Before any solution: governments that can deliver it
Whatever the destination, both sides need governments able to negotiate, compromise and carry out an agreement. Whether either has one today is the question this card asks.
In Israel
Israelis debate this: electoral reform, a constitution and the limits of the courts were at the centre of the 2023 protests. Electing the prime minister directly was tried from 1996 (three prime ministers were elected that way, per the Israel Democracy Institute) and ended with the 2001 Basic Law: The Government, which replaced the 1992 one (Knesset records).
Among Palestinians
In PCPSR's poll of 22–25 October 2025 (1,200 people, face to face in the West Bank and Gaza), 80% wanted President Abbas to resign, a majority saw the PA as 'a burden on the Palestinian people' against 40% who called it an asset, and about two thirds supported presidential and legislative elections a year after the Gaza ceasefire. The PA answers that elections can't be held under occupation and without a vote in East Jerusalem.
What it takes
- Israel: a constitution. The Basic Laws were meant to become one, and the 2023 judicial overhaul and the mass protests against it showed how contested the basic rules still are.
- Israel: an electoral system in which small parties can't hold a coalition hostage. With proportional representation 'using a single nationwide district' and, 'Since 2015', a threshold of '3.25 percent' (Freedom House, 2025), small coalition partners on the far right or among the Haredi parties can threaten to bring a government down over a move on the conflict. The November 2022 vote was 'Israel's fifth parliamentary elections since 2019' (Freedom House, 2023).
- Israel: shared duties for every community. In June 2024 the Supreme Court ruled 'that the military must begin conscripting' ultra-Orthodox men 'in keeping with existing laws' (Freedom House, 2025), and the dispute over drafting them has shaken governing coalitions since.
- Palestinians: elections. Presidential and legislative elections were 'last held in 2005 and 2006, respectively'; Abbas's 'four-year term … expired in 2009', and 'repeated and indefinite postponements' of elections 'have prevented any rotation of power' (Freedom House, West Bank report, 2025).
- Palestinians: one authority with a monopoly on arms. Since 2007, Gaza (Hamas) and the West Bank (the PA) have had rival governments.
- Both: institutions that outlast a change of leader, so that agreements survive the people who signed them
Palestinian figures: PCPSR poll No. 96, 22–25 October 2025 (pcpsr.org/en/node/1000), read 26 September 2026; later polls may differ.
What history says
- Israel 1996–2001: direct election of the prime minister. In 1996 voters cast 'two ballots—one for the Knesset and the other for the candidate for prime minister', and small parties campaigned on 'splitting the vote without risk'; the religious and Arab parties gained seats (Israel Democracy Institute). The 1992 Basic Law that introduced it was replaced in 2001 (Knesset records).
- The 2006 Palestinian election: won by Hamas, rejected by Israel and the West, and followed by the 2007 split. Elections alone don't make a government that can deliver.
- Northern Ireland: power-sharing institutions had to be built (1998) for the settlement to hold, and they collapsed several times when they failed.
The hard questions
- Can Israel reform its system while the coalition parties that benefit from it hold the votes?
- Would Palestinian elections today be won by parties that reject a settlement, and what then?
- Who negotiates in the meantime, and with what mandate?