Argument · heard on both sides
“UNRWA schools teach hatred of Jews and Israel.”
Pro-Israel version: UN-funded schools raise children on antisemitism and glorification of violence. Pro-Palestinian mirror: UNRWA schools are among the best in the region and the attacks on them are a pretext to defund refugee services.
Made publicly as a argument by European Parliament
Where it's been said
“[The European Parliament] is concerned about the hate speech and violence taught in Palestinian school textbooks and used in schools by UNRWA.”
“The EP resolution is in actuality functioning as part of Israel's colonial strategy to prohibit the Palestinian people from utilizing education as a legitimate tool of resistance.”
Traps in play:◆ Citation loop◆ "They all…"
Why people find it convincing
- UNRWA runs schools that many refugee children depend on: in the occupied Palestinian territory alone, 'approximately 400 schools', 'educating approximately 350,000 students' (the UN Secretary-General's figures, as cited in Vice-President Sebutinde's separate opinion to the ICJ, October 2025).
- Textbook reviews have found content that delegitimises Israel and erases it from maps; the EU-commissioned Georg Eckert Institute study (2021) found the books 'contain anti-Semitic narratives and glorifications of violence'.
- The UN's own review says it. The independent review of UNRWA's neutrality, led by Catherine Colonna for the Secretary-General (April 2024), found that 'neutrality-related issues persist', including 'host-country textbooks with problematic content being used in some UNRWA schools'. UNRWA's latest rapid review had found 'issues of concern' on 3.85% of Palestinian Authority textbook pages: maps without Israel, Jerusalem as Palestine's capital, Israeli cities named as Palestinian. The report calls them marginal, 'Even if marginal, these issues constitute a grave violation of neutrality', and notes that some members of UNRWA's Advisory Commission remain opposed to removing 'discriminatory sentences from textbooks'.
- The Colonna review found 'instances of staff publicly expressing political views'; the non-governmental organisation UN Watch reported in January 2024 on 'a 3000-member Telegram chat group of UNRWA Teachers in Gaza who cheered and celebrated Hamas's October 7th massacre', focusing on '30 UNRWA teachers' who, it says, 'called for the execution of Israelis' and praised the attackers as 'heroes' ('UNRWA's Terrorgram', 29 January 2024). The identification is UN Watch's own; UNRWA replied that the chat was ‘not set-up, nor authorized, nor managed by UNRWA’ and that its membership cannot be verified; of the 30 people named, 18 could be reviewed, three of whom ‘do not work for the Agency’, six were ‘inconclusive’ and ‘The remaining nine may be active personnel’, referred to its investigation department (UNRWA, ‘Claims versus Facts’, 26 February 2024). More generally, the UN's independent review (led by Catherine Colonna, April 2024) found that despite rules covering staff's 'use of social media', 'neutrality-related issues persist', including 'instances of staff publicly expressing political views'; no independent check of this Telegram group's membership is sourced here ⚠.
- Palestinian children growing up under occupation or siege learn their national story at home and in the street regardless of what a textbook says.
What's true
The schools matter enormously, and problematic content has been documented.
UNRWA's school system is a lifeline for refugee children. UNRWA uses the curriculum of the host authority — in the West Bank and Gaza, the Palestinian Authority's. An EU-commissioned study by the Georg Eckert Institute (2021), covering 156 of 309 textbooks, found 'a complex picture'. The books 'adopt UNESCO standards … such as material on human rights', yet 'express antagonism towards Israel'. The same summary says they 'contain anti-Semitic narratives and glorifications of violence'. 'Direct calls for violence against Israelis were not found', but there are 'portrayals that defend, or even support, violence against Israelis'. One religious-education book contains 'cumulative stereotypes and accusations that can clearly be characterised as anti-Semitic', and other depictions carry 'implications of a Jewish conspiracy'. In the 18 books amended for 2020/21, some conflict references in maths and science and some references to armed-resistance figures were removed or amended. Israel is 'seldom mentioned by name', usually as the 'Zionist occupation', and 'maps of the region do not show Israel' (the institute's own summary of its findings). IMPACT-se (see its org page) surveyed 122 UNRWA-labelled self-study booklets produced during the 2020 school closures and found that most of the problematic content was 'inherited from the PA curriculum', but that 'in a not-insignificant number of instances' UNRWA had introduced problematic content of its own; one example it gives is a Grade 8 Arabic grammar card from UNRWA's Gaza education department (Summer 2020, pp. 1, 3, 10) with sentences such as 'Jihad is one of the doors to Paradise' (IMPACT-se, January 2021). UNRWA's response (14 January 2021): 'in the rush to continue students' education uninterrupted, some material the Agency had previously identified as not in line with UN values was mistakenly included'; it said it had reviewed all of its self-learning material and was launching a secure platform holding only approved materials. UNRWA's own account of one later step: in June 2025 Commissioner-General Philippe Lazzarini told the Agency's Advisory Commission that UNRWA uses host-government textbooks ('best practice in refugee education globally'), that the PA's Grade 5 Arabic textbook 'includes a portrait of Dalal al Mughrabi, a Palestinian militant, that does not align with United Nations values', that he had written to President Abbas that UNRWA 'would no longer teach' it, and that 'The books have been withdrawn and replaced with self-learning materials developed by the Agency'.
dataGeorg Eckert Institute, 'Report on Palestinian Textbooks' (EU-commissioned, published 2021): FAQ summarising the findings (2021) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-28). 156 textbooks selected from 309, plus 18 amended in 2020. 'a complex picture: on one hand the textbooks adopt UNESCO standards … such as material on human rights. Yet on the other hand they express antagonism towards Israel'; 'contain anti-Semitic narratives and glorifications of violence'; 'Direct calls for violence against Israelis were not found'; 'portrayals that defend, or even support, violence against Israelis'; a religious-education book 'contains cumulative stereotypes and accusations that can clearly be characterised as anti-Semitic'; other depictions carry 'implications of a Jewish conspiracy'; 2020/21 amendments removed some conflict references in maths and science and amended or removed some references to armed-resistance figures; Israel 'seldom mentioned by name', 'Zionist occupation'; 'Maps of the region do not show Israel'. The full 194-page report not read here.
advocacy / viewIMPACT-se, 'Review of UNRWA-Produced Study Materials in the Palestinian Territories' (January 2021) (2021) finding ✓
Read 2026-10-01. Surveyed '122 UNRWA-labeled booklets (of an estimated 150–200)', examined 'in close conjunction with the relevant PA textbooks'; most problematic material 'inherited from the PA curriculum', but 'in a not-insignificant number of instances, we found the introduction of UNRWA-produced problematic content'; Example 3: Arabic Language, Grade 8, pp. 1, 3, 10 (UNRWA Department of Education—Gaza, Supplementary Study Cards, Summer 2020): 'Jihad is one of the doors to Paradise'; notes UNRWA's position that it 'is unable to alter' PA textbook material. Later IMPACT-se reviews (2022, 2023) exist, not read.
primary documentPhilippe Lazzarini, UNRWA Commissioner-General, statement at the meeting of the Advisory Commission (25 June 2025) — UNISPAL copy (2025) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-01. On education: 'In all UNRWA schools, we use textbooks from host governments'; the Grade 5 Arabic textbook's portrait of Dalal al Mughrabi 'does not align with United Nations values'; concerns raised with the Ministry 'multiple times'; letter to President Abbas ('Last December'); books 'withdrawn and replaced with self-learning materials developed by the Agency'. Also: Colonna review, 20 of 50 recommendations to be fully implemented by end of June; staff lists shared with host countries and Israel quarterly. Re-read 2026-10-12 (statement dated 25 June 2025): 'In all UNRWA schools, we use textbooks from host governments. This is best practice in refugee education globally'; 'The Grade 5 Arabic textbook includes a portrait of Dalal al Mughrabi, a Palestinian militant, that does not align with United Nations values'; 'Last December, I wrote to President Abbas informing him that UNRWA would no longer teach the Grade 5 Arabic textbook in our schools. The books have been withdrawn and replaced with self-learning materials developed by the Agency.'
primary documentUNRWA, 'UNRWA Reviews Self-learning Material to Ensure Full Adherence to Highest UN Principles' (statement, 14 January 2021) — UNISPAL copy (2021) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-01. 'more than 700 schools educating more than 500,000 Palestine refugee children'; 'in the rush to continue students' education uninterrupted, some material the Agency had previously identified as not in line with UN values was mistakenly included'; 'a thorough review of the entirety of the self-learning material'; a 'secure Agency-wide self-learning platform'; host-country curricula 'Consistent with UN practice in all refugee situations'.
What's left out
Whose curriculum, who reviews, and what the evidence clusters are.
Much of the content comes from the host authority's curriculum rather than being authored by UNRWA, which says it acts on content that does not align with UN values (Lazzarini, above); how effectively is what IMPACT-se and UNRWA dispute. Much of the evidence comes from parties to the dispute (IMPACT-se on one side, UNRWA and BADIL on the other); the Georg Eckert study was commissioned by the EU rather than by either of them, which is why this entry leans on it. 'All UNRWA schools teach hatred' and 'there is no problem' both fail against it. The two sides also disagree about the yardstick itself. The European Parliament has tied EU funding to 'UNESCO standards of peace, tolerance, coexistence and nonviolence'. The Palestinian refugee-rights group BADIL, rejecting that resolution, called these Israel's 'handpicked educational standards' and defended education as 'a legitimate tool of resistance'. Part of the dispute is over what the books should be measured against, not only over what is in them.
Traps here:◆ Citation loop◆ "They all…"
dataGeorg Eckert Institute, 'Report on Palestinian Textbooks' (EU-commissioned, published 2021): FAQ summarising the findings (2021) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-28). 156 textbooks selected from 309, plus 18 amended in 2020. 'a complex picture: on one hand the textbooks adopt UNESCO standards … such as material on human rights. Yet on the other hand they express antagonism towards Israel'; 'contain anti-Semitic narratives and glorifications of violence'; 'Direct calls for violence against Israelis were not found'; 'portrayals that defend, or even support, violence against Israelis'; a religious-education book 'contains cumulative stereotypes and accusations that can clearly be characterised as anti-Semitic'; other depictions carry 'implications of a Jewish conspiracy'; 2020/21 amendments removed some conflict references in maths and science and amended or removed some references to armed-resistance figures; Israel 'seldom mentioned by name', 'Zionist occupation'; 'Maps of the region do not show Israel'. The full 194-page report not read here.
advocacy / viewBADIL, 'BADIL Rejects the European Parliament's Israeli-influenced Allegations about Palestinian Textbooks' (PR/EN/070521/09, May 2021) (2021) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28). Quotes the EP resolution of 29 April 2021 (2019 discharge report): 'is concerned about the hate speech and violence taught in Palestinian school textbooks and used in schools by UNRWA; […] insists that […] EU funding […] must be made conditional on educational material and course content complying with UNESCO standards of peace, tolerance, coexistence and nonviolence'. BADIL: the resolution is 'functioning as part of Israel's colonial strategy to prohibit the Palestinian people from utilizing education as a legitimate tool of resistance'; the allegations 'recycled from IMPACT-se's reports'. A later EP resolution (11 April 2024) repeated the concern (reported; text not read here).
More context
How to talk about this.
Acknowledge first: UNRWA schools use the host governments' textbooks, and reviews have found content that glorifies violence or erases Israel. Ask one question: 'what exactly is in the current books, and what has been changed?'; the answer has shifted over the years. Share one checkable thing: the independent reviews (including the one commissioned by the EU) and their findings on both problems and improvements. What not to say: 'UNRWA teaches children to kill', or the denial that there's any problem. From the other side: grant that UNRWA also teaches 'more than 500,000 Palestine refugee children' in 'more than 700 schools' (its own figures, 2021) to read and count, then ask who would educate them if it stopped.
primary documentUNRWA, 'UNRWA Reviews Self-learning Material to Ensure Full Adherence to Highest UN Principles' (statement, 14 January 2021) — UNISPAL copy (2021) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-01. 'more than 700 schools educating more than 500,000 Palestine refugee children'; 'in the rush to continue students' education uninterrupted, some material the Agency had previously identified as not in line with UN values was mistakenly included'; 'a thorough review of the entirety of the self-learning material'; a 'secure Agency-wide self-learning platform'; host-country curricula 'Consistent with UN practice in all refugee situations'.
dataGeorg Eckert Institute, 'Report on Palestinian Textbooks' (EU-commissioned, published 2021): FAQ summarising the findings (2021) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-28). 156 textbooks selected from 309, plus 18 amended in 2020. 'a complex picture: on one hand the textbooks adopt UNESCO standards … such as material on human rights. Yet on the other hand they express antagonism towards Israel'; 'contain anti-Semitic narratives and glorifications of violence'; 'Direct calls for violence against Israelis were not found'; 'portrayals that defend, or even support, violence against Israelis'; a religious-education book 'contains cumulative stereotypes and accusations that can clearly be characterised as anti-Semitic'; other depictions carry 'implications of a Jewish conspiracy'; 2020/21 amendments removed some conflict references in maths and science and amended or removed some references to armed-resistance figures; Israel 'seldom mentioned by name', 'Zionist occupation'; 'Maps of the region do not show Israel'. The full 194-page report not read here.
primary documentIndependent Review of Mechanisms and Procedures to Ensure Adherence by UNRWA to the Humanitarian Principle of Neutrality (Colonna report), final report to the UN Secretary-General, 20 April 2024 — UNISPAL (2024) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-27). 'neutrality-related issues persist. They include instances of staff publicly expressing political views, host-country textbooks with problematic content being used in some UNRWA schools, and politicized staff unions'; 'Some Advisory Commission members have demanded that UNRWA remove discriminatory sentences from textbooks used in its schools, while other Advisory Commission members remain opposed to it'; UNRWA's 2022/2023 rapid review: '3.85 per cent of all textbook pages contain “issues of concern to UN values, guidance, or position on the conflict”'; 'Even if marginal, these issues constitute a grave violation of neutrality'; recurrent issues: maps without Israel, Jerusalem as capital of Palestine, Israeli cities as Palestinian, 'Zionist occupation'; of 30 NGO allegations, eight concern material not used in UNRWA schools in Gaza. Also: UNRWA 'is irreplaceable and indispensable'; 706 schools, half a million pupils. Also: UNRWA has 'a more developed approach to neutrality than other similar UN or NGO entities'; on Israel's claims that 'a significant number of UNRWA employees are members of terrorist organizations': 'Israel has yet to provide supporting evidence of this'. Re-read 2026-10-02: the Neutrality Framework covers 'the neutrality of UNRWA staff and other personnel, including their use of social media'; 'Despite this robust framework, neutrality-related issues persist'.
Where it leads if pressed
Working it out: how much of the content, whose content, and which teachers.
'UNRWA schools teach hatred' is a claim about scale and authorship, and both can be measured. How much: UNRWA's own rapid review of 2022–23, as reported by the Colonna review, found '3.85 per cent of all textbook pages' contained 'issues of concern to UN values, guidance, or position on the conflict', such as maps without Israel and 'Zionist occupation'; the review called this 'a grave violation of neutrality' even if marginal. The EU-commissioned Georg Eckert study found 'antagonism towards Israel', 'anti-Semitic narratives and glorifications of violence' alongside UNESCO standards, and no 'direct calls for violence'. Whose: the books are the host authority's; IMPACT-se, surveying 122 UNRWA booklets, found most problematic material 'inherited from the PA curriculum' but some 'UNRWA-produced'; UNRWA's commissioner said one textbook portrait 'does not align with United Nations values' and raised it with the Palestinian Authority. Which teachers: UN Watch reported a Telegram group of UNRWA teachers celebrating 7 October; UNRWA's own review of the 30 people named found three were not staff, six inconclusive and nine who 'may be active personnel'. All this concerns a system of about 700 schools and half a million pupils. The worst case for each side. For 'UNRWA schools teach hatred': take every finding at face value; the measured share of problem pages is under 4%, much of the material comes from the PA's curriculum, the EU study found no direct calls for violence, and part of the political pressure rests on one monitor's reports: the Palestinian refugee-rights group BADIL says the European Parliament's 2021 concerns were 'recycled from IMPACT-se's reports', which, if so, makes them one source line, not two (see 'Citation loop'). For 'nothing is wrong': take UNRWA's own figures; its own review found the problems, the EU study found antisemitic narratives, the Colonna review called them a grave violation, and the European Parliament in 2021 was 'concerned about the hate speech and violence taught in Palestinian school textbooks and used in schools by UNRWA', asking that EU funding depend on 'UNESCO standards of peace, tolerance, coexistence and nonviolence' (as quoted by BADIL, which rejects it). Holds on the evidence here: problematic and sometimes antisemitic content is documented in textbooks used in UNRWA schools, mostly from the host curriculum; some staff celebrated 7 October. Open until the independent review the reports call for: how far revisions have removed it. Not supported: that UNRWA schools as a system teach hatred as their purpose, or that the content problem is invented.
What the labels (Holds, Open, Arguable …) mean
primary documentIndependent Review of Mechanisms and Procedures to Ensure Adherence by UNRWA to the Humanitarian Principle of Neutrality (Colonna report), final report to the UN Secretary-General, 20 April 2024 — UNISPAL (2024) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-27). 'neutrality-related issues persist. They include instances of staff publicly expressing political views, host-country textbooks with problematic content being used in some UNRWA schools, and politicized staff unions'; 'Some Advisory Commission members have demanded that UNRWA remove discriminatory sentences from textbooks used in its schools, while other Advisory Commission members remain opposed to it'; UNRWA's 2022/2023 rapid review: '3.85 per cent of all textbook pages contain “issues of concern to UN values, guidance, or position on the conflict”'; 'Even if marginal, these issues constitute a grave violation of neutrality'; recurrent issues: maps without Israel, Jerusalem as capital of Palestine, Israeli cities as Palestinian, 'Zionist occupation'; of 30 NGO allegations, eight concern material not used in UNRWA schools in Gaza. Also: UNRWA 'is irreplaceable and indispensable'; 706 schools, half a million pupils. Also: UNRWA has 'a more developed approach to neutrality than other similar UN or NGO entities'; on Israel's claims that 'a significant number of UNRWA employees are members of terrorist organizations': 'Israel has yet to provide supporting evidence of this'. Re-read 2026-10-02: the Neutrality Framework covers 'the neutrality of UNRWA staff and other personnel, including their use of social media'; 'Despite this robust framework, neutrality-related issues persist'.
dataGeorg Eckert Institute, 'Report on Palestinian Textbooks' (EU-commissioned, published 2021): FAQ summarising the findings (2021) finding ✓
Read (2026-09-28). 156 textbooks selected from 309, plus 18 amended in 2020. 'a complex picture: on one hand the textbooks adopt UNESCO standards … such as material on human rights. Yet on the other hand they express antagonism towards Israel'; 'contain anti-Semitic narratives and glorifications of violence'; 'Direct calls for violence against Israelis were not found'; 'portrayals that defend, or even support, violence against Israelis'; a religious-education book 'contains cumulative stereotypes and accusations that can clearly be characterised as anti-Semitic'; other depictions carry 'implications of a Jewish conspiracy'; 2020/21 amendments removed some conflict references in maths and science and amended or removed some references to armed-resistance figures; Israel 'seldom mentioned by name', 'Zionist occupation'; 'Maps of the region do not show Israel'. The full 194-page report not read here.
advocacy / viewIMPACT-se, 'Review of UNRWA-Produced Study Materials in the Palestinian Territories' (January 2021) (2021) finding ✓
Read 2026-10-01. Surveyed '122 UNRWA-labeled booklets (of an estimated 150–200)', examined 'in close conjunction with the relevant PA textbooks'; most problematic material 'inherited from the PA curriculum', but 'in a not-insignificant number of instances, we found the introduction of UNRWA-produced problematic content'; Example 3: Arabic Language, Grade 8, pp. 1, 3, 10 (UNRWA Department of Education—Gaza, Supplementary Study Cards, Summer 2020): 'Jihad is one of the doors to Paradise'; notes UNRWA's position that it 'is unable to alter' PA textbook material. Later IMPACT-se reviews (2022, 2023) exist, not read.
primary documentPhilippe Lazzarini, UNRWA Commissioner-General, statement at the meeting of the Advisory Commission (25 June 2025) — UNISPAL copy (2025) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-01. On education: 'In all UNRWA schools, we use textbooks from host governments'; the Grade 5 Arabic textbook's portrait of Dalal al Mughrabi 'does not align with United Nations values'; concerns raised with the Ministry 'multiple times'; letter to President Abbas ('Last December'); books 'withdrawn and replaced with self-learning materials developed by the Agency'. Also: Colonna review, 20 of 50 recommendations to be fully implemented by end of June; staff lists shared with host countries and Israel quarterly. Re-read 2026-10-12 (statement dated 25 June 2025): 'In all UNRWA schools, we use textbooks from host governments. This is best practice in refugee education globally'; 'The Grade 5 Arabic textbook includes a portrait of Dalal al Mughrabi, a Palestinian militant, that does not align with United Nations values'; 'Last December, I wrote to President Abbas informing him that UNRWA would no longer teach the Grade 5 Arabic textbook in our schools. The books have been withdrawn and replaced with self-learning materials developed by the Agency.'
advocacy / viewUN Watch, 'Report: UNRWA's Terrorgram' (press release, 29 January 2024) (2024) pattern ✓
Read 2026-10-01. 'A new UN Watch report exposes a 3000-member Telegram chat group of UNRWA Teachers in Gaza who cheered and celebrated Hamas's October 7th massacre while at the same time asking when their UNRWA salaries will be paid'; 'focuses on 30 UNRWA teachers who among other things called for the execution of Israelis, shared instructions on how to aid Hamas' efforts'; quoted examples ('praised Hamas terrorists as "heroes"'); 'This evidence was collected and analyzed by the non-governmental organization UN Watch'. Recommends an 'independent and impartial investigation'. An advocacy group's own findings (see its org page, 'UN Watch'); not independently verified here.
primary documentUNRWA, 'UNRWA: Claims versus Facts' (press release, 26 February 2024, via UNISPAL) (2024) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-02. The agency's own rebuttal, claim by claim. On UN Watch's January 2024 Telegram report: the chat was ‘not set-up, nor authorized, nor managed by UNRWA’; it is ‘impossible to verify’ that all members of the group are UNRWA employees; of 30 people named, 18 could be reviewed: three ‘do not work for the Agency’, six ‘inconclusive’, ‘The remaining nine may be active personnel’, referred to the investigation department. Also says earlier claims about 129 people since 2022 misidentified more than half as staff. Also covers textbooks (reviewed for ‘UN values and UNESCO standards’). It is UNRWA's account of itself.
primary documentUNRWA, 'UNRWA Reviews Self-learning Material to Ensure Full Adherence to Highest UN Principles' (statement, 14 January 2021) — UNISPAL copy (2021) incident ✓
Read 2026-10-01. 'more than 700 schools educating more than 500,000 Palestine refugee children'; 'in the rush to continue students' education uninterrupted, some material the Agency had previously identified as not in line with UN values was mistakenly included'; 'a thorough review of the entirety of the self-learning material'; a 'secure Agency-wide self-learning platform'; host-country curricula 'Consistent with UN practice in all refugee situations'.
advocacy / viewBADIL, 'BADIL Rejects the European Parliament's Israeli-influenced Allegations about Palestinian Textbooks' (PR/EN/070521/09, May 2021) (2021) incident ✓
Read (2026-09-28). Quotes the EP resolution of 29 April 2021 (2019 discharge report): 'is concerned about the hate speech and violence taught in Palestinian school textbooks and used in schools by UNRWA; […] insists that […] EU funding […] must be made conditional on educational material and course content complying with UNESCO standards of peace, tolerance, coexistence and nonviolence'. BADIL: the resolution is 'functioning as part of Israel's colonial strategy to prohibit the Palestinian people from utilizing education as a legitimate tool of resistance'; the allegations 'recycled from IMPACT-se's reports'. A later EP resolution (11 April 2024) repeated the concern (reported; text not read here).
Fix the curriculum, keep the schools.
If the concern is content, the remedies are curriculum reform with independent review, teacher accountability, and conditioning funding on measurable change — not shutting schools that children depend on, with nothing to replace them. If the goal is instead to end the refugee question by ending the agency, that is a different argument (see 'UNRWA keeps millions of Palestinians as refugees forever — a problem kept alive on purpose.') and should be made openly.