Organisations and sources Β· International human-rights NGO (New York)

Human Rights Watch

What it is

Founded in 1978 as 'Helsinki Watch', investigating 'rights abuses in countries that signed the Helsinki Accords, most notably those behind the Iron Curtain' (its About page); the regional 'Watch' committees merged under the name Human Rights Watch in 1988 ⚠. It says it works in 'close to 100 countries'.

A US non-profit with researchers around the world. Its Israel and Palestine work is done by a regional team; Israel refused its Israel and Palestine director a work permit and deported him in 2019, a decision upheld by Israel's Supreme Court ⚠.

Who funds it

Private donors and foundations. In its words: 'To ensure our independence, we refuse government funding and carefully review all donations'. In 2010 George Soros's Open Society Foundations announced 'a challenge grant of $100 million over 10 years', 'the largest that he has ever made to a nongovernmental organization', on condition that HRW raise a matching $100 million in private contributions. In 2020 it returned a donation accepted in 2012 on the condition that the funds 'not be used to support HRW's work on lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) rights in the Middle East and North Africa', calling the decision 'deeply regrettable' and regretting 'that the grant was made by the owner of a company that Human Rights Watch had previously identified as complicit in labor rights abuse'. The Intercept reported (March 2020) that the grant 'amounted to $470,000', per Executive Director Kenneth Roth, and that the donor, unnamed in HRW's statement, was the Saudi real estate businessman Mohamed Bin Issa Al Jaber, as 'two Human Rights Watch employees confirmed'.

What it wants

Investigating and publicising human-rights abuses by any government or armed group, and lobbying for accountability. On Israel and Palestine it concluded in 2021 that Israeli authorities are committing the crimes of apartheid and persecution ('A Threshold Crossed'), and in December 2024 that Israel is committing 'extermination and acts of genocide' by depriving Gaza of water.

Its record

  • It documents abuses on both sides. In July 2024 it published a 236-page report finding that Hamas and at least four other armed groups committed war crimes and crimes against humanity on October 7, with killing civilians and taking hostages 'central aims of the planned attack, and not actions that occurred as an afterthought'. It has also reported on Hamas's and the PA's treatment of Palestinian dissidents.
  • Its December 2024 report found that Israel's deprivation of water to Gaza's civilians means 'Israeli authorities have committed the crime against humanity of extermination', and that 'This policy also amounts to an "act of genocide"', while noting that genocide requires intent that must be 'the only reasonable inference'.
  • Its April 2021 report 'A Threshold Crossed' found that 'Israeli authorities are committing the crimes against humanity of apartheid and persecution'; Amnesty followed in 2022. Together with B'Tselem's they form the cluster described in 'The citation map of the genocide claim'.
  • Its founder, Robert Bernstein, criticised it in the New York Times in 2009 ('Rights Watchdog, Lost in the Mideast') for, in NGO Monitor's summary, 'ignoring severe human rights violations in closed societies' and 'issuing reports … that are helping those who wish to turn Israel into a pariah state' (quoted by NGO Monitor; the NYT original is not read here ⚠). NGO Monitor, a Jerusalem-based organisation scrutinising NGOs, says its analyses 'demonstrate that HRW disproportionately focuses on condemnations of Israel'; UN Watch is also a sustained critic, and Israel's government rejects its conclusions.
  • Pro-Palestinian critics say it was slow to use the words apartheid and genocide, and that its insistence on reporting Palestinian armed groups' crimes creates false balance (not yet sourced here ⚠).

Citation cluster

Part of the human-rights cluster (HRW, Amnesty, B'Tselem, UN bodies) whose legal conclusions cite each other; its own field investigations, satellite and video analysis are the independent part.

How to read a claim sourced from here

Read what it found separately from how it classifies it. Its reports are long and footnoted, and its fact-finding (interviews, forensic video analysis, satellite imagery) can be checked. Its legal labels, apartheid and genocide, are the part that is most contested and most cited. It reports on Hamas and on Israel; people who cite only one of those reports are using it selectively.

Where it comes up

Sources