Arab congresses from 1919 argued it politically, and the revolts of 1920–21, 1929 and 1936–39 turned it violent. Whatever one thinks of the violence, opposing the transformation of one's country by immigration is a position most peoples would recognise.

    referenceInstitute for Palestine Studies, PalQuest, 'Isa al-Isa' (biography) (1911) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28): 'In January 1911, he founded the newspaper Filastin, which began as a twice-weekly publication and was principally concerned with the welfare of the Orthodox community; later it warned of the dangers of Zionism'; closed by the Ottoman authorities in October 1913; signed the statement of 12 December 1918 to the Paris Peace Conference and the British Foreign Office 'protesting the Zionist movement's attempt to turn Palestine into a Jewish National Home'; co-founded the Muslim-Christian Association in Jaffa to oppose the Balfour Declaration. Archive issues of Filastin: National Library of Israel's historical Arabic press collection (not consulted here). Re-read 2026-10-12: 'In October 1913, the Ottoman authorities closed down his newspaper, claiming that it had published articles inciting ethnic prejudice.'

    Open source β†—

    What changed in 1948, and what didn't.

    The Holocaust 'changed many opinions about Zionism', as My Jewish Learning puts it. The Bund's world was murdered: the Polish Bund, which had pursued 'its relentless campaign against Zionism', 'achieved its greatest political influence between 1936 and 1939, on the eve of the Holocaust' (Jewish Virtual Library, from the Encyclopaedia Judaica). Reform Judaism had already moved to support a Jewish homeland (the Columbus Platform of 1937 affirmed 'the obligation of all Jewry to aid in its upbuilding as a Jewish homeland', 'a haven of refuge for the oppressed' and 'a center of Jewish culture'; it said homeland, not state), and once the state existed 'even Agudat Israel, the political arm of ultra-Orthodoxy, began participating in the Israeli government', while Neturei Karta 'broke from Agudat Israel' in response (My Jewish Learning). After 1948 the question changed. It was no longer whether there should be a Jewish state, but what should happen to the one that existed, with its millions of citizens; today Israeli Jews are 'roughly evenly divided' between Ashkenazi Jews, with roots in Central and Eastern Europe, and Sephardi or Mizrahi Jews, with roots mostly around the Mediterranean and the Middle East (Pew, 2016). Pre-1948 anti-Zionism argued about a plan; anti-Zionism today argues about undoing a country. Some Jewish groups (the Satmar Hasidim, Neturei Karta, which says 'The Torah forbids Jews from having their own sovereignty', and on the left Jewish Voice for Peace) carry the older positions on, and can be held up as proof that anti-Zionism can't be antisemitic (see 'Identity as authority'). The history is real. It shows that opposing Zionism once was, and in a sense still can be, a Jewish position. It doesn't settle what opposing Israel's existence means now.

    Traps here:β—† Identity as authorityβ—† Which Zionism?β—† Judging by origin

    advocacy / viewNeturei Karta International, 'Mission statement' βœ“

    Read (2026-09-29). Describes itself as 'representing many Jews worldwide' who 'reject the legitimacy of the existence of the State of Israel'. 'Jews are in exile … We are forbidden to wage wars or rebel against any people, nation, or country. The Torah forbids Jews from having their own sovereignty. Exile can only end miraculously, by G-d alone, without any human intervention.' Its size is not given there.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentCentral Conference of American Rabbis, 'The Guiding Principles of Reform Judaism' ('The Columbus Platform', 1937) (1937) βœ“

    Read 2026-09-30 on the CCAR's own site. 'In all lands where our people live, they assume and seek to share loyally the full duties and responsibilities of citizenship'; 'In the rehabilitation of Palestine, the land hallowed by memories and hopes, we behold the promise of renewed life for many of our brethren. We affirm the obligation of all Jewry to aid in its upbuilding as a Jewish homeland by endeavoring to make it not only a haven of refuge for the oppressed but also a center of Jewish culture and spiritual life.' Also on the Jewish Virtual Library (https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-columbus-platform-1937), read earlier.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Bund' (from the Encyclopaedia Judaica) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-29). Jewish socialist party founded in Russia in 1897, associated with 'devotion to Yiddish, autonomism, and secular Jewish nationalism'; 'defined Zionism as reactionary and bourgeois'; 'pursued its relentless campaign against Zionism and religious Orthodoxy'; 'The Polish Bund achieved its greatest political influence between 1936 and 1939, on the eve of the Holocaust'; after the war the Bund in the US 'did not recognize the special importance of the State of Israel'.

    Open source β†—

    dataPew Research Center, 'Israel's Religiously Divided Society' (8 March 2016) (2016) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28). 5,601 face-to-face interviews, Oct 2014 – May 2015. 'Israeli Jews are roughly evenly divided between two types of ethnic identity: Ashkenazi Jews (with ancestral roots in Central and Eastern Europe) and Sephardi or Mizrahi Jews (with roots mostly in Spain, elsewhere around the Mediterranean or the Middle East).' Also: asked whether 'Arabs should be expelled or transferred from Israel', Israeli Jews 'strongly agree (21%) or agree (27%), while a similar share disagree (29%) or strongly disagree (17%)'; 'Roughly seven-in-ten (71%)' of Datiim agree, 'Most (58%)' of Hilonim disagree (re-read 2026-09-30). Also: 'Most Israeli Jews (79%) say Jews deserve preferential treatment in Israel'; 'Roughly eight-in-ten Israeli Arabs (79%) say there is a lot of discrimination in Israeli society against Muslims'; 'the vast majority (74%) [of Jews] say they do not see much discrimination against Muslims'; majorities of all four Jewish subgroups say Israel can be both Jewish and democratic; 'Israeli Arabs generally do not think Israel can be a Jewish state and a democracy at the same time'. Also read 2026-10-10: 'About nine-in-ten Haredim (91%), eight-in-ten Datiim (80%) and roughly six-in-ten Masortim (59%) consider themselves Jewish first, while about six-in-ten Hilonim (59%) take the opposite position, saying they see themselves as Israeli first'; if halakha and democratic principles conflict, '89% of Haredim say halakha should be given preference', while 'among Hilonim, an equally lopsided share (89%) say the state should give preference to democratic principles'; 'The vast majority of Jews (98%), Muslims (85%), Christians (86%) and Druze (83%) say all or most of their close friends belong to their own religious community.'

    Open source β†—

    referenceMy Jewish Learning, 'Questioning Zionism' βœ“

    Read 2026-10-02 (Jewish educational site). 'the Holocaust and the rise of European anti-Semitism that preceded it changed many opinions about Zionism. As dreams of universal brotherhood crumbled, the Reform movement embraced the idea of a Jewish state'; 'Once the state was established, even Agudat Israel, the political arm of ultra-Orthodoxy, began participating in the Israeli government. In response to this, a radical anti-Zionist group known as Neturei Karta broke from Agudat Israel'; Buber 'decided to support the Jewish state, particularly in light of the Holocaust', while urging the return of refugees.

    Open source β†—

    Working it out: where each pre-1948 current went, and what that does to today's argument.

    Today's argument often runs: 'Jews opposed Zionism before 1948, so opposing Israel now is a Jewish position, not an anti-Jewish one.' The record lets each current be followed. Reform: in 1885 'no longer a nation, but a religious community', expecting 'neither a return to Palestine'; by 1937 'the obligation of all Jewry to aid in its upbuilding as a Jewish homeland'. The Bund: at its greatest influence 'between 1936 and 1939, on the eve of the Holocaust', and then its world was murdered. Orthodoxy: Agudat Yisrael, founded in 1912 to shield its way of life 'from modernity and Zionism', had a minister in Israel's first governments 'until 1952'; Neturei Karta broke away in response and still says 'The Torah forbids Jews from having their own sovereignty', but its size is not given in its own statement. The assimilationist: Edwin Montagu, a Jewish member of the British government, warned in 1917 that the policy would be 'anti-Semitic in result', a fear about where Jews outside Palestine would stand. Arab opposition followed a different line: it was the position of the people already there, argued in Filastin from 1911 and in the congresses from 1919, and it did not change with the Holocaust. The worst case for each side. For 'anti-Zionism is antisemitism, full stop': before 1948, much of organised Jewry was anti-Zionist, for religious, socialist or civic reasons, and Arab opposition was a local people's objection. For 'today's anti-Zionism continues the Jewish tradition': the main Jewish currents moved towards a homeland or into the state after the Holocaust, and the question changed from a plan to a country with millions of citizens; the groups that carry the older position on are small or, like Neturei Karta, give no size. Holds on the evidence here: pre-1948 anti-Zionism was mainstream among Jews and natural among Palestine's Arabs; most of the Jewish currents changed after the Holocaust and 1948. Holds only case by case: a present-day anti-Zionism that, like the pre-1948 Jewish kinds, has a positive programme for Jews where they live. Not supported: using the pre-1948 Jewish debate as proof about present-day positions, in either direction.

    What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean

    primary documentCentral Conference of American Rabbis, 'Declaration of Principles' ('The Pittsburgh Platform', 1885) (1885) βœ“

    Read 2026-09-30 on the CCAR's own site. Point 5: 'We consider ourselves no longer a nation, but a religious community, and therefore expect neither a return to Palestine, nor a sacrificial worship under the sons of Aaron, nor the restoration of any of the laws concerning the Jewish state.' Adopted by Reform rabbis meeting 16–19 November 1885, Isaac Mayer Wise presiding. Also on the Jewish Virtual Library (https://jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-pittsburgh-platform), read earlier.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentCentral Conference of American Rabbis, 'The Guiding Principles of Reform Judaism' ('The Columbus Platform', 1937) (1937) βœ“

    Read 2026-09-30 on the CCAR's own site. 'In all lands where our people live, they assume and seek to share loyally the full duties and responsibilities of citizenship'; 'In the rehabilitation of Palestine, the land hallowed by memories and hopes, we behold the promise of renewed life for many of our brethren. We affirm the obligation of all Jewry to aid in its upbuilding as a Jewish homeland by endeavoring to make it not only a haven of refuge for the oppressed but also a center of Jewish culture and spiritual life.' Also on the Jewish Virtual Library (https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-columbus-platform-1937), read earlier.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Bund' (from the Encyclopaedia Judaica) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-29). Jewish socialist party founded in Russia in 1897, associated with 'devotion to Yiddish, autonomism, and secular Jewish nationalism'; 'defined Zionism as reactionary and bourgeois'; 'pursued its relentless campaign against Zionism and religious Orthodoxy'; 'The Polish Bund achieved its greatest political influence between 1936 and 1939, on the eve of the Holocaust'; after the war the Bund in the US 'did not recognize the special importance of the State of Israel'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceIsrael Democracy Institute, 'Agudat Yisrael' (party profile) βœ“

    Read 29 Sept 2026. 'Agudat Yisrael was founded in Poland in 1912 and was intended to serve as a political tool that would assist in preserving the ultra-Orthodox lifestyle and in insulating that lifestyle from modernity and Zionism. After World War II, the party's center of operations moved to Israel, where Agudat Yisrael even cooperated with state institutions to some extent.' 'a minister from its ranks served in the first governments of Israel until 1952'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceMy Jewish Learning, 'Questioning Zionism' βœ“

    Read 2026-10-02 (Jewish educational site). 'the Holocaust and the rise of European anti-Semitism that preceded it changed many opinions about Zionism. As dreams of universal brotherhood crumbled, the Reform movement embraced the idea of a Jewish state'; 'Once the state was established, even Agudat Israel, the political arm of ultra-Orthodoxy, began participating in the Israeli government. In response to this, a radical anti-Zionist group known as Neturei Karta broke from Agudat Israel'; Buber 'decided to support the Jewish state, particularly in light of the Holocaust', while urging the return of refugees.

    Open source β†—

    advocacy / viewNeturei Karta International, 'Mission statement' βœ“

    Read (2026-09-29). Describes itself as 'representing many Jews worldwide' who 'reject the legitimacy of the existence of the State of Israel'. 'Jews are in exile … We are forbidden to wage wars or rebel against any people, nation, or country. The Torah forbids Jews from having their own sovereignty. Exile can only end miraculously, by G-d alone, without any human intervention.' Its size is not given there.

    Open source β†—

    primary documentEdwin Montagu, 'The Anti-Semitism of the Present Government' (cabinet memorandum, 23 August 1917) (1917) incident βœ“

    Read (JVL text): the policy is 'anti-Semitic in result and will prove a rallying ground for Anti-Semites in every country in the world'; 'not … suggesting that the Government is deliberately anti-Semitic'; Zionism 'a mischievous political creed'. Re-read 2026-10-10: page title 'Memorandum of Edwin Montagu on the Anti-Semitism of the Present (British) Government - Submitted to the British Cabinet, August 1917'; Montagu: 'before I became a member of the Government'; 'I assert that there is not a Jewish nation'; 'When the Jews are told that Palestine is their national home, every country will immediately desire to get rid of its Jewish citizens'. The page does not say he was the only Jewish member of the cabinet. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'When the Jews are told that Palestine is their national home, every country will immediately desire to get rid of its Jewish citizens, and you will find a population in Palestine driving out its present inhabitants, taking all the best in the country'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceInstitute for Palestine Studies, PalQuest, 'Isa al-Isa' (biography) (1911) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28): 'In January 1911, he founded the newspaper Filastin, which began as a twice-weekly publication and was principally concerned with the welfare of the Orthodox community; later it warned of the dangers of Zionism'; closed by the Ottoman authorities in October 1913; signed the statement of 12 December 1918 to the Paris Peace Conference and the British Foreign Office 'protesting the Zionist movement's attempt to turn Palestine into a Jewish National Home'; co-founded the Muslim-Christian Association in Jaffa to oppose the Balfour Declaration. Archive issues of Filastin: National Library of Israel's historical Arabic press collection (not consulted here). Re-read 2026-10-12: 'In October 1913, the Ottoman authorities closed down his newspaper, claiming that it had published articles inciting ethnic prejudice.'

    Open source β†—

Where this argument points

This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions β€” for, against or around them:

On the timeline

Keep exploring

From the archive

How newspapers reported related events at the time β€” suggested by the archive's own tags, not yet reviewed for this argument. Open a scan and judge for yourself.

Scans: kvetch-of-the-day news archive.