Argument · heard from pro-Palestinian voices

“Jews don't need a state — they should live as equal citizens wherever they're from.”

Zionism accepted the antisemites' premise that Jews don't belong in Europe. The Jewish Bund had it right: 'here, where we live, is our country'. Jews should fight for equal rights where they live, not take someone else's land. And Israelis could go back to where their families came from.

Made publicly as a pro-Palestinian argument by Helen Thomas

Where it's been said

“Tell them to get the hell out of Palestine. … They should go home [to] Poland, Germany … and America and everywhere else.”
Helen Thomas, White House correspondent, Hearst columnist — Remarks to Rabbi David Nesenoff of Rabbilive.com, filmed at the White House, as reported by CNN; she apologised days later and retired, 2010-05-27 ✓

Traps in play:◆ Judging by origin◆ The strict enemy frame

  1. Why people find it convincing

    • The Bund, founded in 1897, built a mass movement on doykeit, 'hereness': Jewish rights, Yiddish culture and socialism where Jews already lived. In Warsaw's December 1938 city elections, 'of twenty Jewish councilmen elected to the hundred-member City Council, the Bund and its allied trade unions won seventeen seats'.
    • American Reform Judaism said it in 1885: 'We consider ourselves no longer a nation, but a religious community, and therefore expect neither a return to Palestine, nor a sacrificial worship under the sons of Aaron, nor the restoration of any of the laws concerning the Jewish state' (the Pittsburgh Platform, Central Conference of American Rabbis). The same body changed course in 1937, affirming 'the obligation of all Jewry to aid in its upbuilding as a Jewish homeland', while holding that 'In all lands where our people live, they assume and seek to share loyally the full duties and responsibilities of citizenship' (the Columbus Platform).
    • Most of the world's Jews still live outside Israel: of 15.7 million in 2023, 'about 8.5 million live outside Israel, with approximately 6.3 million of them living in the United States' (Jewish Agency, from Sergio DellaPergola's figures).
    • Zionism's founder expected antisemites to help him. In his diary for June 1895, planning how emigration would be organised, Theodor Herzl wrote: 'The anti-Semites will become our most dependable friends, the anti-Semitic countries our allies.' On this argument's reading, that shows a movement that accepted the antisemites' premise that Jews did not belong where they lived.
    • A new generation of Jewish writers and activists has revived the Bund's idea, for example Molly Crabapple's history of the Bund, 'Here Where We Live Is Our Country' (Random House, April 2026), which its publisher calls a 'radical vision of solidarity in an age of division'.
  2. What's true

    'hereness' is a real Jewish tradition, and diaspora life can flourish.

    The Bund was no fringe group. It was a mass Jewish party that fought for equal rights and dignity in Poland and Russia and organised Jewish self-defence against pogroms. Its idea that Jews belong where they live, as equal citizens, is the principle liberal democracies profess, and much of Jewish life in the diaspora today rests on it. As Bruce Robbins summarises Crabapple’s history, for the Bund Zionism ‘gave local antisemites a convenient means of eliminating the Jewish population’, encouraging Eastern European Jews ‘to give up the fight … and move elsewhere’; Irving Howe put the Bund’s opposition down mainly to Zionism being a ‘utopian fantasy’, and Robbins names the Bund’s internationalism as the main reason (The Nation, 8 September 2026). Robbins writes as a sympathiser: he concludes that ‘the Bundists, though defeated, were not wrong’.

    historyWarsaw municipal elections, December 1938: the Bund wins 17 of 20 seats won by Jewish parties (1938) aggregate ✓

    Diana Scott, 'The Jewish Bund at Its Peak', Jewish Currents (2017), read: the Bund and allied trade unions won 17 of 20 Jewish seats on the 100-member Warsaw City Council, December 1938.

    Open source ↗

    historyMolly Crabapple, 'Here Where We Live Is Our Country: The Story of the Jewish Bund' (Random House, 7 April 2026), publisher's page (2026) finding ✓

    Read (2026-09-28): published 7 April 2026, 480 pages; 'The dramatic story of the Jewish Bund—a revolutionary movement from a vanished world—and its radical vision of solidarity in an age of division'; listed as a New York Times bestseller.

    Open source ↗

    advocacy / viewBruce Robbins, 'The Bund and the Radical History of Jewish Anti-Zionism', The Nation (8 September 2026; October 2026 issue) (2026) ✓

    Read 2026-10-02. Review of Molly Crabapple's 'Here Where We Live Is Our Country' by a Columbia humanities professor. Summary of the Bund's view: Zionism ‘gave local antisemites a convenient means of eliminating the Jewish population’ and encouraged Eastern European Jews ‘to give up the fight (to the Zionists, a losing fight) and move elsewhere’; doikayt, ‘hereness’. Notes Irving Howe's view that the Bund opposed Zionism as a ‘utopian fantasy’, and argues the primary reason was internationalism; quotes a 1929 Bund leader in Warsaw blaming ‘Zionist politics’ for Arab hatred. Also raises the problems for the Bund's programme (solidarity from non-Jews, pogroms of 1918–21, Soviet arrests of Bundists). The reviewer's own conclusion: ‘the Bundists, though defeated, were not wrong’.

    Open source ↗

  3. What's left out

    The Bund's world was murdered, and for half of Israel's Jews 'where they're from' is not Europe.

    Hereness depended on the neighbours. The Bund's Poland was destroyed in the Holocaust. Its representative in London, Szmul Zygielbojm, took his own life in May 1943 to protest the world's indifference, writing that 'My comrades in the Warsaw Ghetto have fallen with guns in their hands'. After the war, survivors who went home met violence: in Kielce in July 1946 'a mob of Polish soldiers, police officers, and civilians murdered at least 42 Jews'; the government executed nine attackers after 'a hasty judicial investigation', and the pogrom 'touched off a mass migration of hundreds of thousands of Jews from Poland' (US Holocaust Memorial Museum). In the statistics bureau's origin categories, as the Jewish Virtual Library gives them, 14.5% of Israel's Jews are of African and 11.2% of Asian origin. Counted by identity rather than birthplace, Israeli Jews are 'roughly evenly divided' between Ashkenazim and Sephardim or Mizrahim, 'with roots mostly in Spain, elsewhere around the Mediterranean or the Middle East' (Pew, 2016). For them 'go back where you're from' points to the Mediterranean and the Middle East, not Poland; how they left those countries is the subject of 'Jews lived peacefully in the Arab world for centuries until Zionism ruined it; they left because Israel lured them.'. And most are from nowhere else: in 2020, 78% of Israel's Jews were born in Israel, and more than half had at least one parent also born there. If Jews should be safe wherever they live, that includes the place where about seven million of them now live (7.2 million, in the Jewish Agency's 2023 figures).

    Traps here:◆ Judging by origin◆ Which territory?

    historyJewish Historical Institute (Warsaw), '“The sky is cold and silent like the people down below”. Farewell letters from Shmuel Zygielbojm' (2021) (2021) incident ✓

    Read 29 Sept 2026: 'On the night of 11/12 May 1943, Shmuel (Szmul) Zygielbojm took his own life, protesting the Allies' indifference to the extermination of the Jews'; the Bund was 'the leading Jewish socialist party, opposed to Zionism'; he sat on the National Council of the Polish government in exile from 1942. Gives the letter to Raczkiewicz and Sikorski (11 May 1943): 'Through my death, I wish to express my deepest protest against inaction with which the world is watching and permitting destruction of the Jewish people.' Also: 'My comrades in the Warsaw Ghetto have fallen with guns in their hands.' Undated on the page; the year follows its footnote (source accessed 10 May 2021).

    Open source ↗

    dataJewish Virtual Library, 'Vital Statistics: Latest Population Statistics for Israel' (2026) aggregate ✓

    Read (2026-09-28), from CBS figures: 'In 2020, 78% of the Jewish population were “Sabras” - born in Israel - compared with just a 35% native-born population at Israel's independence in 1948. More than half of the Jewish population is Israeli-born, with at least one parent also Israeli-born. Those of European and American ancestry constitute approximately 2.2 million (36%) of the Jewish population in Israel, while Africans constitute another 14.5%, and Asians 11.2%.'

    Open source ↗

    dataPew Research Center, 'Israel's Religiously Divided Society' (8 March 2016) (2016) aggregate ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). 5,601 face-to-face interviews, Oct 2014 – May 2015. 'Israeli Jews are roughly evenly divided between two types of ethnic identity: Ashkenazi Jews (with ancestral roots in Central and Eastern Europe) and Sephardi or Mizrahi Jews (with roots mostly in Spain, elsewhere around the Mediterranean or the Middle East).' Also: asked whether 'Arabs should be expelled or transferred from Israel', Israeli Jews 'strongly agree (21%) or agree (27%), while a similar share disagree (29%) or strongly disagree (17%)'; 'Roughly seven-in-ten (71%)' of Datiim agree, 'Most (58%)' of Hilonim disagree (re-read 2026-09-30). Also: 'Most Israeli Jews (79%) say Jews deserve preferential treatment in Israel'; 'Roughly eight-in-ten Israeli Arabs (79%) say there is a lot of discrimination in Israeli society against Muslims'; 'the vast majority (74%) [of Jews] say they do not see much discrimination against Muslims'; majorities of all four Jewish subgroups say Israel can be both Jewish and democratic; 'Israeli Arabs generally do not think Israel can be a Jewish state and a democracy at the same time'. Also read 2026-10-10: 'About nine-in-ten Haredim (91%), eight-in-ten Datiim (80%) and roughly six-in-ten Masortim (59%) consider themselves Jewish first, while about six-in-ten Hilonim (59%) take the opposite position, saying they see themselves as Israeli first'; if halakha and democratic principles conflict, '89% of Haredim say halakha should be given preference', while 'among Hilonim, an equally lopsided share (89%) say the state should give preference to democratic principles'; 'The vast majority of Jews (98%), Muslims (85%), Christians (86%) and Druze (83%) say all or most of their close friends belong to their own religious community.'

    Open source ↗

    historyUS Holocaust Memorial Museum, Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'The Kielce Pogrom: A Blood Libel Massacre of Holocaust Survivors' incident ✓

    Read 30 Sept 2026. 4 July 1946: 'a mob of Polish soldiers, police officers, and civilians murdered at least 42 Jews and injured over 40 in the worst outburst of anti-Jewish violence in postwar Poland'; triggered by a false kidnapping claim (blood-libel pattern); 'the government executed nine of the attackers on July 14, following a hasty judicial investigation'; the event 'touched off a mass migration of hundreds of thousands of Jews from Poland and other countries of eastern and central Europe' (film caption).

    Open source ↗

    dataThe Jewish Agency for Israel, 'Jewish Population Rises to 15.7 Million Worldwide in 2023' (press release, 19 September 2023) (2023) aggregate ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). 15.7 million Jews worldwide; 'the number of Jews in Israel is 7,200,000'; 'about 8.5 million live outside Israel, with approximately 6.3 million of them living in the United States'. Figures from Sergio DellaPergola (Hebrew University), for the American Jewish Year Book 2023. (Later releases, per search summaries: 15.8 million, 7.3 million in Israel, 2024.)

    Open source ↗

  4. More context

    How to talk about this.

    Acknowledge first: the Bund and many Jews believed exactly this, and for a century much of Jewish life thrived in the diaspora. Ask one question: 'what happened to the Jews who stayed where they lived: in Poland in 1942, in Baghdad in 1941, in Cairo in 1956?'; those are the cases the premise has to answer. Elsewhere it has held, which is the argument's strongest ground. Share one checkable thing: the Bund's own fate in the Holocaust, and the Jews expelled from Arab countries after 1948. What not to say: 'Jews can only be safe in Israel', which erases the diaspora Jews who live safely where they are. From the other side: grant the diaspora's successes, then ask where Jews should go when those places turn on them.

    historyWarsaw municipal elections, December 1938: the Bund wins 17 of 20 seats won by Jewish parties (1938) aggregate ✓

    Diana Scott, 'The Jewish Bund at Its Peak', Jewish Currents (2017), read: the Bund and allied trade unions won 17 of 20 Jewish seats on the 100-member Warsaw City Council, December 1938.

    Open source ↗

    historyJewish Historical Institute (Warsaw), '“The sky is cold and silent like the people down below”. Farewell letters from Shmuel Zygielbojm' (2021) (2021) incident ✓

    Read 29 Sept 2026: 'On the night of 11/12 May 1943, Shmuel (Szmul) Zygielbojm took his own life, protesting the Allies' indifference to the extermination of the Jews'; the Bund was 'the leading Jewish socialist party, opposed to Zionism'; he sat on the National Council of the Polish government in exile from 1942. Gives the letter to Raczkiewicz and Sikorski (11 May 1943): 'Through my death, I wish to express my deepest protest against inaction with which the world is watching and permitting destruction of the Jewish people.' Also: 'My comrades in the Warsaw Ghetto have fallen with guns in their hands.' Undated on the page; the year follows its footnote (source accessed 10 May 2021).

    Open source ↗

    historyThe Farhud, Baghdad, 1–2 June 1941 (1941) incident ✓

    USHMM Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'The Farhud' (read 30 Sept 2026): 'rioters murdered between 150 and 180 Jews, injured 600 others'; 'According to the official report of the commission investigating the incident, 128 Jews were killed, 210 were injured'; 'about 135,000 Jews lived in Iraq (nearly 3 percent of the total population), with about 90,000 in Baghdad'. The Jews' share of Baghdad's population is not given there. Also: about 1,500 stores and homes looted; the official commission's report: 128 killed, 210 injured. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Other Arab nationalists also perceived the Baghdad Jews as Zionists or Zionist sympathizers and justified the attacks as a response to Arab-Jewish conflict in Palestine. Nevertheless, killing helpless Jews, including women and children, was an unprecedented phenomenon that contradicted Muslim law. In this situation, antisemitic ideology, derived in part from Nazi propaganda, helped to legitimize murdering Jews in Iraq.'

    Open source ↗

    advocacy / viewJIMENA (Jews Indigenous to the Middle East and North Africa), 'FAQ on Jews from Arab Countries' — quoting UNHCR statements of 1957 and 1967 incident ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. Quotes Lindt (February 1957, report to the UN Refugee Fund): 'Another emergency problem is now arising: that of refugees from Egypt. There is no doubt in my mind that those refugees from Egypt who are not able, or not willing to avail themselves of the protection of the Government of their nationality fall under the mandate of my office'; JIMENA's gloss that he meant Jews leaving after Suez; and a UNHCR letter of July 1967 (Dr. E. Jahn): 'such persons may be considered prima facie within the mandate of this Office'. UNHCR's page for the 1957 speech returned 403 (Wayback 429). Re-read 2026-10-15, the letter as JIMENA quotes it: 'I refer to our recent discussion concerning Jews from Middle Eastern and North African countries in consequence of recent events. I am now able to inform you that such persons may be considered prima facie within the mandate of this Office.'

    Open source ↗

  5. Where it leads if pressed

    Working it out: where the principle has held, where it failed, and what it asks now.

    'Jews should live as equal citizens wherever they're from' is a principle with a real record on both sides. Where it has held: most of the world's Jews live outside Israel today, about 8.5 million of 15.7 million, some 54%, with about 6.3 million in the United States (this page's arithmetic from the Jewish Agency's figures); Reform Judaism's 1885 platform declared Jews 'no longer a nation, but a religious community', and its 1937 platform committed to the 'full duties and responsibilities of citizenship' in every land while also supporting 'the rehabilitation of Palestine'. The Bund built a mass movement on it, winning 17 of 20 Jewish seats on Warsaw's council in 1938. Where it failed: the Bund's Poland was destroyed in the Holocaust; in Kielce in 1946 a mob 'murdered at least 42 Jews' who had come home; Jews of Arab countries lost their place after 1948 (see 'Jews lived peacefully in the Arab world for centuries until Zionism ruined it; they left because Israel lured them.'). What it asks now: 'where they're from' no longer means Europe for most Israeli Jews; 78% of Israel's Jews were born there, and about half are Sephardi or Mizrahi. Taken as a principle for the future, it supports equal citizenship for Jews where they live, including in a shared state if one were ever agreed; taken as a demand that Israel's Jews 'go home', as Helen Thomas put it in 2010, it becomes a call for expulsion. The worst case for each side. For 'Jews don't need a state': grant the diaspora's successes; in its worst failure, other countries at Evian in 1938 'refused to admit more refugees', which is the case for a state of one's own (see 'Jews can only be safe as a majority in their own state.'). For 'the diaspora can't work': grant the failures; most Jews live outside Israel today, as citizens of other countries. Holds on the evidence here: equal citizenship has worked for many Jews and failed catastrophically for others. Arguable, as both camps argue: that a Jewish state is a necessary backstop, or that it makes diaspora Jews less safe. Not supported: that Israel's Jews have a 'where they're from' to return to, or that diaspora life cannot work.

    What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean

    dataThe Jewish Agency for Israel, 'Jewish Population Rises to 15.7 Million Worldwide in 2023' (press release, 19 September 2023) (2023) aggregate ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). 15.7 million Jews worldwide; 'the number of Jews in Israel is 7,200,000'; 'about 8.5 million live outside Israel, with approximately 6.3 million of them living in the United States'. Figures from Sergio DellaPergola (Hebrew University), for the American Jewish Year Book 2023. (Later releases, per search summaries: 15.8 million, 7.3 million in Israel, 2024.)

    Open source ↗

    primary documentCentral Conference of American Rabbis, 'Declaration of Principles' ('The Pittsburgh Platform', 1885) (1885) ✓

    Read 2026-09-30 on the CCAR's own site. Point 5: 'We consider ourselves no longer a nation, but a religious community, and therefore expect neither a return to Palestine, nor a sacrificial worship under the sons of Aaron, nor the restoration of any of the laws concerning the Jewish state.' Adopted by Reform rabbis meeting 16–19 November 1885, Isaac Mayer Wise presiding. Also on the Jewish Virtual Library (https://jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-pittsburgh-platform), read earlier.

    Open source ↗

    primary documentCentral Conference of American Rabbis, 'The Guiding Principles of Reform Judaism' ('The Columbus Platform', 1937) (1937) ✓

    Read 2026-09-30 on the CCAR's own site. 'In all lands where our people live, they assume and seek to share loyally the full duties and responsibilities of citizenship'; 'In the rehabilitation of Palestine, the land hallowed by memories and hopes, we behold the promise of renewed life for many of our brethren. We affirm the obligation of all Jewry to aid in its upbuilding as a Jewish homeland by endeavoring to make it not only a haven of refuge for the oppressed but also a center of Jewish culture and spiritual life.' Also on the Jewish Virtual Library (https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-columbus-platform-1937), read earlier.

    Open source ↗

    historyWarsaw municipal elections, December 1938: the Bund wins 17 of 20 seats won by Jewish parties (1938) aggregate ✓

    Diana Scott, 'The Jewish Bund at Its Peak', Jewish Currents (2017), read: the Bund and allied trade unions won 17 of 20 Jewish seats on the 100-member Warsaw City Council, December 1938.

    Open source ↗

    historyJewish Historical Institute (Warsaw), '“The sky is cold and silent like the people down below”. Farewell letters from Shmuel Zygielbojm' (2021) (2021) incident ✓

    Read 29 Sept 2026: 'On the night of 11/12 May 1943, Shmuel (Szmul) Zygielbojm took his own life, protesting the Allies' indifference to the extermination of the Jews'; the Bund was 'the leading Jewish socialist party, opposed to Zionism'; he sat on the National Council of the Polish government in exile from 1942. Gives the letter to Raczkiewicz and Sikorski (11 May 1943): 'Through my death, I wish to express my deepest protest against inaction with which the world is watching and permitting destruction of the Jewish people.' Also: 'My comrades in the Warsaw Ghetto have fallen with guns in their hands.' Undated on the page; the year follows its footnote (source accessed 10 May 2021).

    Open source ↗

    historyUS Holocaust Memorial Museum, Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'The Kielce Pogrom: A Blood Libel Massacre of Holocaust Survivors' incident ✓

    Read 30 Sept 2026. 4 July 1946: 'a mob of Polish soldiers, police officers, and civilians murdered at least 42 Jews and injured over 40 in the worst outburst of anti-Jewish violence in postwar Poland'; triggered by a false kidnapping claim (blood-libel pattern); 'the government executed nine of the attackers on July 14, following a hasty judicial investigation'; the event 'touched off a mass migration of hundreds of thousands of Jews from Poland and other countries of eastern and central Europe' (film caption).

    Open source ↗

    dataJewish Virtual Library, 'Vital Statistics: Latest Population Statistics for Israel' (2026) aggregate ✓

    Read (2026-09-28), from CBS figures: 'In 2020, 78% of the Jewish population were “Sabras” - born in Israel - compared with just a 35% native-born population at Israel's independence in 1948. More than half of the Jewish population is Israeli-born, with at least one parent also Israeli-born. Those of European and American ancestry constitute approximately 2.2 million (36%) of the Jewish population in Israel, while Africans constitute another 14.5%, and Asians 11.2%.'

    Open source ↗

    dataPew Research Center, 'Israel's Religiously Divided Society' (8 March 2016) (2016) aggregate ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). 5,601 face-to-face interviews, Oct 2014 – May 2015. 'Israeli Jews are roughly evenly divided between two types of ethnic identity: Ashkenazi Jews (with ancestral roots in Central and Eastern Europe) and Sephardi or Mizrahi Jews (with roots mostly in Spain, elsewhere around the Mediterranean or the Middle East).' Also: asked whether 'Arabs should be expelled or transferred from Israel', Israeli Jews 'strongly agree (21%) or agree (27%), while a similar share disagree (29%) or strongly disagree (17%)'; 'Roughly seven-in-ten (71%)' of Datiim agree, 'Most (58%)' of Hilonim disagree (re-read 2026-09-30). Also: 'Most Israeli Jews (79%) say Jews deserve preferential treatment in Israel'; 'Roughly eight-in-ten Israeli Arabs (79%) say there is a lot of discrimination in Israeli society against Muslims'; 'the vast majority (74%) [of Jews] say they do not see much discrimination against Muslims'; majorities of all four Jewish subgroups say Israel can be both Jewish and democratic; 'Israeli Arabs generally do not think Israel can be a Jewish state and a democracy at the same time'. Also read 2026-10-10: 'About nine-in-ten Haredim (91%), eight-in-ten Datiim (80%) and roughly six-in-ten Masortim (59%) consider themselves Jewish first, while about six-in-ten Hilonim (59%) take the opposite position, saying they see themselves as Israeli first'; if halakha and democratic principles conflict, '89% of Haredim say halakha should be given preference', while 'among Hilonim, an equally lopsided share (89%) say the state should give preference to democratic principles'; 'The vast majority of Jews (98%), Muslims (85%), Christians (86%) and Druze (83%) say all or most of their close friends belong to their own religious community.'

    Open source ↗

    pressCNN, 'White House correspondent Thomas retires amid controversial comments' (7 June 2010) (2010) incident ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). Asked on 27 May 'Any comments on Israel?': 'Tell them to get the hell out of Palestine'; 'Remember, these people are occupied and it's their land, it's not German. It's not Poland'; asked where the Jews should go: 'They should go home,' which she identified as 'Poland, Germany ... and America and everywhere else.' Her apology: 'They do not reflect my heart-felt belief that peace will come to the Middle East only when all parties recognize the need for mutual respect and tolerance.'

    Open source ↗

    historyUS Holocaust Memorial Museum, Holocaust Encyclopedia, 'The Evian Conference' incident ✓

    Read 2026-10-01. 'In July 1938, delegates from 32 countries met in Evian, France … The delegates expressed sympathy for the Jews who were seeking to flee Nazi persecution. Most countries, however, refused to admit more refugees.' Outcomes: 'With the exception of the tiny Dominican Republic, no country was willing to accept more refugees. However, one result of the conference was the establishment of the Intergovernmental Committee on Refugees (ICR)'. Caption: the St. Louis in 1939 'carried Jewish refugees seeking temporary refuge in Cuba. It was forced to return to Europe after Cuba refused to allow the refugees entry into the country.' The Wagner-Rogers bill to admit 20,000 refugee children 'was not supported by the Senate in 1939 and 1940'.

    Open source ↗

    From 'Jews belong everywhere' to 'Jews don't belong here'.

    The Bund's principle was inclusive: Jews belong where they live. Turned against Israel, it can become the opposite: a claim that one place is the exception where Jews may not live, and that seven million people should 'go back', as when Helen Thomas said Israel's Jews 'should go home' to 'Poland, Germany … and America'. That is the step from a diaspora ethic to a demand for expulsion. Used another way, the argument means equal citizenship for Jews where they already live, in one shared state; then the question is what would guarantee it. Both readings start from the same principle, that Jews should be safe and equal where they live; they part over whether Israel, where about seven million Jews now live, counts as one of those places.

    Traps here:◆ The strict enemy frame

    pressCNN, 'White House correspondent Thomas retires amid controversial comments' (7 June 2010) (2010) incident ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). Asked on 27 May 'Any comments on Israel?': 'Tell them to get the hell out of Palestine'; 'Remember, these people are occupied and it's their land, it's not German. It's not Poland'; asked where the Jews should go: 'They should go home,' which she identified as 'Poland, Germany ... and America and everywhere else.' Her apology: 'They do not reflect my heart-felt belief that peace will come to the Middle East only when all parties recognize the need for mutual respect and tolerance.'

    Open source ↗

    dataThe Jewish Agency for Israel, 'Jewish Population Rises to 15.7 Million Worldwide in 2023' (press release, 19 September 2023) (2023) aggregate ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). 15.7 million Jews worldwide; 'the number of Jews in Israel is 7,200,000'; 'about 8.5 million live outside Israel, with approximately 6.3 million of them living in the United States'. Figures from Sergio DellaPergola (Hebrew University), for the American Jewish Year Book 2023. (Later releases, per search summaries: 15.8 million, 7.3 million in Israel, 2024.)

    Open source ↗

The usual reply — and its own traps

Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.

heard from pro-Israel voices“Jews can only be safe as a majority in their own state.” Both lean on: ◆ The strict enemy frame

Where this argument points

This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions — for, against or around them:

On the timeline

Keep exploring

From the archive

How newspapers reported related events at the time — suggested by the archive's own tags, not yet reviewed for this argument. Open a scan and judge for yourself.

Scans: kvetch-of-the-day news archive.