Organisations and sources · Israeli journal of thought and policy (Hebrew)

HaShiloach (השילוח)

What it is

Not stated on the page read ⚠.

In its own words, 'an Israeli journal of thought and policy', and 'the flagship of the publications of the Center for Israeli Liberty' (המרכז לחרות ישראלית), a public-benefit company that holds the site's copyright. Its About page names a publisher, an editor-in-chief and an editorial staff.

Who funds it

Not stated on the page read ⚠ (published by the Center for Israeli Liberty).

What it wants

To be 'a home for in-depth discourse on the big questions before us', through long essays 'without academic trappings, but in careful language and with intellectual honesty'. Its subjects run from general thought and 'Jewish and Zionist thought and literature' to public policy in economics, society, culture, education and national security. The Center for Israeli Liberty says it believes that 'conservative intellectual leadership' can contribute to the future of the Jewish people, the State of Israel 'and the whole Western world'.

Why it makes its arguments

Originator: it makes these arguments as part of its own programme.

Stated aim, in its own words: 'a home for in-depth discourse on the big questions before us'; its publisher believes 'conservative intellectual leadership' can contribute to the future of Israel and the West. (HaShiloach, 'About us' page (Hebrew; translated))

Is there reason to doubt it?

  • Does it say what it is? Yes, in outline: a journal of 'thought and policy' published by the Center for Israeli Liberty, which calls its own aim 'conservative intellectual leadership'. It does not state its founding year or funders on the page read. (HaShiloach, 'About us' page (Hebrew; translated))

Only what is documented: stated aims in the actor's own words, and sourced tests of them. 'No evidence found' is a finding too. See the argument that isn't meant to win.

Its record

  • September 2017: published Bezalel Smotrich's 'Israel's Decisive Plan' (English version on its site), cited on israel-apartheid, majority-is-safety and river-to-the-sea, and quoted on the Religious Zionism page. The plan offers the West Bank's Arabs a choice between staying without a Knesset vote 'at the first stage', aid 'to emigrate', or facing the security forces 'with a strong hand'; it also says the arrangement 'does not make the State of Israel into an "apartheid state"'.
  • What else it has published, and how others describe it, are not yet sourced here ⚠.

Citation cluster

Israeli journals of thought and policy; in its publisher's own word, 'conservative'.

How to read a claim sourced from here

Read it as a journal of argument: the essays make a case, and publishing an essay is not the same as the journal endorsing every line of it. When an entry quotes the Decisive Plan, the words are Smotrich's, not HaShiloach's. The journal's own description of itself is 'thought and policy'; the Center that publishes it calls its aim 'conservative intellectual leadership'. No label here goes beyond those words.

Where it comes up

Sources

  • HaShiloach, 'About us' page (Hebrew; translated) ✓
    What was readRead 2026-09-29 (Hebrew; this site's translation): 'an Israeli journal of thought and policy', the flagship of the Center for Israeli Liberty, which believes 'conservative intellectual leadership' can contribute to the future of Israel and the West; no funding stated.
  • Bezalel Smotrich, 'Israel's Decisive Plan', Hashiloach (September 2017), English version ✓
    What was readRead (2026-09-28). 'This will be life with the maximum of democratic rights: life, liberty, and property; a life of freedom of religion and expression … It will also contain the right to vote for the system which runs their everyday lives.' 'The Arabs of Judea and Samaria will be able to conduct their daily life in freedom and peace, but not to vote for the Israeli Knesset at the first stage. This will preserve the Jewish majority in decision making in the State of Israel.' 'this is, albeit, an imperfect situation in terms of civil rights'. 'And no, this graduated arrangement does not make the State of Israel into an "apartheid state."' Re-read 2026-09-30: the plan's options: residency without the Knesset vote for those who 'let go of their national ambitions'; 'Those who choose not to let go of their national ambitions will receive aid to emigrate'; those who fight 'will be dealt with by the security forces with a strong hand'; and 'It will be possible to consider granting full citizenship as a third option, including voting for the Knesset', 'alongside the declaration of complete loyalty to the Jewish State by serving in the armed forces'.