Organisations and sources Β· Media-monitoring organisation (described in press reports as 'a pro-Israel media watchdog'; its own About page could not be read here)
HonestReporting
What it is
Founded in 2000, at the start of the Second Intifada β .
A media watchdog that critiques coverage of Israel and campaigns for corrections β . Its executive director in 2023 was Gil Hoffman (Forward/AP).
Who funds it
Private donors β .
What it wants
Countering what it sees as bias against Israel in the media β (its own statement of aims not read; its About page is walled to this site's fetcher).
Its record
- Has exposed errors and conflicts of interest in coverage, including journalists and stringers with ties to militant groups.
- In November 2023 it published photos taken early on 7 October by seven Gaza freelancers and sold to Reuters and AP, asking whether they had known of the attack in advance; Israel's prime minister's office then called them 'accomplices in crimes against humanity'. The agencies 'categorically denied any foreknowledge' (AP said its first pictures were taken more than an hour after the assault began); CNN and AP cut ties with one freelancer, Hassan Eslaiah, whom the watchdog had shown posing with Yahya Sinwar in an image 'apparently taken well before Oct. 7', though CNN said it had no reason 'to doubt the journalistic accuracy' of his work. Hoffman later told AP the group had no evidence to back up its insinuations: 'we don't claim to be a news organization' (Forward, relaying AP).
- Its work mirrors that of pro-Palestinian media critics: it looks for the other side's errors.
Citation cluster
Part of the pro-Israel monitoring cluster with CAMERA and others.
How to read a claim sourced from here
A useful error-finder; check the claim against the original report and the outlet's response, and treat insinuations about motives as advocacy.
Where it comes up
Sources
- HonestReporting β
- The Forward, 'Questions raised about photographers who covered Hamas attacks' (November 2023; relays AP) β
What was read
Read 2026-09-30 (November 2023): HonestReporting's post and the prime minister's office's 'accomplices' line; the agencies 'categorically denied any foreknowledge'; CNN and AP cut ties with Hassan Eslaiah over an image with Sinwar 'apparently taken well before Oct. 7'. (HonestReporting's own About page is behind a wall.)