Argument · heard from pro-Israel voices

“The West Bank isn't occupied — it's disputed territory, and Jews have every right to live there.”

You can only occupy another sovereign's land, and in 1967 there was no legitimate sovereign: Jordan had annexed the West Bank illegally, and no Palestinian state ever existed. The Mandate recognised the Jewish right to settle the whole land. So 'Judea and Samaria' are disputed, not occupied, and settlements are not illegal.

Common pro-Israel argument — made by Levy Committee (Edmond Levy, Alan Baker, Tchia Shapira), Natasha Hausdorff, Mike Pompeo, Julia Sebutinde

Where it's been said

“the classical laws of 'occupation' as set out in the relevant international conventions cannot be considered applicable to … Israel's presence in Judea and Samaria.”
Levy Committee (Edmond Levy, Alan Baker, Tchia Shapira), committee appointed by the Israeli government — Report on the status of building in Judea and Samaria (conclusion), as quoted by the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs (2012); the report's own English text not yet read, 2012-07 ✓
“when Israel liberated those areas in 1967, it cannot be considered an 'occupation,' as it was legally already part of Israel.”
Natasha Hausdorff, barrister, legal director of UK Lawyers for Israel — Interview in HaMizrachi (World Mizrachi), 2024 ✓
“The establishment of Israeli civilian settlements in the West Bank is not per se inconsistent with international law.”
Mike Pompeo, US Secretary of State — State Department press remarks, 2019-11-18 ✓
“Given the location of the borders of the Mandate of Palestine, applying the doctrine of uti possidetis juris to Israel would mean that Israel has territorial sovereignty over all the disputed areas of Jerusalem, the West Bank, and Gaza, except to the degree that Israel has voluntarily yielded sovereignty since its independence.”
Julia Sebutinde, Vice-President of the International Court of Justice — Dissenting opinion, ICJ Advisory Opinion on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, 2024-07-19 ✓

Heard two ways

'The right of the Jewish people to the Land of Israel' (Netanyahu, 2009 and his government, 2022)

  • The milder meaning: A historic homeland that can be shared. At Bar-Ilan in 2009 Netanyahu said of Judea and Samaria, 'This is the land of our forefathers', and in the same speech: 'within this homeland lives a large Palestinian community. We do not want to rule over them', with 'two peoples' living 'side-by-side', each with 'its own government', in a demilitarised Palestinian state.
  • The harder meaning: An exclusive claim to all of it. The guiding principles of the government he formed in December 2022: 'The Jewish people have an exclusive and inalienable right over all areas of the Land of Israel', with a plan to 'advance and develop settlement in all parts of the land of Israel – in the Galilee, Negev, Golan Heights, and Judea and Samaria' (Adalah's translation). The same leader used the same idea of a right both ways, thirteen years apart.

Both meanings are sourced below. Neither is assumed for any given speaker; ask which one is meant. See one word, two meanings.

Who makes this argument, and what they say they want

  • Likud (originator) — fits its stated aim. The guiding principles of the government it leads (December 2022) claim 'an exclusive and inalienable right over all areas of the Land of Israel' and plan to 'advance and develop settlement' in 'Judea and Samaria'. That goes with the argument's second half ('Jews have every right to live there'). The legal label 'disputed, not occupied' is not in the passages quoted here.

From the organisations' own pages: each one's stated aim, sourced tests of it, and how this argument compares. Who repeats an argument is a separate question from who makes it: people who share it can have their own reasons, and polls of supporters show how far those differ (see same slogan, different goals).

Traps in play:◆ Which territory?◆ Motte and bailey

  1. Why people find it convincing

    • Jordan's 1950 annexation of the West Bank had little international recognition, so in 1967 Israel took the territory from a state that had no recognised title to it. Legal scholar Yehuda Blum called this the 'missing reversioner' ('The Missing Reversioner: Reflections on the Status of Judea and Samaria', Israel Law Review, 1968). In 2017 the journal chose it as one of five articles that 'had a lasting impact on scholarly debate and beyond', and asked Eyal Benvenisti to comment; in Blum's words, Benvenisti 'made a frontal attack on the central thesis' (Blum's 2018 reply). On the recognition count: 'Among Israelis, it has long been customary … to emphasize that, internationally, only Britain (or only Britain and Pakistan) ever recognized it', writes Martin Kramer (Washington Institute, 2020), who argues that Abdullah did 'gain some recognition'.
    • Under the customary rule of uti possidetis juris, new states inherit the administrative borders of the territory they emerge from. Legal scholars Abraham Bell and Eugene Kontorovich argue this gives Israel the Mandate's borders as of May 1948, including the West Bank, East Jerusalem and possibly Gaza (Arizona Law Review, 2016). Barrister Natasha Hausdorff (UK Lawyers for Israel) has made this argument widely, concluding that land already legally Israel's cannot be 'occupied'.
    • The argument now has a judge of the International Court of Justice behind it. Dissenting from the Court's 2024 advisory opinion, its Vice-President Julia Sebutinde wrote that the Court 'misapplied the law of belligerent occupation' without first analysing 'the application of the principle of uti possidetis juris to the territory of the former British Mandate'. Israel, she wrote, was 'the only State to emerge as an independent State, inheriting the whole of the disputed territory under uti possidetis juris', and 'Israel's settlements in the disputed territories accord with Article 6 of the Mandate' (a section heading).
    • The Mandate (1922, Article 6) required the administration to 'encourage … close settlement by Jews on the land, including State lands and waste lands not required for public purposes', 'while ensuring that the rights and position of other sections of the population are not prejudiced'. The UN Charter's Article 80 says nothing in its trusteeship chapter shall 'alter in any manner the rights whatsoever of any states or any peoples or the terms of existing international instruments', which advocates read as preserving the Mandate's terms.
    • The 1949 armistice lines were explicitly not borders: the Jordan–Israel agreement says its demarcation lines 'are agreed upon by the Parties without prejudice to future territorial settlements or boundary lines or to claims of either Party relating thereto', its provisions 'dictated exclusively by military considerations' (Arts. VI(9) and II(2), Avalon Project text). That the land was never sovereign Palestinian territory is the advocates' conclusion from this history; it is not sourced here as a finding ⚠.
    • An Israeli government committee headed by a former Supreme Court justice concluded in 2012 that 'the classical laws of "occupation" … cannot be considered applicable' to Judea and Samaria (the Levy Report).
    • The United States has at times taken it. On 2 February 1981 President Reagan called the settlements 'not illegal', while criticising them as 'ill-advised' and 'unnecessarily provocative'; three years earlier the State Department Legal Adviser had told Congress they were illegal (Nicholas Rostow, The American Interest, 2010), and in November 2019 the US Secretary of State announced that 'the establishment of Israeli civilian settlements in the West Bank is not per se inconsistent with international law', while leaving the final status to negotiation. Earlier, Stephen Schwebel, later President of the International Court of Justice, wrote in 'What Weight to Conquest?' (1970) that Secretary of State Rogers 'appeared to uphold the legality of continued Israeli occupation of Arab territory' pending peace, and that 'In this Secretary Rogers is on sound ground', since 'Israel's action in 1967 was defensive' and 'occupation – though not annexation – is justified, pending a peace settlement' (opening, as summarised by Cambridge University Press). His own word there is occupation; his fuller argument that a defensive conqueror can have better title than an unlawful prior holder is in the body of the article, not read here ⚠.
  2. What's true

    The West Bank's pre-1967 status really was unusual, and 'disputed' has a legal pedigree.

    Jordan's 1950 annexation was recognised by very few states (only Britain and Pakistan, in the Levy Report's account as summarised by the JCPA), and there was no Palestinian state in 1967. Israeli legal scholars (Blum, later the Levy Committee, which concluded that 'the classical laws of "occupation" … cannot be considered applicable' to Israel's presence there) built a serious argument on that: the Fourth Geneva Convention speaks of the territory of a 'High Contracting Party', and the West Bank arguably wasn't one's. The armistice lines were not borders, and the land's final status was always left to negotiation, including in the Oslo Accords, which Israel and the PLO both signed. The uti possidetis argument is a serious one, published in a peer-reviewed law review and applied by its authors to other mandates and colonies (Iraq, Syria, Togoland, Cameroon).

    advocacy / viewJerusalem Center for Public Affairs, 'The Levy Report and the “Occupation” Narrative' (2012) (2012) finding ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). Quotes the report's conclusion: 'the classical laws of ‘occupation’ as set out in the relevant international conventions cannot be considered applicable to … Israel's presence in Judea and Samaria'; summarises its reasoning: 'no previously recognized sovereign' in 1967; Jordan's 1950 annexation recognised only by Britain and Pakistan; residual rights from the Mandate. JCPA: see its org page.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtYehuda Z. Blum, 'The Missing Reversioner: Reflections on the Status of Judea and Samaria', Israel Law Review 3 (1968) (1968) finding ✓

    Crossref (2026-09-29): Yehuda Z. Blum, 'The Missing Reversioner: Reflections on the Status of Judea and Samaria', Israel Law Review, April 1968, doi:10.1017/s0021223700001436; the abstract shows only the opening (Hebron and Bethlehem magistrates' decisions of February 1968 on Order No. 145). Its reception, from Blum's own 2018 reply 'The Status of Judea and Samaria Revisited: A Response to Eyal Benvenisti' (Israel Law Review, doi:10.1017/s0021223718000109, abstract read): chosen in 2017 as one of five articles that 'had a lasting impact on scholarly debate and beyond'; Benvenisti 'made a frontal attack on the central thesis', also in the AJIL (April 2017). The article's full argument is not read.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtAbraham Bell & Eugene Kontorovich, 'Palestine, Uti Possidetis Juris, and the Borders of Israel', Arizona Law Review 58 (2016) 633 (2016) finding ✓

    Abstract checked against the PDF: uti possidetis juris 'would dictate that Israel inherit the boundaries of the Mandate of Palestine as they existed in May, 1948', supporting claims to East Jerusalem, the West Bank and potentially Gaza (not the Golan).

    Open source ↗

  3. What's left out

    Israel's own Supreme Court has treated the West Bank as held under belligerent occupation since 1967, and so have the ICJ and the ICRC.

    In Beit Sourik (2004), Israel's Supreme Court wrote: 'Since 1967, Israel has been holding the areas of Judea and Samaria … in belligerent occupation', and called this 'the general point of departure of all parties', meaning the state too. The military commander's authority, it said, 'flows from the provisions of public international law regarding belligerent occupation'. Israel governs the West Bank through a military commander rather than by annexation, and the court located that commander's authority in the law of belligerent occupation. The International Court of Justice (2004, and again in 2024) and the ICRC treat it as occupied (allies' positions are not surveyed here, and the US position has shifted, see below), and the Levy Report (2012), a panel appointed by Netanyahu that concluded Israel is not an occupying power in the West Bank, could have its recommendations implemented only if the attorney general approved them (Human Rights Watch, which urged the government to reject it); whether any government later adopted its conclusions is not yet sourced here ⚠. In 2004 the Court held that the territories between the Green Line and the Mandate's eastern boundary 'were occupied by Israel in 1967' and that 'Subsequent events … have done nothing to alter this situation'; its one dissenting judge, Thomas Buergenthal, objected that the Court lacked 'the requisite factual bases for its sweeping findings', yet shared its conclusion that the Fourth Geneva Convention applies to 'the Occupied Palestinian Territory'. 'Disputed' is also true — but that describes the final status, not the legal regime in the meantime; a territory can be both disputed and occupied. As the ICRC puts it: 'The disputed status of a territory does not prevent the applicability of the law of occupation.' Against uti possidetis: the Mandate's administrative lines were meant to become a state for all its inhabitants, and in 1947 the UN partitioned them; Israel's own Declaration of Independence invoked that partition resolution. Israel never extended its law to the West Bank as sovereign territory (unlike East Jerusalem and the Golan), and its Supreme Court has treated it as held in belligerent occupation (Beit Sourik), even while governments avoided the word (see the 1968 cable below). In 2024 the ICJ held that Israel 'is not entitled to sovereignty over or to exercise sovereign powers in any part of the Occupied Palestinian Territory on account of its occupation' (para. 254) — though it did not address the uti possidetis argument by name; a scholarly reply exists: David Kretzmer (Verfassungsblog, October 2024) argues that 'at the time of independence Israel's political leaders did not claim that the new State was established in the whole of the territory of the Mandate', that its Provisional Government treated land the army held beyond the partition borders 'as occupied territory', and he summarises earlier objections by Malcolm Shaw and Ariel Zemach. Note also citation independence: where advocates of the doctrine cite the Bell and Kontorovich article, they count as one line of argument, not several confirmations (how many rely on it is not surveyed here ⚠). The argument's own history also cuts against it. In September 1967 the Foreign Ministry's legal adviser, Theodor Meron, advised the Prime Minister's office that 'civilian settlement in the administered territories contravenes explicit provisions of the Fourth Geneva Convention', adding that if settlement went ahead it was 'vital' that it be 'carried out by military and not civilian entities', in camps 'of a temporary rather than permanent nature' (the memo became public in 2006). Ted Belman, a retired lawyer whose pro-settlement blog Israpundit reproduces the memo, answers that Meron 'erred': in his reading Article 49 bars forcible transfer, and 'There is no prohibition against Jews moving to the territories'. A March 1968 cable that Meron co-signed (the Comay–Meron cable) explains why Israel avoided the word 'occupation': 'we must not acknowledge that our status in the administered territories is simply that of an occupying power', so the state 'always stressed the unique features of our situation: lack of recognized borders, Jordan's status as an occupier in the West Bank'. So the 'disputed territory' framing was, in part, a deliberate choice of vocabulary, co-signed by the same legal adviser who had warned against civilian settlement. And the US position has changed with each administration: Carter's legal adviser called the settlements inconsistent with international law in 1978, Reagan disagreed, Pompeo agreed with Reagan, and the Biden administration went back to 'inconsistent' in 2024. Vice-President Sebutinde's dissent from the 2024 opinion does not say there is no occupation either. Its own headings read 'An occupation through the lawful use of force (self-defence) is not unlawful' and 'A lawful occupation does not become unlawful due to passage of time', and it describes 'Israel's occupation' as different from decolonisation cases. The strongest judicial voice for Israel's claim argues a lawful occupation over disputed land, not the absence of one.

    Traps here:◆ Which territory?◆ Motte and bailey◆ Citation loop

    law / courtHCJ 2056/04 Beit Sourik Village Council v. Government of Israel (Supreme Court of Israel) (2004) finding ✓

    Judgment of 30 June 2004 (English translation, Cardozo project), paras. 1 and 23; checked against the text. Re-read 2026-10-12: para. 1, 'Since 1967, Israel has been holding the areas of Judea and Samaria [hereinafter – the area] in belligerent occupation'; para. 23, 'The general point of departure of all parties – which is also our point of departure – is that Israel holds the area in belligerent occupation (occupatio bellica)'; 'The authority of the military commander flows from the provisions of public international law regarding belligerent occupation.'

    Open source ↗

    law / courtICJ Advisory Opinion, Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (2004) finding ✓

    Read 2026-09-30 in the UN General Assembly document A/ES-10/273 (UNISPAL), which reproduces the opinion and the separate opinions. Para. 78: the territories 'situated between the Green Line … and the former eastern boundary of Palestine under the Mandate were occupied by Israel in 1967 … these were therefore occupied territories in which Israel had the status of occupying Power. Subsequent events in these territories … have done nothing to alter this situation. All these territories (including East Jerusalem) remain occupied territories'. Main findings by 14 votes to 1 (Judge Buergenthal against). Buergenthal's declaration: 'the Court did not have before it the requisite factual bases for its sweeping findings', but 'I share the Court's conclusion that international humanitarian law, including the Fourth Geneva Convention … [is] applicable to the Occupied Palestinian Territory'; 'the wall is causing deplorable suffering to many Palestinians'.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtICJ Advisory Opinion on the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (2024) finding ✓

    19 July 2024 (read on UNISPAL's copy of the Court's text). Para. 94: Israel's withdrawal 'has not entirely released it of its obligations under the law of occupation. Israel's obligations have remained commensurate with the degree of its effective control over the Gaza Strip.' Para. 254: 'Israel is not entitled to sovereignty over or to exercise sovereign powers in any part of the Occupied Palestinian Territory on account of its occupation.' Paras. 209–210: punitive demolitions under Mandate Defence (Emergency) Regulation 119. Verified 2026-09-30 against the Court's English PDF on UNISPAL (186-20240719-adv-01-00-en): paras. 94, 209–210 and 254 as quoted; para. 210 in full reads 'the measure of punitive demolition appears never to have been used against properties connected to Israeli civilians having committed similar offences'. Para. 119 (re-read 2026-09-30): 'the transfer by Israel of settlers to the West Bank and East Jerusalem, as well as Israel's maintenance of their presence, is contrary to the sixth paragraph of Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention'. Paras. 205–206 (read 2026-10-02, same PDF): 'through its practice of restricting movement, Israel differentiates in its treatment of Palestinians with reference to their freedom of movement'; the Court 'has taken note of Israel's security concerns', but 'the protection of the settlers and settlements … cannot be invoked as a ground to justify measures that treat Palestinians differently', and restrictions 'on all Palestinians solely on account of their Palestinian identity are disproportionate'; conclusion: the policies 'amount to prohibited discrimination' under the ICCPR, ICESCR and CERD. Paras. 225 and 229 (full PDF 186-20240719-adv-01-00-en, re-read 2026-10-12): Article 3 of CERD 'refers to two particularly severe forms of racial discrimination: racial segregation and apartheid'; 'The Court observes that Israel's legislation and measures impose and serve to maintain a near-complete separation in the West Bank and East Jerusalem between the settler and Palestinian communities. For this reason, the Court considers that Israel's legislation and measures constitute a breach of Article 3 of CERD.' (It does not say which of the two forms.) Para. 94 re-read 2026-10-13 in the Court's PDF on UNISPAL, verbatim: 'Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza Strip has not entirely released it of its obligations under the law of occupation. Israel's obligations have remained commensurate with the degree of its effective control over the Gaza Strip.'

    Open source ↗

    primary documentTheodor Meron (Foreign Ministry legal adviser), memo 'Settlement in the Administered Territories' (14 September 1967) and covering note to the Prime Minister's political secretary (18 September 1967), English text as reproduced on Israpundit (21 January 2014) (1967) finding ✓

    Read 2026-09-30 (the Military Court Watch PDF copy is behind a bot wall; its Wayback copy was rate-limited). Covering note: 'My conclusion is that civilian settlement in the administered territories contravenes explicit provisions of the Fourth Geneva Convention.' Memo: Article 49's last paragraph and the ICRC Commentary, 'The prohibition therefore is categorical and not conditional upon the motives for the transfer or its objectives'; 'If it is decided to go ahead with Jewish settlement … it seems to me vital, therefore, that settlement is carried out by military and not civilian entities … in the framework of camps and is, on the face of it, of a temporary rather than permanent nature.' The site's commentary (Ted Belman, 'a retired lawyer living in Jerusalem'; pro-settlement): 'In hindsight it is easy to see where Meron erred … There is no prohibition against Jews moving to the territories.' An English text on a partisan blog; the Hebrew original is not read here.

    Open source ↗

    primary documentComay–Meron cable, 20 March 1968 (Israel State Archives, published by Akevot) (1968) incident ✓

    Checked on the Akevot page: 'we must not acknowledge that our status in the administered territories is simply that of an occupying power…'. Re-read 2026-10-13 on the Akevot page: 'Therefore, we have always stressed the unique features of our situation: lack of recognized borders, Jordan's status as an occupier in the West Bank, etc.'

    Open source ↗

    primary documentUS Secretary of State, press remarks on Israeli settlements, 18 November 2019 (2019) incident ✓

    Full text checked: 'not per se inconsistent with international law'; cites Reagan 1981; 'We are not addressing or prejudging the ultimate status of the West Bank.'

    Open source ↗

    law / courtICRC: What does the law say about the responsibilities of the Occupying Power in the occupied Palestinian territory? finding ✓

    Read: Gaza remains occupied because Israel 'still exercises effective control … notably through key elements of authority … including over its borders (airspace, sea and land – at the exception of the border with Egypt)'; also 'The disputed status of a territory does not prevent the applicability of the law of occupation.' Re-read 2026-10-12, full sentence: 'The ICRC considers Gaza to remain occupied territory on the basis that Israel still exercises effective control over the Strip, notably through key elements of authority over the strip, including over its borders (airspace, sea and land – at the exception of the border with Egypt).'

    Open source ↗

    law / courtDissenting opinion of Vice-President Sebutinde, ICJ Advisory Opinion on the Occupied Palestinian Territory (19 July 2024), UNISPAL copy (2024) finding ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). Summary points: the Court 'should have refrained'; a 'one-sided “forensic audit”'; 'misapplied the law of belligerent occupation … without a prior critical analysis of … uti possidetis juris'. Text: Israel 'the only State to emerge as an independent State, inheriting the whole of the disputed territory under uti possidetis juris'; headings 'An occupation through the lawful use of force (self-defence) is not unlawful', 'A lawful occupation does not become unlawful due to passage of time', 'Israel's settlements in the disputed territories accord with Article 6 of the Mandate'; 'Israel's occupation is different from cases of decolonization'. (icj-cij.org walled; UNISPAL copy.) Re-read 2026-10-01 (Gaza): 'the only time Israel has unilaterally withdrawn from the Gaza Strip in 2005 and not insisted on concurrent security guarantees for itself, the results have been disastrous for Israel'; the same passage says Oslo collapsed through 'Israel's unwillingness to continue its withdrawal … in the absence of effective security guarantees from the Palestinian side'. Her background section also records that the UN 'considers the Gaza Strip territory occupied by Israel precisely because Israel retains significant control over Gaza's borders, airspace, and maritime access'. Re-read 2026-10-01 (Gaza): 'the only time Israel has unilaterally withdrawn from the Gaza Strip in 2005 and not insisted on concurrent security guarantees for itself, the results have been disastrous for Israel'; the same passage says Oslo collapsed through 'Israel's unwillingness to continue its withdrawal … in the absence of effective security guarantees from the Palestinian side'. Her background section also records that the UN 'considers the Gaza Strip territory occupied by Israel precisely because Israel retains significant control over Gaza's borders, airspace, and maritime access'. Re-read 2026-10-15 (UNISPAL PDF), summary point in full: 'The Court has misapplied the law of belligerent occupation and has adopted presumptions implicit in the question of the General Assembly without a prior critical analysis of relevant issues, including the application of the principle of uti possidetis juris to the territory of the former British Mandate, the question of Israel's borders and its competing sovereignty claims, the nature of the Palestinian right of self-determination and its relationship to Israel's own rights and security concerns'.

    Open source ↗

    advocacy / viewHuman Rights Watch, 'Israel: Reject Settlements Report' (18 July 2012) (2012) finding ✓

    Read 2026-09-30. The panel headed by retired Supreme Court Justice Edmond Levy (with Tchia Shapira and Alan Baker), appointed by Netanyahu in January 2012, concluded 'that Israel is not an occupying power in the West Bank and that settlements do not violate international law'; report issued 9 July 2012; 'Under the terms of the panel's establishment, its recommendations will not be implemented unless Israel's attorney general approves them'; recommended retroactive authorisation of outposts. HRW urged the government to reject it. Also: '136 government-authorized West Bank settlements, with more than 500,000 residents'.

    Open source ↗

    advocacy / viewDavid Kretzmer, 'The principle of uti possidetis juris and the borders of Israel', Verfassungsblog (9 October 2024), in the debate on the 2024 ICJ Advisory Opinion finding ✓

    Read 2026-10-02. On 'the Bell/Kontorovich/Sebitunde argument': 'at the time of independence Israel's political leaders did not claim that the new State was established in the whole of the territory of the Mandate. In fact, the founding fathers of the State of Israel claimed the opposite: they accepted the principle of partition'; the Provisional Government 'related to territories held by the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) that were not included in the Jewish State under the UN Partition Borders as occupied territory'; summarises Malcolm Shaw (the principle may be departed from to protect peace) and Ariel Zemach (never applied to let a minority claim sovereignty over the whole territory), and calls their grounds 'convincing'.

    Open source ↗

  4. More context

    How to talk about this.

    Acknowledge first: the West Bank's legal history really is unusual, Jordan's annexation was barely recognised, and the final status was always left to negotiation. Ask one question: 'if it isn't occupied, what is the legal status of the Palestinians who live there?'; the answer shows where the argument leads. Share one checkable thing: Israel's own Supreme Court, in Beit Sourik (2004), described the area as held 'in belligerent occupation'. What not to say: 'it's just stolen land' as if the Jewish historical connection didn't exist. From the other side: grant the legal arguments serious lawyers make for 'disputed', then ask what rights they give the people living there.

  5. Where it leads if pressed

    Working it out: the legal argument, the state's own position, and what follows.

    'Disputed, not occupied' is a serious legal argument with a history, so the test is how it fares against the record, including Israel's own. The case for 'disputed': Jordan's 1950 annexation was recognised by very few states, so no recognised sovereign held the West Bank in 1967; Yehuda Blum argued in 1968 that this left a 'missing reversioner'; the Levy Report (2012) concluded that 'the classical laws of "occupation" … cannot be considered applicable'; Bell and Kontorovich argued that uti possidetis juris gives Israel the Mandate's borders, and Judge Sebutinde's ICJ dissent leaned the same way. A third position accepts the word and defends the fact: Stephen Schwebel wrote in 1970 (American Journal of International Law) that, since 'Israel's action in 1967 was defensive', 'occupation – though not annexation – is justified, pending a peace settlement'. That is an argument that the occupation is lawful, not that there is none. The case for 'occupied': the ICJ in 2004 and 2024 and the ICRC; and Israel's own Supreme Court, which in Beit Sourik (2004) wrote that 'since 1967, Israel has been holding the areas of Judea and Samaria … in belligerent occupation', calling this 'the general point of departure of all parties'. In 1967 the Foreign Ministry's legal adviser, Theodor Meron, concluded that 'civilian settlement in the administered territories contravenes explicit provisions of the Fourth Geneva Convention'. And David Kretzmer notes that at independence Israel's founders did not claim the whole Mandate territory. Israel's political branches have since moved the other way: in 2025 the Knesset voted 71 to 13 for a non-binding motion on 'applying Israeli sovereignty to Judea, Samaria and the Jordan Valley', and security-cabinet decisions in February 2026, in the words of a pro-Israel, pro-two-state group, 'eroded the legal and practical distinctions between Israel and the West Bank'. That cuts both ways: it is the strongest sign that Israel's own government treats the territory as disputed and claimable, and a motion to apply sovereignty also concedes that it does not yet apply. The worst case for each side. For 'disputed, not occupied': grant Blum and Levy at their strongest; Israel still governs the territory through a military commander whose authority its own Supreme Court traces to the law of belligerent occupation, and in that case the state itself argued from the occupation framework. For 'just occupied, nothing more': grant the ICJ at its strongest; the pre-1967 status really was unusual, the US position has moved before (in 1978 the State Department's legal adviser told Congress the settlements were illegal; in 1981 Reagan called them 'not illegal', as Nicholas Rostow recounts), and even the 2019 US statement on settlements said it was 'not addressing or prejudging the ultimate status of the West Bank'. Holds on the evidence here: Israel's own courts, the ICJ and the ICRC treat the West Bank as occupied; the 'disputed' argument has a real legal pedigree, but the courts and bodies cited here, including Israel's own Supreme Court, have not adopted it. Could happen under a negotiated settlement: a final status that differs from either label. Not supported: that the West Bank is simply Israeli territory under international law, or that its status has no legal complexity.

    What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean

    historyMartin Kramer, 'The Ghost of Annexation Past', Washington Institute for Near East Policy (25 June 2020) (2020) finding ✓

    Read 29 Sept 2026 (the page carries the article's opening). Perspective: Kramer is the Institute's Walter P. Stern Fellow; see the washington-institute org page. On 24 April 1950 Jordan's parliament resolved on 'complete unity between the two banks'. 'Among Israelis, it has long been customary to dismiss Abdullah's act as illegal, and to emphasize that, internationally, only Britain (or only Britain and Pakistan) ever recognized it.' His summary: Abdullah could 'redraw the map, gain some recognition, and still leave only regrets'. The recognition he means is not detailed in the part read.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtYehuda Z. Blum, 'The Missing Reversioner: Reflections on the Status of Judea and Samaria', Israel Law Review 3 (1968) (1968) finding ✓

    Crossref (2026-09-29): Yehuda Z. Blum, 'The Missing Reversioner: Reflections on the Status of Judea and Samaria', Israel Law Review, April 1968, doi:10.1017/s0021223700001436; the abstract shows only the opening (Hebron and Bethlehem magistrates' decisions of February 1968 on Order No. 145). Its reception, from Blum's own 2018 reply 'The Status of Judea and Samaria Revisited: A Response to Eyal Benvenisti' (Israel Law Review, doi:10.1017/s0021223718000109, abstract read): chosen in 2017 as one of five articles that 'had a lasting impact on scholarly debate and beyond'; Benvenisti 'made a frontal attack on the central thesis', also in the AJIL (April 2017). The article's full argument is not read.

    Open source ↗

    advocacy / viewJerusalem Center for Public Affairs, 'The Levy Report and the “Occupation” Narrative' (2012) (2012) finding ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). Quotes the report's conclusion: 'the classical laws of ‘occupation’ as set out in the relevant international conventions cannot be considered applicable to … Israel's presence in Judea and Samaria'; summarises its reasoning: 'no previously recognized sovereign' in 1967; Jordan's 1950 annexation recognised only by Britain and Pakistan; residual rights from the Mandate. JCPA: see its org page.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtAbraham Bell & Eugene Kontorovich, 'Palestine, Uti Possidetis Juris, and the Borders of Israel', Arizona Law Review 58 (2016) 633 (2016) finding ✓

    Abstract checked against the PDF: uti possidetis juris 'would dictate that Israel inherit the boundaries of the Mandate of Palestine as they existed in May, 1948', supporting claims to East Jerusalem, the West Bank and potentially Gaza (not the Golan).

    Open source ↗

    law / courtDissenting opinion of Vice-President Sebutinde, ICJ Advisory Opinion on the Occupied Palestinian Territory (19 July 2024), UNISPAL copy (2024) finding ✓

    Read (2026-09-28). Summary points: the Court 'should have refrained'; a 'one-sided “forensic audit”'; 'misapplied the law of belligerent occupation … without a prior critical analysis of … uti possidetis juris'. Text: Israel 'the only State to emerge as an independent State, inheriting the whole of the disputed territory under uti possidetis juris'; headings 'An occupation through the lawful use of force (self-defence) is not unlawful', 'A lawful occupation does not become unlawful due to passage of time', 'Israel's settlements in the disputed territories accord with Article 6 of the Mandate'; 'Israel's occupation is different from cases of decolonization'. (icj-cij.org walled; UNISPAL copy.) Re-read 2026-10-01 (Gaza): 'the only time Israel has unilaterally withdrawn from the Gaza Strip in 2005 and not insisted on concurrent security guarantees for itself, the results have been disastrous for Israel'; the same passage says Oslo collapsed through 'Israel's unwillingness to continue its withdrawal … in the absence of effective security guarantees from the Palestinian side'. Her background section also records that the UN 'considers the Gaza Strip territory occupied by Israel precisely because Israel retains significant control over Gaza's borders, airspace, and maritime access'. Re-read 2026-10-01 (Gaza): 'the only time Israel has unilaterally withdrawn from the Gaza Strip in 2005 and not insisted on concurrent security guarantees for itself, the results have been disastrous for Israel'; the same passage says Oslo collapsed through 'Israel's unwillingness to continue its withdrawal … in the absence of effective security guarantees from the Palestinian side'. Her background section also records that the UN 'considers the Gaza Strip territory occupied by Israel precisely because Israel retains significant control over Gaza's borders, airspace, and maritime access'. Re-read 2026-10-15 (UNISPAL PDF), summary point in full: 'The Court has misapplied the law of belligerent occupation and has adopted presumptions implicit in the question of the General Assembly without a prior critical analysis of relevant issues, including the application of the principle of uti possidetis juris to the territory of the former British Mandate, the question of Israel's borders and its competing sovereignty claims, the nature of the Palestinian right of self-determination and its relationship to Israel's own rights and security concerns'.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtICJ Advisory Opinion, Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (2004) finding ✓

    Read 2026-09-30 in the UN General Assembly document A/ES-10/273 (UNISPAL), which reproduces the opinion and the separate opinions. Para. 78: the territories 'situated between the Green Line … and the former eastern boundary of Palestine under the Mandate were occupied by Israel in 1967 … these were therefore occupied territories in which Israel had the status of occupying Power. Subsequent events in these territories … have done nothing to alter this situation. All these territories (including East Jerusalem) remain occupied territories'. Main findings by 14 votes to 1 (Judge Buergenthal against). Buergenthal's declaration: 'the Court did not have before it the requisite factual bases for its sweeping findings', but 'I share the Court's conclusion that international humanitarian law, including the Fourth Geneva Convention … [is] applicable to the Occupied Palestinian Territory'; 'the wall is causing deplorable suffering to many Palestinians'.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtICJ Advisory Opinion on the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (2024) finding ✓

    19 July 2024 (read on UNISPAL's copy of the Court's text). Para. 94: Israel's withdrawal 'has not entirely released it of its obligations under the law of occupation. Israel's obligations have remained commensurate with the degree of its effective control over the Gaza Strip.' Para. 254: 'Israel is not entitled to sovereignty over or to exercise sovereign powers in any part of the Occupied Palestinian Territory on account of its occupation.' Paras. 209–210: punitive demolitions under Mandate Defence (Emergency) Regulation 119. Verified 2026-09-30 against the Court's English PDF on UNISPAL (186-20240719-adv-01-00-en): paras. 94, 209–210 and 254 as quoted; para. 210 in full reads 'the measure of punitive demolition appears never to have been used against properties connected to Israeli civilians having committed similar offences'. Para. 119 (re-read 2026-09-30): 'the transfer by Israel of settlers to the West Bank and East Jerusalem, as well as Israel's maintenance of their presence, is contrary to the sixth paragraph of Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention'. Paras. 205–206 (read 2026-10-02, same PDF): 'through its practice of restricting movement, Israel differentiates in its treatment of Palestinians with reference to their freedom of movement'; the Court 'has taken note of Israel's security concerns', but 'the protection of the settlers and settlements … cannot be invoked as a ground to justify measures that treat Palestinians differently', and restrictions 'on all Palestinians solely on account of their Palestinian identity are disproportionate'; conclusion: the policies 'amount to prohibited discrimination' under the ICCPR, ICESCR and CERD. Paras. 225 and 229 (full PDF 186-20240719-adv-01-00-en, re-read 2026-10-12): Article 3 of CERD 'refers to two particularly severe forms of racial discrimination: racial segregation and apartheid'; 'The Court observes that Israel's legislation and measures impose and serve to maintain a near-complete separation in the West Bank and East Jerusalem between the settler and Palestinian communities. For this reason, the Court considers that Israel's legislation and measures constitute a breach of Article 3 of CERD.' (It does not say which of the two forms.) Para. 94 re-read 2026-10-13 in the Court's PDF on UNISPAL, verbatim: 'Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza Strip has not entirely released it of its obligations under the law of occupation. Israel's obligations have remained commensurate with the degree of its effective control over the Gaza Strip.'

    Open source ↗

    law / courtHCJ 2056/04 Beit Sourik Village Council v. Government of Israel (Supreme Court of Israel) (2004) finding ✓

    Judgment of 30 June 2004 (English translation, Cardozo project), paras. 1 and 23; checked against the text. Re-read 2026-10-12: para. 1, 'Since 1967, Israel has been holding the areas of Judea and Samaria [hereinafter – the area] in belligerent occupation'; para. 23, 'The general point of departure of all parties – which is also our point of departure – is that Israel holds the area in belligerent occupation (occupatio bellica)'; 'The authority of the military commander flows from the provisions of public international law regarding belligerent occupation.'

    Open source ↗

    primary documentTheodor Meron (Foreign Ministry legal adviser), memo 'Settlement in the Administered Territories' (14 September 1967) and covering note to the Prime Minister's political secretary (18 September 1967), English text as reproduced on Israpundit (21 January 2014) (1967) finding ✓

    Read 2026-09-30 (the Military Court Watch PDF copy is behind a bot wall; its Wayback copy was rate-limited). Covering note: 'My conclusion is that civilian settlement in the administered territories contravenes explicit provisions of the Fourth Geneva Convention.' Memo: Article 49's last paragraph and the ICRC Commentary, 'The prohibition therefore is categorical and not conditional upon the motives for the transfer or its objectives'; 'If it is decided to go ahead with Jewish settlement … it seems to me vital, therefore, that settlement is carried out by military and not civilian entities … in the framework of camps and is, on the face of it, of a temporary rather than permanent nature.' The site's commentary (Ted Belman, 'a retired lawyer living in Jerusalem'; pro-settlement): 'In hindsight it is easy to see where Meron erred … There is no prohibition against Jews moving to the territories.' An English text on a partisan blog; the Hebrew original is not read here.

    Open source ↗

    advocacy / viewDavid Kretzmer, 'The principle of uti possidetis juris and the borders of Israel', Verfassungsblog (9 October 2024), in the debate on the 2024 ICJ Advisory Opinion finding ✓

    Read 2026-10-02. On 'the Bell/Kontorovich/Sebitunde argument': 'at the time of independence Israel's political leaders did not claim that the new State was established in the whole of the territory of the Mandate. In fact, the founding fathers of the State of Israel claimed the opposite: they accepted the principle of partition'; the Provisional Government 'related to territories held by the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) that were not included in the Jewish State under the UN Partition Borders as occupied territory'; summarises Malcolm Shaw (the principle may be departed from to protect peace) and Ariel Zemach (never applied to let a minority claim sovereignty over the whole territory), and calls their grounds 'convincing'.

    Open source ↗

    primary documentUS Secretary of State, press remarks on Israeli settlements, 18 November 2019 (2019) incident ✓

    Full text checked: 'not per se inconsistent with international law'; cites Reagan 1981; 'We are not addressing or prejudging the ultimate status of the West Bank.'

    Open source ↗

    pressAl Jazeera, 'Israeli parliament approves symbolic motion on West Bank annexation' (23 July 2025) (2025) incident ✓

    Read: Knesset vote 71–13 on a non-binding motion 'applying Israeli sovereignty to Judea, Samaria and the Jordan Valley'.

    Open source ↗

    advocacy / viewIsrael Policy Forum, 'Israel's New Escalation of West Bank Annexation' (February 2026) (2026) incident ✓

    Read: security cabinet decisions of 8 February 2026 (repeal of the Jordanian-era restriction on land sales to Israelis, among others); 'eroded the legal and practical distinctions between Israel and the West Bank'. IPF is a US pro-Israel, pro-two-state organisation. Re-read 2026-10-12: 'these decisions cap off more than three years of policies that have eroded the legal and practical distinctions between Israel and the West Bank, accelerating the slide toward full Israeli sovereignty of the territory'.

    Open source ↗

    law / courtStephen M. Schwebel, 'What Weight to Conquest?', American Journal of International Law 64 (1970) 344 (1970) finding ⚠

    Crossref (2026-09-29): 'What Weight to Conquest?', American Journal of International Law, April 1970, doi:10.2307/2198669; reprinted in Schwebel's Justice in International Law (Cambridge UP, 1994), doi:10.1017/cbo9780511551765.032. Read 2026-10-01: the Cambridge chapter summary (the opening paragraphs): Rogers 'appeared to uphold the legality of continued Israeli occupation of Arab territory pending "the establishment of a state of peace between the parties instead of the state of belligerency." In this Secretary Rogers is on sound ground. That ground may well be based on appreciation of the fact that Israel's action in 1967 was defensive, and on the theory that, since the danger in response to which defensive action was taken remains, occupation – though not annexation – is justified, pending a peace settlement.' The body of the article (the better-title argument) is not read ⚠.

    Not yet read at the source. Tried: 2026-10-01: full text behind the publisher; only the reprint's record read.

    Open source ↗

    advocacy / viewNicholas Rostow, 'Are the Settlements Illegal?', The American Interest 5(4) (1 March 2010) (2010) finding ✓

    Read 29 Sept 2026. Perspective: the author (then SUNY university counsel) argues that deciding the legality question 'is a pitfall the Obama Administration has been wise to avoid'. 'In 1978, the State Department Legal Adviser wrote Congress to that effect' (that settlements were illegal); 'On February 2, 1981, President Reagan stated that the settlements were "not illegal", although he criticized them as "ill-advised" and "unnecessarily provocative."' Reagan's own words are quoted from this secondary account; the primary transcript is not read.

    Open source ↗

    If it isn't occupied, what are the Palestinians who live there?

    The occupation framework is, among other things, what gives West Bank Palestinians their legal protections under the law of war — protections Israel's own court enforces against its army (Beit Sourik rerouted the separation barrier for exactly that reason). Remove the framework and the law-of-war protections go with it: the territory isn't annexed, so its Palestinians aren't citizens; if it isn't occupied, they're not protected persons either. The argument has to answer that question, and the answers on offer are few: citizenship (the one-state models), autonomy without citizenship (as in several annexation plans), or rule over a population without rights. Its honest core — that the final status is open and the Jewish historical connection is real — survives without it, in negotiation. The uti possidetis version makes this sharper: if the West Bank is sovereign Israeli territory, its Palestinian residents are residents of Israel. A state can't claim the land as its own and the people on it as nobody's responsibility, which leaves citizenship, autonomy without citizenship, or the rule of a population without rights — and only the first gives the people the protections the occupation framework gave them.

    law / courtHCJ 2056/04 Beit Sourik Village Council v. Government of Israel (Supreme Court of Israel) (2004) finding ✓

    Judgment of 30 June 2004 (English translation, Cardozo project), paras. 1 and 23; checked against the text. Re-read 2026-10-12: para. 1, 'Since 1967, Israel has been holding the areas of Judea and Samaria [hereinafter – the area] in belligerent occupation'; para. 23, 'The general point of departure of all parties – which is also our point of departure – is that Israel holds the area in belligerent occupation (occupatio bellica)'; 'The authority of the military commander flows from the provisions of public international law regarding belligerent occupation.'

    Open source ↗

The usual reply — and its own traps

Arguments travel in pairs. Here is what the other side typically answers. Check whether both lean on the same trick.

heard from pro-Palestinian voices“Israel is an apartheid state.” Both lean on: ◆ Which territory? ◆ Motte and bailey

Where this argument points

This argument comes up in the debate about these solutions — for, against or around them:

Keep exploring