Argument Β· heard on both sides

β€œTheir leader isn't even from here: Netanyahu is Polish, Arafat was Egyptian.”

Look at who leads them. Israel's founders came from Poland and Russia, and Netanyahu's family is Polish; Arafat was born in Cairo and spoke with an Egyptian accent. A people whose leaders come from elsewhere doesn't really belong to the land.

Made publicly as a argument by Richard Kemp

Where it's been said

β€œArafat was not a β€œPalestinian Arab”, he was an Egyptian, born in Cairo.”
Richard Kemp, retired British Army colonel, commentator β€” Post on X, 2023-12-31 ⚠ Not yet checked at the source. Tried: 2026-10-13: x.com post not readable by this site's fetch tool (login wall); not bypassed.
The mirror, from the other side
β€œTell them to get the hell out of Palestine. … They should go home [to] Poland, Germany … and America and everywhere else.”
Helen Thomas, White House correspondent, Hearst columnist β€” Remarks to Rabbi David Nesenoff of Rabbilive.com, filmed at the White House, as reported by CNN; she apologised days later and retired. Said of Israeli Jews in general rather than their leaders: the same 'from elsewhere' argument aimed the other way, 2010-05-27 βœ“

Traps in play:β—† Judging by origin

  1. Why people find it convincing

    • Israel's first prime minister and its fourth were born in Eastern Europe: David Ben-Gurion in PΕ‚oΕ„sk (1886), Golda Meir in Kyiv (1898). Benjamin Netanyahu's father, the historian Benzion Netanyahu, was born 'Benzion Mileikowsky' in Warsaw in 1910, though his family moved to Palestine in 1920, when he was ten.
    • Yasser Arafat was born in Cairo in 1929 by most accounts and grew up partly there; the place is disputed β€” the Nobel biography notes that other sources give Jerusalem or Gaza.
    • Both national movements were in part started by people living elsewhere. Political Zionism's founder Theodor Herzl was born in Budapest and worked in Vienna, and the Dreyfus case in Paris 'became one of the determinants in the genesis of Political Zionism' (JVL). Arafat's Fatah was founded in 1958 by him and friends while he was working in Kuwait, though his mother came 'from an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem' (Nobel biography).
  2. What's true

    Both founding generations were often born elsewhere.

    Zionism was organised in Europe, and its leaders included immigrants, among them Ben-Gurion and Golda Meir. Palestinian nationalism's leaders also included people born or based outside the land, Arafat among them (see below); how many, and where, is not counted here ⚠. Both facts are real, and each side's arguments use the other's.

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'David Ben-Gurion' βœ“

    Read: 'born in Plonsk, Poland, on October 16, 1886'. Re-read 2026-09-29 (page now at /david-ben-gurion): 'David Yosef Gruen was born in Plonsk'; in 1910 'He signed his first article with his new name, Ben-Gurion, taken from one of the Jewish generals who led the revolt against the Romans in the time of Bar Kochba' (JVL's wording).

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Golda Meir' βœ“

    Read: 'born in Kyiv in 1898'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceThe Nobel Prize, 'Yasser Arafat β€” Biographical' (1994 Peace Prize) βœ“

    Read: born 24 August 1929 in Cairo ('The place of Arafat's birth is disputed. Besides Cairo, other sources mention Jerusalem and Gaza'); father 'a Palestinian with some Egyptian ancestry', mother 'from an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem'; four years with an uncle in Jerusalem. Footnote (re-read 2026-09-28): 'The place of Arafat's birth is disputed. Besides Cairo, other sources mention Jerusalem and Gaza as his birthplace.' Also (re-read 2026-09-29): 'his mother from an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem'; after graduating in 1956 he 'resettled in Kuwait'; 'In 1958 he and his friends founded Al-Fatah'.

    Open source β†—

  3. What's left out

    A leader's birthplace says nothing about a people, and both leaders had roots in the land.

    Netanyahu was born in Tel Aviv in 1949; in 2020, 78% of Israel's Jewish population were born in Israel (Israel's statistics bureau, via the Jewish Virtual Library), and about half of Israeli Jews identify as Sephardi or Mizrahi, with roots mostly around the Mediterranean or in the Middle East (Pew, 2016), not in Poland. Arafat's mother came from 'an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem' and his father was 'a Palestinian with some Egyptian ancestry'; after his mother's death he spent four years of his childhood with an uncle in Jerusalem; Mahmoud Abbas was born in Safed. The refugees of 1948 and their descendants number 'some 6 million', in AP's description 'most living in slum-like urban refugee camps in Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and the Israeli-occupied West Bank', and make up 'around three-quarters' of Gaza's population (AP, May 2024): a people mostly born in the land or in the camps around it, though no single count of birthplaces is sourced here ⚠. Judging a people by its leader's birthplace, or his father's, is the genetic fallacy (see 'Judging by origin'), and it proves nothing either way. Even 'born in Cairo' is less settled than the argument assumes: the Nobel Foundation's biography gives Cairo but notes that 'the place of Arafat's birth is disputed. Besides Cairo, other sources mention Jerusalem and Gaza.'

    Traps here:β—† Judging by origin

    referenceThe Nobel Prize, 'Yasser Arafat β€” Biographical' (1994 Peace Prize) βœ“

    Read: born 24 August 1929 in Cairo ('The place of Arafat's birth is disputed. Besides Cairo, other sources mention Jerusalem and Gaza'); father 'a Palestinian with some Egyptian ancestry', mother 'from an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem'; four years with an uncle in Jerusalem. Footnote (re-read 2026-09-28): 'The place of Arafat's birth is disputed. Besides Cairo, other sources mention Jerusalem and Gaza as his birthplace.' Also (re-read 2026-09-29): 'his mother from an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem'; after graduating in 1956 he 'resettled in Kuwait'; 'In 1958 he and his friends founded Al-Fatah'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Benjamin Netanyahu' (biography) βœ“

    Read: born 21 October 1949 in Tel Aviv, grew up in Jerusalem, adolescence in the US where his father Benzion taught.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Mahmoud Abbas' βœ“

    Read: 'born in Safed on March 26, 1935'.

    Open source β†—

    dataPew Research Center, 'Israel's Religiously Divided Society' (8 March 2016) (2016) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28). 5,601 face-to-face interviews, Oct 2014 – May 2015. 'Israeli Jews are roughly evenly divided between two types of ethnic identity: Ashkenazi Jews (with ancestral roots in Central and Eastern Europe) and Sephardi or Mizrahi Jews (with roots mostly in Spain, elsewhere around the Mediterranean or the Middle East).' Also: asked whether 'Arabs should be expelled or transferred from Israel', Israeli Jews 'strongly agree (21%) or agree (27%), while a similar share disagree (29%) or strongly disagree (17%)'; 'Roughly seven-in-ten (71%)' of Datiim agree, 'Most (58%)' of Hilonim disagree (re-read 2026-09-30). Also: 'Most Israeli Jews (79%) say Jews deserve preferential treatment in Israel'; 'Roughly eight-in-ten Israeli Arabs (79%) say there is a lot of discrimination in Israeli society against Muslims'; 'the vast majority (74%) [of Jews] say they do not see much discrimination against Muslims'; majorities of all four Jewish subgroups say Israel can be both Jewish and democratic; 'Israeli Arabs generally do not think Israel can be a Jewish state and a democracy at the same time'. Also read 2026-10-10: 'About nine-in-ten Haredim (91%), eight-in-ten Datiim (80%) and roughly six-in-ten Masortim (59%) consider themselves Jewish first, while about six-in-ten Hilonim (59%) take the opposite position, saying they see themselves as Israeli first'; if halakha and democratic principles conflict, '89% of Haredim say halakha should be given preference', while 'among Hilonim, an equally lopsided share (89%) say the state should give preference to democratic principles'; 'The vast majority of Jews (98%), Muslims (85%), Christians (86%) and Druze (83%) say all or most of their close friends belong to their own religious community.'

    Open source β†—

    dataJewish Virtual Library, 'Vital Statistics: Latest Population Statistics for Israel' (2026) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28), from CBS figures: 'In 2020, 78% of the Jewish population were β€œSabras” - born in Israel - compared with just a 35% native-born population at Israel's independence in 1948. More than half of the Jewish population is Israeli-born, with at least one parent also Israeli-born. Those of European and American ancestry constitute approximately 2.2 million (36%) of the Jewish population in Israel, while Africans constitute another 14.5%, and Asians 11.2%.'

    Open source β†—

    pressAP (via PBS NewsHour), 'Palestinians mark 76 years of dispossession as yet another catastrophe unfolds in Gaza' (May 2024) (2024) incident βœ“

    Read 2026-10-02. 'Some 700,000 Palestinians β€” a majority of the prewar population β€” fled or were driven from their homes'; the refugee community 'now numbers some 6 million, with most living in slum-like urban refugee camps in Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and the Israeli-occupied West Bank'; in Gaza refugees and descendants are 'around three-quarters of the population'. Israel's position: refugees should be absorbed by host countries; it 'points to the hundreds of thousands of Jews who came to Israel from Arab countries'.

    Open source β†—

  4. More context

    'He's really Mileikowsky / GrΓΌn': the renamed-leader version.

    A variant says Hebrew surnames hide foreign origins: 'Netanyahu is really Mileikowsky', 'Ben-Gurion is really GrΓΌn'. The name changes are real, and they were made in public. David GrΓΌn, born in PΕ‚oΕ„sk, signed his first article in the party newspaper in 1910 'with his new name, Ben-Gurion, taken from one of the Jewish generals who led the revolt against the Romans' (Jewish Virtual Library): a chosen Hebrew name, not a patronymic. Benzion Netanyahu was born Benzion Mileikowsky in Warsaw and moved to Palestine in 1920, aged ten; his son Benjamin was born a Netanyahu, in Tel Aviv in 1949. The surnames being replaced were themselves recent for many Ashkenazi Jews. In 1787 Emperor Joseph II ordered all Jews in the Habsburg Empire to take family names (Jewish Currents, left-wing Jewish magazine), and the onomastics scholar Alexander Beider writes that 'but for a very few exceptions, the family names were invented during a short period of time, around the turn of the nineteenth century', while personal names 'represent an organic part of Jewish culture'. A Hebrew name replacing a German or Slavic one marks a change of language and identity. Whether that gives anyone a claim to the land is the question the rest of this entry weighs; the name itself does not settle it either way.

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'David Ben-Gurion' βœ“

    Read: 'born in Plonsk, Poland, on October 16, 1886'. Re-read 2026-09-29 (page now at /david-ben-gurion): 'David Yosef Gruen was born in Plonsk'; in 1910 'He signed his first article with his new name, Ben-Gurion, taken from one of the Jewish generals who led the revolt against the Romans in the time of Bar Kochba' (JVL's wording).

    Open source β†—

    pressJewish Currents, 'November 12: Jews Acquire Family Names' βœ“

    Read 2026-09-29 (left-wing Jewish magazine; history column). 'In a decree promulgated on this date in 1787, Holy Roman Emperor Joseph II ordered all Jews in the Hapsburg Empire to acquire family names.' Quotes Alexander Beider (YIVO Encyclopedia): personal names 'represent an organic part of Jewish culture … but for a very few exceptions, the family names were invented during a short period of time, around the turn of the nineteenth century.'

    Open source β†—

    How to talk about this.

    Acknowledge first: many of both movements' founders were born elsewhere, from Ben-Gurion in Poland to Arafat in Cairo. Ask one question: 'where were most of the people living there today born?'; for Israeli Jews, 78% in Israel (2020); for Palestinians the figure is not yet sourced here. Share one checkable thing: Netanyahu was born in Tel Aviv, and Mahmoud Abbas in Safed. What not to say: the same argument back at the other side, which is just the same fallacy twice (see 'Judging by origin'). The honest version: both peoples are there now, and neither is going anywhere.

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'David Ben-Gurion' βœ“

    Read: 'born in Plonsk, Poland, on October 16, 1886'. Re-read 2026-09-29 (page now at /david-ben-gurion): 'David Yosef Gruen was born in Plonsk'; in 1910 'He signed his first article with his new name, Ben-Gurion, taken from one of the Jewish generals who led the revolt against the Romans in the time of Bar Kochba' (JVL's wording).

    Open source β†—

    referenceThe Nobel Prize, 'Yasser Arafat β€” Biographical' (1994 Peace Prize) βœ“

    Read: born 24 August 1929 in Cairo ('The place of Arafat's birth is disputed. Besides Cairo, other sources mention Jerusalem and Gaza'); father 'a Palestinian with some Egyptian ancestry', mother 'from an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem'; four years with an uncle in Jerusalem. Footnote (re-read 2026-09-28): 'The place of Arafat's birth is disputed. Besides Cairo, other sources mention Jerusalem and Gaza as his birthplace.' Also (re-read 2026-09-29): 'his mother from an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem'; after graduating in 1956 he 'resettled in Kuwait'; 'In 1958 he and his friends founded Al-Fatah'.

    Open source β†—

    dataJewish Virtual Library, 'Vital Statistics: Latest Population Statistics for Israel' (2026) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28), from CBS figures: 'In 2020, 78% of the Jewish population were β€œSabras” - born in Israel - compared with just a 35% native-born population at Israel's independence in 1948. More than half of the Jewish population is Israeli-born, with at least one parent also Israeli-born. Those of European and American ancestry constitute approximately 2.2 million (36%) of the Jewish population in Israel, while Africans constitute another 14.5%, and Asians 11.2%.'

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Benjamin Netanyahu' (biography) βœ“

    Read: born 21 October 1949 in Tel Aviv, grew up in Jerusalem, adolescence in the US where his father Benzion taught.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Mahmoud Abbas' βœ“

    Read: 'born in Safed on March 26, 1935'.

    Open source β†—

  5. Where it leads if pressed

    Working it out: founders, leaders now, and the people.

    The argument uses birthplaces as a proxy for belonging. Taken three ways, it says less than it seems to. Founders: Herzl was born in Budapest, Ben-Gurion in PΕ‚oΕ„sk, Golda Meir in Kyiv; Arafat's birthplace is 'disputed', Cairo by most accounts, with a mother 'from an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem'. Both founding generations included people born or raised elsewhere. Leaders now: Netanyahu was born in Tel Aviv in 1949, Mahmoud Abbas in Safed in 1935. The renamings are real and were public: Ben-Gurion chose his name in 1910 after a general of the revolt against Rome, and Benzion Netanyahu was born Mileikowsky in Warsaw; European Jews were ordered to take surnames at all only from 1787 in the Habsburg lands. The people: in 2020, 78% of Israel's Jews were born in Israel, against 35% at independence (Israel's statistics bureau via the Jewish Virtual Library), and about half are Sephardi or Mizrahi; the comparable figure for Palestinians is not sourced here, but about 700,000 became refugees in 1948 and their descendants now number some 6 million, most of them born outside the land they claim. The worst case for each side. For 'their leaders are foreigners': take the founders at face value; the current leaders were born in the land, and so were most of the people they lead. For 'birthplace means nothing': take the founding generation; the movements were shaped partly abroad, which is a fact of their history rather than a disqualification. Holds on the evidence here: both founding generations included many born elsewhere; today's leaders and most of today's Israeli Jews were born in the land (78% of Israeli Jews in 2020). Open, needs Palestinian birthplace data: a like-for-like comparison. Not supported: that a leader's birthplace decides a people's claim, a test that would disqualify both.

    What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Theodor (Binyamin Ze'ev) Herzl' (biography) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-29): 'Herzl was born in Budapest on May 2, 1860'; the family moved to Vienna in 1878; Paris correspondent of the Neue Freie Presse; 'the Dreyfus Case became one of the determinants in the genesis of Political Zionism'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'David Ben-Gurion' βœ“

    Read: 'born in Plonsk, Poland, on October 16, 1886'. Re-read 2026-09-29 (page now at /david-ben-gurion): 'David Yosef Gruen was born in Plonsk'; in 1910 'He signed his first article with his new name, Ben-Gurion, taken from one of the Jewish generals who led the revolt against the Romans in the time of Bar Kochba' (JVL's wording).

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Golda Meir' βœ“

    Read: 'born in Kyiv in 1898'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceThe Nobel Prize, 'Yasser Arafat β€” Biographical' (1994 Peace Prize) βœ“

    Read: born 24 August 1929 in Cairo ('The place of Arafat's birth is disputed. Besides Cairo, other sources mention Jerusalem and Gaza'); father 'a Palestinian with some Egyptian ancestry', mother 'from an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem'; four years with an uncle in Jerusalem. Footnote (re-read 2026-09-28): 'The place of Arafat's birth is disputed. Besides Cairo, other sources mention Jerusalem and Gaza as his birthplace.' Also (re-read 2026-09-29): 'his mother from an old Palestinian family in Jerusalem'; after graduating in 1956 he 'resettled in Kuwait'; 'In 1958 he and his friends founded Al-Fatah'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Benjamin Netanyahu' (biography) βœ“

    Read: born 21 October 1949 in Tel Aviv, grew up in Jerusalem, adolescence in the US where his father Benzion taught.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Mahmoud Abbas' βœ“

    Read: 'born in Safed on March 26, 1935'.

    Open source β†—

    referenceJewish Virtual Library, 'Benzion Netanyahu' (biography) βœ“

    Read (2026-09-29): 'Netanyahu (born Benzion Mileikowsky, March 25, 1910; died April 30, 2012) was born in Warsaw, Poland, and he emigrated with his family to pre-state Israel in 1920, living in Jaffa, Tel Aviv, and Safed before finally settling down in Jerusalem.'

    Open source β†—

    pressJewish Currents, 'November 12: Jews Acquire Family Names' βœ“

    Read 2026-09-29 (left-wing Jewish magazine; history column). 'In a decree promulgated on this date in 1787, Holy Roman Emperor Joseph II ordered all Jews in the Hapsburg Empire to acquire family names.' Quotes Alexander Beider (YIVO Encyclopedia): personal names 'represent an organic part of Jewish culture … but for a very few exceptions, the family names were invented during a short period of time, around the turn of the nineteenth century.'

    Open source β†—

    dataJewish Virtual Library, 'Vital Statistics: Latest Population Statistics for Israel' (2026) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28), from CBS figures: 'In 2020, 78% of the Jewish population were β€œSabras” - born in Israel - compared with just a 35% native-born population at Israel's independence in 1948. More than half of the Jewish population is Israeli-born, with at least one parent also Israeli-born. Those of European and American ancestry constitute approximately 2.2 million (36%) of the Jewish population in Israel, while Africans constitute another 14.5%, and Asians 11.2%.'

    Open source β†—

    dataPew Research Center, 'Israel's Religiously Divided Society' (8 March 2016) (2016) aggregate βœ“

    Read (2026-09-28). 5,601 face-to-face interviews, Oct 2014 – May 2015. 'Israeli Jews are roughly evenly divided between two types of ethnic identity: Ashkenazi Jews (with ancestral roots in Central and Eastern Europe) and Sephardi or Mizrahi Jews (with roots mostly in Spain, elsewhere around the Mediterranean or the Middle East).' Also: asked whether 'Arabs should be expelled or transferred from Israel', Israeli Jews 'strongly agree (21%) or agree (27%), while a similar share disagree (29%) or strongly disagree (17%)'; 'Roughly seven-in-ten (71%)' of Datiim agree, 'Most (58%)' of Hilonim disagree (re-read 2026-09-30). Also: 'Most Israeli Jews (79%) say Jews deserve preferential treatment in Israel'; 'Roughly eight-in-ten Israeli Arabs (79%) say there is a lot of discrimination in Israeli society against Muslims'; 'the vast majority (74%) [of Jews] say they do not see much discrimination against Muslims'; majorities of all four Jewish subgroups say Israel can be both Jewish and democratic; 'Israeli Arabs generally do not think Israel can be a Jewish state and a democracy at the same time'. Also read 2026-10-10: 'About nine-in-ten Haredim (91%), eight-in-ten Datiim (80%) and roughly six-in-ten Masortim (59%) consider themselves Jewish first, while about six-in-ten Hilonim (59%) take the opposite position, saying they see themselves as Israeli first'; if halakha and democratic principles conflict, '89% of Haredim say halakha should be given preference', while 'among Hilonim, an equally lopsided share (89%) say the state should give preference to democratic principles'; 'The vast majority of Jews (98%), Muslims (85%), Christians (86%) and Druze (83%) say all or most of their close friends belong to their own religious community.'

    Open source β†—

    pressAP (via PBS NewsHour), 'Palestinians mark 76 years of dispossession as yet another catastrophe unfolds in Gaza' (May 2024) (2024) incident βœ“

    Read 2026-10-02. 'Some 700,000 Palestinians β€” a majority of the prewar population β€” fled or were driven from their homes'; the refugee community 'now numbers some 6 million, with most living in slum-like urban refugee camps in Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and the Israeli-occupied West Bank'; in Gaza refugees and descendants are 'around three-quarters of the population'. Israel's position: refugees should be absorbed by host countries; it 'points to the hundreds of thousands of Jews who came to Israel from Arab countries'.

    Open source β†—

    The 'real locals' contest, whose logic removes both peoples.

    Pushed further, the argument becomes a contest over who are the 'real' natives (see 'Only a small share of ancient Jews ever left; Palestinians are the real descendants of the ancient inhabitants, and today's Jews are mostly Europeans.' and 'Most Palestinians are descendants of recent Arab immigrants who came for the jobs Zionism created; the real locals were only a few villagers and tribes.'). Applied fairly, it disqualifies both: millions of Israelis whose families came in the last century, and some Palestinians whose families arrived in the 19th and 20th centuries too (see 'Most Palestinians are descendants of recent Arab immigrants who came for the jobs Zionism created; the real locals were only a few villagers and tribes.'). Its only consistent conclusion is that someone has to leave, which is where the solutions that need a people to disappear begin. The honest version stops earlier: both peoples are there now, most of them born there, and neither is going anywhere.

    Traps here:β—† The strict enemy frame

Keep exploring