Argument Β· heard from pro-Palestinian voices
βIsrael is a cancerous tumour in the region β the Zionist regime will be uprooted.β
Israel is a Western colonial implant, a 'Zionist regime' rather than a real country, imposed on the Muslim world by Britain and kept alive by America's weapons. The Islamic Revolution refuses to accept it. Resistance will uproot it, and then the land's original inhabitants β Muslims, Christians and Jews β can decide its future in a referendum.
Made publicly as a pro-Palestinian argument by Ali Khamenei and Mojtaba Khamenei
Where it's been said
β#Israel is a malignant cancerous tumor in the West Asian region that has to be removed and eradicated: it is possible and it will happen.β
βapproaching the final stages of its cursed existenceβ
Heard two ways
'The elimination of Israel' (Khamenei)
- The milder meaning: A vote, not a massacre. In his 2014 document '9 key questions about elimination of Israel', Iran's Supreme Leader said he opposes 'a massacre of the Jewish people in this region'; the 'proper way of eliminating Israel' is a 'public and organized referendum' of 'all the original people of Palestine including Muslims, Christians and Jews'.
- The harder meaning: The same document shuts part of the population out of that vote ('Jewish immigrants who have been persuaded into emigration to Palestine do not have the right to take part'; CNN notes it is 'unclear who Khamenei thinks the "original people of Palestine" are') and says that meanwhile 'armed resistance is the cure', with the West Bank to be 'armed like Gaza' (CNN). In 2018 he called Israel 'a malignant cancerous tumor β¦ that has to be removed and eradicated'. Both meanings are in his own words.
Both meanings are sourced below. Neither is assumed for any given speaker; ask which one is meant. See one word, two meanings.
Who makes this argument, and what they say they want
- Islamic Republic of Iran (the state and its Supreme Leader) (originator) β fits its stated aim. The argument is the Supreme Leader's own phrase, repeated from 2018 to 2025: Israel a 'cancerous tumor' to be 'removed and eradicated'.
From the organisations' own pages: each one's stated aim, sourced tests of it, and how this argument compares. Who repeats an argument is a separate question from who makes it: people who share it can have their own reasons, and polls of supporters show how far those differ (see same slogan, different goals).
Traps in play:β The strict enemy frameβ Judging by origin
Why people find it convincing
- Advocates point to events as confirmation: in June 2025 Israel struck Iran ('Operation Rising Lion') and the United States struck its nuclear facilities; a month later Khamenei called Israel a 'cancerous tumor' and the United States its partner, praising the fight against both it and what he called its 'leashed dog' (Ynet, 16 July 2025).
- Israel was created under a British mandate and is backed militarily by the United States (in 2016 the US pledged $38 billion for FY2019β2028, 'the largest single pledge of military assistance in U.S. history', in the White House's words), and it has an undeclared nuclear arsenal: the Arms Control Association estimates 90 warheads, while noting that Israel 'does not admit nor deny having nuclear weapons, and states that it will not be the first to introduce nuclear weapons in the Middle East'.
- Iranians remember foreign interference in their own country, above all the 1953 coup that overthrew Prime Minister Mosaddeq: in 2013 declassified CIA documents gave what the National Security Archive calls 'the CIA's first formal acknowledgement that the agency helped to plan and execute the coup', with Britain involved too. That history makes 'Western implant' resonate.
- The Islamic Republic has held the same position since 1979, and Iranian media present the annual Quds Day rallies, which Khomeini 'established β¦ in 1979 β¦ to show solidarity with Palestinians', as a sign of wider anger: 'Millions of people in Iran and across the world are taking to the streets β¦ voicing their solidarity with Palestinians' (Jamaran; publication date not shown on the page read; crowd sizes are the outlet's own).
- Iran's leaders insist they oppose Zionism, not Jews: Iran has one of the oldest Jewish communities in the region, and its constitution reserves it a seat in parliament ('The Zoroastrians and Jews will each elect one representative', Art. 64).
What's true
The grievances it draws on are real, and the position is consistent.
Western powers did shape Israel's creation and its security: the 2016 US memorandum alone, 'the largest single pledge of military assistance in U.S. history', is worth '$38 billion ($3.8 billion per year)' for 2019β2028. The Palestinians' dispossession is real. Iran's own grievance against Western interference has a documented basis too: in 2013 the National Security Archive published declassified CIA documents including 'what is believed to be the CIA's first formal acknowledgement that the agency helped to plan and execute' the 1953 coup against Mosaddeq. And Israel 'is estimated to have 90 nuclear warheads', has 'never joined the NPT', neither admits nor denies having them, and 'states that it will not be the first to introduce nuclear weapons in the Middle East' (Arms Control Association, 2026). Khomeini 'established Quds Day in 1979 shortly after the Islamic Revolution' (Jamaran), and the line has been repeated by the Islamic Republic's leaders since. Khamenei stated it plainly in June 2018: '#Israel is a malignant cancerous tumor in the West Asian region that has to be removed and eradicated: it is possible and it will happen.' He used the same image in his Quds Day speech of May 2020, returned to it after the June 2025 war with Israel and the United States (Ynet, 16 July 2025), and the same image has since been posted in the name of his son and successor, Mojtaba Khamenei: a Hajj message published in May 2026 described Israel as a 'cancerous tumor' 'approaching the final stages of its cursed existence', and said it would not exist within 15 years (Iran International) β a leader wounded in the February 2026 strike that killed his father and most of his family, and not seen in public since, whose statements are read out or posted for him (ABC News, 30 August 2026). The line outlived the man who coined it; it is the regime's line. Iran does distinguish rhetorically between Jews and Zionism: Khamenei's '9 key questions' rejects 'a massacre of the Jewish people in this region' and proposes a referendum of 'all the original people of Palestine including Muslims, Christians and Jews' (CNN, 10 November 2014); and Iran's constitution recognises Jews as a religious minority with one elected representative in parliament (Arts. 13 and 64).
pressTimes of Israel, 'Khamenei: Israel a "cancerous tumor" that "must be eradicated"' (4 June 2018) (2018) incident β
The article is from June 2018 (after the Gaza border protests), not the Quds Day 2020 speech; the id is historical. Read 2026-09-26.
pressYnet, 'Khamenei: Israel is a cancerous tumor, America's dog β we can hit back even harder' (16 July 2025) (2025) incident β
Read (date from page metadata): Khamenei's Tehran speech nearly a month after Operation Rising Lion and the US strikes β Israel a 'cancerous tumor', the US a partner in its crimes, Israel its 'leashed dog'.
pressABC News (Australia), 'Dead or alive? The mystery of Iran's absent leader' (30 August 2026) (2026) incident β
Read: the 28 Feb 2026 strike killed Ali Khamenei; Mojtaba Khamenei 'has not been seen since he was appointed at the beginning of the Iran war'; the 28 Feb strike 'killed most of his immediate family' and 'many senior regime figures'; an Iranian ambassador: wounded in the 'legs, hand and arm'; a 'deluge of AI-generated or AI-edited content' of him; US officials: likely in a shelter, messages by courier.
pressJamaran, 'Millions march on International Quds Day to support Palestinians amid Israeli genocide' (date not shown) incident β
Read 2026-10-01. Iranian news site (its menus centre on Khomeini's biography). 'Imam Khomeini, established Quds Day in 1979 shortly after the Islamic Revolution in Iran to show solidarity with Palestinians. It has since become a symbol of resistance'; 'Millions of people in Iran and across the world are taking to the streets'; rallies 'in many countries in the West Asian region, including Iraq, Yemen and Lebanon'. Counts and framing are the outlet's own.
pressCNN, 'Iran leader's call to "annihilate" Israel sparks fury as nuclear deadline looms' (10 November 2014) (2014) incident β
Read (2026-09-28). On Khamenei's posted document '9 key questions about elimination of Israel': he opposes 'a massacre of the Jewish people in this region' and seeks a referendum; the 'proper way of eliminating Israel' is for 'all the original people of Palestine including Muslims, Christians and Jews wherever they are β¦ take part in a public and organized referendum'; 'Jewish immigrants who have been persuaded into emigration to Palestine do not have the right to take part'; meanwhile 'armed resistance is the cure', with the West Bank 'armed like Gaza'. CNN: 'It's unclear who Khamenei thinks the "original people of Palestine" are.'
law / courtConstitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran (1979, rev. 1989), Art. 64 and Art. 13 (Constitute Project) (1989) β
Read 2026-09-29. Art. 64: 'The Zoroastrians and Jews will each elect one representative; Assyrian and Chaldean Christians will jointly elect one representative; and Armenian Christians β¦ will each elect one representative.' Art. 13: 'Zoroastrian, Jewish, and Christian Iranians are the only recognized religious minorities'.
pressIran International, 'Israel will not exist in 15 years, Mojtaba Khamenei says' (26 May 2026) (2026) incident β
Read (2026-09-29). A Persian-language opposition outlet: 'in a message published Tuesday for the Hajj pilgrimage β¦ Israel would not exist within the next 15 years'; 'Describing Israel as an "unstable Zionist regime" and a "cancerous tumor," the message said it was "approaching the final stages of its cursed existence"'; 'No image or audio recording of Mojtaba Khamenei has been released since his appointment'.
primary documentThe White House (Obama administration), 'Fact Sheet: Memorandum of Understanding Reached with Israel' (14 September 2016) (2016) aggregate β
Read 2026-10-01. 'the largest single pledge of military assistance in U.S. history: The total value of the new MOU, which covers FY2019- FY2028, is $38 billion ($3.8 billion per year)'; $3.3 billion FMF and $500 million missile defence a year; succeeds the $30 billion 2007 MOU.
primary documentNational Security Archive (George Washington University), 'CIA Confirms Role in 1953 Iran Coup' (19 August 2013) (2013) finding β
Read 2026-09-29. Posts declassified CIA documents: 'American and British involvement in Mosaddeq's ouster has long been public knowledge, but today's posting includes what is believed to be the CIA's first formal acknowledgement that the agency helped to plan and execute the coup' (from the internal history The Battle for Iran, mid-1970s).
referenceArms Control Association, 'Nuclear Weapons: Who Has What at a Glance' (fact sheet, last reviewed June 2026) (2026) aggregate β
Read 2026-09-29 (US non-partisan arms-control NGO). 'Israel is estimated to have 90 nuclear warheads, with fissile material stockpiles for about 200 weapons.' 'Israel does not admit nor deny having nuclear weapons, and states that it will not be the first to introduce nuclear weapons in the Middle East. Nevertheless, Israel is universally believed to possess nuclear arms'. Israel 'never joined the NPT'.
What's left out
Seven million people, the regime's own record, and Iranians themselves.
The 'referendum of the original inhabitants' the regime proposes would give a vote only to those it counts as original, leaving most Israeli Jews, including those whose families fled Arab countries and Iran itself, without a say in a land they were born in. In December 2006 the Foreign Ministry's Institute for Political and International Studies hosted a Tehran conference that included 'an examination of whether or not the Holocaust ever took place', initiated by President Ahmadinejad, who had called the Holocaust 'a myth'; Foreign Minister Mottaki said, in RFE/RL's words, that Iran 'intends neither to confirm nor deny the Holocaust', and Israel's foreign ministry spokesman called it 'official sanction, official endorsement, to Holocaust denial' (RFE/RL, 11 December 2006); and in 2020 Khamenei's office used the phrase 'final solution' on a poster about Israel before insisting it meant the state, not Jews. Lebanon has borne one of those wars: from 8 October 2023 to November 2024, amid 'Israeli airstrikes and Hezbollah missile hits in Israel', more than 3,000 people were killed in Lebanon, '58 per cent higher than the 1,900 people killed during the 34-day conflict in 2006', and an estimated 1.3 million displaced (UN OCHA, via UN News); in Gaza, OCHA relayed '73,669 Reported fatalities' by September 2026, figures from the Gaza Health Ministry that the UN marks as not yet verified by it (OCHA, 9 September 2026; how the count is disputed is set out in 'Counting the dead in Gaza'). And many Iranians reject the policy. The protest slogan 'Neither Gaza nor Lebanon, I sacrifice my life for Iran' 'first gained prominence during the 2009 Green Movement', reappeared in the protests of 2017β18, 2019 and 2022, and was chanted again from 28 December 2025; Kamran Talattof (University of Arizona), writing as 'an expert of Iranian history and culture', reads it as protesters 'drawing a direct line between foreign policy choices and domestic suffering', and, in his own hedged words, 'I believe, rejecting the theocratic system in Iran entirely' (The Conversation, January 2026, as republished by Informed Comment). The best available soundings come from GAMAAN, a Netherlands-based group that polls Iranians anonymously online: in September 2025, three months after the June war, 44% of its 30,372 respondents inside Iran held the Islamic Republic responsible for starting that war (33% Israel), 42% named 'anger at the Islamic Republic' as their main emotion, and Israel was viewed favourably by 39% and unfavourably by 48% β second only to the United States among the eight countries asked about. The sample (literate Iranians over 15, reached through a VPN network) has its own tilt, but it is not the regime's line.
Traps here:β Judging by originβ Whose war is it?
pressYnet, 'Khamenei: "final soultion" is eliminating Jews, just Israel' [headline as published, typo and missing 'not' included] (20 May 2020) (2020) incident β
Read 2026-09-29 (short news item; Israeli outlet): Khamenei publicised a poster on social media 'which called for freeing Palestine through a "final solution"', then said he 'does not support eliminating all Jews, just the State of Israel.' Confirms the entry's sentence on the 2020 poster.
dataGAMAAN, 'Iranians' Attitudes Toward the 12-Day War' (survey 24β28 September 2025; published 5 November 2025) (2025) aggregate β
Read: 30,372 respondents inside Iran via the Psiphon VPN network; literate residents 15+; 95% credibility level, 5% interval. Blame for starting the war: Islamic Republic 44%, Israel 33%, both 16%; 51% say Israel achieved its objectives; top emotion 'anger at the Islamic Republic' 42%; favourability: US 53% positive / 37% negative, Israel 39% / 48%.
pressRFE/RL, Golnaz Esfandiari, 'Iran: Official Sanction Of Holocaust Conference Distresses Many' (11 December 2006) (2006) incident β
Read 2026-10-01. Two-day conference 'that includes an examination of whether or not the Holocaust ever took place'; organised by the Foreign Ministry's IPIS, 'which calls it a scientific forum'; initiated by Ahmadinejad, who 'has called the Holocaust "a myth"'; Mottaki: Iran 'intends neither to confirm nor deny', and asked 'why Palestinians should be made to pay for the crimes of the Nazis'; Regev (Israeli MFA): 'official sanction, official endorsement, to Holocaust denial'; attendees reported to include Faurisson and TΓΆben; condemned by Blair and others. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Iranian Foreign Minister Manuchehr Mottaki addressed the participants, saying that Iran intends neither to confirm nor deny the Holocaust' (RFE/RL's paraphrase).
historyKamran Talattof, ''Neither Gaza nor Lebanon!' Iranian Unrest is about more than the Economy', The Conversation (January 2026), republished on Informed Comment (2026) finding β
Read 2026-10-01. By Kamran Talattof, University of Arizona. 'A familiar slogan has echoed through the streets of various Iranian cities in recent days: "Neither Gaza nor Lebanon, I sacrifice my life for Iran." That phrase has been chanted at protests that have sprung up around Iran since Dec. 28, 2025'; it 'first gained prominence during the 2009 Green Movement' and appeared in the 2017β18, 2019 and 2022 protests; 'When people in Iran chant "Neither Gaza nor Lebanon," they are, I believe, rejecting the theocratic system in Iran entirely'; protesters are 'drawing a direct line between foreign policy choices and domestic suffering'. The reading is the author's, marked by him as belief. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'as an expert of Iranian history and culture, I believe the slogan's presence signals that protests go deeper than economic frustration alone'.
pressUN News, 'Lebanon conflict at "critical point" with more than 3,000 confirmed dead' (November 2024) aggregate β
Read 2026-10-02. 'The war in Lebanon has now killed more than 3,000 people in Lebanon amid ongoing Israeli airstrikes and Hezbollah missile hits in Israel'; OCHA: the toll since 8 October 2023 is '58 per cent higher than the 1,900 people killed during the 34-day conflict in 2006 between Israel and Hezbollah'; 'an estimated 1.3 million people have been displaced across Lebanon and into neighbouring countries'.
primary documentOCHA oPt, 'Reported impact snapshot: Gaza Strip' (9 September 2026), PDF (2026) aggregate β
Read 2026-09-29 (UN humanitarian office, relaying MoH figures). '73,669 Reported fatalities' (source: MoH Gaza); '71,444 identified fatalities as of 31 December 2025 as: Children 21,283, Women 10,983, Elderly 5,100, Men 34,078' (the four sum to 71,444). Disclaimer: 'Figures that are yet-to-be verified by the UN are attributed to their source β¦ The fatality breakdowns currently cited are those that the MoH in Gaza has fully identified as of 31 December 2025 out of the higher number of casualties they report.'
More context
How to talk about this.
Acknowledge first: this is the Iranian regime's stated position, repeated in its leaders' speeches, and its supporters present it as a religious and anti-colonial cause. Ask one question: 'what happens to the seven million Jews when a tumour is removed?'; the metaphor implies an answer. Share one checkable thing: the phrase is the Supreme Leader's own, repeated in official speeches β it is the regime's line; the best anonymous surveys suggest many Iranians do not share it (see above). What not to say: 'Iranians want to destroy Israel', which confuses a regime with its people. From the other side: the same care applies to Israeli leaders who speak of Palestinians in dehumanising terms.
Where it leads if pressed
Working it out: the regime's words, its own fine print, and its people.
The claim is the Iranian state's stated position, so the question is not whether it is said but what it commits to, and who holds it. The words: Khamenei in 2018, 'a malignant cancerous tumor β¦ that has to be removed and eradicated'; again after the 2025 war; his son's 2026 message that Israel 'would not exist within the next 15 years'. The fine print the regime adds: Khamenei's '9 key questions' document says he opposes 'a massacre of the Jewish people' and proposes a referendum of 'all the original people of Palestine'; in 2020, after publicising a poster calling for a 'final solution', he said he did not support eliminating all Jews, 'just the State of Israel'; and the Islamic Republic's constitution reserves a parliamentary seat for Jews, who 'will each elect one representative' with the Zoroastrians (Art. 64). A referendum that only 'original' inhabitants may vote in still leaves most Israeli Jews, born there, without a vote, and the regime hosted a 2006 conference examining 'whether or not the Holocaust ever took place'. Its people: in GAMAAN's 2025 survey of 30,372 respondents inside Iran, 44% blamed the Islamic Republic for starting the war with Israel and 33% Israel, while views of Israel itself were 39% positive and 48% negative; and protesters have chanted 'Neither Gaza nor Lebanon, I sacrifice my life for Iran'. The worst case for each side. For 'it's only anti-Zionist rhetoric, not a threat': take the referendum proposal at face value; it still ends the state of the people living there without their consent, the 'final solution' poster came from the leader's own account, and the aim has had a state institution since the revolution: Quds Day, which Khomeini 'established β¦ in 1979 shortly after the Islamic Revolution'. For 'Iranians want to destroy Israel': take the leaders' words at their worst; the best available anonymous survey shows many Iranians blaming their own regime. Holds on the evidence here: the Islamic Republic's leaders have repeatedly called for Israel's removal, framed as a referendum that excludes most Israelis. Open, as far as survey methods allow: that many Iranians do not share the aim, even where they view Israel unfavourably. Not supported: that the slogan is empty rhetoric, or that it speaks for Iranians as a people.
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable β¦) mean
pressTimes of Israel, 'Khamenei: Israel a "cancerous tumor" that "must be eradicated"' (4 June 2018) (2018) incident β
The article is from June 2018 (after the Gaza border protests), not the Quds Day 2020 speech; the id is historical. Read 2026-09-26.
pressYnet, 'Khamenei: Israel is a cancerous tumor, America's dog β we can hit back even harder' (16 July 2025) (2025) incident β
Read (date from page metadata): Khamenei's Tehran speech nearly a month after Operation Rising Lion and the US strikes β Israel a 'cancerous tumor', the US a partner in its crimes, Israel its 'leashed dog'.
pressIran International, 'Israel will not exist in 15 years, Mojtaba Khamenei says' (26 May 2026) (2026) incident β
Read (2026-09-29). A Persian-language opposition outlet: 'in a message published Tuesday for the Hajj pilgrimage β¦ Israel would not exist within the next 15 years'; 'Describing Israel as an "unstable Zionist regime" and a "cancerous tumor," the message said it was "approaching the final stages of its cursed existence"'; 'No image or audio recording of Mojtaba Khamenei has been released since his appointment'.
pressCNN, 'Iran leader's call to "annihilate" Israel sparks fury as nuclear deadline looms' (10 November 2014) (2014) incident β
Read (2026-09-28). On Khamenei's posted document '9 key questions about elimination of Israel': he opposes 'a massacre of the Jewish people in this region' and seeks a referendum; the 'proper way of eliminating Israel' is for 'all the original people of Palestine including Muslims, Christians and Jews wherever they are β¦ take part in a public and organized referendum'; 'Jewish immigrants who have been persuaded into emigration to Palestine do not have the right to take part'; meanwhile 'armed resistance is the cure', with the West Bank 'armed like Gaza'. CNN: 'It's unclear who Khamenei thinks the "original people of Palestine" are.'
pressYnet, 'Khamenei: "final soultion" is eliminating Jews, just Israel' [headline as published, typo and missing 'not' included] (20 May 2020) (2020) incident β
Read 2026-09-29 (short news item; Israeli outlet): Khamenei publicised a poster on social media 'which called for freeing Palestine through a "final solution"', then said he 'does not support eliminating all Jews, just the State of Israel.' Confirms the entry's sentence on the 2020 poster.
pressRFE/RL, Golnaz Esfandiari, 'Iran: Official Sanction Of Holocaust Conference Distresses Many' (11 December 2006) (2006) incident β
Read 2026-10-01. Two-day conference 'that includes an examination of whether or not the Holocaust ever took place'; organised by the Foreign Ministry's IPIS, 'which calls it a scientific forum'; initiated by Ahmadinejad, who 'has called the Holocaust "a myth"'; Mottaki: Iran 'intends neither to confirm nor deny', and asked 'why Palestinians should be made to pay for the crimes of the Nazis'; Regev (Israeli MFA): 'official sanction, official endorsement, to Holocaust denial'; attendees reported to include Faurisson and TΓΆben; condemned by Blair and others. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'Iranian Foreign Minister Manuchehr Mottaki addressed the participants, saying that Iran intends neither to confirm nor deny the Holocaust' (RFE/RL's paraphrase).
dataGAMAAN, 'Iranians' Attitudes Toward the 12-Day War' (survey 24β28 September 2025; published 5 November 2025) (2025) aggregate β
Read: 30,372 respondents inside Iran via the Psiphon VPN network; literate residents 15+; 95% credibility level, 5% interval. Blame for starting the war: Islamic Republic 44%, Israel 33%, both 16%; 51% say Israel achieved its objectives; top emotion 'anger at the Islamic Republic' 42%; favourability: US 53% positive / 37% negative, Israel 39% / 48%.
historyKamran Talattof, ''Neither Gaza nor Lebanon!' Iranian Unrest is about more than the Economy', The Conversation (January 2026), republished on Informed Comment (2026) finding β
Read 2026-10-01. By Kamran Talattof, University of Arizona. 'A familiar slogan has echoed through the streets of various Iranian cities in recent days: "Neither Gaza nor Lebanon, I sacrifice my life for Iran." That phrase has been chanted at protests that have sprung up around Iran since Dec. 28, 2025'; it 'first gained prominence during the 2009 Green Movement' and appeared in the 2017β18, 2019 and 2022 protests; 'When people in Iran chant "Neither Gaza nor Lebanon," they are, I believe, rejecting the theocratic system in Iran entirely'; protesters are 'drawing a direct line between foreign policy choices and domestic suffering'. The reading is the author's, marked by him as belief. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'as an expert of Iranian history and culture, I believe the slogan's presence signals that protests go deeper than economic frustration alone'.
law / courtConstitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran (1979, rev. 1989), Art. 64 and Art. 13 (Constitute Project) (1989) β
Read 2026-09-29. Art. 64: 'The Zoroastrians and Jews will each elect one representative; Assyrian and Chaldean Christians will jointly elect one representative; and Armenian Christians β¦ will each elect one representative.' Art. 13: 'Zoroastrian, Jewish, and Christian Iranians are the only recognized religious minorities'.
pressJamaran, 'Millions march on International Quds Day to support Palestinians amid Israeli genocide' (date not shown) incident β
Read 2026-10-01. Iranian news site (its menus centre on Khomeini's biography). 'Imam Khomeini, established Quds Day in 1979 shortly after the Islamic Revolution in Iran to show solidarity with Palestinians. It has since become a symbol of resistance'; 'Millions of people in Iran and across the world are taking to the streets'; rallies 'in many countries in the West Asian region, including Iraq, Yemen and Lebanon'. Counts and framing are the outlet's own.
A tumour is removed, not negotiated with.
Calling a country of ten million people a 'tumour' leaves only one treatment. It's the exact mirror of 'Islam is a cancer destroying the West': both turn a people into a disease, and both lead to removal. It also raises the question of whose war this is, and what it offers Palestinians themselves (see 'Whose war is it?'). The narrower claims survive without it: Palestinians' rights, the occupation's end, and opposition to foreign domination can all be argued without a plan to 'uproot' anyone.
Traps here:β The strict enemy frame
The usual reply β and its own traps
Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.
heard from pro-Israel voicesβIran is the head of the octopus β cut it off and Hamas and Hezbollah fall.β